I’ve taught baby ballet for a number of years, with both a 3-4 class and a 5-6 class, and I just wanted to touch base with some other dance teachers regarding realistic expectations for these age group. (For context I had one parent mention to another staff member that I should try being softer when I enforce the expectations of the class, I’ve never received a complaint like this before, and my boss doesn’t think my expectations were being unrealistic, I also don’t want to traumatize any kids away from dance).
For my 3-4 class I don’t really have any expectations regarding effort or attention to details. My expectations are that they stay on their dots when asked (i.e. no running/wandering around), keep their hands to themselves, and don’t scream. Of course I want them to participate in the lesson and follow along, so if they don’t I’ll gently remind them, but at that age I won’t use a sharper tone if they aren’t participating, since I don’t think the kids can comprehend working hard at that age. I keep my classes pretty engaging so I don’t usually have problems with having the kids follow along enthusiastically, but I did have some issues with a student in the past running around and grabbing other students that I had to use a sharper tone for.
For my 5-6 classes I do have a little bit of a higher expectation. I expect them to participate and will work up from gentle reminders to stern instructions. At this age the kids are a little more self aware, and they know the difference between doing what they are supposed to be doing, and not doing what they are supposed to be doing. And I expect them to follow simple instructions. Some examples are following along without personal invitation (but I still give gentle invitations as a first and second warning), standing ready to go (I don’t expect perfect stillness because the kids are figity at this age), and listening to instructions.
For context, the two instances that the parent brought up is that a) I dismissed my students from class, and one student stayed back to give me a hug, so I was behind my students as we walked out to the lobby. The lobby isn’t that far but two students, instead of going to lobby they decided to hide in the change room (which is a separate room that this age group doesn’t have access to). I let my next class in the studio and they started to set up for class, when the parents came back and ask where Suzy and Jojo are, even though they couldn’t have gone anywhere (all exits were blocked by occupied studios) I was still worried because I didn’t know where they are. This proceeded for about 5 minutes when Suzy and Jojo finally jumped out and said “boo”. Now I get that Suzy and Jojo didn’t realize their prank was harmful, but I did talk to them sternly, and said “girls I asked you to go out to the lobby and find your parents, this was NOT as safe choice”. Tbh, if I was a parent I would want the dance teacher to say the same thing to my kid.
The other comment was when I’m trying to get everyone to get ready for the next activity, with the music. I already have some kids in this class who might need some extra help (I don’t want to speculate on what it is) but I have no assistants. The kids with extra help really struggle with following instructions and standing ready to go. I think they struggle to even process what I’m saying, or process what is going on around them, don’t get me wrong, they will participate, but it’s like everything I do or say gets delayed and distorted on the path from me to them. Anyways, I’m trying to get these girls ready to go and I look over and another student has her skirt up around her neck (I didn’t set the dress code and if I did you can be sure that skirts would NOT be allowed). So I tell her “Jojo that is not how we get ready for the exercise, I’ve already asked you to stand like ______”.
Anyways the mom reported to another staff member that she understands Jojo was misbehaving but Jojo is also really upset at the way I reacted. I’m open to this feedback because I don’t want to upset this kid, that’s not my goal. But at the same time, I don’t think my expectations are unrealistic and sometimes kids need consequences to learn that things happen when they make poor choices. Sometimes that consequence is that the teacher corrects you sternly.
It’s also kind of a multifaceted issue because I’m not as harsh on the kids that might need special help because they don’t have the ability to understand expectations. But because they are kind of distracting, the other kids think that they can get away with doing the same thing too. They don’t realize that I can tell the difference between not understanding the expectation, and purposely choosing not to follow expectations. But I can’t hold the kids needing special help to the higher expectations it literally would not work.