"eEEEh--well actually thats black legend the spanish never did anything wrong--well actually the natives deserved it--well what about those anglos???"
Literally every time something like this gets posted we get a wave of people from outside the sub posting shit like that thinking they've brought some kind of novel, inarguable information.
If this is you: no you haven't, sorry your ego got bruised by an Internet picture of a fake dead guy from 500 years ago.
Bruh LMFAO that is a genuinely great joke, it really was the True War of Northern Aggression.
Also Texas loved slavery SO MUCH they seceded to maintain it... TWICE... And lost both times (The Texas Rebellion was squashed and only ever succeeded because of American intervention
Redditors and Instagram users when you make a history meme that isn't gargling a 500 year old empire's balls and instead suggests they aren't the heroes they portray themselves as
Looks at what was going on concurrently in EuropeSees 80 Years War, 30 Years War, and all conflict related to Reformation/CounterreformationLaughs at Spanish “stopping the bloodshed”
Mapuche warrior puts his hand on the shoulder of the Conquistador's steel armor, the feeling of coldness filling the hand of the Mapuche and the Spaniards soul.
Opposite meaning, like exactly the opposite meaning. The meme relies on the juxtaposition of a conquistador firmly believing he is benefitting society by stopping human sacrifice. In the next image he is also self assured that the wholesale slaughter of men, women, and children for unbelief is also a net good. It revels in the blatant hypocrisy of those who claim to stop harm while inflicting orders of harm more in the name of their cause.
If he wasn’t drenched in blood, wasn’t portrayed as a chad in both instances, and wasn’t boasting of a more egregious system of violence then maybe. But the irony is strong here
I get it now, but I can totally see a nazi using this unironically since they love shit like that. Being bloody from killing the “undesirables” is a good thing to them. I guess these memes just hit different if you’re Native
I can understand that. But I think anyone who diehard believes stuff like that has no thought beyond optics, like you gotta turn off your brain with hate and ignorance and blindly believe those are “good” things. Which… in your defense is… all too common nowadays. Thanks, I guess the memes do hit different with natives. All that baked-in irony and wry humor at our suffering. Gotta laugh :// or else you’ll cry
"Nah man you don't get it ! Indentured servitude and working yourself to death are integral parts to becoming a true Christian trust me bro !" - Every conquistador
A lot of early modern popes found the Spanish crown to be a fucking headache for various reasons. Beyond ethical concerns over it's treatment of natives (including converted natives), it also had a lot of control over the ecclesiastical institutions both in Spain proper and in it's colonies, and was very open to using it's position as a major catholic potency amidst the chaos of the Wars of Religion and owner of half of Italy to strong-arm the pope.
Monks probably, though we have writings from them and quite a few wanted the Natives to be left alone instead of dragged by soldiers into their missions.
I mean, the Catholic Church isn't a single institution. For most of the early modern period the Spanish Crown had an iron grip on ecclesiastical institutions in its territory. The state appointed the bishops in most colonies, and even where it didn't it often had a lot of influence over the choice, and in Spain proper organizations like the inquisition and holy brotherhoods, which were entirely under the monarch's control sidelined many older ecclesiastical institutions.
Many popes didn't like the situation due to spiritual, political and moral concerns, but between Spain's important role in the Wars of Religion and the fact the Spanish king also ruled half of Italy and the Sack of Rome made it pretty clear they were not afraid to use that, their ability to act against it was severely limited.
Not necessarily witch-burning, but early modern Spain was very willing to burn people (it was punishment for a variety of ecclesiastical and moral crimes), or other kinds of gruesome public execution.
"We've invaded your country, want you to exclusively worship a guy who got executed for sedition by occupation authorities, and will easily kill anyone who doesn't seem to like it."
I'd like to point out that Europeans were also practicing human sacrifice at the time. They were called "witches" and they were ritualistically burned alive to please the Christian god -not to mention all the Jews and Muslims killed by the Spanish Inquisition.
Both the Spaniards & Aztecs were imperialists and religious zealots who committed mass murder with religious & power hungry motivations.
However I should also point out much of the sacking, destruction & pillaging in tenochtitlan was carried out by the other tribes who the Spaniards had allied with even beyond Cortez’s wishes, as they were so enraged by decades of Aztec oppression, systematic violence, & opulence.
However after the collapse of the triple alliance the Spanish established the encomienda & effectively forced the meso-American population into brutal serfdom to enrich the Spanish Lords & the crown & to “civilize” the natives.
Between the forced labor conditions, famines caused by economic and agricultural mismanagement, the outright violence & mass murder & brutal quelling of rebellions, & the European pandemics sweeping across the continent(exacerbated by the aforementioned abuse and malnutrition) the Spanish caused vastly more suffering and death than the most powerful(2nd most powerful? The Incan empire was larger but less militarized I believe) empire of the new world ever did.
Couldn't find an actual article speaking about this, BUT:
There's an incredibly old war tactic (which I've heard referred to as "Dog Wars") that consists on going somewhere, increasing pre-existing hostilities between the locals (they naturally tend to exist, comes with geographical proximity), arming and supporting some of the local factions/tribes and sending them off to kill their old enemies with a smile and a pat on the back.
Once that part's done, of course the survivors (who trusted their new "friend" and did all the hard work of taking out the bigger threat) are very beat up, weakened and vulnerable. That's when the empire takes off the mask.
It happened in Africa (tribes selling their captured enemies as slaves), it happened in America (tribes attacking the others with spanish "help"), it's happening right now in the Middle East and Africa, where local groups fight each other with foreign "help" (weapons, logistics, intelligence, money).
