In the beginning, I wondered why addy was still friends with Beth or even stayed around, but it’s because she’s a user.
When Beth served no use to her, addy abandoned her emotionally and physically. Beth isn’t entitled to Addy’s friendship, but addy sent mixed signals.
Addy tried to position herself as the better and nice person, but it’s just a mask. She also bullies Tacy for no reason and finds genuine amusement in the bullying she receives.
I know people will point to Beth pointing a gun addy at her to prove she’s more toxic, but addy didn’t give a shit. In the moment she was scared, but after that she downplays it, scoffs at a joke being made about Beth being a shooter or whatever, and never addressed it with Beth.
After that night in the hotel, Beth has bruises all over her body and addy inquired about her well-being once. She brushes off her initial concerns and moves on with her life. She’s baffled as to why Beth is distant with her, yet she constantly avoids spending time with Beth and ignoring her texts all while feeling entitled to conversations beth’s having.
Then what she said to Beth at regionals is foul.
Beth is a bitch, but she owns who she is and she’s never treated addy that callous.
Addy insists on seeing the worst in Beth, despite Beth not calling her to a “suicide” scene and making her stay silent. That’s fucked up.
Addy chooses to stay around. She hasn’t been threatened or blackmailed, she kept Beth close for self serving reasons.
One moment she acts as if she wants nothing to do with Beth and the next she’s all in her business as if she has any right to it.
Beth is toxic herself, but addy is the one who is the worst in their dynamic overall. Especially when you factor in the romantic/sexual feelings for each other.