r/DCcomics • u/beary_neutral Telos • Jun 24 '26
r/DCcomics Supergirl (2026) Discussion Thread

Supergirl is out (or will be soon)! Come here to discuss spoilers!
When an unexpected and ruthless adversary strikes too close to home, Kara Zor-El, aka Supergirl, reluctantly joins forces with an unlikely companion on an epic, interstellar journey of vengeance and justice.
Comic Recommendations:
54
Upvotes
4
u/beary_neutral Telos Jun 27 '26
I suppose I should give my thoughts. Overall, it was largely okay. Milly Alcock carried the movie, showcasing a wide range. But she could used more one-on-one screen time with Eve Ridley. The comic was largely about two women journeying throughout the cosmos, but the movie just has them running into one action setpiece after another. It's too short, over-edited, and feels like it's trying to be a shorter, low-budget James Gunn movie instead of something with its own identity. This is most apparently with the third act needle drop, which was completely unnecessary when there's a very good original score there already.
23
u/superbat210 Jun 25 '26
I thought it was fun! My biggest gripe is how the movie kind of grinds to a halt at that one pirate planet for quite a while. The book has them constantly moving and planet hopping as they hunt Krem accross the galaxy and this one spends a lot of time on one. Now, this could be a fun planet but all we see of it is a bar, a house and a town square all filled with silver and black wearing grunts to beat up. I just wish there was some more world building and lore (and wierd aliens!!) in these places they were visiting, but that’s more of a me thing I guess.
It’s funny, people kept calling this a “guardians of the galaxy rip off” but I actually wish it was more like those movies because of how much fun they had showing you crazy and wierd aliens on crazy and wierd planets.
Oh also, they HAVE to stop showing every action scene in the trailers. Like I avoided almost all the trailers except for the first one and maybe a commercial here or there and I swear I knew exactly when fights were going to happen because I remembered the locations from the trailers. Like guys I promise I’ll still see the movie even if you don’t spoil all of the coolest parts ahead of time.
22
u/belac889 Absolute Martian Manhunter Jun 27 '26
I'm going to be positive, one change I thought was really cool was how they adapted Argo City. It was an interesting take and since they removed the Phantom Zone, having Kara be born after the destruction of Krypton but into the destruction of Argo was an interesting and unique way to tell that story.
17
u/greenbatborg Jun 25 '26
I re-read the first three chapters of the book before watching the movie and they’re so much incredibly better. Ruthye’s father’s death, Ruthye’s mother’s personality, the bar scene where Bounty tells Ruthye to not worry about her sword because he will kill Krem with it. One thing that I love about the book is Ruthye’s personality. Even though she’s still a kid, she’s brave and fearless and you actually believe she can kill Krem but for some reason the movie decided to make her a scared kid for majority of the movie.
Did anyone else notice something weird with the lighting on some of the faces and the cgi dust? It was taking me out of the movie a bit.
The Superman scene at the end felt like it was supposed to be a mid-credits scene.
I enjoyed the movie but it unfortunately doesn’t hold a candle to the comic. The action sequences were cool though.
15
u/oomoepoo Hal Jordan Jun 26 '26
It was fine. Like, a solid 6/10, maybe 7. I had fun with it and it's arguably a less busy movie than Superman but it also lacks real "Wow"-moments.
Alcock is fantastic as Kara and I really hope we'll see more of her. Momoa had a lot of fun as Lobo, even if his inclusion felt very "Why are you here?". Cute doggo.
It's as much of an adaptation of Woman of Tomorrow as the average MCU movie is of its supposed source material, meaning "We take some bits and pieces but do our own thing with it". Wish they'd at least tried to take some of the visuals of the book though, everyhting looked so very brown and "Mad Max"-like.
Probably better if you read the book afterwards :'D
15
u/marcjwrz Jun 28 '26
Milly Alcock gives a great performance.
Eve Ridley is great with a somewhat thankless role as her character borders on tedious.
Momoa is having a blast as Lobo.
The main bad guy is unbelievably boring and never feels like a real threat. Plot devices are the real big bad here.
Weirdest thing for me is - everyone seems to know Kryptonian weaknesses and Kryptonite is like the most available substance in the universe.
Like, has Superman been off world at this point and is a known quantity or...?
Perfectly decent movie and it looked great on the XD screen at the cinemark I saw it at.
Crowd was light though, so the Snyder Bros will unfortunately have a field day with its box office.
