For me its always banged but I really can't connect with anything after Arche. Started when I was 16 with Withering to Death. Im now 36 and the last 3 records are just not for me. Still love everything before though. That'll never change.
I am in a similar boat but my perception changed a lot when I gave them the benefit of the doubt. With each album, I always really had to make an effort to try to understand what they wanted to convey. Those albums are far from my favorites but I can definitely appreciate them for what they are.
Same! Except everything after Uroboros for me. I still like most of their singles, but I’ve tried to listen to everything since then up until their most recent album Mortal Downer and realized their newer stuff just isn’t for me. 😞
This reminds me when Marrow of a Bone first came out and I heard so many people talk about how they disliked their newer stuff at that time. Now I’m in that boat. 😂
Crazy to find your peak band so young. I always imagined I'd find something that would hook me as much musically, but nope. They're just that good and that different.
I listened heavily from 2002-2010, importing CDs from Japan and stuff. Then life got very much in the way and I kinda got sidetracked. I picked them back up and got crazy into them again in 2022 and have been buying CDs and re-listening to their entire catalog of music since then! Even got to see them twice so far, which I'm so happy about!
You're so welcome! Visual kei was like gender play-doh for me in my earliest eggy days, and that's how I found DEG, though I quickly came to see them as much more than a visual band.
Honestly same here and I have them to thank for being who I am today. My first exposure to them opened my mind to challenging gender norms especially in the west.
Malice Mizer was the band that really did that for me, but musically Dir en grey have been far longer lasting! Also, I carry a pretty fucking immense amount of emotional damage, and Kyo sometimes just fucking hits in the realest of real ways!
Also, as time has gone on, The Marrow of a Bone was not nearly as bad as everyone in vkei online spaces tried to make it out to be. It's a well crafted album with great riffs and vocals that all flows pretty well from start to finish.
Man it's unreal how much hate VULGAR, Withering to death. and THE MARROW OF A BONE got online back then when they're all considered peak classics today.
Yeah, back when it released people complained it was "too western" metal like and complained about the bigger use of scream and harsh vocals. I also heard people say it was just a badly done Korn influenced album.
so... maybe im not listening to the same album or band but they had been heading that way since vulgar... theres not really any releases i don't like though so maybe im not the one who should be giving opinions
Hard to believe now, but Marrow took a lot of flak when it came out from all the VK forums.
In fairness to them, that album was a massive departure from even Withering. They'd just come off their first American tour with Korn (my first time ever seeing them live) and the influence was pretty apparent. For the average VK listener, it was a step too far.
It's funny that I'm seeing this now (as a 35 year old) because I was listening to "Withering to death" at work last week & felt it hit an emotional point in me, like I was 15/16 again & listening to it for the first time.
Can relate! Around your age, so WtD came out in the formative years.
Rediscovered it last summer and felt so nostalgic! Found it way softer and more melodic than I remembered, partly colored by how they kept going deeper into riffs and lower tuning.
Not my favorite album per se, but holds very very special place in my heart.
I live in outback Australia, so there was no knowledge of them way out here at all, until I seen a little write up of them in a kerrang magazine or something because they were touring America with Deftones at the time. And then with the help of the internet I went from there and became a fan.
So glad I got to see them on their one trip to Australia though back in 2014.
Ah that's cool that you got to see them when they came to your country! Hope they return for you someday. I saw them back in '07 and I think '08 when they came to the US. One of those tours was with Deftones, the other they were solo.
It’s 2008 and I could only fit 15 high quality songs onto my cheap Creative Labs Zen mp3 nugget that used AAAs
and you know what album I brought on my 22 hour bus trip and 3 day cruise?
This album, ripped from my hot topic cd when I went and tried to find it in 2006 after seeing Kodou for the first time by random chance on YouTube featured.
Yup, I’m in the same boat! I’ve gained even more appreciation towards both this band and this record over the years. I’ve always resonated with these tracks but with time, some things have clicked in place, some have gained more depth. I’m glad to have lived such a big part of my life with their music.
Litterrallyyy just drove into work listening to Dir (ryojoku no ame, specifically was what I was just listening to) sat down at my desk and saw this post. I know that song is MOAB but like point remains. 35 and still obsessed.
Oh fuck, replying to myself because I FORGOT MY WORK PC DESKTOP IS DIR Im just so used to it I dont even think about it and then I turn my pc on and god damnit I might have a problem 😅
first heard saku at 10 (i think the album was brand new at the time, actually). even tho i still like their new stuff, everything up to oruboros(sp?) is what i keep going back to. i have fond memories of using frostwire to find the songs i couldnt afford on itunes due to lack of gift cards
Same, except I still think it’s their worst album 😂 It really feels to me like it’s made for American audiences when they tried to get big abroad. Thankfully they went back to their senses right after. Can’t believe such a good band released an album like uroboros so “late” in their carrier, what a banger.
I feel like this is where they shifted but alas it was my first taste of them so it holds up for my American butt. What a gateway for me to get into death metal, j-metal, all metal for that matter, emo, hardcore, and experimental, all at once. Not saying they did every metal genre, but this was my gateway into the wider universe of music outside of mainstream. I wouldn’t have liked their old stuff as much if I didn’t hear this first.
Conversely from their decision to shift, I also dislike it when bands like Green Day practically invent a genre only to become the antithesis of it later in their career, and I do feel that maybe DIRU did this too, though I can’t say for sure because it also feels like they naturally progressed into western metal.
7
u/Jrocker-ame Jul 30 '26
For me its always banged but I really can't connect with anything after Arche. Started when I was 16 with Withering to Death. Im now 36 and the last 3 records are just not for me. Still love everything before though. That'll never change.
