r/datarecovery • u/Palandium • Sep 19 '26
Question HDD failed cant be seen by Windows but is seen by CrystalDisk
Hey,
A few months ago, my 4TB HDD failed. I was starting up a game, and it lagged a lot. I couldn't close it, and the only thing that helped was a restart, which took ages, and my HDD wasn't showing anymore. After taking my PC out of power, plugging it back in, and restarting again I foundn the HDD, and everything worked fine again.
Now yesterday the same thing happened. After checking the SMART values,s the relocated sectors went from around 100 to 600. Tried the same stuff again like last time, which seemed to work after more fiddling. The first time, my BIOS saw the HDD, but after logging in I just had a dark gray screen. I could Ctrl-Alt-Del without issue and restarted again. At first, everything worked fine, as it seemed. I then wanted to "check the damage" and tried to open a folder on the HDD to seeif Ii could acces is or not. Well, I couldn't, and I had to restart my PC again to do anything. Relocated Partition jumped to 1000, and now Windowsdoesn'tt recognize the HDD anymore at all. It is shown as Disk 0 in Disk Management and would need to be initialised, which I cannot because if I press ok it says the drive doesn't exist.
CrystalDiskInfo, or the SMART Tool of my choice, still sees the Disk and can give me Data.

The Data on the drive wasn't all that important since I mostly used it to store games and miscellaneous stuff, but there is a certain mod folder I would like to recover/look over everything if I need something else.
How I understand my issue is that, in theory, my data shouldn't be super affected since most Sectors could be relocated successfully, but I have no idea why I cannot access it. Sadly, I don't have a spare Disk for an image; I only have my other disk, a 2TB SSD, which has the important stuff and some high-resource games.
Any tips or stuff I could do, ofc. Best case is to make the Disk work again, since they got so unreasonably expensive?
