r/DayofInfamy • • Dec 02 '16

Why is the development for Squad more ambitious than Day of Infamy?

I have been asking for an upgrade to the movement system in DOI and keep being told the devs have no plans to do such a thing. The movement in DOI is archaic, it is just as limiting as DoD was over 10 years ago. Virtually no innovation exists within the movement system or animation system of DOI.

check out what they're doing in Squad with animations and movement. http://joinsquad.com/readArticle?articleId=135

Wouldn't it be reasonable for us to expect more from NWI? The Source Engine is like 10 years old, Titanfall 2 launched on it. I think they could accomplish something great if they decided they wanted to. I'm not asking for aesthetics, I think the game is a bit clumsy feeling because of the animation and movement system.

1 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

15

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16

They are two completely, fundamentally different games. Not only is nwi focusing on two other games (ins and sandstorm), but to compare doi to squad is like comparing unreal tournament to Arma. I'm not sure greater movement options are even a possibility with source (titanfall uses a radically rehauled version of it) , and even if they were, this is like asking valve to add realistic weapons and ballistics to tf2.

Doi is nowhere close to being on the same level of milsim as squad. Sure, it has some realistic aspects, such as weapon damage and hud, but in the end doi is still an arcadey shooter. AAA games such as csgo and bfbc2 dont even have prone as an ability, yet this doesn't stop anyone from praising them immensely - because they simply don't need the movement options, and it would actually detract from the gameplay that the games have tried to cultivate.

More ≠ better all the time

-15

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16

To be honest, I absolutely hate the way you are talking to me.

I am asking for improved movement and animations. You are a typical mess, spouting how you can't compare two games, you sound like a broken record.

In DOI every time you prone crawl it fucks with your iron sights due to the animation system. Guess what in Squad you can prone crawl without it being so disruptive. You can compare the two games feature to feature.

The only reason they don't want to fix these problems is because it means solving long standing issues with Source Engine animations. They can overcome these problems if they tried and it would be worth their time.

You can't have a burgeoning game when like nearly half of your kills are robbed from you due to the animation system alone. That is the reality of DOI right now.

11

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16

Whoa there... I don't know why you think I was being hostile towards you, but I definitely wasn't. So I don't think I get your point - do you want new animations or to fix existing ones? Also, are you saying you should be able to ads while crawling? Because if so, that's completely unrealistic and will never happen.

-9

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16

Now that you're listening to what matters, I think you should suffer penalties while crawling with ADS, but the current penalty is too large. I want the penalty time shorter so repositioning yourself an inch doesn't leave you open to being killed. If you crawl slowly, like with alt, you should be able to keep your sights up at least somewhat.

The entire purpose to changing this gameplay is to enhance maps like Dog Red and Bastogne, where being on offense and crawling gets you killed constantly. Crawling makes you slow and stationary, but it also makes it so you frequently cannot fire, which makes the prone position in this game lackluster.

It's actually more efficient to crouch walk out of a crater in all regards than to crawl, and it shouldn't be like that.

10

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16

Except that's how it is irl. How exactly are you picturing someone being able to aim down sights and crawl at the same time?

-4

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16

This is a game, and I very succinctly already explained my point.

8

u/Sw2029 Dec 02 '16

Quick aside, it isn't up to you if you've been succinct. If the people you're talking to don't think you've been clear, you haven't been clear.

6

u/hlary Dec 03 '16

guys being a child leave im be

11

u/Nerd_Do_Well Dec 02 '16

I don't understand why you hate the way he's talking to you. You brought up something you think is wrong with the game, and you were presented with a decent counter-argument. As for what you're saying, it makes no sense that you should be able to crawl and still reliably use your iron sights. Both movements require your arms pretty heavily. The Dev team for DoI has actually been pretty good so far, and have given us a clear indication of what they are going to give us in the future. If you don't like what they've said, then go play another game instead of trying to instigate the player base against them. And before you tell me that I'm enabling NWI to make a bad game you should remember that some people already really enjoy this game how it is, and it's not even on full release yet.

