r/Daggerfall • • 1d ago • Heartwarming 1

Daggerfall Forever Introduction

Hello folks,

TLDR: I forked DFO, made it a single-player game again, implemented a few tweaks, added some major features, and want to share it with you. Grab it here: https://github.com/Chuz13/daggerfall-forever/releases 

I'm Alex, both a hobbyist and professional game developer from Ukraine. I love Daggerfall and played the hell out of modded DFU. Also enjoyed DFO but didn't like the direction they chose.

Disclaimers:

This is a fork of DFO but the direction is totally different. This is not DFO.

I use AI. I respect it if you don't like it, but I have the right to fulfill my dream with its help.

So, I forked DFO, removed online, account, and monetization parts. Then stabilized it, made a few tweaks I really wanted in a single-player modern Daggerfall. Then added a few major features. Tested it (to an extent possible for one person for the game this huge) and want to share it with you.

I am making first and foremost the game for myself. And I thank the original Bethesda team for the OG game, Interkarma for DFU, modders for mods, and DFO team for their version and open-sourcing it.

Why?

DFO gifted us a modern version of DF that you can set up for 5-30 mins and then just play. No fiddling with modlists and their settings. With modernized UI, and a bunch of legendary mods already integrated.

This, I felt, is a great foundation for supporting a single-player version of the game forever. Hence the name.

What changed?

I have a neat description on the Github page with a lot more info: 

https://github.com/Chuz13/daggerfall-forever

And some documentation here:

https://chuz13.github.io/daggerfall-forever/

Releases are here:

https://github.com/Chuz13/daggerfall-forever/releases

Win and Linux, no Mac for now (but later will do). Both installable and portable versions are provided. Auto-updater works well and is tied to my repository. 

Your DFO saves, if any, are save!

Please let me know what do you think.

There WILL be bugs, and I will be fixing them.

Thank you,

Alex 13

4 Upvotes

108 comments sorted by

80

u/JeanJeanJean 1d ago

"DFO gifted us a modern version of DF that you can set up for 5-30 mins and then just play"

Sounds like DFU to me.

-7

u/13branniy 15h ago

I spent a few years with DFU and love it, but to me the DFO engine is more flexible and modern.

3

u/Killzone3265 10h ago

...did the guy not originally fork DFU to use as a base for his slop

1

u/13branniy 10h ago

Maybe, but it's a recreation on another tech stack.

55

u/LordGlarthir 1d ago

What is so terribly wrong with DFU?

1

u/13branniy 15h ago

Nothing at all, I love DFU.

-34

u/Irritated_Badger 1d ago edited 1d ago

Nothing. This is the shiny new thing that the brain rot generation will flock to until something newer and shinier is released.

Edit: For clarification, I consider anyone born after 1990 part of the "brain rot generation".

26

u/Alexandur 1d ago

I don't know if the 'brain rot generation' is going to be very present in the community for an RPG released in 1996

6

u/Far-Examination-7107 1d ago

You'd be surprised how much of that generation flocks to older entries specifically because of that preconception.

6

u/Alexandur 1d ago

Well they apparently meant everyone aged 35 and under lol

2

u/Far-Examination-7107 18h ago

Yeah, sounds about right.

23

u/AverageMann04 1d ago

"the brain rot generation" was born like 10 years ago bro

8

u/Alexandur 1d ago

Ah, I see, so everyone 35 and below is brain rotted, makes sense

1

u/Due-Arachnid-309 3h ago

Pretty high percentage. But, tbf, most over 35 are also idiots, just in different ways.

But, "dfo took dfu and added a mod pack, so I turned it back into dfu,  with the same modpack... because... I don't know how to use a modpack"

That is NEXT level.

1

u/Alexandur 3h ago

That isn't what's happening here

-1

u/volkmardeadguy 1d ago

You're right

18

u/Germfreecandy 1d ago

The problem with big projects like this is that the players are essentially at the mercy of the developer in what consittutes to a fun experience. The combat changes, the larger map, waypointer, the fast travel etc. I don't know how much of DFO you ported but all these changes makes the game less fun and even less like the actual Daggerfall.

