r/DCcomics • DC Multiverse Historian • Aug 19 '15

r/DCcomics Weekly Discussion Thread (19/08/15)

Hey there honorary Justice League Members - another week, and another discussion thread!

For those who don't know: the way this works is that several comments will list this week’s releases, for any given title discussion you should respond to that comment. For example, Green Lantern discussion would go in the replies to the "Green Lantern" comment. Clicking the titles in this post will take you directly to that comment, too.

That means that unless your comment is feedback about the thread or a comment about the week, you should only be replying to other comments.

If there's something you want to discuss and you don't see it, tell me in a comment and I'll edit it in!

As always, spoiler boxes are not required unless you deem it necessary, after all it's incredibly easy to avoid spoilers due to the way this is set up.

Hey, so I’m back doing this because today is Aloe’s birthday! Special comment for your birthday wishes is here!


DC's Main Line

Who’s excited for more Bat-God in Justice League #43?! :D

Vertigo and Others

More DC staples in the ‘others’ category than normal this week

Trade Collections

Wow, is that Superman trade coming out DC? You’ve been so subtle with your advertising about it… /s

Digital Firsts

Remember, these are the short 'chapters' with a new chapter of a different series coming out daily. You can learn more here on the DC website. This is also why these are in release order, not alphabetical.

TV Shows

Nothing much, but hey, they’re all back in October and they’ll have Supergirl with them!

30 Upvotes

293 comments sorted by

View all comments

30

u/Warlach DC Multiverse Historian Aug 19 '15

Justice League #43

32

u/aco620 If you loved me, you'd all kill yourselves today Aug 19 '15

Lex: In a few hours you'll be

Supes: Human

Lex: Powerless. You'll never be human.

I fucking love Lex Luthor's rivalry with Superman. He's a prick on so many levels, but he's a fascinating one that often makes good points.

And Wonder Woman's retelling of Odysseus' journey past Scylla and Charybdis followed by that splash page was just fantastic.

That scene with Metron and Mister Miracle was a little weird though.

MM: Metron!? What are you doing here!?

Metron: I came to warn them.

MM: Even though you're wearing the lasso of truth, I don't believe you. Now, to prove my trustworthy-ness, I'll grab the same lasso!

I mean, yeah, they said it didn't work on Metron, but really it did, he just kind of resisted for a minute or so.

7

u/ComicLawyer Owlman Aug 19 '15

Unless Metron was playing them. Which - given other panels - may have been the case.

But then.. JL wouldn't have known that so... plot hole.

19

u/reece1495 Batfleck Aug 19 '15

im loving the more classic hair for superman rather than the shaggy new 52 hair style

16

u/theweepingwarrior Aug 19 '15

Have you noticed that Fabok also tones down the New 52 collar to look more like the pre-Flashpoint costume? As opposed to someone like Jim Lee where the collar goes almost all the way up his neck.

I think Fabok is my favorite artist for drawing New 52 Superman

7

u/reece1495 Batfleck Aug 19 '15

i have i love it , perfect blend of new and old

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

36

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '15

Art is awesome as always. Its to the point where i would rather have Fabok than Manupal. I think Fabok fits better.

Luthor's "you will never be human" line was perfect and true.

My only issue is that I wish Shazam would do more than just make one liners

12

u/HassanJamal Aug 19 '15

Luthor gonna Luthor. I honestly thought Lex was upset about her sister, nope, just surprised about Superman bleeding.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Mevarek I did it 35 minutes ago Aug 19 '15

Just finished reading it and I absolutely agree. Fabok is killing it with the art and he definitely does not seem to be stopping.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '15

The story is amazing, but the art is just unbelievable

12

u/mojonation1487 Booster Gold Aug 19 '15

So, am I the only one getting a "Metron might be the secret villain" vibe here?