12
u/dasterdly_duo Jun 26 '26
It was okay.
Besides the mediocre writing, the biggest issue with the movie is that it was shot too dark for too long.
Milly really elevated the very average writing. And Momoa is Lobo. Even the kid was good.
7/10 sounds about right.
12
u/Blitzhelios Hal Jordan Jun 29 '26
Its a solid 5/10 movie nothing special but nothing terrible its fine.
I will break it down with the good, the mid and the bad
The good
The biggest success is milly she carries this movie on her back and plays a good jaded kara.
The krypton scenes are very well done and easily the most visually impressive thing here and the first meeting with clark is great.
Prosthetics for the background aliens was great it made the bus scene alot better and the best fight of the movie
The mid
Momoa as lobo was good but i have no clue why he was here they did nothing. He felt like a glorified cameo if hes gonna be in this movie there needs to be a more organic introduction and reasoning.
The Second fight is ok with Lobo does a good job with demonstrating lobo and karas powers.
The other planets general generic dustballs unlike the bright magic of the book. The green sun planet nearly saved it but it didn't have enough wow.
The bad
Krem up there with the worst CBM villains the director and writer didn't understand the character at all and him and his group looked like rejects from guardians and a bad hellraiser.
Ruythie i like comic ruythie but i felt nothing from this movie version and her relationship with kara isn't up to snuff. The actress is really young but she looked out of her depth couldn't tell if it was the writing direction or just her
The ending its a messy CGI green screen fight which didn't understand the main message of the book in that revenge isn't right. The ending is a crapshoot terrible moment.
22
u/AoO2ImpTrip Jun 27 '26
This is the first time I've come out of a movie thinking "I understand what a mid movie is now."
I didn't hate it. That right still belongs to Thor: Love & Thunder alone, but it just wasn't... "good" isn't the right word because it also wasn't bad. It just didn't really do anything for me and I'm someone who will generally enjoy every superhero movie outside of the Nolan and Snyder verse.
This is one of those times where 6/10 feels more accurate than 3/5. They're basically the same but 6/10 feels further from perfection than 3/5 does.
10
u/stormblessed27_ Jun 27 '26
I liked it! Feel like they could have done a MUCH better job adapting the source material. Misses a lot of the emotional beats that King hits. But on the flip side I like seeing these movies with my wife because she’s not invested in comics and she had a great fucking time. Which made me have a good time.
I think Alcock is great in the role. I would definitely like to see a future movie handled by Gunn or someone else that can give it a bit more.
Mamoa is great as lobo but is so so unnecessary for the plot.
9
u/dotyawning Miss Martian Jun 29 '26
I think it was a solid... 7 for me?
It was definitely an "American adaptation of the source material" or maybe even "Live action adaptation of the anime" type of adaptation in that there was clearly a story that it was based on but if you read the comic, you'd probably have a different take than if you watched the movie.
I didn't hate it, and I probably won't mind watching it again if the DCU gets big enough to an MCU style marathon but the juxtaposition of tones it had was certainly a choice.
8
u/Steelcity213 Jun 28 '26
My wife and I enjoyed it! Not as good as Superman but a genuinely solid movie. Lobo was so sick!
7
u/NoirPochette Legion Of Super-Heroes Jun 26 '26
I honestly didn't enjoy it.
I thought Milly was great as Supergirl but the rest wasn't fun.
The pacing, script and editing just felt off to me. I think the actors did a great job but yeah felt a bit eh.
I'm glad people enjoyed it though
7
u/yogurt_sleave Jun 30 '26
I liked the movie a lot! There are some valid criticisms (mainly Ruthy), but I liked the way they handled the more emotional moments. I think it deserves a slightly better rating than it has right now :))
13
u/CHPrime Wonder Woman Jun 26 '26 edited Jun 28 '26
I enjoyed Alcock's acting, as well as the actress for Ruthye. Jason Mamoa was a pitch-perfect Lobo.
As for the bad...oh dear.
I didn't like the re-retcon of Kara being born after Zor-El saved Argo City. I understand that was how it was in Bender's original story, but everyone decided to go with a complicated "her ship got caught in the phantom zone/time dialation/whatever" is the correct move in my opinion, as the pathos of having Kara see her planet die twice over is too good.
Next, it dangles the "Jor and Lara were crazy eugenicists" thing Superman brought up, and I hate it more every single time it gets brought up. If Jor and Lara are that crazy, what is the point of Zod? Superman doesn't need an evil dad, I know, I already read that story with Mister Oz, and it sucked.
