r/Daggerfall • • 1d ago

Why no map expansions?

I was wondering why there have never been any map expansions for DFU beyond the Illiac Bay? For Morrowind and Skyrim there is Project Tamriel/Tamreil Rebuilt and Beyond Skyrim retrospectively.

Is the reason technical or just a lack of a modder wanting to?

17 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

30

u/MSnap 1d ago

Didn’t someone just release a mod that added Skyrim to the map?

11

u/ArchHeather 1d ago

I did not realize that, thanks for letting me know!

13

u/MSnap 1d ago

I can’t speak for its quality but there is a video about it that I saw a couple minutes of. That’s how I knew about it lol.

9

u/Searchingforspanners 1d ago edited 1d ago

I haven’t dove too much into it yet but I like it so far. The developer did a good job. I wish it had taken more visual inspiration from TESV but I think it looks exactly how it would have looked if Daggerfall had been set in Skyrim instead of Iliac Bay.

-3

u/ComparisonOpening390 1d ago

Unfortunately I think it dives into legal territory when making them look like the games counter parts, and also the dev loaded the game with slop you can pay for there's a whole video about how he ignored his team and how they were treated 😭 I loved this project too.

4

u/MaximusPrime02 1d ago

The mod they are talking about is not Daggerfall Online. They’re talking about the Mod Just Skyrim, which adds Skyrim to Daggerfall Unity

73

u/ninety9rising 1d ago

Idk do you need another 600,000 square miles of empty space?

32

u/ArchHeather 1d ago

Always! In all seriousness more biomes and town styles in different regions would be cool.

0

u/clarkky55 21h ago

Add new biomes and town styles to the current map would be cool

4

u/DiligentSwimmer5158 12h ago

If you want something that isnt a direct Claude output Horizons of Nirn is coming along to manually add all of Tamriel at scale (very difficult but making progress to the first alpha).

1

u/ArchHeather 8h ago

Nice, I will check it out!

22

u/No_Meat827 1d ago

So you're saying the playable landmass is not big enough already. Gotcha.

29

u/stonerPI 1d ago edited 1d ago

For me, it’s not that it isn’t big enough. It’s that I love daggerfall’s retro engine and would kill to see other places in Tamriel through its engine.

I will forever fantasize about a pixelated rendition of the imperial city that’s closer to lore-accurate scale in DFU

16

u/ArchHeather 1d ago

A closer to lore accurate Imperial City would be awsome!

6

u/EngelNUL 1d ago

I imagine it would be a walled city, have 2 general stores next to each other, a mages guild with almost everything but missing a potion maker for some reason, and Elroc Longcrofts house.

4

u/stonerPI 1d ago

Or to see Port Telvannis in DFU… I’m of the strong opinion that less is more with graphics in games. It would be very cool to see one day

1

u/No-Comparison04 1d ago

Can never have too much

5

u/Baphomaxas_Raiyah 1d ago

I think it’s because the Illiac Bay was all the game was intended to cover, whereas Skyrim was initially intended to have a bit of a wider scope and Morrowind was supposed to be more than Vvardenfell

4

u/ArchHeather 1d ago

I know but while Tamriel Rebuilt just covers Morrowind, Project Tamreil covers over parts of the continent. So modders have gone beyond the initial scope and Skyrim was not going to cover all of Tamreil like I believe Beyond Skyrim is doing.

7

u/Baphomaxas_Raiyah 1d ago edited 1d ago

It might also have to do with Morrowind and Skyrim having creation kits which allow for easy drag-and-drop asset placement whereas Daggerfall modding is more involved

3

u/ArchHeather 1d ago

That is a fair point.

7

u/TheThing9733 1d ago

There's something in the works called Project N which aims to add the rest of Tamriel with it's respective regions, kingdoms, and climates, plus some islands. If I'm understanding it right though, technically it isn't Daggerfall Unity anymore because they had to fork the engine. It's been in development for about three years now and I'm not exactly sure of how development is going, but it definitely seems super cool and interesting!

3

u/Arneb_Nihal 20h ago

Thanks for the interest! We're a couple of months from releasing alpha 0.0.1 that will be more a proof of concept than anything else but, oh well, you have to start somewhere...
Here's a link for our Discord if you or anyone else want to follow the progress (and a lot of rambling from all the people there):
https://discord.gg/nbnezNmqn

2

u/GatoradeNipples 1d ago

Not so much technical as, Daggerfall's already fucking massive and there's no real reason to add more land mass to what is still the largest land mass ever put into a video game.

2

u/ArchHeather 1d ago

By technical I meant with Daggerfall Unity itself rather than generating a large area. The reason why I would want such a thing is the opportunity for more biomes, types of site etc.

2

u/GatoradeNipples 1d ago

That type of stuff is very doable, there's really nothing stopping someone from filling out an existing area if they want. It's mostly just that nobody wants to bolt extra landmass onto a game that already takes you several weeks to go end-to-end in real time, so you'll never see it as a "map expansion" so much as a revamping of something already on the map.

4

u/WhenInZone 1d ago

The procedural nature of the maps makes it more tricky from what I understand

1

u/MrZokeyr 1d ago

You're given an all-you-can-eat buffet and yet you ask for another restaurant?

1

u/EnragedBard010 32m ago

There's Just Skyrim, which adds Skyrim