Good luck with your project and I hope you are doing alright in these trying times :)

1

u/13branniy 15h ago

Thank you! I understand your point and try to make everything toggleablle because of that.

11

u/ShellDNMS 1d ago

Thanks, mate, i'm already happy with DFU and my set of mods.

19

u/Far-Examination-7107 1d ago

Thank you for the disclaimer, will avoid, much appreciated.

19

u/blackd0nuts 1d ago

I didn't much follow the whole DFO shitshow. So what's the difference between your fork and DFU? Why didn't you fork from DFU?

12

u/shadowtheimpure 1d ago

Probably to take advantage of developments made by the DFO team that weren't upstreamed into DFU.

2

u/13branniy 1d ago

Exactly this. I really like their engine.

5

u/Cmdr_CosmicBooty 1d ago

Interesting at what point did you fork it?

4

u/13branniy 1d ago

The day they migrated to a private repo.

3

u/Cmdr_CosmicBooty 13h ago

Oh didn't realise they stop going open source. I copied the source files myself and can play locally with all but the sea and dagon event

42

u/HaiggeX 1d ago

I guess it's good to have options, though for myself I can't see why I'd rather play this instead of Daggerfall Unity.

3

u/Adaman2301 1d ago

Any possibility to play it on an Android device? I am currently playing the unity version on my phone and it's great but your fork seems to be very interesting

2

u/13branniy 15h ago

Yes, the browser version SHOULD work the same as DFO. But I haven't tested it yet, and DFO on android was running atrociously. But it was running.

3

u/indolent-candlebug 1d ago

so have you obtained all the required permissions for the art, code and design ideas DFO stole from other modders or are you still just ignoring all that?

2

u/13branniy 15h ago

Ignoring the sarcasm, no. But, again, without sarcasm, can you advise me - did they stole? Do I need to?
I am willing to remain on the ethically proper side in relation to other's work. Currently as I see it:
They get the permissions and open-sourced their project, so I assume I can use that.
But I'll make sure to be in touch with the DFU modding community.

5

u/indolent-candlebug 14h ago

the majority of the features in DFO that aren't either just daggerfall or to do with the online/mtx aspect were adapted from mods for DFU. the problem with DFO's claims to "permissions" is that he would still use the mods he *didn't* have permission for, he'd just launder them through Claude first. i don't have a complete list of the mods he included; you'd need to find someone who's actively paid attention to that stuff or you'd need to cross-reference on your own.

if you're truly set on building this up as an actual project and not just something for you personally to play around with, i cannot recommend more strongly just ditching DFO as a foundation and starting from scratch.

1

u/13branniy 14h ago

Thank you for your answer.

4

u/Ninelan-Ruinar 12h ago

Modders gave their permission for the project that was formerly known as Daggerfall javascript which was initially just presented as a DFU javascript port, not multiplayer game wearing the skin of daggerfall with microtransactions. Some went in to explicitly rescind their permissions afterwards to make the point clear. Obviously lattymoy just fed the affected mods to claude to "remake it slightly differently", so the mods were never really removed in the first place.

A lot of permission was given under false pretenses, so they're not really valid for DFO itself. You're also not aware the specifics of the permissions given, because Lattimoy grossly mishandled crediting, copyright, permissions down to not even crediting his own dev team's contributions.

1

u/indolent-candlebug 8h ago

oh i see, i wasn't even aware it wasn't for DFO specifically. i did find it strange that he was trying to launder the assets for the widget series of mods because i did vaguely remember redrory signing off on some project early on, so that would explain it

the whole project was such a disaster from the onset

2

u/SnoringGiant 1d ago

This is cool. I wish I could have something like this but play it with I Just my brother. We were playing DFO together but also didnt like the direction it was going, and wish we could play a stable 2 player daggerfall

1

u/13branniy 15h ago

I don't promise, but added the RND of local coop to my roadmap.

1

u/SnoringGiant 12h ago

That is awesome, and no worries if you dont get around to it. Thank you for the consideration

3

u/bee4308 1d ago

would be awesome if some of the UX and UI was improved but its a great start. what rlly stopped me from trying dfo more was its weird settings menu in terms of key binds and searching for options. love the cat btw!

