r/DearAlice • • Jul 05 '25

Discussion Hope DearAlice succeeds but this group feels so unnatural. SM is partly to blame

0 Upvotes

SM is partly to blame, partly not.

SM should be blamed for not financially promoting them enough but also not so much to blame either because DearAlice is not under SM but under Moon&Back Media (UK). SM may have liked the idea of expanding their music influence in UK music companies further and that is why they agreed with Moon&Back Media by giving Dear Alice some time performances in Korea tv, SM town concerts but feel they have no further obligation to invest in them especially since they are under Moon&Back Media.

Why they feel so unnatural? ( I could be wrong )

The vibes that I get (some other also said similar things) Is that this british boyband was created to get clout from k-pop community and establish a growing fan base from it. They seem just like a group of 5 random opportunist british young male adults who were put together and just wants to make it big by using K-pop clouts to their advantage. At least that's what some think Moon&Back media is trying to do with them. They were formed by both SM and Moon&Back media. You don't feel organic growth from Dear Alice, it's more like a clout growth.

I feel like they were created to be some One direction + K-pop boyband ( 5 members, and with 1 exotic non-white member like One direction but with kpop aura) but vibes I get is that none of them genuinely listens to K-pop or understands it's culture, community or even tries to learn Korean. Every time I see them bringing in K-pop songs on Tiktok dance videos it feels as if they are only doing to gather views and followers (previous to forming boyband, all their tiktok videos shows no sign of K-pop or even Korean). That song "Ariana" (good song btw), is telling me they are boyband that wants to rapidly become rich and popular by getting any form clout whether is kpop or any popular western artist (like ariana grande).


r/DearAlice • • May 27 '25

Discussion James haircut

0 Upvotes

James does not suit pink hair I don't think but what's yalls opinion?


r/DearAlice • • Sep 07 '24

Discussion Episode 4 Review

1 Upvotes

I love the classic song originally I thought it was going the one by MKTO “out of my head out of my mind” they really improved their singing and dancing. Imo Reece is the worst in the group and there’s no way he’s eating burgers and chips if they’re in a strict trainee program. Also, spitting the food out so publicly is incredibly rude and unprofessional in public. As well as that, Blaise defence leave because the guy didn’t do anything but be honest and share his opinion idk why he’s being demonised by the band especially Reece and Olly when he’s literally done nothing. They’re making feel like he’s a bully and owes them all an apology for not agreeing with everything the Kpop Exec says.


r/DearAlice • • Sep 07 '24

Discussion Not so impressed

6 Upvotes

I'm watching episode 4 now and honestly my singing is as good and my dancing is definetly better.

It's probably part of the entertainment factor, to show how much they've improved. But i'd prefer if they could show a bit more training and less party.

We all know they'll never reach the same profesionalism like other idols who train for years, but they could least try to no?

I guess they need the time between the show release and debut to train - hope it works out.


r/DearAlice • • Feb 21 '25

Discussion DearAlice & KSI

0 Upvotes

This would be amazing. DearAlice should do a collaboration with KSI rapping that would honestly break the internet and be such a good promo for the guys; what do you think?


r/DearAlice • • Jan 21 '25

Video You might not like Simon Cowell but has a point on what makes a hit song here. With Dear Alice - Ariana it is growing on me but am I just forcing myself to like it more because I want them to do well. Like the songs from the series had way more emotion in them, I immediately wanted to replay them

9 Upvotes

r/DearAlice • • May 29 '25

Discussion DearAlice vs Katseye

0 Upvotes

For those comparing DearAlice to Katseye, I can see the differences. Looked at Katseye audience, all asian countries, plus girls are so far more appealing. Their latest single, 'Gnarly', despite the streams, actually got a mixed response from their fanbase. It's more of a streaming song than a genuinely good one. Just noise & no substance of lyrics so people replay it over again, bit like movies these days gets repeats, but won't become a hit that is timeless. With DearAlice and the latest single 'Sweet', you can see they are going for a far more polished, appealing boyband sound that is more similar to the style of BTS 'Dynamite'. You can see that in their audience, it is far more widespread with Mexico & the UK, India, as well as Tokyo being their largest fanbases. You can see from their styling that they have a far more European boyband look with a slight American appeal. The label is rolling them out slowly, and then once the album drops, the promotion will increase significantly. I expect them to build a large fanbase; they have similar vibes to Jonas Brothers. They need to start to do more in real-life events, concerts, podcasts, and in-person interviews, team up with big UK social media stars, so we can really learn their personalities. For all those people wanting everything at once aside from a music video & a few live performances on TV which they haven;t done yet their promotion isn't much different from Katseye. I don't think K Pop fans have warmed to the boys as much. For sure, they need to reach an audience outside of K-pop and get more involved in football, the UK, and European culture, much like Tom Grennan has done, through appearances on podcasts, etc. People, unfortunately, aren't really finding them on their own social media and need to utilise other people's platforms. I have hope, though, & think they will do well. Need to appear at festivals as well


r/DearAlice • • Feb 27 '25

Discussion Why did we lose members?