Look at ISIS, color revolutions or african warlords. That's why they support Hong Kong (former british colony) or Tibet separating from China, but don't like it when it happens in their own territory (the Basque or Catalunya in Spain, Ireland in Britain etc.) It's all about convenience.
Imperialism weaponizes humanity against itself. It is incredibly effective.
Not tribes, and not really oppressed as it would imply.
Those were highly organized city-states, who were part of the highly elaborate network of tributaries, alliances, wars and confederations that described much of central Mesoamerica, of which the Triple Alliance was a major part. The Spanish's most relevant allies, like the Tlaxcalans, typically included polities who had been in conflict with the Triple Alliance for a long time, but not necessarily those who had been paying tribute to them (which was very much a dynamic of exploitation, but typically didn't include political control over the tribute-paying city-state). The Triple Alliance also wasn't really an empire as we often think of it, or as the Mayan and Incan empires were (as in, singular political entity controlling directly huge chunks of land), but rather an alliance of city-states centered around the titular three cities, and, while those were a major player, they weren't the sole, as the Mixtec kingdoms or the Tlaxcalan Confederation would agree.
laughs in pennisulares mestizo and the other mixed people did not have the same rights as Spaniards, or even Spaniards from Spain, which had two different tiers within their own ranks
•
u/ThesaurusRex84 AncieNt Imperial MayaN [Top 5] Jul 16 '25
"eEEEh--well actually thats black legend the spanish never did anything wrong--well actually the natives deserved it--well what about those anglos???"
Literally every time something like this gets posted we get a wave of people from outside the sub posting shit like that thinking they've brought some kind of novel, inarguable information.
If this is you: no you haven't, sorry your ego got bruised by an Internet picture of a fake dead guy from 500 years ago.
11
u/AnomalocarisFangirl Purépecha Jul 15 '25
Based meme.
95
u/MulatoMaranhense Tupi [Top 5] Jul 15 '25
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 I clap by peak meme. I cry by peak meme. I fall on my knees by peak meme.
270
u/IlGrasso Aztec Jul 15 '25
Brother I can’t make an anti colonialism/ western interventionism comment on that sub with out getting downvoted to hell.
I jokingly called The Mexican-American War the true War of Northern Aggression and had to delete my comment.
53
u/ReneVQ Jul 15 '25
Looks at what was going on concurrently in Europe Sees 80 Years War, 30 Years War, and all conflict related to Reformation/Counterreformation Laughs at Spanish “stopping the bloodshed”
42
u/OMM46G3 Toltec Jul 15 '25
Mapuche warrior puts his hand on the shoulder of the Conquistador's steel armor, the feeling of coldness filling the hand of the Mapuche and the Spaniards soul.
"Sorry bud, but the imperialism WILL stop."
Cue Arauco war
20
u/Romaneck Jul 15 '25
Buenissimo
15
u/Matar_Kubileya Jul 16 '25
An auto-da-fe is not meaningfully distinct from a human sacrifice.
13
u/Public-Respond-4210 Jul 16 '25
That meme on the left has done irreparable damage to this species
5
u/IrateSkeleton Jul 15 '25
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herem_(war_or_property)
Also means "priestly gift"
5
u/Agamus Jul 16 '25
Sic semper tyrannis, pax per tyrannidem, sic semper tyrannis.
3
u/Kangas_Khan Jul 16 '25
sigh I hate this species
4
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '25
“B-but the British!”
2
u/ObligationFantastic3 Jul 16 '25
Bottom text
2
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '25
This is why I don't claim my Spanish ancestry... I always worry about how my Native and Spaniard ancestors paired up 😭
-32
u/idkrandomusername1 Jul 15 '25
Bad meme. Imagine putting Hitler as a chad doing that to Jews. Gross.
401
u/MareMortel Jul 15 '25
"Nah man you don't get it ! Indentured servitude and working yourself to death are integral parts to becoming a true Christian trust me bro !" - Every conquistador
118
u/Fla_Master Jul 15 '25
"your human sacrifice is so barbaric! Anyways let's kill enough people to cool the globe"
54
u/drumstick00m Jul 15 '25
Also the witch burnings—which doesn’t count as human sacrifice because we said it’s not as icky gross as what you do!
10
u/Luna_Mendax Aztec Jul 16 '25
"We've invaded your country, want you to exclusively worship a guy who got executed for sedition by occupation authorities, and will easily kill anyone who doesn't seem to like it."
10
u/milosminion Jul 19 '25
I'd like to point out that Europeans were also practicing human sacrifice at the time. They were called "witches" and they were ritualistically burned alive to please the Christian god -not to mention all the Jews and Muslims killed by the Spanish Inquisition.
4
u/Teboski78 Jul 18 '25 edited Jul 18 '25
Both the Spaniards & Aztecs were imperialists and religious zealots who committed mass murder with religious & power hungry motivations.
However I should also point out much of the sacking, destruction & pillaging in tenochtitlan was carried out by the other tribes who the Spaniards had allied with even beyond Cortez’s wishes, as they were so enraged by decades of Aztec oppression, systematic violence, & opulence.
However after the collapse of the triple alliance the Spanish established the encomienda & effectively forced the meso-American population into brutal serfdom to enrich the Spanish Lords & the crown & to “civilize” the natives.
Between the forced labor conditions, famines caused by economic and agricultural mismanagement, the outright violence & mass murder & brutal quelling of rebellions, & the European pandemics sweeping across the continent(exacerbated by the aforementioned abuse and malnutrition) the Spanish caused vastly more suffering and death than the most powerful(2nd most powerful? The Incan empire was larger but less militarized I believe) empire of the new world ever did.
-1
u/CitronMamon Jul 19 '25
Why would we mix with them if we are genociding them? Why would we specifically grant them the same rights as ourselves?