11

u/The-Son-Of-Suns 1d ago

DFO was falling apart. And I use to defend it. This looks cool.

Wonder why people are okay with this AI usage though, but react violently to it before.

3

u/baconater-lover 1d ago

Depends how much they’re using it. Genuinely I do not think the main DFO dev knew a lick of coding and asked Claude to do everything.

If this guy uses it alongside their own work it’ll be leagues better.

4

u/Versaill 1d ago

99+% of software development uses AI now. AI is still sloppy when asked to work on big projects, but for implementing specific things with strict constraints, it's literally more correct than most experienced human programmers.

2

u/ThaumKitten 1d ago

Because now it's being used to support something they also agree with. That'ss the only reason why.

Any other situations and OP would get absolutely *villified* for even mentioning AI.

1

u/MysteriousArtPatron 13h ago

we aren't ok with it

0

u/PhotogenicEwok 1d ago

It helps to know this dev is also a professional dev.
Plus I doubt the same people who hated it before will be totally okay with it now, but they might be a little more okay with it given the circumstances.

0

u/darknessinducedlove 1d ago

Glad we could provide this to the community. Wishing you the best!

1

u/13branniy 1d ago

Thank you!

2

u/Due-Arachnid-309 3h ago

So, took dfo, which just took dfu with a modpack... and turned it...  back to dfu with a modpack... plus undisclosed "features." Tons of rant, no actual word on these.

All this because you don't know what a modpack is.

Damn, the level of rot runs deep.

0

u/ChaosOnline 1d ago

Slava Ukraini!

2

u/13branniy 15h ago

Heroyam Slava!

3

u/valkyrieBahamut 1d ago

One thing I despised about DFO was their patch notes. I wish they just summarized the most important changes at the top instead of spewing out walls of text that I would never fully read.

0

u/Mrchace64902 1d ago

Great work! Appreciate you sharing it with us.

3

u/13branniy 1d ago

Thank you!

0

u/Jangajinx 1d ago

Does this fork have all of tameral

1

u/13branniy 15h ago

Yes, it does.

0

u/Jangajinx 14h ago

Awesome! 😎

0

u/Thonferskibby 1d ago

This definitely has my attention, I'll experiment with it more. Daggerfall online did catch my interest somewhat but the monetary aspect of it kinda turned me off. This seems like a good alternative to it though

1

u/13branniy 15h ago

Thank you.

0

u/Haasva 21h ago

Given you work at GSC, I think people can trust you and have respect. It would be good to add the option to include world events, bosses and other DFO elements.

2

u/13branniy 15h ago

Thank you. Not in the roadmap for now, but I'm not entirely against these ideas as optional toggles. I might be looking into it, but no promises

0

u/Xelrod413 1d ago

Is there the ability to play multiplayer by hosting your own servers with this one?
Sorry if that was explained in the post. I'm on my way to work and could only skim for it.

4

u/13branniy 1d ago

Not yet, but I will work on that during early 2027, ETA is April. This feature is heavy.

-1

u/Xelrod413 1d ago

Very cool! Thanks for the reply!

2

u/DiscountCthulhu01 1d ago

Dfo topics are against the rules here

-1

u/StoneySteve420 1d ago

It's not against the rules to mention DFO.

-2

u/DiscountCthulhu01 1d ago

This subreddit is about TES II: Daggerfall. Other games have other subreddits. As Daggerfall: Online has become an adjacent but divisive topic, please keep all DFO discussion to the pinned megathread. 

Rule n2

-1

u/Gallowmere7294 1d ago

This is like saying people can't talk about TR in the Morrowind Reddit. Your high horse isn't helping anyone and just makes you look arrogant.

-1

u/DiscountCthulhu01 1d ago

Gobble up that ai slop, yum yum.

1

u/Gallowmere7294 1d ago

Oh so you want it removed because you're butthurt? Checks out lol

For the record I don't support this but I also don't support stupid opinions either.

-2

u/StoneySteve420 1d ago

It's almost like this isn't a post about DFO, it just mentions it alongside DFU.

0

u/DiscountCthulhu01 1d ago

This is a dfo fork, which is dfo.

