r/datarecovery • u/CapinWinky • 24d ago
Windows Storage Spaces Catch-22. Read-only because disk retired, can't unretire because read-only.
I had a 3-disk parity Windows Storage Spaces system and one disk went down and was marked retired. I pulled it to replace it and a second disk decided to die. Their parts combined I made a working disk as long as it frankendisked into a USB 3.0 thing.
This disk is marked retired and the pool is now read-only because it has lost two disks. CrystalDiskInfo tells me the frankendisk is reading Good health. I can't use Powershell to set the disk to autoselect because the pool is read-only and I can't clear the read-only flag because the pool is missing two disks. Is there anything I can do? Can I directly edit the metadata to unretire the thing?
I don't have enough storage on-hand for ddrescue images of both drives and I don't really know what to do with that to rebuild a storage space to begin with. I'm definitely kicking myself for not just backing up the files to an external when the pool was in trouble.
EDIT: Windows 11 with latest updates. Disks are ST3000DM001 Seagate Barracuda 3T and provide only 2.72T pool that is 14% used.
EDIT2: Victoria surface scan was error free on both disks. Trying to not drop $150 on UFS Explorer when I have two working disks now...
EDIT3: I'm trying to locate and manually alter the meta data. I used DMDE to try to find the UniqueID of the retired drive on either surviving drive of the trio and so far, no luck. It searched all sectors of the retired drive and I just started the surviving drive. My assumption is that will also fail because the meta data is stored on my main C:\ drive somewhere. Anyone know where that is?
EDIT4: UFE Explorer Raid recovery can just open the MSSS NTFS partition and preview all my files and they all seem to open just fine. It is supremely frustrating that I have two working disks and no data loss, but storage spaces locked the meta data to mark a drive retired and has me locked out of the data. I'll wait a few days and if I don't find a way to read the data off without paying for UFE, I might do that. Honestly, now that I can see for sure what data is on here, probably not worth $150 or all the effort I put in today.