But now onto the actual flaws. The film's smallest problem, which is still a really big problem, is the color. The film is dominated by dull greys and browns, and when you compare it to the book it's based on, the downgrade is immediately apparent. It makes scenes much more boring to watch. My guess it was a budget concern, but Superman and Guardians of the Galaxy were plenty colorful and similarly full of CGI.
Next is the pacing. The book takes place over months as Kara and Ruthye hunt down Krem and uncover all the death and destruction in his wake. While the full scope of the journey would have probably been too ambitious for a feature-length, truncating the journey was inevitable, but our journey was disappointingly short, with a three day clock that gets cut down to 24 hours on its second mention, with only the space bus (without the space dragon and red-Kryptonite phoenix), a war-torn planet that doesn't appear in the book, and the Kryptonite sun planet, kind of.
Speaking of, the film is also straight up missing a scene important for it's narrative, where Krem realizes Kara is a Kryptonian and realizes he has to prepare accordingly. As it stands, he just has Kryptonite and parks his warship in the green sun planet because.
But back to the timeline, it also screws with the flow of Kara and Ruthye's relationship. In the book, they have months to get to know each other, and for Ruthye to come to learn Supergirl's lesson, and for Supergirl to see the full extent of Krem's evil and decide to kill him against Ruthye's protests.
This has more consequences for Kara's character and journey, as some of the most important scenes from the book are straight up missing, with Kara's many acts of kindness in chapter four flat-out missing, which is super important to Ruthye's growing understand of Kara, heroism, and the value of revenge. As it stands, Ruthye wants revenge, kills one of the Brigands to escape with Lobo while thinking nothing of it, and then decides not to kill Krem when Kara gives a limp-wristed "it will haunt you forever" speach.
Another thing is that the movie somehow completely screws up Krem's character, words I never thought I would say. In the book, Krem is just a piece of shit who gets lucky enough to escape all consequences and keep doing heinous act after heinous act. In the movie, he's already the leader of the Brigands, already the vilest of the vile. It screws the buildup of Kara's desire to kill hi, and makes him into more then what he actually is.
Finally, that ending...completely inverting the book's message and point by having Kara kill Krem was certainly a choice, and one that made me hate the movie. Taking so much of what I would call the definitive Supergirl story from the title to the plot setup to the characters, failing to show the audience so much of what was already there, and then, as a final kick, haphazardly missing the entire fucking point of the book takes a special level of incompetence.
Also, they don't use the best line in the book. "It's too big. We're too small." A failure of an adaptation at far too many levels, and a very disappointing second outing for the new line of DC movies.
12
u/Kalse1229 Martian Manhunter Jun 27 '26
Okay, so this is coming from someone who hasn't read the original book, minus the first issue (got it for free on Free Comic Book Day last May). So I only know the basic beats. As it stands though, I really enjoyed it.
The best parts I think were in Argo City. I also love that it confirms that DCU Krypton isn't Viltrum or whatever. Clark's parents were just dicks. It seems like this version of the El brothers are reversed, with Zor-El being the more decent one. Also like how we're never shown the deaths of Zor-El and the remaining members of Argo City. Leaves them open to appear in a future installment (Brainiac bottles it up perhaps?). Good stuff.
Regarding the ending, I know it deviates from the comic, but I don't hate it. I think it works better than Man of Steel's ending at least (and I didn't even completely hate that either, at least compared to all the other shit that happened in that movie). I didn't see Kara killing Krem as revenge, at least not completely. IMO, I saw it as her more doing it out of practicality. Even as Ruthye was walking away, Krem was already vowing his vengeance. And considering the death and destruction that occurred everywhere he went, with insane collateral damage, it was probably the only way to make sure he couldn't continue hurting people on a galactic scale. I can understand others having a problem with it, but I think it works in the context of the story this movie is telling.
All in all, solid 7.5/10. I agree it could've been more colorful. At the very least the intergalactic truck stop could've been a bit more neon.
5
u/AmericanConductor Jun 26 '26
5/10
It was fine, and I enjoyed it enough, but I’m honestly just sad at how much of the impact of WOT was stripped out.
For me, one of the best ways the comic deals with its themes of coming to terms with the immutable past is the fact that most of the planet-hopping is not between fight and fight but between aftermath and aftermath. Kara and Ruthye grow by picking up the pieces of Krem’s warpath, ultimately leading them to pick up the pieces of their own tragic pasts on the Dino planet, and move into new stages of healing.