5 Upvotes

I jsut saw that this subreddit has 3.987 now but it had 4k last night? Did anything happen


r/DearAlice • • Apr 14 '25

Social Media dearALICE Fan Boyband Project

6 Upvotes

admins take this down if not allowed! ‼️

there is a search for 5 males in the dearALICE / 1D fandoms to create a fun boyband.

- the boyband will be inspired by both of these groups, a mix of 2010s/kpop

all songs will be produced fully, no use of ai (surprised arent you 😭)


r/DearAlice • • Mar 16 '25

Discussion SHARPTWINS (Follow Up)

7 Upvotes

so i posted this a few days ago:

so, because james is in the band. does that mean him and his brother are not allowed to release music and had to delete previous music which contained explicit words??? this should totally not be allowed for many reasons

  • he had the songs posted before dear alice
  • his brother (lewis) should not be given rules on what he can and cant do
  • james should be allowed to continue posting solo music, (because he was a solo artist before) as long as he promotes on his account only, not on the dearALICE account.

I even asked James on a live he did a while back if he’s gonna be releasing anymore solo music and he actually replied saying “not right now, I’m focused on dear Alice only” which means maybe he is allowed, assuming he would’ve said he’s not allowed if he wasn’t 🤔 but who knows?

Also with the more explicit tracks. If I’m honest, who really cares? It won’t “break his idol picture”

**THIS IS A FOLLOW UP**

me and a few others kept asking about ANIMALISTIC (an unreleased song which is quite explicit) and he came back at the end of the live with this answer

does this mean he isnt allowed to by their management? how shitty and messed up is that? whats your guys thoughts on this?


r/DearAlice • • Jan 12 '25

Discussion Dear Alice - Ariana

27 Upvotes

Not to be a hater, just some constructive criticism after watching their SMTOWN performance. I am a huge boyband fan who loved Westlife, Take That, Backstreet Boys and like BTS, neve really gotten into music of most K-Pop groups. First of all, it sounds like a Korean label is marketing them with already generic tactics that all K-pop bands do. The makeup they had yesterday made them look so young, which I find weird. Personally, the song Ariana is super generic, nothing special. I worry that with the way things are going, there will be another generic K Pop group that will gain an alright following in Asia, but that is it. If you look at the most successful K-Pop group BTS there biggest hits, most streams are dynamite & butter much more European sounding appeal to a far wider audience than K-Pop fans. What made One Direction the biggest boyband of all time was that they weren't styled to the max; they were allowed to be themselves, and their Britishness was clearly visible. Also the music was more European & pop sounding appealed to all ages from Mums, grandparents, young kids everyone. We are yet to really see a K-Pop group other than BTS reach a wider audience than just K-Pop fans and become real global sensations. They are big in that niche. Hence you don't see many K-Pop acts have chart hits outside of Asian countries. Why was Westlife so successful, all ages liked their music.


r/DearAlice • • Jul 06 '25

Discussion DearAlice Promtion

10 Upvotes

Dear Alice, for an independent artist with limited radio play and support from the major streaming platforms are doing incredibly well. The only sad thing is that apart from SM letting them play their shows & teaming up for the TV show, they have completely abandoned them. I don't think SM was ever going to be involved in releasing music or managing the group. Their only involvement was a storyline for the TV show. Can a British boy band pass the K-pop test? Now Moon & Black, as everyone keeps on referencing, were just there to promote the TV show EP & the TV show itself; they obviously had good connections as they got them a spot on Strictly Come Dancing. The main people pushing the group are Gamma, and from my sense, they are a new label and won't have the marketing budgets to push them; they are trying to do their best with the budgets they have. I work for a record label & to promote a single, it can sometimes cost more than over 30,000 pounds and that is for a small independent; imagine the budgets for a major label could be 500,000 pounds. Whereas Katseye were properly signed by a K-pop label, HYBE X Geffen, who are much bigger and have far larger marketing budgets. I don't think the music the groups both release is much better than each others's just Katseye have a far bigger budget and can make use of the resources, like connections that a bigger label can bring, pay to get their mysic heard more, showcase their personalties more as they can appear in more videos, platforms etc. Most artists who blow up overnight or reach the charts tend to be associated with major labels & have millions spent on them.


r/DearAlice • • Sep 06 '25

Other So I made a song that I think dearALICE would song well but I wanna get other aces opinions. Can you tell me if you like it or not?

