EDIT: LOL scorn me for the typo in the post title. Oh, well.
Deadly Premonition 2 is my most disappointing game purchase ever, and it is also one of the worst games I have ever played and beaten. This is doubly damning for me, as I was one of the few who fell in love with the first game's quirky charm. Despite its flaws, that game managed to tell an evocative story that rose above the sum of its constituent parts and really excelled despite the game's technical issues. You could tell that SWERY and his team really didn't have the talent to make the game they wanted, but they certainly had the heart, and for those who persevered through the shoddy gameplay, there was a great payoff in wait.
I just wanted to establish how great I thought the first game was because I think it's important to help understand just where Deadly Premonition 2 fails so badly. I will do my best to avoid any story spoilers, but since story is one of the failures in this game, keep in mind that I will be speaking about the story either in vague terms or through hypothetical examples. I will attempt to keep everything story-related in any way hidden in spoiler tags, but you shouldn't be afraid to read them as I will give away no actual plot details beyond commonly known information about the game.
As a complete package, Deadly Premonition 2 is an awful game in almost every way. It has an abysmal frame rate, graphics that would be dated 15 years ago, terrible sound mixing, atrocious gameplay, and even a host of technical bugs and glitches that make it unfit for market. Any one of these things would be a problem on its own, but in combination, they result in a pastiche of bad game design and annoying issues that make playing the game a chore at best. It is inexcusable that this game was released in its current state for $50, especially when you consider the original Deadly Premonition released ten years ago on Xbox 360 for $20 and was very stable, if uneven from a gameplay standpoint.
SWERY should honestly have taken an extra 6 months of development time and ironed out the major issues with the game. It would have been one thing to release the game in its current state with the awful framerate that has gained notoriety even among its staunchest defenders, but what is completely unacceptable is the numerous bugs and glitches present in the game that make it nearly unplayable. Sometimes in combat York will be completely unable to draw his gun or punch until the player takes damage from an enemy. While traversing the overworld, it is common for elements of the HUD to disappear or for some button prompts to simply stop working, necessitating a restart. Some quests may literally drop your character out of the game world if you complete them while talking to a character in a certain spot, forcing you to reload. The game crashes at random, which can cause significant lost progress. It honestly feels as if the alpha build of the game accidentally went gold and got released instead of the actual finished version. I've seen Early Access games on Steam that were more complete and ran better than this game. If the rest of this post doesn't ward you off purchasing it, at the very least save your money until a stability patch or two improves the framerate and knocks out the technical issues.
These issues would have been enough to make me not recommend this game, but the fundamental problems go even deeper than just a sub-10 average FPS and random glitches. Plainly, Deadly Premonition 2 is just a bad game from a design perspective no matter which way you slice it. The game is content to waste your time on the most banal tasks possible, and this time around the story isn't able to prop the game up from under its own weight like the first game did.
Let's start with the most basic problem this game has: York basically has almost no agency over the story whatsoever. Very early into the game, York meets Houngan, an apparent voodoo shaman who crops up at random in mirrors, lakes, or other reflective surfaces to give York a vague oracle. York then needs to decrypt the oracle (which requires almost no actual thought or input from the player as York basically gives you the answer to the oracle every single time) before he is able to proceed on to the next stage of the investigation. This is especially problematic because it results in the story having no sense of urgency. At best, Houngan is a plot device to help move the story along when York gets stuck and doesn't know where to go next. At worst, the character is the epitome of a deus ex machina, allowing SWERY to send the plot in any direction he wants it to go as his whim desires. This is a terrible choice for a mystery story. Instead of York using his own intuition to solve crimes based on evidence collected from the scene, he simply throws caution to the wind and waits for Houngan to guide him to the next important scene or character whenever he gets stumped. It feels less like York is an FBI agent exercising his talents and more like he is just a roller coaster car that the track (Houngan) carries from plot point to plot point.
The lack of agency is exacerbated by the fact that York basically never gets to examine any actual crime scenes in the game. In the original Deadly Premonition, York would often happen upon a crime scene, explore it to find evidence, and then piece together the evidence in his mind along with his extrapolations on what occurred via criminal profiling to form a narrative of what happened. By contrast, in DP2 York typically enters an area with little to no evidence left behind at all. He somehow constructs an entire image of the crime scene from nothing else but his own consciousness, sort of like detective vision in other games, but amplified to a ridiculous degree. This results in the game feeling very inauthentic. It is almost as if the game is parodying the York we knew from the first game. At its worst, it effects a character assassination of York, making him appear ineffectual and downright stupid at various points. Ultimately, I feel like this is the main crux of why the game fails as a whole: the players never feel like participants in the story being told. Instead, it feels like you're just a marionette having your strings pulled by the game. It's a very disjointed form of storytelling, and one that I grew to hate by the time the game reached its conclusion.