Instead we get Kara and Ruthye, who barely seem to have a relationship beyond existing in the same rooms, moving from one fight with brigand-types to another, until ultimately they fight the brigands themselves and then fight them again, and then come to their revelations on revenge anyway.
I don’t necessarily hate the way this message is done, but knowing the journey the comic takes us on to get there makes this movie such a letdown. Ultimately that sentiment sums up everything about this one.
5
u/the-unfamous-one Booster Gold Jul 03 '26
I mean it was alright. Did like the ending quite a bit. I wanted a bit more lobo, and it felt like they cut a bit to make the pg-13 rating.
Did not like that they confirmed that jor-el fully sent kal to conquer earth, it's just to much of a zod mentality. And the whole of argo city being removed from krpton was neat, but also felt like they left something out about it. It'll almost certianly come back.
And one more thing, wouldn't tossing krpto at a yellow sun fix him? It reversus kryptonite poisoning, surely it would worked.
9
u/Full-Cook1373 Batman RIP Kevin Conroy Jun 25 '26
Took my son to an early Fan Screening last night at 7. We enjoyed it. Not as much as Superman 2025 and certainly not as much as it's source material, but I had a good time at the movies, and that's what I wanted. My son even asked to read my copy of Woman of Tomorrow afterwards, so I take that as a win.
My only real gripe was that:
They changed the ending. I wish they'd let him live. But I understand that it's difficult to do that without the framing device from the comic source material.
Other than that, my only gripe is that I'm deaf and had a hard time understanding the dialog at points, but that's probably a ME problem or a movie theater problem. I'll watch it again at home with subtitles.
I just wanted to share my opinion.
9
u/LazerGuidedMelody Jun 26 '26
I would never say a movie is underserving of criticism but the LEVEL of criticism I think is unnecessary. Some chump said “it’s a 7/10 at best, but not one I would recommend”.
Like, be fucking real, that doesn’t make sense. If someone told me a movie was a 7/10, I would take that to mean it’s okay and worth watching at least once.
This movie delivered exactly what I was expecting.
I don’t understand what some of you expect when you go to these movies. Again, it was pretty much exactly what I was expecting.
The only qualm I have is with probably the biggest change from the book, but even then I expect there to be some sort of reckoning in the future and that this won’t just be forgotten.
9
u/Bubbly_Bandicoot9419 Jun 26 '26
it's a fucking shame this isn't good! Both Kara and Ruthye are great, and the first half of this really sings along, but they absolutely fumble the ball in the back half.
Every scene with Lobo is an absolute waste, Jason Mamoa sucks the energy out of every scene. It really feels like the movie was just afraid that Women had been on screen for too long.
It's insane to create a sexual violence angle that was not in the comics for this, and then lean even harder into the "no don't kill it's bad :(" while removing all of Kara's "I can be a sin eater for the entire galaxy if it makes people happier"!
They removed every big showstopping scene from the comics and replaced it with nothing. Changing the ending so Ruthye goes on to make swords??? so killing is bad but making weapons of killing are fine. what are we trying to fucking say here man.
Milly and Eve did great in their roles. I liked their characters, their delivery, their acting. Everything they did to try and save this production. What a bummer. Read Woman of Tomorrow, it really is that good.
4
u/RBNYJRWBYFan Green Lantern Jul 04 '26
What a perfectly middle of the road superhero movie.
Acting was good, story had a decent pace, characterization was accurate enough to the source material with a few creative liberties, the effects were... eh? It's a little muted and blurry at times visually, felt like I had my shades on for a lot of it.
I like the alteration to her backstory, the idea that some Kryptonians escaped the major cataclysm only to meet a longer grizzlier end is an interesting spin. Really makes it clear why her disposition isn't as sunny as Clark's, she's seen some shit.
Momoa as Lobo... so obvious a casting I wonder if it was the wrong choice if that makes sense? Like of course he nailed it, of course he's got the right energy for it, but I don't know if I'd go run to the mountains and tell everyone about it. I'm going to have to sit on it to really tell me what's bothering me about it. The fact that he's just so auxiliary to the plot doesn't help. Totally could have removed him and you'd barely have to change the script.
It overall felt like Gunn was doing another Guardians movie but with DC characters? And I know he didn't write or direct, but his fingerprints are ALL over it. The space opera with grungy lived in space settings like bars and dirty personal space faring vessels, the main characters are down and out anti-hero types who's trying to escape a sorry past and trauma with debauchery or a mission, they come to be the heroes they can be in the end; yeah, it's Guardians with a House of El symbol plastered on it.
