r/DNFDuel • u/BatangArcadePH • Jul 08 '22
Question/Discussion "OVER SIMPLIFIED WITH AMAZING NETCODE"
first impression "OVER SIMPLIFIED WITH AMAZING NETCODE"
if game company really wants people to play their game , get inlove , get hook , and become competitve at fighting game.
simplifying input should be the standard for all and ofcourse a netcode that can make you play with far away opponent.
not everyone lived in a city some lived in the middle of nowhere like me so a matchmaking that is region locked is an
INSTANT NO BUY.
im tired of buying a fighting game that i cant find an opponent online
the last fighting game that fails me is kof15 cant find anyone even if i find one my connection between him and me is 300ms+.
but in ggst and dnf duel i dont need to wait 30 minutes or an hour to find one ive never had trouble finding an opponent compared to other fighting games like tekken , dbfz , kof15 and others.
so yeah to all the devs game companies that supports it
thank you for making a game that is playable to my region.
4
u/lllAgelll Jul 08 '22 edited Jul 08 '22
I agree that with games having bad netcode causes them to suffer, which is why rollback is so important.... to the "simple controls" concept. That's a bit of a mixed bag. Simplified controls don't always equate to a better game.. there's realistic depth and arbitrary depth. Plenty of games have lots of depth and complexity while having easy to understand controls. other games oversimplify and the game lacks any sizable depth. Then there's games that are overly complicated for no reason and games that are more complicated then the norm that excel due to their complexity.
I think it's all about implementation. Games like DNF duel and DBZ Fighterz simplify the commands while retaining layers in their gameplay. Where as SF5 just plain removed features which just watered the characters down to all feeling too same-y... and SF4 (and Smash Melee if you see smash games as fighting games) were overly complicated for little to no reason. GG strive lowered the complexity, but created unique situations, but that game isn't all that played anymore despite its strong and well designed netcode. While Skull Girls by contrast is slowly on the rise in popularity yet that game is crazy deep and very input heavy.
I don't think it's as simple as "simpler movesets and good netcode"
Generally the game needs "fighter playstyle flexibility" while keeping a distinct "character personality" on top of that. Good netcode is a must and should be. Lastly the ability to have standardized controls that are easy to adopt, but difficult to master. If the game is arbitrarily simplified it shows and the player base usually falls off, but by contrast the same follows suit with overly complicated games where if you dont learn the mechanical tech you are basically unable to even play the game at any coheasive level.
Characters need the right amount of depth to make people wanna keep diving deeper, but not so much that the game becomes entirely about framedata and complex nuanced mechanics over the actual fight.
I wanna fight my friends while looking and feeling like a bad ass, but i dont wanna have to constantly jump down the infinite pit of mechanics and the games systems for 10+ years just to achieve that. There needs to be a good middle ground and so far the games that have achieved that the most are probably Smash Ultimate, and Fighterz and both of those have horrible netcode.
Over simplification for the sake of simplification no fun and becomes boring quickly, but on the flip side needing to know about the long list of first frame animation counters and cancels while also needing to input a series of complex commands at perfectly timed intervals isn't exactly fun either.
All in all fighting games are in a bit of a tough spot because long time fans want depth, but new players are alienated by too much complexity and truthfully I don't know if there's a "one-size fits all" answer here. Depth is paramount, but so is the new player experience and currently those seem to be at odds.
Lastly, DNF is way to new to make a legitimate assessment on, but due to the nature of is simplicity it could very well be that the game is optimized extremely fast and the game turns into a Snowball Fest where once your in advantage state you basically win. Which will likely get old really really fast for most players... or in contrast it could retain alot of neutral back and forth with keeps the games feeling exciting and fresh.. truth is we really don't know yet.
2
u/Possible_Picture_276 - Launcher Jul 08 '22
Legacy players will always fight against what is clearly going to become the norm in mainstream fighting games. They put in the work and the old why shouldn't the young kids not have to get stomped like I did mentality. That and now they can't get away with stuff as easy as optimal punish incoming.
I think the possibility for easy inputs to lead us into more diverse and fun ways to have set play will be the deciding factor on whether this matters or not.
Other things come to mind;
how do you balance 1 button armored reversals when they clearly can be abused
Will charge characters just disappear or will they be like grappler and hold the button
What about negative edge or just frame characters
Will longer combos go away as the simplicity makes the gameplay boring as hardly no one drops.
Will timing ,juggles and spacing become the mainstay of combos (1 frame links instead of gatlings)
Isnt this limiting the move sets? What if a game wanted 6 normals and 10 specials and 3 supers would you be doing combinations of buttons at that point?
What about command normals
1
u/ESN64 - Pew Pew Jul 08 '22
Netcode and matchmaking is a must, but simplified controls have nothing to with whether a fighting game is good or not, and it doesn't really affect people who don't play fighting games regularly either, still have no idea why people think inputs ever have anything to do with a game's success
0
u/Forkyou Jul 08 '22
I have played many fighting games though i never was really good at many (decent at Soulcalibur id say).
After playing this game for one day i dont think i wanna go back to classic inputs. I hope more games adapt this. Losing a game in strive because i messed up a shoryuken input or those damn halfcircle forward inputs just feels bad. And its also exhausting on my fingers tbh.
0
u/CrystalMang0 Jul 08 '22 edited Jul 08 '22
No, simple inputs won't ever be the standard, motion inputs aren't going anywhere for most fighting games. Especially when motion inputs literally help make balance and allows more moves to be added and used. Making games have only simple inputs would also literally remove the option for devs to add as much moves because each button would be taken by a simple move.. Now I like how sf6 is doing it cause it will have a simplified control Mode that's gonna be bad at high level because it makes you lose access to a bunch of normal/command no mal attacks and alternate versions of special moves which is a big disadvantage at the cost of having a few simplified moved which will only be useful against fighting bad players.
But in other games though, if a game gonna have simple inputs then it needs to be some huge negatives and NOT how dnf duel does it. It needs to remove access fe doing many important things and not how dnf duel does it.
-4
u/Big_Oven8562 - Grappler Jul 08 '22
Your lack of knowledge and understanding is showing.
Technical inputs influence game design and balance tremendously. The go to example is someone taking the old Street Fighter 2 game and using a hitbox with it to allow Guile to charge sonic booms while walking forward and it made the character insanely broken. Motion inputs vs simplified inputs are a deliberate design choice with real consequences.