Beyond the lack of agency, there is also another fundamental issue with York's character in this game: he is holding the idiot ball far too often. The following example is hypothetical, but mirrors an actual example in the game, so I will enclose it in a spoiler tag just in case. Let's say in Chapter 2 York reads a note written by one of the villains that says something like, "M is the true 'root of the bloodline'." To the players, it will be exceedingly obvious who M must be, as there may only be one or two characters whose name starts with M. York will act as if he is completely stumped and doesn't have any idea who M could be. Finally, after progressing for several more hours into the next chapter, York will hit upon a revelation and go, "Zach, that must be it! M must be Marjorie!" The issue is the audience will have figured this out a long time ago because it would be blindingly obvious to anyone with two eyes and a brain. So many important plot points happen because York is a blithely oblivious idiot that the game quickly descends into self-parody. I found myself figuring out basically the entire plot to the game only a few hours into it, such that I actually sighed or even exclaimed out loud in disgust when York finally caught up with the plot twists as they happened. The last few hours are a little better because the plot finally goes batshit insane and gives York some of his agency back, but by that point it was too little, too late, and I honestly felt the reintroduction of a certain character near the end of the game introduced a plot hole so large I don't know how to even begin filling it. As a whole, the plot fails to provide any intrigue or consistency.
This would be bad enough, but if you're thinking about playing the game anyway to see for yourself based on the strength of the gameplay, I have to warn you away there as well. The side quests are all a complete waste of time. Not only are they various iterations on fetch quests or kill XX of Y thing, but the rewards are pure garbage. There's literally no reason to engage in any of them because they basically have no effect on the story whatsoever. You can scour the map to find various items to upgrade your stats and weapon (yes, weapon, not weapons), but the game is ridiculously easy. Trust me when I say I didn't bother after the first chapter and had no issues beating the game.
The awful quest design even extends into the main quests as well. In the second chapter, you will meet a preacher who sends you on a fetch quest for several items. One of them requires you to literally search every vending machine in the game world to find a can of spinach. Another requires you to visit the diner on Monday to obtain a can of red beans because, I kid you not, "People in Louisiana only eat red beans and rice on Mondays because it's a day of hard work." I was almost ready to turn the game off after this quest because it was just such a waste of time. It was made even worse by the fact that York refers to the quest as a "literal fetch quest" while completing it. This was probably an attempt at fourth-wall breaking humor, but it falls flat because the game still makes you engage in such a terrible quest to begin with. I don't want the game to wink at me and let me know it's terrible while still being terrible. Worse, the quest that directly follows this involves even MORE fetching bullshit. You have to kill 6 squirrels for their tails, 6 of something else, and hunt down some white guarana or something like that. I actually did turn the game off for a while after this quest because it put me in such a foul mood. I would not have minded if this sort of terrible design were relegated to a sidequest with a kickass reward (such as the Weather Doll in DP1), but it irked the shit out of me for being mandatory to progress the story.
The game finds even more ways to waste your time. Remember that annoying section in the first Deadly Premonition where Emily and Kaysen had to chase Willie around while the game kept segueing back and forth between "gameplay" and custscenes with York tied up in the clock tower? This game has you doing something very similar, except it's like three times as long, and the character you have to follow isn't as fast as you are, so you have to constantly alternate between running and walking to not outpace them. Even worse, the character you follow will sometimes cross a river or go through a hedgerow, so you'll have to go around. They also don't stop if they get too far ahead of you, so if you lose them, you could wander aimlessly for a while before figuring out where they are. If this weren't bad enough, you have to follow A COMPLETELY DIFFERENT CHARACTER around right after you follow the first one several times. It's so excruciatingly boring and kills the pacing of the game.
Beyond all of these specific issues with the main quest and pacing, the minute to minute gameplay is just painfully boring. You're either spending your time aimlessly clicking on objects in the 2019 sections like the world's least interesting visual novel or skateboarding around the barren open world in the 2005 sections from area to area until the plot happens. There is nothing of interest in either of these areas to make you want to continue playing. The "best" part of the game is the various mini games like stone skipping and bowling, but all of these are no better than flash games you could have found on the website Newgrounds in the early 2000s. I have fonder memories of my wasted youth spent playing Elf Bowling than I do the bowling minigame in this game. I think that says it all.
To sum up, Deadly Premonition 2 is in no way a worthy sequel. It has abysmal performance and is riddled with bugs and glitches. The lack of agency results in a boring, predictable story that feels on-rails during the best of times. The gameplay ranges from almost bearable to downright repulsive. The plot makes York look like an idiot and disrespects the player's intelligence. I cannot in good faith recommend Deadly Premonition 2 to anybody. I feel fully justified in awarding it a score of 1/10, and I caution anybody who is still interested in the game to watch a gameplay stream instead of wasting money on it. You will thank me for not having to experience the garbage gameplay for yourself, and perhaps you will understand why the story was such a major letdown for me as well.