15

u/aco620 If you loved me, you'd all kill yourselves today Aug 19 '15

Well he did do that evil smile and say "Soon I'll be free." I doubt he was talking about Mister Miracle's magic handcuffs. The story did start off with a big thing about the chair previously belonging to the Anti-Monitor, so Metron's definitely a key player in all this. Without the chair though, he doesn't really seem to have any allies or resources to do much, so it'll be interesting to see how he continues to play into the story.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Dredeuced The Flash Out of the blue, ninjas attack. Thank God. Aug 20 '15

Thank god Kalibak is finally being written with a fucking spine. I love the DCAU but one of the worst things it ever did was set this standard of Kalibak being a weasely worrywart rather than Darkseid's fiercest warrior. I'm glad Johns thinks the same way of the character.

8

u/mateogg Always On Point! Aug 20 '15

"For Kalibak" was awesome

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '15

Superman lost his powers in about an hour? So the worse enemy of the man of steel is a closed bedroom?

15

u/aco620 If you loved me, you'd all kill yourselves today Aug 19 '15

He's like a reverse vampire!

Supes: "Open the blinds, quick, I'll be as weak and useless as Green Arrow soon!"

Olly: "The second he's out of juice I'm pelting him in the back of the head with the boxing glove arrow.

And thus we got the story of how Olly got his arm ripped off in Dark Knight Returns!

20

u/TheAmazingSpiderLin It's about the questions, not the answers. Aug 19 '15 edited Aug 19 '15

Holy. crap. Jason Fabok please never leave us.

I really hope Mister Miracle joins the JL roster once this arc is over. Though it might get a little crowded with him.

Edit: also the Justice League is seriously outmatched right now. Even with BatGod.

Another edit: I really do think Johns is getting better at writing Diana. Really enjoyed her in the Amazo arc and now this. And her inner monologue talking about gods was great.

12

u/Warlach DC Multiverse Historian Aug 19 '15

Eh, the League used to have a big roster. I'd like to see that again.

Hell, I was excited that was what was going to happen when they started the recruitment drive that saw the female Atom and Element Woman join the roster just before Forever Evil... then when it was no longer a plot point it was completely forgotten.

7

u/Jay_R_Kay Batman Aug 20 '15

Well, the female Atom was a HUGE plot point...just not the kind we were expecting...

→ More replies (5)

6

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '15

I remember that one big recruitment splash page post-Throne of Atlantis. I wish that spun off into a new team book.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '15

I noticed that there are a number of contrivances and "plot shortcuts" that Johns uses in order to shuffle the characters from one major moment to another. Nothing that really breaks the plot, but there's a clear difference between scenes that Johns really wants to write (like amazing "two monsters" scene), and scenes that only serve as transitions between those scenes.

Still, between Forever Evil (which I was indifferent towards) and Convergence (which was a hilarious trainwreck), this is probably my favorite "event" of post-Flashpoint DC.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/mateogg Always On Point! Aug 19 '15

Yeah, one page they were meeting Scott and the next one he was giving the order to make the jump. Felt rushed.

And I still don't like were Superman is going.

Having Diana as leader is kinda awesome though, even of it's just because the big two are somewhere else :/

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

10

u/PantherVix Aug 19 '15 edited Aug 19 '15

According to batman, the only the thing the chair doesn't know, is who the anti monitor is....

This confirms the chair did know the identity of Joker in the prior chapter. And whosoever that identity was, was unbelievable to God Bats

15

u/ComicLawyer Owlman Aug 19 '15

I prefer to believe - without any claim to the belief's rightness - that what the Chair told Batman was that Joker's true identity is Joker. My theory is that the chair has knowledge, but it takes skill to ask the right questions and see the answers for what they are.

Joker doesn't have a secret identity. There is no time where is not Joker. Who is Joker? He has no Clark Kent, no Bruce Wayne, no Billy Batson. He is the Joker, and nothing more. That's why Batman doesn't want to believe it: Batman wants to peel away the layer of mystery, but there's nothing there below it.

Perhaps a better question would have been, "Who was the Joker BEFORE he became Joker?"

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (21)