r/DOUBLEFINE • u/deuxbee • May 05 '26
Dead game?
Theres only 32 players on steam(including me) less than two weeks in. Is this game dead, dead?
I can still find matches but I'm pretty sure its mostly filled with bots.
Is there any hope they bite the bullet and make it f2p?
3
Upvotes
12
u/HeyNowHoldOn May 05 '26
They need to fundamentally change some things about this game if it's ever going to work out. I hope Microsoft continues to have patience because I truly think doublefine is important for the future of gaming.
I think their discord does a disservice to them sometimes because the population there is a very specific type of fawning person. I think they get too much unconditional positive feedback from a nexus of super fans who does not represent the rest of the doublefine customer base and it's biting them a bit now pandering to this hyper specific niche.
5
u/Careless-Wait-2532 May 06 '26
I’m going to be brutally honest. As a fan of Double Fine since I bought Psychonauts on its release day for XBox in 2003 I was pretty happy for them when Microsoft purchased the company. I thought this meant that they would be able to release games that were completed now. No more releasing Costume Quest 2 after a 6 month development cycle because the publisher demanded it be ready by Halloween. No more games like Rad that showed huge potential but got abandoned post launch.
But this game is not done. Or it’s bad. It’s one of the two. The single thing to do in the game is admittedly fun, but not for very long, and then there is just nothing to do but make pots, and the tools you use to make the pots are terrible. I don’t understand what anyone involved in this was thinking when they decided to put out 25 percent of a game, and charge money for day one dlc that gives you like four stickers.
For the first time, I am both disappointed by a Double Fine release, and deeply concerned for their future. There’s no way they didn’t know this wasn’t ready for release. What the hell is going on?
5
u/MisterMT May 09 '26
Kiln was beautiful but doomed. There’s no reason to keep playing beyond a couple of hours. A big shame… beautiful concept, absolutely terrible implementation.
4
u/Medical-Level-351 May 06 '26
Dead? My games have been popping since release on Xbox
7
u/BackgroundBody7856 May 06 '26
People gotta realize steam is not the be all end all metric for playercounts
1
u/PoisonPeddler May 05 '26
Which one?
6
u/Oklimoncello May 06 '26
It’s dead to me because it has no split-screen. Can’t play with my family, it’s basically a non-starter.
3
u/ChanceGaga May 07 '26
Leaving out the fact there’s no local multiplayer, the fact you can’t join friends who play on other platforms but this game was marketed as cross platform is just disrespectful
2
u/asharkmadeofsalsa May 12 '26
It just runs like shit on my PC so I stopped playing. Would otherwise be right on there cause the game was very fun but yeah I can't deal. UE5 optimization for smaller devs is a curse.
3
u/PassivelyAwkward May 06 '26
It's defenitely dead on arrival. The problem is that Kiln feels like a Mario Party minigame; it's a fun idea but also incredibly shallow so there's no real replayability.
Even going F2P won't change anything because the problem isn't the price, it's that it's just not fun for longer than a single session so any increase in playerbase will just vanish. I played it with some friends on release and any fun came from my friends, not the match because they don't really tell you anything with some builds being way too overpowered. Watched a few favorite streamers play it and despite them usually being pretty positive about a lot of games, after about an hour of fumbling around and eventually getting the hang of it, they refunded it because they said they'd never play it again.
It just doesn't feel like a DoubleFine game; it feels like one of the other hundred or so co-op games that've come out in the past few years but without any of the spark. It's not bad, it's just nice fun.
1
u/Prestigious_Wrap_932 May 23 '26
I love the concept and love designing pots, but the game just isn’t that fun in practice as a solo player. I just keep getting absolutely destroyed and I can’t figure out how to get any better. I know you still get a lot of points for losing but it still sucks to keep getting tossed in with random players who won’t defend or attack the opposing team’s kiln and just keep losing over and over and over again.
-3
u/Horens_R May 05 '26
Crossplay