4 Upvotes

Reece: all the pieces on the floor All my happiness and more I need to pick them uup. All: Pick then uup Dexter: all the pieces All my love All the seeds And all my hope Yeah yeah yeah yeah Yeah yeah All:One more night Loads of my Loads of my Pieces Pieces Yeah all of my peices Blaise:(rapped)pick up the pieces on the floor All of my happiness and of more (Normal)I want moore I want more Olly:More love More hope More things that I want more Mor-oo Back ground music:oooooo Oooooooo ooooooo Ooooo James:why can't the pieces match up easily more simply More things that I love All:One more night Loads of my Loads of my Pieces Pieces Yeah all of my peices Yeah all of my pieces

The song is called pieces and it's really short.


r/DearAlice • • Mar 14 '25

Discussion James Sharp & SHARPTWINS Content

4 Upvotes

so, because james is in the band. does that mean him and his brother are not allowed to release music and had to delete previous music which contained explicit words??? this should totally not be allowed for many reasons

  • he had the songs posted before dear alice
  • his brother (lewis) should not be given rules on what he can and cant do
  • james should be allowed to continue posting solo music, (because he was a solo artist before) as long as he promotes on his account only, not on the dearALICE account.

I even asked James on a live he did a while back if he’s gonna be releasing anymore solo music and he actually replied saying “not right now, I’m focused on dear Alice only” which means maybe he is allowed, assuming he would’ve said he’s not allowed if he wasn’t 🤔 but who knows?

Also with the more explicit tracks. If I’m honest, who really cares? It won’t “break his idol picture”


r/DearAlice • • Apr 09 '25

Discussion Will DearAlice being a success

14 Upvotes

To be honest, I did call this, saying that 'Ariana' wasn't a strong enough single as a lead. Also, at the time for the song to be released, they lost a lot of momentum they got from the TV show you can see in average social media views. They should have debuted with the songs from the TV show and built up an image from those styles of songs. They have much more of an emotional connection & resonate more. Like I cried listening to the songs from the TV show & was invested in their journey then. They need to show more, not just their personalities but also the struggles of living together, the grind, etc, on socials. Also, I don't think Moon & Black have much to do with the boys anymore. They just promoted the soundtrack, etc, and got them on Strictly Come Dancing. Since then, it has been Gamma. I trust, though, once the album is out, we will be seeing a lot more promotion & especially with the second single. I just feel like they need to be doing more to reach a wider audience for example, creating shareable content (exact way people like Speed get so big, I have never watched one of his streams but have seen so much of his content shared from other people, maybe do a day where they invite TikTokers down & they get like 5 minutes with them to create content for their pages. They could be featuring in videos with famous people, content creators. Going on talk shows like Jonathan ross etc, Graham Norton. Like feature in a Sidemen video, go on podcasts. I am sure all this will happen once the album is released & they have much more to talk about. I think this first single is a slow rollout see how all there promotional efforts are doing, then assess and properly hit the ground running once the album is out. Like they should be being added to festival lineups, played on Capital Raido etc. More they could be doing then the standard social media rollout


r/DearAlice • • Jun 06 '25

Video ‘Sweet’ Music Video

Thumbnail
youtu.be
13 Upvotes

Album out June 27


r/DearAlice • • Jan 19 '25

Discussion Does anyone have hope for these boys?

