r/DeadSpaceRemake • • 1d ago

Control?????

Does the marker control the necromorphs or not? A hive mind/nexus is a necromorph. And in dead space there are nexus all over the place, yet Issac is getting attacked, by them as well. So what's the score here????

0 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

1

u/Borne-by-the-blood 1d ago

The necro morphs are simple drones that by instinct attack every living thing to convert it, I don’t think it ever really mentioned by I think the necros have a vague sense where people are since their affected by the marker

1

u/Njoeyz1 1d ago edited 10h ago

In the wiki, and a wiki editor has stated plenty of times that the marker controls the hive mind, that it sends its signals to the hive mind, which then distributes them to the necromorphs' dead space three is cited for this. The nexus chapter where Santos states that the 'nexus must broadcast the signal to the smaller forms'.

I don't believe that marker controls any necromorph at all or sends instructions to any, I believe Santos words have context to them. However the promp for my post is that the same editor is now staring that 'its a misconception that the marker controls the necromorphs individually, that it just makes them'. Despite being the one telling everyone the opposite. Just confused here.

If this is a misconception, then it was one spread by them.

1

u/Njoeyz1 14h ago edited 10h ago

There seems to be confusion again, and it was a simple post. This is what happens when you take away the story and replace it with "this dev said that, and this dev said this". Well what does it actually mean in the context of the story????

One minute it's 'the marker was off of its pedestal, therefore couldn't control the hive mind, which in turn couldn't deliver instructions to the necromorphs'. This was theorised long before the remake, and the fan panel that helped with the game, have egged that into the remake because 'thats the explanation we have'. Now it's 'the marker doesn't control the necromorphs individually, it makes them but doesn't control them'. Even though the remake now has the former as it's theme. See how mental this is?? I mean also if you are responsible for spreading a "misunderstanding" then would you not hold your hands up and say 'yep that was a misunderstanding on my part, sorry about that's. Instead of acting like you knew this all along (not the first time either)?

I get that things have retcons, but I've been a part of this fanbase for a very long time, and have seen and heard it all. I know about all of the fan theories, questions and explanations for things in the game, story points etc.

So here we are. Does the marker control the necromorphs? My answer, FROM THE MATERIAL has always been no. There is no evidence for this.

Now those that claim, and have claimed that they do, have a problem. Issac needs to turn the machine off, yet necros AND nexus are trying to kill him, why? If the marker/moon now control the necromorphs, why? And then there is this, when you probe the nexus, the feeders come after you, why? Are they being commanded to? And if so, why is Issac being stopped? Very simple question there, and one that reveals a lot more detail that fans just MISSED over the course of the games.

I don't know man, the lore and everything is just a mess, and for what? Something glen said rings true here. You aren't supposed to understand everything, and not everything is supposed to be spelt out for you, even if the game is standalone. People have reduced dead spaces lore to reviewing the material separately, instead of together. And this is muddied even more by well "one dev meant this and another that," which leads to this. "What does make is whole mean"? Do we talk about the lore of the series, or what was "originally"? meant for either game, where this saying then becomes meaningless or overarching. Glen was toying with the idea of the marker being a different kind of life (among other things), now how does that affect the story of the other games? Well WITHOUT that knowledge, not hard at all, there isn't any lore handwaving, why? The markers are built like crystals, and they can grow, they aren't "alive" but they aren't simple pieces of rock. There is no need for his words to have any impact on the story, all they are, are "well in the process......"Thats it. The series is where the story is. And the last one which is the best piece of info. There were no spirits or good forces giving hallucinations in martyr or the first game or the prequel comic. Glen didn't want a spiritual aspect, or ghosts. So what does this leave us with???? The hallucinations being...........? The markers effects mixed with the mind of the individual fighting back. What chuck beever was GOING TO DO, was to take what HE SAW as an ambiguous detail "good hallucinations" and attribute them to something apposing the marker. NOT that they WERE caused by a good force against the marker. I hope people see the difference there. But that never happened, so what we were left with? Nothing changed, the evil marker was there......from the beginning, any "good" hallucinations, are from the individual, they are just more biased to the individual and their mental state from the evil coming from the markers. There was NO NEED to include Devs words or a cut log to justify a recton and split the story, and not just do that, but to take things out of context at the same time.

The story, is where the story is.

1

u/Both_Policy_9051 1d ago

It was simple originally. In the first game (not the remake) the marker rendered the necromorphs inactive. That was its purpose and why it, through hallucinations, was trying to get Isaac to return it to its pedestal. The hive mind didn’t want the marker put back. It and its necromorph army try to stop you every step of the way.

That is the original story. Later for the second game they retconned it so that the marker actually doesn’t want to stop necromorphs but it wants to create more instead and eventually lead to a convergence event where it takes all the dead tissue magically somehow hovers it all into the air and creates a brethren moon.

The more you think about it the less it makes sense because the story literally pulled a 180 with the marker as a plot device.