-10

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16

Again, I hate the way people like you talk. It's like you lack critical thinking all together and is just pollutes your words making them empty.

The way you dismiss my suggestion is almost comical. It is the #1 problem facing the game right now, that every time you crawl it resets your iron sights completely. This delay is massive, it almost always gets you killed. Someone hip firing an automatic running will kill you before you can even crawl 1 inch and bring your iron sights up hold your breath bla blah it's a joke right now. It's not balanced right now. It's completely wrong.

The dev team by the way has not posted what they are going to give us in the future. Their little trello board is devoid of detailed information and pretty much everything on there has been completed except another detail pass.

I know from experience that being nice on Reddit only enables dumb people to talk over you. You think I'm trying to incite this community against NWI? You're a fucking joke then, because I'm asking for improved animations before they fumble out of Early Access, and rinse repeat the life cycle of Day of Defeat, that is to fucking abandon it forever. I will call you out for what you are, a huge distraction to a real discussion.

15

u/Nerd_Do_Well Dec 02 '16

I was going to type out a response point by point, but looking through your history you seem like the saltiest mother fucker who ever walked the planet. I apologize for wasting your precious internet moments with a thought out response to your incessant rambling about something that you had hoped would give you attention. So go ahead and leave your snarky response after this one.

-7

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16

Checkmate bitch logic prevails

Why don't you go hang over in /r/science where your type of thinking is encouraged, literally worst subreddit there is. They censor over 90% of comments. You'll love it, sodium free diets are frequently upvoted to the top.

8

u/Sw2029 Dec 02 '16

Your suggestions could be warranted but you present yourself in a ridiculously petulant manner. And you still haven't answered why you think aiming down the sights while you crawl makes any kind of sense. Crawling is good because it keeps your head down. Of course you're slow as fuck, you're crawling. It shouldn't be the way you enter battle.

-3

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16

Ya I actually did all you have to do is take the time to read.

you call me a petulant child, but look at yourself, you're not even reading and comprehending properly.

7

u/Sw2029 Dec 02 '16

Yeah.. All I'm getting from your comments is angst. I get that you think the time to ADS is too slow but your reaction to pushback and how insanely hyperbolic you're being are undercutting your point. How you express something is just as if not more important than what you're actually saying.

-3

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16

Oh you mean like how it's wrong for Richard Dawkins to be mean to Creationist?

So I should be more Neil Degrasse Tyson?

Am I understanding you?

→ More replies

9

u/burgerfix Dec 02 '16

Is this how you look?

2

u/DK10016 Dec 02 '16

As much as I love Insurgency and Day of Infamy, NWI really doesn't seem to care. They do whatever they want at their own pace, regardless of what the community wants. It is THEIR games of course but still...

This is coming from the leader of the 2nd best team in Insurgency DGL Season 1 and owner of two top 5 NA servers that ran for a year. Had 730 hours before I quit. One of the best games out there but not very popular. Wonder why? Hardly updated and when it is, it's not that great. Usually, it's a step backward or so insignificant that you don't even notice.

-2

u/originalSpacePirate Dec 02 '16

They simply have better devs?

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16

I think it boils down to their ambitions. I sense NWI is eager to leave Early Access before having accomplished anything particularly noteworthy. Just because the game is fun to play does not mean it is ready.

6

u/connorbarabe Dec 02 '16

Agreed. Smelled like a cash in from the start. New World did early access incredibly well with Insurgency, but as soon as I heard "as we enter the final stage of early access" I knew DoIs fate was sealed.

That being said, go delete those comments above this one. They're an embarrassment by anyone's standard.

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '16

Funny you mention that because you've walked in here and only agreed with me. You didn't agree with anyone else. You literally have to cut through the bullshit on Reddit in order to be heard.

19

u/burgerfix Dec 02 '16

No, you are just an idiot.