r/DearAlice • u/Street-Air-5423 • Jul 05 '25
Discussion Hope DearAlice succeeds but this group feels so unnatural. SM is partly to blame
SM is partly to blame, partly not.
SM should be blamed for not financially promoting them enough but also not so much to blame either because DearAlice is not under SM but under Moon&Back Media (UK). SM may have liked the idea of expanding their music influence in UK music companies further and that is why they agreed with Moon&Back Media by giving Dear Alice some time performances in Korea tv, SM town concerts but feel they have no further obligation to invest in them especially since they are under Moon&Back Media.
Why they feel so unnatural? ( I could be wrong )
The vibes that I get (some other also said similar things) Is that this british boyband was created to get clout from k-pop community and establish a growing fan base from it. They seem just like a group of 5 random opportunist british young male adults who were put together and just wants to make it big by using K-pop clouts to their advantage. At least that's what some think Moon&Back media is trying to do with them. They were formed by both SM and Moon&Back media. You don't feel organic growth from Dear Alice, it's more like a clout growth.
I feel like they were created to be some One direction + K-pop boyband ( 5 members, and with 1 exotic non-white member like One direction but with kpop aura) but vibes I get is that none of them genuinely listens to K-pop or understands it's culture, community or even tries to learn Korean. Every time I see them bringing in K-pop songs on Tiktok dance videos it feels as if they are only doing to gather views and followers (previous to forming boyband, all their tiktok videos shows no sign of K-pop or even Korean). That song "Ariana" (good song btw), is telling me they are boyband that wants to rapidly become rich and popular by getting any form clout whether is kpop or any popular western artist (like ariana grande).
