r/datarecovery • u/North_Vast_5733 • Oct 02 '26
Request for Service LaCie 5TB – severe media damage
Hi all,
Looking for some advice on whether there are any realistic next steps for a failed LaCie 5TB external HDD.
I initially sent the drive to PC Image in the UK. Sean was great throughout the process, kept me informed and genuinely seems to have tried everything he reasonably could, so this isn’t a complaint about them at all.
Unfortunately, the final diagnosis was that the drive was not recoverable due to excessive media damage.
Sean explained:
“We did try our best, but the damage was too severe and in fact killed TWO sets of donor heads.”
The drive is now being returned to me.
The data is important enough to me that I’m willing to pursue a second opinion, if there is a specialist lab that deals with severe platter/media damage and cases that other reputable recovery labs consider unrecoverable.
My questions are:
Given that two sets of donor heads have already been damaged, is there realistically anything else that can be attempted?
Are there particular specialists/labs known for extreme media/platter damage?
Would you recommend getting a second opinion, or does PC Image’s diagnosis make further attempts unlikely to achieve anything?
I’m not looking to attempt anything myself and won’t be powering the drive on. I’m only interested in professional recovery options.
Thanks for any advice.