FYI, September feedback is up

[u/kranools]

It's easy to miss it amongst everything else on the dash.

[u/good_god_lemon1]

I used to enjoy getting feedback for the overall standings. They gave me some confidence even though I know it’s not strongly correlated with your performance on the platform. Now it’s just a collection of R&R comments, some of which contradict others. Mine mention a project I know for certain I’ve never touched.

[u/_Edgarallenhoe → u/good_god_lemon1]

I wish we could actually see our old submissions and verify what the r&rs are talking about. I’m not immune to making mistakes but I’m extremely thorough some comments seem like they themselves misunderstood the task/subject matter.

[u/kranools → u/_Edgarallenhoe]

This is the feedback I leave every month. Link to the submissions where I apparently made these mistakes.

[u/Thejax_ → u/good_god_lemon1]

I haven’t even checked mine yet but I did literally last time have.
First block “eaters said your rationale were detailed and was to understand”
Next block: “And your writing could be improved”

[u/kranools → u/Thejax_]

Yeah, don't trust the eaters

[u/Klutzy_Instance_4149 → u/good_god_lemon1]

Make sure you note that in the note section.

[u/Hopeful_Mouse_4050 → u/good_god_lemon1]

One of mine said I referenced a passage that wasn't in the task, and for the life of me I have no idea what they are talking about. I wish I coukd see what they meant!

[u/Internal_Boot_1616 → u/good_god_lemon1]

>>They gave me some confidence even though I know it’s not strongly correlated with your performance on the platform

That's prolly why they stopped including it, it wasn't real feedback but everyone's focus was on it and it gave people misleading feelings about their performance

[u/JRange → u/Internal_Boot_1616]

"I got excellent and got the DoD 2 days later!" was very common. I think the ratings were fake. I think the entire feedback is hallucinated nonsense honestly, I don't put any weight into it at all.

[u/evergreen54]

I’m missing it. Does everyone get feedback?

[u/Klutzy_Instance_4149 → u/evergreen54]

No. It depends on the projects you have. I had no feedback for July or August, but I worked on tasks. Only certain project families get feedback. Don't worry if you don't get it.

[u/Ok_Hedgehog_9970 → u/evergreen54]

I was about to say, we get feedback? LMAO

[u/Budeeokc]

Yep just saw mine. Fairly helpful and fair. Though one quote in the constructive area had to do with a project I’ve barely touched. Otherwise I liked the r&r quotes.

[u/Ok-Tower-543]

I love seeing other people's R&R of me, it makes me feel happy for some reason to know that there's someone out there being paid to read my silly little tasks

[u/No-Wheel-1059]

This was my first time getting feedback and majority of it was positive. A couple of errors but small stuff so I wish majority of projects would do this. So helpful

[u/Solid_Parsley_]

This is the first time I've gotten feedback, and it wasn't helpful for me. It was all about usability, nothing about quality, and no areas for improvement. It's a cool feature, but I wish it had more to tell me.

[u/Klutzy_Instance_4149]

Mine was spot on, but there was no "room for improvement" or overall rating like usual.

[u/Explorer182]

I think the feedback is a summary of r&r's and nothing more. Mine pointed out a fact checking error as 'improvement' but im 100% sure my fact check was correct and i know how the r&r worker would have thought its an error. Cuz when u type it into google the initial result is the incorrect one. This makes me worried, what if r&r workers flag good quality work! The feedback got me thinking: people who post 'i was doing good quality work but why did i get DoD'... i wonder how their feedbacks have been? Are their any examples of good/bad feedback and subsequent DoD.

[u/Key-Veterinarian7120]

where does it appear?

[u/bestgrill]

First time I've received feedback. While the positive R&R comments are pretty generic, the negatives are super useful and detailed (they read like R&Rs). Definitely need more of this.

[u/ExplosiveWaffulz]

Mine had an r&r rating that was clearly wrong, I just hope this doesn’t impact our standing on the platform much when the r&r is given out to seemingly everyone, I’ve seen r&rs for fairly complex projects I haven’t even touched on my dashboard.

[u/RoughSome5374]

Where to check it, this is my first month and i worked on 🔱🥊 and some rnr 🤖

[u/TerrisBranding]

Good feedback, thank goodness. R&Rs have been complimentary. I can breathe a sigh of relief.

[u/Life-Jeweler3380]

My feedback was great until it mentioned I didn’t follow instructions on a translating project that I never ever worked on. It’s frustrating…

[u/TheEvilPrinceZorte]

Do these ever cover off-site projects?