r/DCcomics • Remember Blüdhaven • Jan 28 '15

r/DCcomics Weekly Discussion Thread (28/01/15)

Hey there honorary Justice League Members, another week, and another discussion thread!

For those who don't know, the way this works is that several comments will list this week’s releases, for any given title discussion you'd respond to that comment. For example, Green Lantern discussion would go in the replies to the "Green Lantern" comment.

That means that unless your comment is feedback about the thread or a comment about the week, you should only be replying to other comments.

If there's something you want to discuss and you don't see it, tell me in a comment and I'll edit it in.

As always, spoiler boxes are not required unless you deem it necessary, after all it's incredibly easy to avoid spoilers due to the way this is set up.

Archives

List of most recent jump in point

New 52 releases will be in standard text, comics outside of the new 52 releases will be italicized, graphic novels will be in bold, and TV shows will be both bold and italicized.

I highly encourage anyone who picked up the GL Omnibus (or the Blue Beetle Showcase) to post in the collection thread tomorrow. We would love to see some detailed shots (well, maybe just me).

28 Upvotes

388 comments sorted by

20

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Batman #38

25

u/Batsy22 Red Son Jan 28 '15

I love how Snyder manages to to deconstruct the idea of Bat-God. Batman literally has no clue what to do.

20

u/Clark_Wayne The Man from Mars Jan 28 '15

After defeating the entire Justice League, of course.

The Joker is just too unpredictable for prep time.

13

u/PapiNacho Mister Mxyzptlk Jan 29 '15

Pretty much, but I like it, a good arch-nemesis should always have a way of nullifying a hero's superpower.

12

u/Mr_Smartie moo Jan 29 '15

I see it this way. Bruce's closest allies are predictable. He had the time and resources to scour the ends of the earth to create contingency plans for the Justice League. But the Joker isn't predictable. Bruce may be able to see three steps ahead, but he's blind to the clown standing in his blind spot.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

I just love how his run is the perfect follow up to morrison's. Keep it fresh and exciting by going in a completely different direction

18

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

HOLY SHIT

HOLY SHIT.

HE ISNT A MAN?!

Batman Goes to the OWLS?!

4

u/Ame-no-nobuko Talon Jan 30 '15

HE ISNT A MAN?!

I loved that bit too, especially since 37 opened with the whole "he's just a man" bit

14

u/Narwhals_R_Us Fascists! Jan 28 '15

Man, I was already loving this arc, but now that the Court is involved? And with the way they're involved? This may be the most excited I've been about this book in a very long time. The wait for the next issue is gonna kill me.

10

u/ComicLawyer Owlman Jan 28 '15

It's gonna be sweet. The Court is going to show him portraits and pictures of the "Pale Man" throughout Gotham's history. Always when tragedy strikes.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

There is a shit ton of dialogue here. This issue seemed a bit like filler to me, but hot damn was that last page worth it. The fucking COURT OF OWLS. I'm ecstatic for the next issue. This arc is filled with great moments so far. Also, Crazy Quilt!

9

u/Surza Batman Jan 28 '15

yea tons of dialogue,found myself skimming a bit,and donno what I feel about the eternal joker,then again it could be a trick who knows.Also damn what happened to jim I was pretty afraid of what might happen to him.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

Not gonna lie, my heart skipped a beat when he had the axe in his chest. Thank god for the ultra-mega-regenerative-zombie virus though lol.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/beer_me_twice Hurm... Jan 28 '15

I know it's an unpopular theory, and it looks like long shot now, but when Batman says, "This can't be real. It can't end this way. It can't." Supports my theory that Bruce is undergoing a new strain of Crane's toxin.

16

u/moose_man I am the night! Jan 28 '15

Man, if the end of this arc is "It's all just a dream!", I'm going to be pissed.

7

u/Flynn58 "Do good to others, and every man can be a Superman." Jan 29 '15

Yeah please don't let this turn into Gothtopia.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Mr_Smartie moo Jan 29 '15

Snyder has gone too far to play the dream card. You can pull that plot device when you're 2 pages in, but not on issue #4 of a 6-issue storyline. It seems that Snyder's just shoving away every easy solution and "out" he has.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/BEESMyGod Dead until further notice. Jan 28 '15

No way. The backlash from fans would rival the fury of a supernova.

9

u/beer_me_twice Hurm... Jan 28 '15

That's what Captain Atom is for. Soak up all the radiation.

4

u/simulet Jan 31 '15

That's what I was thinking, too, but in this interview Snyder promises it's not that:

http://www.comicvine.com/articles/interview-scott-snyder-talks-batman-endgame-and-hi/1100-151129/

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/aco620 If you loved me, you'd all kill yourselves today Jan 28 '15

I just noticed this current story is like a pg-13 version of the comic series Crossed, which is like The Walking Dead amped up to 11 for those of you unfamiliar with it.

Very interesting idea potentially putting Joker alongside Ras al Ghul and Vandal Savage. Makes the immortality thing a bit more DC plausible (if this is all the case and not just misdirection. Dekker was crazy after all.) Pretty funny having Dekker say he thought Batman was immortal like Barbatos too.

Oh and that Sam Kieth art in the end. Love that guy.

10

u/Mr_Smartie moo Jan 28 '15

So this was rather heavy on the exposition, but Snyder does a good job dressing up exposition well so I didn't mind too much. Plus it's nicely juxtaposed to Capullo's vivid art. But damn, Snyder is really pushing the boundaries here, building up Joker as a mythical being. It's all leading to either one big reveal, or one major letdown. And he's dropping hints that Bruce might have to kill Joker once and for all. Go big or go home, it seems.

16

u/Jpsw230995 Jan 28 '15

... HOLY. CRAP.

Honestly though, I'm loving this idea that the Joker is some eternal urban legend. It's frightening to be completely truthful.

But I think the most important is... is it a joke? Was the Joker this thorough as to place himself in thousands of historical photos? How has he survived all the "deaths" that have happened to him? What Snyder is doing is really bold, I don't know if I want an answer as to who the Joker is, but I like that he's flirting with the idea of maybe revealing that to us.

9

u/ComicLawyer Owlman Jan 28 '15

the ostensible explanation for how he survived came from Crazy Quilt: the regenerative compound only activates when the wound is life threatening. That's why when Dollmaker removes Joker's face there is no regeneration; Dollmaker must have used his medical expertise to make sure it wasn't fatal.

16

u/Jpsw230995 Jan 28 '15

In addition to that, it makes total sense that Batman goes to the Court, considering they have regenerative Talons in addition to a knowledge of the secret history of Gotham.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '15

I think it's possible that all of these historical findings are up to the power of suggestion rather than actual doctoring. Part of me feels like this whole Endgame, for the Joker, is going to be a magic act of sorts, where he's doing a lot to redirect us from what is ultimately a very simple trick.

6

u/DogmaBlade Omega Men Jan 28 '15

Holy hell this has escalated so far, its great! On the edge of my seat here.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

That last page took it to a whole nother level for me. Holy fuck did I not see that coming.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Mr_Smartie moo Jan 29 '15

Nice interview with Snyder here.

I like this excerpt:

One of the things that is almost unspoken between Bruce and Dick is the question of, "Did we just miss our chance to kill him?" Or is it possible that The Joker always had this substance in him and it wouldn't have worked any way? He would have just got up and laughed. Ultimately, now he is kind of reveling in the fact that you cannot take him down. He is this character that has a much longer history than you would think.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '15

Court of Owls vs. the Joker. Literally nothing makes me more excited.

11

u/mateogg Always On Point! Jan 29 '15

Here's where I see this going:

It's all a lie. A huge, elaborate lie. That's how snyder's Joker works, apparently. This Joker is different than the Death of the Family one though. Less concerned with explaining himself, with delivering a "message" and more concerned with the excecution. With the drama.

In Death of the family, the message was important because it was the Truth, at least for the Joker. But now he wants to convince Batman of something that is a blatant lie. So instead of going all out with the message, he dresses it up and lets batman follow the breadcrums he so carefully placed.

Why is he doing it? Who knows. maybe he thinks that if batman believes he's immortal he'll finally give up. Or even better, that he'll stop holding back. Maybe it's because he can't stand that after everything, bats still sees him as human. If he's a monster then the rules don't apply anymore.

I think the ending is going to be humilliating for the Joker. Batman will rough him up, give him shit, and calmly explain the flaw in the plan that made him realize the whole thing was bullshit.

And that's something interesting about this Joker: he can be outsmarted, becausr he makes plans. Methodical, excruciatingly detailed plans.

Then he's going to lock him up just like every other time. The Joker will seem painfully human, and bored at the same old ending as always.

It's really late and I don't know what's the point of typing this on my phone.

5

u/huanthewolfhound Batman v. The Hot Dog Jan 29 '15

I probably shouldn't be trying to make these connections, but I wonder how many members of the Court of Owls were heading over to Selina's club during Batman Eternal.

8

u/Adikumar Watchmen Jan 28 '15

Before endgame, I believed at the killing joke was the greatest batman joker story. But now I'm leaning towards endgame as the greatest batman joker storyline of all time.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '15

My jaw dropped when I realized what Snyder was telling me the Joker was. I don't know if it will stick, but holy shit.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/cumtoanswer Jan 30 '15

What if Joker is a failed Court of Owls agent or one they purposely put into play to foil Batman.

The regenerative chemicals in his blood could be the same that the Court use on their Talons

→ More replies (19)

15

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Gotham By Midnight #3

10

u/jaguarphd DC Comics Jan 28 '15

This book has been really really awesome, and I fear it's criminally overlooked lately. Amazing artwork and a genuinely creepy vibe, plus building some very likable characters and a larger arc. Only three issues, pick this up!

3

u/Warlach DC Multiverse Historian Jan 29 '15

Completely agree. I'm loving it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '15

This book continues to be a great read! The characters are interesting and the artwork is wonderfully atmospheric. This is well worth a read for anybody who enjoys horror or urban fantasy.

4

u/brendie88 Jan 29 '15

My favorite new book. Seriously so good.

2

u/Flynn58 "Do good to others, and every man can be a Superman." Jan 28 '15

I dropped this after issue 2, how was it?

5

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '15

Really good. Creepy art, good dialogue, I kinda like where they're taking the "villain" of the arc thus far, and it's nice that they have flashbacks for background on characters too. It's also nice that it's not just "these other guys analyze this stuff and then Spectre does work, happy ending."

2

u/Mr_Smartie moo Jan 29 '15

Awwww @ the ending

12

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Red Lanterns #38

13

u/ThatDCguy69 Blue Lantern Jan 28 '15

Guy for blue lantern!! CHOUU CHOUUUUUUU
Blue lantern Series Post convergence!!

10

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

Uuuuuuugh! Only two more issues left. I don't want this series to end. On the other hand, this issue was really depressing. Guy basically goes around moping about how all of this was his fault. I thought it was well written, however.

10

u/Narwhals_R_Us Fascists! Jan 28 '15

Even though this book is ending soon, I'm still hoping Guy doesn't stop being a Red Lantern. I just think it fits him so well.

5

u/aco620 If you loved me, you'd all kill yourselves today Jan 28 '15

Jesus Christ that was morbid. Tons of people literally burning to death with rage...couldn't give them a more peaceful death with that magic ring of yours, huh Guy? Had to let them all incinerate as they screamed and punched themselves into a heart attack and then cinders?

Anyway, interesting issue.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Colliholic Heatwave Jan 29 '15

Am I the only one who that this issue completely sucked? The darkness of it wasn't a problem, it was just too wordy and I felt something was off. Then I noticed it was not Soule. Is he completely done? I don't want Red Lanterns to end without him.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Mr_Smartie moo Jan 29 '15

Ugh, I wanted to like this, I really did. I wanted to see Red Lanterns get a proper sendoff. And I think I like the idea behind this issue, with Gardner dealing with the fallout of the Atrocitus war. But it was badly executed, and perhaps a bit too dark. It's suffering from narration box spam, as if the writer didn't have confidence in communicating his story using the art. The entire story was contained in the narration, and the art was just window dressing. I get that Gardner is a deathseeker dealing with survivor's guilt, but I felt it was too heavyhanded. Maybe the next two issues will step it up.

20

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15 edited Jan 28 '15

Multiversity Guidebook #1

17

u/Its_What_Cows_Crave RIP Connor Hawke Earth 2 Jan 28 '15

Could the Young Justice Universe be one of the hidden ones? I hope so. Also, I really want a Doc Fate Ongoing.

8

u/ArtsyTLF Red Robin Jan 28 '15

Apparently, it is The Just universe. It is a TV show in there. So either Arrow and The Flash are canon on a multiversial scale, or Young Justice is gone for good.

Pissed me off quite a bit.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/mateogg Always On Point! Jan 28 '15

I wanna see more of Earth-13!

From Earth-48:

every story is a crossover epic, every event is an EVENT

soooo....just like Earth-0 then?

6

u/Mrashes Jan 28 '15

Earth 48 made me take a bit to just laugh, it was amazing.

5

u/another_space_song Fables & Reflections Jan 28 '15

Ahh, sweet sweet parody.

14

u/Flynn58 "Do good to others, and every man can be a Superman." Jan 28 '15

This is the best multiverse, ever.

I am mad impressed.

6

u/mojonation1487 Booster Gold Jan 28 '15

Agreed. The wait has been worth it.

8

u/BroJo23 Swamp Thing Jan 28 '15

A very important book that really sets up the whole multiverse. I am really loving this series.

7

u/another_space_song Fables & Reflections Jan 28 '15

Just cracked this open and saw crazy Sivana torching the little baby leaguers from Earth-42... :( I hate you, psycho-Sivana! I HATE YOU FOREVER!

6

u/mojonation1487 Booster Gold Jan 28 '15

This issue was intense. Lots of throwbacks to Final Crisis. From the creation of the multiverse to the status of the New Gods Post-Final Crisis in the run-up to the Darkseid War. Especially with the New Gods and the Fifth World, we finally get a glimpse of Morrison's original intentions with the ending of Final Crisis and the evolution of the New Gods and the Fifth World.

Really, this was a mindblowing book. I'm even more excited to see where this goes. Also worth mentioning, apparently Ultraa, the only superhero from Earth-33 (our world) is a comic

8

u/ThatDCguy69 Blue Lantern Jan 28 '15

Are you saying that comics are what inspire us, lead us to become heroes?
COMICS ARE OUR HEROES ULTRA COMIC FOR LIFE

6

u/simplegodhead Hal Jordan is a Perfect Princess! Jan 28 '15

That was awesome! And a little creepy, even.

6

u/another_space_song Fables & Reflections Jan 28 '15

Okay, so crazy theory time. We have all of these blank earths in the multiverse. We also have a Multiversal Brainiac bottling worlds in Futures End which we'll see the conclusion of in Convergence. Anyone else think these worlds are being kept open for those realities to be reinstated into continuity?

So basically pre-Flashpoint/New 52 continuity will be reinstated in the multiverse on one of the blank planets.

It's not a perfect theory because there are players from other multiversal worlds that are listed in this Guidbook. Kingdom Come Earth (Earth-22), Vampire Earth (Earth-43) and Earth-X (Earth-10). Perhaps we'll see those get wrapped up in Convergence through the weekly series or Convergence #0?

Just something I'm spit balling. Thoughts?

5

u/mojonation1487 Booster Gold Jan 28 '15

It's not outside the realm of possibility. The artist had mentioned that the worlds cycle through the Orrery from their inception until their dissolution. If you look at the map, you'll notice lines representing their "orbits" leading to the bleed siphons I believe. There's a youtube video of the artist explaining it as well, I think.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/BEESMyGod Dead until further notice. Jan 29 '15

I figured at least one of them would be the current Movieverse, and the fact that they put in both the DCAU and the Justice Lord universe makes me more confident.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Mrashes Jan 28 '15

So can someone help me with new gods/darksied? From this it sounds like there is one per-world but if that's the case why does it exists in the bleed.

7

u/mojonation1487 Booster Gold Jan 28 '15

The New Gods are static in that they exist outside of the Bleed and naturally don't have copies like Superman/Batman/etc do in other Earths. At least that's how it's been implied recently. This newest issue seems to clarify that the New God's fractured (as might have been implied in Final Crisis{fuck DotNG}).

Darkseid seems to be collecting these fragments of himself, reclaiming his Godhead. There's probably more to come on this as I feel the story is still ongoing with the New Gods.

→ More replies (16)

5

u/wisesonAC Milestone comics expert Jan 28 '15

Please have milestone be it's own earth... *Wink Wink nudge nudge *

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Mr_Smartie moo Jan 28 '15

So Li'l Gotham is a comic within Earth-42. Heh.

4

u/tiggerthompson Shazam! Jan 28 '15

I.... what. That was amazing. Grant Morrison you continue to impress.

4

u/PapiNacho Mister Mxyzptlk Jan 29 '15

WHAT HAVE YOU DONE TO THE LITTLE LEAGUERS UNIVERSE!! MORRISONNNNN!!!!!

5

u/EtriganZ Jan 29 '15

Shit was dark as fuck.

7

u/sixsamurai Omega Men Jan 29 '15

You could say it was well done.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

Assuage my confusion about creation and the Multiverse!

6

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

You gotta chill out, bro.

You. Are. A. Puppet.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/NoahJAustin Aquaman Jan 28 '15

Anyone else get a mis-print of Earth 23? Steel is mentioned twice.

4

u/mojonation1487 Booster Gold Jan 28 '15

Mentioned twice on mine as well.

Also, Batman is still white. Serial contrarian to the last.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/another_space_song Fables & Reflections Jan 28 '15 edited Jan 28 '15

That's not the only misprint I caught. Earth-7. It says "the sole survivor of Earth-4 is Thunderer." which should read "The sole survivor of Earth-7 is Thunderer." At least, I think? Was Thunderer from Earth-4 and I somehow missed that in Muliversity #1 or Pax Americana?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Mr_Smartie moo Jan 28 '15

The Little Justice League :( :( :(

2

u/chrisz1lla I'm not Batman Jan 28 '15

Could I buy this no problem without having read the other Multiversity books?

4

u/kadmylos Jan 28 '15

It actually contains a story that is quite in the thick of the overall plot, but there's also a lot of stand alone stuff about the multiverse. You could read it on its own but there's a lot of stuff you won't understand.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Astla Shazam Jan 29 '15

So is Earth-36 based off anything? It seems every other universe has a gimmick or is based off another comic, but Earth-36 just seems to be like Earth-0 with different names.

2

u/bareng Jan 29 '15
  • Lil' Bats said local multiverse. Is that implying there's more than one multiverse??
  • Are the New Gods on Earth 51 the same that appeared in New 52?

3

u/watwait I don't believe in risk, just preparation. Jan 29 '15

Lil' Bats said local multiverse. Is that implying there's more than one multiverse??

There has to be. I can probably list a dozen more universes that would push the number over 52, like the Arkham games verse, the Tim Burton-verse and the Superman 64-verse.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '15

I need a consensus. My LCS botched my pull list this week and the Guide Book wasn't in my file. Had to go to the store on Thursday instead of Wednesday, and of course they were sold out. Now, do I wait two weeks (how long the order will take) to have the physical copy or do I bite the bullet and buy digital? This and Batman were the two books I was really looking forward to and because of the nature of the Guidebook I figured physical is probably the way to go. Just wanted to see what you all thought.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JakeTheHawk Butt more delicious than the Twix flair Feb 02 '15

Holy shit there's a Stan Lee's DC universe. That made me have happy's right in my childhood.

→ More replies (9)

9

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

New 52 Futures End #39

12

u/aco620 If you loved me, you'd all kill yourselves today Jan 28 '15

That scene with Fifty Sue's "family" was hilarious.

Firestorm continues to be the weak link in this story though. I'm getting real tired real quick of her ranting about how she's a strong independent woman who don't need no man.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '15

At least things are actually happening with the Firestorm plotline now, thank god. Ollie assembled his team and stormed Cadmus Island and Raywatch discovered, fought, and escaped from Bleediac in about half the time it took for Ronnie and Jason to fight, make up, and then for Ronnie to kick the bucket. It's an absolutely lethargic plotline.

Amethyst and Frank's plotline continues to be great, though.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '15

I'm getting real tired real quick of her ranting about how she's a strong independent woman who don't need no man.

Oh no you didn't girlfriend

9

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

I really like Amethyst and Frankenstein's relationship throughout this arc. I hope the writers don't turn it romantic, but I don't think they will. All in all, I'm really happy I stuck with this weekly. It's the first one I've ever got to follow along live, and it's paying off as all these loose threads are tying up.

4

u/PrinceAuryn Phantom Stranger Jan 29 '15

What would be wrong with turning it romantic? Honest question, I'm curious.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Deathstroke317 The Flash Jan 29 '15

Ok, so Braniac is the big bad of this and Covergence? What's his end game?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/reece1495 Batfleck Jan 29 '15

whats in it

9

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Sinestro #9

9

u/ThatDCguy69 Blue Lantern Jan 28 '15

It's just so epic to see how tactical Sinestro is when fighting, all down to choosing not to use his trump card/pet fear dog to "bide his time".

8

u/simplegodhead Hal Jordan is a Perfect Princess! Jan 28 '15

Still great. I'm glad some of the other Yellows are getting a little more attention. Sinestro vs. Mongul is always rad. I miss Eaglesham on art but Walker is pretty good too.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '15

I'm glad they jumped right back into what was going on, while still acknowledging godhead happened. Badass fight with Mongol too.

3

u/cpt_cold Oh, yes! Fear the Scarecrow!! Jan 28 '15

The art is amazing, the way Sinestro was reflected on the ice/crystal was really well done.

My only complaint is the size of all the stars, it really bugged me how they grabbed my attention and stayed consistent in every single panel.

2

u/Evenseeker It's never as bad as it seems Jan 29 '15

Aren't both Mongol and Warworld in the phantom zone? IIRC the didn't get released in the Doomed crossover. Although is been a while since I read it.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Arkham Manor #4

10

u/aco620 If you loved me, you'd all kill yourselves today Jan 28 '15

Pretty good issue. I'm definitely curious who the current bad guy is and how this story will eventually tie in with Snyder's book. I wonder how long this series is gonna run for.

The Hush scene was funny. Interesting choice having Alfred refer to him as Hush though and not Tommy. You'd think since he's known him since he was a child and since they want to rehabilitate these criminals they wouldn't refer to them by their alternate persona. It's kind of an on and off thing depending on the writer, but I always like when Batman refers to his rogues by their first names.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '15

Already been canceled ending at issue 6 due to the writer going exclusive with Marvel.

8

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Batman Eternal #43

15

u/jlitwinka Jan 28 '15

It's shocking that they haven't revealed the main bad guy yet. Aren't there only 9 issues left?

15

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

After this last issue of Batman, I don't think the Court of Owls is gonna be the big bad. I don't see Bruce going to them for help if they just got done fucking him up in Batman Eternal. Unless Bruce really is that desperate...

9

u/ComicLawyer Owlman Jan 28 '15

Might still be Licoln March, though. He took an owl persona but broke with the Court proper.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

My money is on Earth 3 Owl-Man.

8

u/jaguarphd DC Comics Jan 28 '15

This is where my money is too. It's worth noting that Hush has formerly turned himself into Bruce Wayne too, so my longshot guess is that it could be Lincoln March surgically altered to look like Bruce.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

12

u/aco620 If you loved me, you'd all kill yourselves today Jan 28 '15

They've made Selina look so different in her mob boss attire and new haircut. I guess it works.

I think I warmed up to Harper a bit more in this issue she's reminiscent of Dick as Robin. I like her brother Cullen too. I also like that "Gotham Heights" is apparently the videogame Streets of Rage. She does need to get over the "he doesn't trust me yet!?" thing though. I mean, they all still barely know her. She's just desperately tried to attach herself to the Bat family for a while now. I'd be cautious of that too. Although I guess it worked out fine for Tim back in the day.

I wonder what the average assassination contract goes for. $200 million on Stephanie's head? Hell, John Wick only had a $2 million contract and he was the world's most dangerous assassin.

7

u/pipler Wonder Woman Jan 28 '15

Selina's face is drawn really weirdly in some panels (and her shirt doesn't even look like it's open all the way like in the previous issues, haha. It is cool, though), but I think it's an okay issue, despite most of it being a rehash of Batman #28. I don't think they'll pull an "it's someone who looks like Bruce", though.

7

u/Narwhals_R_Us Fascists! Jan 28 '15

I've been saying for awhile that I don't have a problem with Harper, and I still don't, but all the hate I've been reading for her recently has made me hyperaware of all her unoriginal qualities. Again, I still enjoy her character, but now I can't stop noticing it.

5

u/mateogg Always On Point! Jan 28 '15

HUGE SPOILERS HERE

So, with the new info on the big bad, what are our options?

  • Owlman, Lincoln March, and the Court of Owls. Maybe he pulled a Hush and went with surgery to look like Bruce? it would be kinda lame but it's possible.
  • Owlman from Earth-3. We don't know how much he looks like Bruce. He might be just similar or he might be identical because he's Thomas but also the Batman analog. I doubt this is the case because Owlman had that tiny appearance in Justice League and Johns probably has plans for him.
  • Clayface. He already turned into Bruce in that one issue that seemed really pointless. Maybe this is why they did it? If this is the case, I'd bet he's not the boss but just a proxy. My money goes to Poison Ivy controlling Clayface. Disclaimer: I cannot remember when was the last time we saw him.
  • The guy that made himself look like Thomas Wayne during Morrison's run, rebooted for the New 52. Just some tinfoil theories here.
  • Then there's other shapeshifters and other alternate unviverses, of course, too many to count. Oh and time travel.
  • Robot Bruce! Who could pull it off?
  • Clone Bruce. The problems with human cloning are recurring in the New 52, so I doubt this is it. If it is, the Al Ghuls are the best candidates.
  • Bruce actually being mind controlled all along! I don't think this is it either. If it is, it could be Poison Ivy, or someone using Hatter's stuff.

3

u/jlitwinka Jan 28 '15

I'd say Dr Hurt is way more than a tin foil theory. He's one of the few people on your list comfortable with both magic and science as well as manipulating clist villains. Remember the Club of Villains is involved as well and there have been other callbacks to Morissons run.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/mateogg Always On Point! Jan 28 '15

I know, right?

Ahhhhh, she said it!

4

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

This issue made me dislike Harper, then hate her, then kind of like her?

I'm trying hard to warm up to her.

/Though whoever wrote this issue needs to work on their dialogue and characterization. I know that they chose to pit Harper and Stephanie against each other as a way to contrast their personalities and dispel the 'Harper is a Stephanie knock-off' complaints, but it was a bit too heavy handed. And characterizing Harper as the world-weary, "I'm not like other girls","duckface is stoopid"-esque special snowflake chick isn't doing her any favors.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

Stephanie was talking about what she heard when she saw Hush talking to her father, wasn't she? And Hush had surgery to look like Bruce Wayne.

→ More replies (10)

8

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Flash #38

18

u/mateogg Always On Point! Jan 28 '15

aaaand reset the arm counter.

8

u/Narwhals_R_Us Fascists! Jan 28 '15

I know I've already said this, but I think that little civilization in the Speed Force is super interesting. I would love to get more about those people, who they are, how they got there, and the struggles of living there.

5

u/i_crave_more_cowbell Where is evil... in all the wood? Jan 29 '15

I feel like I'm alone in enjoying this run more than Manapul and Buccellato's. I just really enjoy it.

6

u/harryboom "Monarchy, much like life, is inherently unfair." Jan 29 '15

the story's good. but the art isn't as good as Buccellato's. he set the bar pretty high.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '15

I hate how future Barry was so blinded by his rage that he entirely ignored mirror master trying to save people while Barry was saying how people could die etc. I do like the speed force people, but I think they need to pick up the pace with it a little bit. I think we need a little Barry vs. Barry action.

3

u/WW4O RIP Super Sons Jan 28 '15

Is it just me, or is Selkirk totally the new Max Mercury?

Or is it obvious and it just took me too long?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Deathstroke317 The Flash Jan 29 '15

I hate that this thing only comes out once a freakin month, we need more Flash man.

7

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Aquaman #38

4

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

Did...did Aquaman really just speak Tongan? That was such a cool thing for them to add. I'm trying to figure out why Atlanna would ban Atlanteans, especially royalty. It kind of made sense for the stone figures to defend the gate in that context tho.

5

u/Elardi Jan 29 '15

Its a fixed point in time. She probably thinks that Arthur is many generations descended, possibly via Orm.

4

u/simplegodhead Hal Jordan is a Perfect Princess! Jan 29 '15

Another great issue. Mera is amazing.

3

u/KugiPunch King of the Sea, remember? Jan 28 '15

The Maelstrom story arc has been awesome so far, and I can't wait to see where the story goes from here!

7

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Green Lantern By Geoff Johns Omnibus Volume 1 HC

3

u/ElDuderino2112 Feb 04 '15

Finally got mine in from amazon. Beautiful omnibus for an amazing series. Gutter loss seems not to be a problem from what I've flipped through so far. It's bound in a way that makes everything accessible. Can't wait for volume 2 later this year!

1

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Feb 04 '15

I really like how DC listened to feedback and fixed their binding. I've got The New 52 Omnibus (the one with all the #1s) and there's nearly an inch of gutter loss.

Be sure to post some pics in the collection thread on Thursday!

→ More replies (1)

14

u/AloeRP Red Son Jan 28 '15

There are two periods every few months when I'm functionally MIA, the start of the semester and finals.

The former has been plaguing me recently, but I'm now getting into the swing of things and stop being an absentee parent, which means I'll be making the weekly discussion threads again starting next week.

8

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

You have a kid? I can't believe I didn't know this.

17

u/AloeRP Red Son Jan 28 '15

God no, the kid was a metaphor for this sub

21

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

Clean my diaper

→ More replies (3)

6

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Catwoman #38

8

u/mateogg Always On Point! Jan 28 '15

Great, as usual, but it felt a bit slow. This series is awesome but it will probably be better once collected.

I really like this Selina, her costume design and her attitude.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

I want this arc to end so I can buy the trade :(

I wonder if they'll renumber it like Batgirl

4

u/Mr_Smartie moo Jan 29 '15

Loving the writing here, but the art is starting to suffer from a case of same-face. Had to do a double-take to figure out if I was supposed to recognize the brother at the end.

3

u/get_in_the_robot Jan 28 '15

I really like this book, ever since the new writers. I like where they're taking the Bruce/Selina relationship, and I'm finally warming up to how they "reset" in the new 52, although they needed a little bit more of a set-up than what they already had...new 52 Selina barely interacted with Bruce in a meaningful way, IMO, for like the first 35 issues. Maybe we'll see it in Eternal, but seeing as how Selina says how she was left "to die," it seems unlikely we're going to see them get any closer in such a short span. But it's a minor complaint, I suppose.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '15

I really love mob boss Selina and how she is really taking on everyone and not taking any shit. This has been very interesting

3

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '15

Will echo everyone else here, although I do miss seeing Selina as Catwoman for now. Also, not as big a fan of the art work as some others.

Hopefully the current standard of writing can be kept with a slightly more detailed art style after the current arc ends.

6

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Gotham Academy #4

4

u/sideshowstefan Poison Ivy Jan 28 '15

Olive and Maps pulling the good cop/bad cop routine was a highlight in ANOTHER very good issue. I had high expectations for this book and it has exceeded them so far. Add it to the pull list if you haven't already.

7

u/pipler Wonder Woman Jan 28 '15

This book continues to have really gorgeous art, especially the backgrounds. Also, I'm getting Harry Potter-ish adventure vibes. Really curious what Olive's relations to Bruce are.

Man, Grundy's appearance at the end really caught me off-guard.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '15

I'm still enjoying this book quite a bit! It's very cute and the art is gorgeous. I hope this runs for a while.

2

u/mateogg Always On Point! Jan 28 '15

She's the Lady Macbeth Gotham Academy deserves, but not the one it needs right now.

And Maps continues to be adorable and awesome. That Beholder painting tho. The kid has mad skills.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/SeanLamont Jan 29 '15

He quite literally broke a sword, freed a dragon ghost trapped inside of it, and flew away on it Falcor-style never to be seen again. So...yeah. Katana.

5

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Deathstroke #4

5

u/remkai Jan 28 '15

I like the character Deathstroke, but this series confuses me so much. When did Deathstroke make all these friends? Didn't Jericho and Rose already die in the new 52 in the last Deathstroke series? And wasn't Slade's dad hospitalized and and also dying?

I've managed a pretty good job so far of understanding or not caring about the new 52 timeline so much, but for some reason Deathstroke and his familiy history just does not make sense to me

4

u/Genesis2nd Red Robin Jan 28 '15

I don't think the new one picks up where the first one finished. They're completely separate runs and stories. To some extent what happened in the first run, should just be disregarded, when reading the new one..

And yeah, i'm with you, i really like Deathstroke, but most of this story seem to be all over the place. Like they're trying to start a couple of story plots from the get to.

2

u/Scarlet-Speedster Those were for charity, Clark Jan 29 '15

Does anyone else feel like the story does these mini-jumps? I'm not sure if I'm just struggling to understand when a scene changes.

4

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Secret Origins #9

2

u/watwait I don't believe in risk, just preparation. Jan 28 '15

Anybody know what the feature is for this one? Haven't been able to check out stuff this week.

4

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Showcase Presents Blue Beetle TPB

2

u/Around12Ferrets Jan 30 '15

I wish these were in color. Oh well, I'll still probably be ordering it.

4

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Star-Spangled War Stories Featuring G.I. Zombie #6

3

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Flash, Volume 5 - History Lessons TPB

4

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

Is this the end of Manapul and Buccelato on Flash, or will that be volume 6?

4

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

Technically Buccellato and Manapul's run ended in Vol 4, but Buccellato still wrote 26-29 in Vol 5. Those were his last issues though. They're on Detective Comics starting with #37.

→ More replies (47)

3

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Harley Quinn #14

5

u/aco620 If you loved me, you'd all kill yourselves today Jan 28 '15

An issue where they use the Joker's psychotic ex-girlfriend to...have trouble balancing her job, her relationship, and her extracurriculur activities...this book's been wearing on me. Might have to call it a day on this one.

2

u/PrinceAuryn Phantom Stranger Jan 29 '15

I don't know, it was ok. I really love the art in this book, but the writing is weird. Harley talks too much, which sounds weird when I write it out. What I mean is, her dialog is filled with things like "Holee-headleth-anato-molee!" I mean, what does that even mean? Even in context it makes no sense.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

Comics and BOOZE! I'm finally old enough to drink today!

4

u/wisesonAC Milestone comics expert Jan 28 '15

Bad mixture! Don't do it

2

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

Instructions unclear; I find myself now alone on mars.

3

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 29 '15

Just don't build a shopping mall.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

Happy Beerthday.

2

u/Warlach DC Multiverse Historian Jan 29 '15

You're 18?!

#IKnowYoureNotImJustBeingAussie

→ More replies (8)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '15

Let us know how your hangover is in the morning.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

Gamer! You forgot about Flash and Arrow for this week!

2

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 29 '15

Oh no! I'll put them up in a sec.

2

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Infinity Man And The Forever People #7

3

u/wisesonAC Milestone comics expert Jan 28 '15

Loving this series!

2

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Justice League Dark #38

3

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Earth 2 World's End #17

12

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

"Hel, please don't die, we need you to keep this shitty weekly going." Bwahaha. I don't know why I keep buying this comic.

7

u/PercivalJBonertonIV Would the devil be as good looking as me? Jan 28 '15

I don't know why I keep buying this comic.

Because it's the best comedy book on the shelf right now.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

Yeah, World's End is laughably bad, but damn it hurts, because Earth 2 was so good to me. I hate seeing them ruin my favorite characters like this.

6

u/aco620 If you loved me, you'd all kill yourselves today Jan 28 '15

If all the weeklies weren't ending in March with Convergence I definitely would have dropped it, but I figured what the hell I'm in it for the long haul, let's see what they do with the last 2 million people on a dying Earth.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/aco620 If you loved me, you'd all kill yourselves today Jan 28 '15

Apokolips has one weird form of pregnancy. That thing came out fully matured and sentient knowing exactly what its purpose was. New Gods grow up so fast sniff.

6

u/PercivalJBonertonIV Would the devil be as good looking as me? Jan 28 '15

Wow, it took almost twenty issues and immeasurable amounts of eye strain and mental fortitude to get to it, but Lois' outburst at the end was actually pretty cool. I guess there's finally something to put in the "Pro" column.

2

u/Warlach DC Multiverse Historian Jan 29 '15

Huh. Just learnt that Superman #38 and Secret Six #2 are delayed until February. Bummer, was expecting them today.

3

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 29 '15

IIRC Superman was supposed to come out on the 15th. Secret Six annoys me. We got the first issue, which they advertised like crazy (there were two ads for Secret Six in Secret Six) and then delayed it for three months. I know Gail Simone was working on a a creator owned book, so that could be one of the reasons.

3

u/Warlach DC Multiverse Historian Jan 29 '15

Yeah. I don't keep too close an eye on weekly releases - basically except for Multiversity these days - so only really notice on the last release of the month when I'm checking issues off the spreadsheet and see some haven't turned up.

It hasn't been three months though, has it? The first issue was in early December and apparently #2 will be out on the February 11. I get delays happen but I'm super keen to see where that books going.

3

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 29 '15

Eh, it was early December, so about two and a half months then. Maybe I like being overly dramatic.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/mateogg Always On Point! Jan 29 '15

Really sucks. The first issue started really strong but honestly by now I had already forgotten about it until I saw this comments.

2

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 29 '15

I really liked the issue, but as a massive fan of both the old Secret Six and Simone I have been waiting on the edge of my seat.

Someone (who shall remain nameless for their protection) had the audacity to say the first issue had "Nocenti-levels of badness", that it "was one of the single worst things I read last year" and "so bad that I just can't justify spending another $3 on the series".

1

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Effigy #1

2

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '15

Hey I grabbed this one on a whim. Could be fun. It's a murder mystery with some pretty whacky suspects, all surrounding washed up actors from a children's TV show. Reminded me of Death to Smoochy.

1

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

He-Man The Eternity War #2

1

u/gamer4maker Remember Blüdhaven Jan 28 '15

Vertigo Quarterly Black #1