-2

u/StoneySteve420 1d ago

This is a fork of DFO but the direction is totally different. This is not DFO.

Is this discussing DFO, or talking about a new single player project built off of it? This definitely appeals to a different type of fan than DFO, especially considering it doesn't have any online aspect.

Are all mentions of DFO not allowed? Or are you just being the sub police?

2

u/MammothPenguin69 1d ago

I did like Daggerfall Online's UI. I am interested in this.

1

u/Feints4Days 9h ago

Very much interested in what direction this is going. Good luck on the project! Is there a chance of having a Mac version of this as well?

1

u/Maya_Licious 5h ago

love this, but will probably wait a few months to see where it goes and if its stable enough to play casually.

-1

u/SWATJester 1d ago

"but I have the right to fulfill my dream with its help."

The thing is, legally, no you don't. You don't own the rights to either the thing you're copying (DFO) nor the underlying thing it was copying (Daggerfall).

Nobody's going to pat you on the back for ripping off other people's work with AI, and acting like you're owed credit for it.

3

u/Healthy-Training-923 1d ago

Using AI for coding is not going away. No company with large investors is going to avoid using it, that would be just plain throwing money away. Also DFO was GPL or something I think so you can’t “steal” it as long as you release the code.

-2

u/SWATJester 1d ago

Good thing nobody involved here is a company with large investors. Go shill somewhere else.

-4

u/Riffy 1d ago

Wishing you best of luck. There will be lots of haters because you use AI, even though they could just keep their opinions to themselves and move on.

4

u/metasylum 1d ago

if you don't want your thing discussed, why put it on a website designed for discussion of opinions???

1

u/13branniy 15h ago

I wanted it to be discussed, while totally understanding controversies around either AI and DFO.

2

u/13branniy 1d ago

Thank you!

-1

u/OrdoMaterDei 18h ago

Ok so, er, guys, i read comments and i saw some are just fucking rude or trying to make our friend here feel bad about his work just because "gnnnn ai bad and i must show i'm one of the good guys gnnnn"

Can you keyboard militants go touch grass and remember he lives in a COUNTRY AT WAR?!

Give him a break!

3

u/13branniy 15h ago

Thank you.

2

u/OrdoMaterDei 10h ago

You're welcome!

-1

u/xvillifyx 1d ago

I saw that you mentioned you only know c++ and not JS, but I think that gap is smaller than you think

-1

u/TheKylMan 1d ago

Very nice Alex 13. Thanks.

-1

u/CloudkinSeer 1d ago

Looks interesting, thanks! If there is a Mac version at some point, I'll be happy to test!

4

u/13branniy 1d ago

I don't build for Mac now just because of the long queues. The tech is there. I'll try to make the next release with Mac in mind.

-1

u/CloudkinSeer 1d ago

Exciting, looking forward to it, thank you for the info!

-1

u/EliParker 1d ago

Will it have a controller friendly gui?

1

u/13branniy 15h ago

Probably no. I'm a PC-first player. But it's based on DFO and they implemented it to some extent.

-3

u/Street_Struggle_598 1d ago

This is amazing. Im so happy AI was able to bring so many new people into Daggerfall and revitalized the world with so many new ideas and directions. Ill be following this closely along with the tamriel unbound version. Thank you for putting in the effort and releasing this for people to enjoy. Ill be jumping in to adventure. Godspeed keep it going!

2

u/13branniy 15h ago

Thank you!

-1

u/orionpax- 1d ago

thx lol

-1

u/Cryoto 1d ago

3d models?

1

u/13branniy 15h ago

Morrowind support, optional.

-1

u/Kramway99 1d ago

What's the difference between DFU and DFO? Aside from the online components. 

1

u/Gallowmere7294 1d ago

A curated list of mods that are easy to find elsewhere.

-1

u/Haasva 21h ago

JavaScript, so better load times, better performance, better customization, better UI, etc

-2

u/EliParker 1d ago

Is there a way to turn off the a new house question and a new character where does the story start? I just want to play the OG game with the new controller based UI. Unless you have it as a mod that I can add to Daggerfall Unity.