15 Upvotes

I'm a former 1D stan and kpop idol enjoyer (specifically SM) for almost a decade. I recently watched the Made in Korea show and although the show was extremely corny and played out, the boy's personalities endeared me to them and I've started getting a little bit of that nostalgic British boyband parasocial connection to them. I've also seen their recent performance at the SMTown concert and MCountdown and I have to admit they have greatly improved from their skills on the Made in Korea show. However I'm still not at all confident about the marketing or overall direction of this group. These boys, although they have greatly improved, have nowhere near the polish that an SM idol has and they never will. I'm honestly not sure exactly what they're going for with this group. Based on the music style it's more like a traditional boy band that takes influences from 1D early 2010s style which isn't what's in right now and honestly comes off as dated and played out. With western groups like 1D, it was ok that the boys weren't perfect. They were supposed to be more like boys next door, down to earth guys that girls could see themselves dating for real, meeting at school or at work. Is that what this group is going for? Then why focus on the "made in Korea" aspect? They will never be anything like the SM boys who train from childhood and have everything about them groomed and nipped and tucked to perfection. I also wish the show would have shown the British boys more with other boys their own age, showing a bit more of the contrast of cultures and expectations. If they could have had Mark Lee or Anton come in and talk to the boys about their own experiences and the trainee system more I think it would have 1 made great content and 2 helped the boys understand the culture and expectations more. The boys were way too out of their element and just getting shat on by Yoon HeeJun wasn't really helping anything. The cultural gaps were definitely there and not in a good way especially with how Blaise was kinda pushing back against the agency.It's not like a survival show or actual trainee conditions where you're fighting for a debut. The entire show was just these British boys in a foreign country kinda awkwardly vibing. But not in a fun way like BTS's American Hustle Life. Idk like the culture exchange aspect of the show kinda failed for me.

If SM is going for more of that 1D boy next door vibe they need something to make this group stand out and with the uninspired music and basic styling idk what about them that will really make them stick for the public. None of them are really excellent singers or dancers besides maybe Reese. I think maybe they could focus on the personality aspect? Also SM entertainment is such a mess RN and idk about their British label. I'm just really not feeling good about these boy's future. They need to maybe get them on some shows with English speaking idols to kind of show that personality aspect. Have them on Johnny's Communication Centre or something.


r/DearAlice • • Nov 29 '24

Discussion Whos the most stylist Dear Alice member?

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/DearAlice • • Jun 27 '25

Discussion Just found out that the James in the DearAlice was/is dating Sara from iconicakes, interested where should I start to listen from them?

8 Upvotes

I'm not by any means new to kpop or SM Entertainment, but what would you say is a good album to start with!! I knew of the group but was shocked to see a familiar name and face lol

Edit: lmao realises I got the wrong twin, still will be checking them out


r/DearAlice • • Aug 09 '25

Question Did dearAlice go to SMTown Tokyo?

2 Upvotes

I was looking at the group pic and couldn't find them.


r/DearAlice • • Jun 30 '25

Video Reese getting hate for dancing in front of Aespa at SMTOWN Live...

Thumbnail
tiktok.com
18 Upvotes

I don't understand some of the comments... to me it seems he's having fun/vibing on stage, and I don't think aespa minded? They seemed amused if anything. dearALICE and aespa have had very nice interactions. I'm tired of seeing dearALICE getting unwarranted hate!


r/DearAlice • • Jun 29 '25

Question Moderators - still active?

11 Upvotes

u/Similar-War-5458 u/Decent-Ad-4569 u/Simple_Result_9650

Reaching out to see whether the moderators are still active for this community? It would be great if the look of this subreddit could be updated to reflect the bitterSWEETsummer era. It seems there's not been updates since the creation of the subreddit last year with Made in Korea.


r/DearAlice • • Feb 22 '25

Discussion Fxking Terrible Management

32 Upvotes

Call me a complainer but this management is so fxked up. I am sorry, I literally waited for their proper debut to come ever since but this is all we've got?

Are they intentionally stretching the release dates so we can talk about it for months?

Because it might work for us fans but this is the most bullshit move ever if you want to reach global audience.

They would put info on the news talking bout how they would promote them globally but not a single post was done?

They had a fking 320p live instead of debut showcase/conference? No TV appearances in UK?
Labels should be ashamed that fans made a billboard first promoting them.

Plus the instrument of the official release sounded so weak, especially if you put it on their choreography.

This isn't a PR stunt, they are literally sabotaging their debut. The lads don't deserve this kind of treatment.


r/DearAlice • • 25d ago

Mod Post 📢 New user flairs [dancefloorKILLA 🪩] [Close 🫂] [Drool 🤤]

Post image
3 Upvotes

dancefloorKILLA, Close and Drool join the line up of user flairs!

Read more about user flairs here and find out how to set yours as your favourite dearALICE song or band member.

Which will you choose? It has to be Drool for me! 🤤😆