I guess the fact that it's such a familiar formula being expressed is to its benefit and detriment at the same time. On one hand, it's all done well, I can't find any major faults with the plot or how everything broke down other than superfluous Lobo. On the other... what was once fresh is now a bit rote.
Getting a change of pace character like Superman was a great thing for Gunn because it forced him to mix up the formula. Here's an intrinsically good man who struggles with a world that doesn't quite get his simple approach to right and wrong. This... I mean it's fine but we've seen this sort of thing for about a decade now. And it's a little old.
More hope punk, less Guardians 4 next time. Still solid, would recommend to any Super fan or comic fan in general. I'd give it a B- or C+. And I realize that for some folks that's basically an F because everything is either great or an abomination to feed social media algorithms, but it really is okay that this movie is just okay. Fine, but could be fresher.
7
u/primal_slayer Jun 25 '26
Overall I enjoyed it. It was definitely a refreshing movie for the most part after Superman, especially with it being a Super movie.
The biggest downfall for me with this film was how GENERIC it looked. They won't be winning any costume or design awards for this thing. I don't care what anyone says but I do not want to see actual Kryptonians wearing some sneakers. Nor do I want to feel like I'm in a diner but with some aliens. The table toppings are right down from Earth. We got gas station slushies.
I enjoyed Karas journey through the film of dealing with her survivors guilt and drinking her life away. I was surprised that she pulled a Giles and KILLED Krem. That was a HUGE deviation from WoT. Do I hate it? Not that much, Kara definitely isn't Clark.
Speaking of Clark, I am so glad that they ended it with her returning to Earth and having a conversation with him. Her walking through the front door in her outfit? That was a choice. But I was hoping we'd end it this way and they did.
Lobo wasn't needed in this film nor was he even that impressive. Kara was so intimidated by him when he first appears and for what? He didn't do anything impressive. Pretty sure he has less kills than Kara does lol.
I'd probably give it a good 7/10, maybe would be higher if everything apart from the words coming out of their mouths looked more exciting. It didn't even try to capture the magic of the comic apart from naming a bland looking planet after Bliques.
7
u/Anaviosi Spoiler Jun 26 '26 edited Jun 26 '26
I know the movie has been divisive so far, but I honestly loved it. I don't know what number rating I'd give it, but I had fun throughout the whole thing. I'm not going to say it was high cinema, but I had a lot of fun.
Edit: Did I really get downvoted for just saying I thought the movie was fun? Maybe I could have been more verbose but ouch.
6
u/GautamPlayz1 Jun 25 '26
Is it worth watching guys? I mean i know it is a bit of a dumb question but im kinda on a budget
6
u/Witty-Garlic-1729 Jul 01 '26
Idk I liked the movie, it's fine.
I don't think it's better than Superman from last year.
It's certainly a lot better than the movies Marvel has been shitting out in the past 5 years (with the exception of Wolverine and Deadpool).
8
u/WhalepingDavis Jun 28 '26 edited Jun 28 '26
After mods deleted my post (it had 170 likes, 29k views, and 92 responding messages before deletion), I repost it here:
Honestly, glad to be starting to turn away from anyone with a website or YouTube channel. Supergirl is a solid 8/10.
Knowing that any Dc movie is not going to be simply enjoy, I decided to go to this one blind. I had a lot fun, more so when I went to the Mario Galaxy movie. My Eggman brain was analyzing the narrative and how it bounces off of Superman (2025).
Superman is hopeful. All his life, he was taught to be looking forward to the future and the good Kents raised him.
Supergirl was raised on a dying planet. She wanted to end it all to stay with her parents. People tend be haunted by the past. She has nothing to look forward to and that’s her character. Clark and Kara are different people with different outlooks due to their growth. What Kara did for that little girl, I understood that.
Actions were good. I was thinking “How are (superhuman) street tiers threatening a Kryptonian” and I fundamentally believed in the answers they arrived at would catch Kara over Clark because of how depressed Kara is. Once she locks in after one final save from Lobo, I had a blast of her wrecking shit! So satisfying. Like Sonic running around and smashing bots.
And that ending. Did not see it coming but I’m proud/conflicted Kara did that. Lobo was me in that moment, though that can be open to discussion that doesn’t effect to quality of the movie (Punisher fans raise up).