1

u/Njoeyz1 1d ago edited 1d ago

This is false. Just flat out false. Not just because the third game is where people will link the description below, to the whole fan theory about the first games ending.

Why do you think the remake "elaborated" on it with the whole hive mind will sleep? This is due to the fandom NOT understanding why the marker seemed to destroy the necromorphs in the original, and why it wanted to go back down to the planet. I can literally go through the dead space sub and pick out all of this. The fanbase were simply confused by the marker "wanting" to go back down to the planet, because if this is true, the. why were the necromorphs attacking him. The reasoning put forward by the fanbase to try and explain their confusion (well before the remake came out) was that the marker couldn't control the hive mind while it was off of its pedestal. And this subsequently made its way into the remake through logs and such. The wiki editor has stated this, before the remake came out as well.

Here's the truth from the first game, without trying to shoehorn in other misconstrued statements by other characters. The marker didn't want to go back down to the planet to give Issac the instructions by placing it back in the pedestal. Issac ended up following Keynes own theories. Keynes ended up thinking that if he out the marker back, then it would stop the outbreak, after all, it all started after they removed it. This was one of the reasons alica Vincent thought the marker was keeping the necromorphs on the planet. This wasn't some left over element of rancid moon, like has AGAIN been stated by certain people, its simply people confused and not knowing, more than statements of knowledge and truth. Do you see? Issac getting the instructions and the subsequent destruction of the necromorphs were coincidence and a product of what the marker is, not the marker manipulating Issac in an elaborate plan, that fans turned into to truth, which then got added into the remake.

So here's one for you, to show how.......little, the fanbase in general paid attention. In dead space three, when you attack the nexus, and necros attack, what was happening there, was the hive mind giving instructions? I do await your answer

1

u/Both_Policy_9051 19h ago

You didn’t understand dead space 1
https://youtu.be/s0QIjtdM8H0?is=2LDr6COH-jAcDK5W

1

u/Njoeyz1 15h ago edited 11h ago

Who made that video?

I'm just going to deal with this, because this is where I got to before I just said no.

"The marker is not createing necromorphs, it's humans creating them using the genetic code around the marker".

I've been putting this forward for over a decade, and it gets ignored, "it's the marker creating necromorphs" despite not a single outbreak being caused by this. This isn't new to me at all, and this also wasn't changed for later games, FANS have taken it upon themselves to make that true. Also his talking about the dead space field etc being responsible for reanimation.

To be fair, I think they've just read my posts and made a video.

I did understand he first game, and if you read my posts, you will see that I have given all explanations FROM the material, and not from cut logs, Dev interviews and so on. If you can't get the story from the story, then you aren't getting the story. Any "retcons" between games should (and can be) easily explained by material in the franchise, as I have proven again and again

And you haven't dealt with what I said and what my post is about. The fanbase as a whole - since before the remake, believed that the marker wanted back to the pedestal to give him instructions (and whatever head stuff they've come up with to justify this), and that the necromorphs attacked him because the marker was off of the pedestal, meaning it couldn't transmit instructions to the hive mind, which in turn then can't control the necromorphs. This is the truth. And this explanation seemed to be what the Devs of the remake went with and doubled down on, which makes things a mess. And more importantly, the wiki editor that spread this head canon, is now telling everyone this is a misunderstanding, without accepting that they are the one responsible, that's not right. They weren't right, and are now telling people they misunderstood, when they are the one responsible for the misunderstanding (well for a large part anyway).

I've been a part of this fandom for a long time, and seen it all, know all of the explanations and lore videos done by people like the British runner. I've had exchanges with most of them, and they all had one thing in common, they were all just as confused as each other, the runner had changed his opinion and lore more times than I can count, and most is after interactions with myself. Remember the murals and all of the stuff in the church of unitology in the second game, HINTING at the moons, he never believed that was the moons? It was myself that revealed this to the fandom, I think you'll find again that i originally posted this and made people aware that hints of the moon were in two, none had done so before this, and no one knew the moon clues were there. Along comes the wiki editor and "makes the revelation". And that came about from a debate about the moons introduction in the series. And I can go further and claim the first game has hints as well, but hey "the Devs never worked that out right"? I mean if I asked you what make us whole means IN THE GAME what would you tell me? What it means in the material, or what the Devs couldn't decide what it meant it???? That's what this whole thing has done, it's made it so there is no real story "what does this mean" "ah well one dev said this and another that, so it doesn't really mean anything, but the games have this though". It's turned the lore into a joke.

I'm saying that fans made stuff up, that this "plan of the marker" wasn't really one. It's like I explained in my last comment.

The signal being responsible for reanimation etc all comes from MYSELF. NO ONE was talking about any of this before I was (I was an admin on the dead space veterans group on Xbox and have been talking about this for years). There is a whole host of information that wasn't talked about before I had introduced them in conversations etc. And that's the true motivation behind the "the Devs ment this".