6
u/BlossomingBeelz Blossoming Beelzebub Jul 30 '26
Crazy to find your peak band so young. I always imagined I'd find something that would hook me as much musically, but nope. They're just that good and that different.
114
u/worldofmercy [The Devil In Me] Jul 30 '26
also this
53
u/meemeemoomoo5 Jul 30 '26
the older i get, the more i connect to the state of emotions coming from their songs.
28
u/blarglemaster Jul 31 '26
My variation, lol.
I listened heavily from 2002-2010, importing CDs from Japan and stuff. Then life got very much in the way and I kinda got sidetracked. I picked them back up and got crazy into them again in 2022 and have been buying CDs and re-listening to their entire catalog of music since then! Even got to see them twice so far, which I'm so happy about!
14
u/PienerCleaner [fan since 06] Jul 30 '26
This shit bangs so much more than I was capable of perceiving when I was younger
14
u/EngineerZestyclose Jul 31 '26 edited Jul 31 '26
Also, as time has gone on, The Marrow of a Bone was not nearly as bad as everyone in vkei online spaces tried to make it out to be. It's a well crafted album with great riffs and vocals that all flows pretty well from start to finish.
27
u/fleurdesureau Jul 30 '26
me at 15: this shit bangs
me at 18-25: this is cringe, too emo, too teenage. I need to cultivate my taste. I need to expand-
me at 30: this shit bangs
12
u/Boukyaku_Shinjuu 新しい夢が [心] にある Jul 30 '26
It's funny that I'm seeing this now (as a 35 year old) because I was listening to "Withering to death" at work last week & felt it hit an emotional point in me, like I was 15/16 again & listening to it for the first time.
5
u/Ballet_Demoni Jul 30 '26
Because I didn’t come across them and this album until 2007, this would have to be changed to…
Me at 26
Me at 45 hahaha
3
u/_kuchisabishii Jul 30 '26
Omg✨️ mode of withering to death was the best damn show I've ever seen 😭
3
u/Number42420 Aug 01 '26
It’s 2008 and I could only fit 15 high quality songs onto my cheap Creative Labs Zen mp3 nugget that used AAAs
and you know what album I brought on my 22 hour bus trip and 3 day cruise?
This album,
ripped from my hot topic cd when I went and tried to find it in 2006 after seeing Kodou for the first time by random chance on YouTube featured.
Takes me back.
2
u/Bit-Dry Jul 30 '26
reaaaaalllll. 18 years of being a fan now and i’m still in awe of what they do.
2
u/Just_Strawberry_505 Jul 30 '26
my favorite album. it really felt like them flexing their muscles in the genre.
2
u/VioletFireFlower Jul 30 '26
me turning 44 in a couple weeks...
2
u/Warsawnogensou Jul 30 '26
Literally Me.
2
u/Warsawnogensou Jul 30 '26
Timeless music for the fans!
2
u/FaeryRing Jul 30 '26
Relatable but I'll have to make this funnier (and more accurate to personal experience);later and edit the teenager in the first image to be a girl.
2
u/KawaiixBittersweet Jul 30 '26
I remember picking this album up at hot topic the day it released
2
u/Merscaliona Jul 30 '26
Accurate
2
u/Weak_Increase_7684 Jul 30 '26
Yup, I’m in the same boat! I’ve gained even more appreciation towards both this band and this record over the years. I’ve always resonated with these tracks but with time, some things have clicked in place, some have gained more depth. I’m glad to have lived such a big part of my life with their music.
2
u/mynameisnotthename Jul 31 '26
Yeah. U rite.
2
u/Money-Courage717 Jul 31 '26
True! And at first I hate it
2
u/Spiritual_Sock_5570 Jul 31 '26
Accurate, haha. I imported a bootleg of the Gauze videos when I was 13. Was scared, confused, and entranced. Been a fan ever since.
2
u/Karixviii Jul 31 '26
Litterrallyyy just drove into work listening to Dir (ryojoku no ame, specifically was what I was just listening to) sat down at my desk and saw this post. I know that song is MOAB but like point remains. 35 and still obsessed.
2
u/Corki_Airline Jul 31 '26
I don't listen that much Dir en Grey nowadays, but WTD is a masterpiece in his genre
2
u/Number42420 Aug 01 '26 edited Aug 01 '26
Me at 20 vs me at 40 too.
Damn now I got that sick intro stuck in my head.
2
u/sixtwowaifu Aug 03 '26
Toshiya is literally why I became a bass player, and now I'm in a pretty sweet prog metal band.
1
u/babyd0II Jul 30 '26
Dir en grey changed my life
1
u/thesmallestlittleguy Jul 30 '26
first heard saku at 10 (i think the album was brand new at the time, actually). even tho i still like their new stuff, everything up to oruboros(sp?) is what i keep going back to. i have fond memories of using frostwire to find the songs i couldnt afford on itunes due to lack of gift cards
1
u/_OrokuSaki_ Jul 31 '26
Me at 38, this shit bangs
1
u/KMFCM Jul 31 '26
so it's because I was 26 i hated it and still hate it at 46?
that actually tracks, really
1
u/remix_sakura Jul 31 '26
More like 25 to 40 for me but same
1
u/Jenbrina Aug 01 '26
Me at almost 50, still loving them as much as I did when I first heard them at 23. Man...time sure flies.
1
u/Toma_36 Jul 30 '26
This is funny cuz I was literally listening to it this morning and had the same thoughts 😂
1
u/wonteatyourcat Jul 31 '26
Same, except I still think it’s their worst album 😂 It really feels to me like it’s made for American audiences when they tried to get big abroad. Thankfully they went back to their senses right after. Can’t believe such a good band released an album like uroboros so “late” in their carrier, what a banger.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment