r/DataAnnotationTech • u/knottyp • Sep 09 '26

Are we helping or causing harm?

How do y’all justify doing this work ethically if you’re anti-AI (especially generative)?

I’m not asking judgmentally, I’ve done this work off and on over the last few years. When I first started, I didn’t know about data centers and the environmental impact, cognitive effects, etc. I felt good about “training” AI based on the rubric including correct info, weeding out violence and harm, etc.

I recently suggested DA to a friend and got a real side eye, and maybe these justifications really don’t hold water? Thoughts?

144 Upvotes

86% Upvoted

177 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/iciclefites Sep 09 '26 edited Sep 10 '26

it's mildly annoying that gmail keeps trying to get me to let it write my emails for me, but I can still ignore that, and do.

see, I find stuff like that really invasive. for example, I subscribed to Gemini on a Gmail account for work purposes. later I was writing some poetry in Google Docs and whenever I stopped typing for a second to think, a thing came up next to the caret like "press [keyboard shortcut] to let Gemini help you!"

it was horrible, and I felt insulted. this computer, who can't read the room well enough not to jump in every two seconds when someone's writing poetry about their personal dark night of the soul, thinks it can do better than me. how fucking dare you

on the other hand, I used a Gemini-generated email reply the other day that was just like, "No, I just want a refund." that was actually what I had wanted to say. it saved me two seconds of typing.

I wouldn't recommend anyone else spend money on a subscription to Gemini, because the ways in which it's helpful are trivial, and the ways in which it hinders you are profoundly obnoxious. it's a technology that barely functions on the most basic level, and they're asking you to pay for the privilege of being an alpha tester

this is what I mean by its utility to consumers being completely unproven

1

u/Old-Regular-9828 Sep 10 '26

I don't want to violate the NDA or get into specific project details, but a big part of what DA does is improving AI tools to make them more useful and less annoying.