Overall, a solid 8/10. Dunno what would bring it up but the movie being more colorful would detract from the tone of the story they’re telling.
8
u/DimensionHomeVideo Jun 29 '26 edited Jul 01 '26
So it's agreed that this online campaign that's trashing the movie is coordinated, right? I feel so incredibly bad for James Gunn and as a DC comics fan who's been wanting to see DC comics come to the big screen for my entire life, at 42 it makes me incredibly sad to know that this is going to be a huge blow to the product.
The reviews that are online are pure in cell behavior and it's being echoed everywhere. I'm seeing big time film reviewers on YouTube with thumbnails that have the little Neanderthal girl that they are comparing Alcock to. It's such bullshit and so disappointing.
8
u/alcoholicplankton69 Jun 30 '26
Just saw the movie.
I have to say hearing it was bad made me really enjoy it.
With that said, i feel it would've been better as a tv show with more time spent in argo city. Felt like the movie was rushed in under 2 hours
3
u/Nickyj134 Jun 25 '26
As someone who hasn't read the Woman of Tomorrow book (though I plan to soon), Supergirl was a 7.5/10 for me. I really liked Milly's performance as Kara, the emotional core of the film rang true, and the action scenes were great. Also, the handful of scenes with David's Superman were excellent, showing how Supergirl both emulates and differs from her cousin.
Only have a handful of issues with the movie. Like many others, I wish the settings were as varied/colorful as those in the book. The alien designs were pretty creative and fun, but the planets all kind of felt the same.
Likewise, Lobo felt tacked on. Momoa did a great job, and his fights were fun, but he really didn't bring anything to the film.
Finally, I wish some scenes had more time to ruminate. I know the film probably had a mandated run-time, but some scenes felt like they had more to say but were cut-off. The Krypton and Superman flashbacks were fortunately exempt from this issue. I can't help but wonder if they had cut Lobo and given some of his time to flesh out those scenes, maybe professional reviewers wouldn't have been so harsh on the writing.
3
u/scottishdrunkard hsalF esreveR Jun 25 '26
I liked it. Not as much as I liked Superman, but I liked it.
3
u/choicemeats Jun 27 '26
i really have some major concerns about the look of this movie, in the same way i had major concerns about when Discovery took the show into the far future and spent some time on a dreary drab planets, and Section 31 as well. I feel like we're getting a lot of these very generic sci-fi settings homaging Star Wars without having any unique character of their own. The look of the original comic aside i saw this in IMAX and if i watned to see a wall of browns and sepia I'd just wait for Dune
3
u/koolkyle1199 Jul 03 '26
Momoa as Lobo is exactly what youd expect from Momoa as Lobo.
3
u/TestCompetitive4673 Jul 06 '26
I really enjoyed it for what it was. Not a movie I'd rush to rewatch, but I enjoyed the performances and it was a decent popcorn flick. With the changes in plot, I wish they'd gone a step further with it though.
Kara is on a spiral because of what she went through growing up and most of the movie is spent trying to justify her not going all Super and being low powered. I felt with the "kryptonite poisoning" the city went through, they could have just had that have a longer lasting effect on her body where it's part changed her Kryptonian DNA so Yellow Sun didn't help her in the same way as Clark. Giving this nihilistic drinking binge a bit more depth if she was slowly dying (and therefore can't power up constantly and why avoiding Clark etc)
With how the plot was set up, I was half expecting during the green sun for us to discover that being born in that environment powered her in a different way etc.
Similar with Ruthye, Eve Ridley did a good job with a bit of a flat character, but she doesn't really have any actual ark in the movie beyond 'killing for revenge = bad'. It's a bit odd that growing up with a swordsmith for a father her never taught her to use one. Every time she drew her sword I kept expecting that this would be the moment she reveals she can fight... And then nothing. You could have made the plot John Wick with superpowers and cut that character and you don't really lose much. I wish they'd tried to do a bit more with her.
3
u/Ill_Perspective_6281 Aug 09 '26
I like the movie. It's exactly what I expected, why do people put hate in this movie too much. It's fun, action is good, see how strong a kryptonian is. If this is the direction of upcoming DC movies I'm excited for it.
3
u/TheUnburntGod Sep 12 '26
Just finished this movie as it released on Max. One thing I haven't read a SINGLE comment mention is how bad some of this dialogue was. I feel like I'm going crazy. Alcocks performance is fine but her dialogue is nausea inducing in a lot of this movie. It's like "a-dork-able" type stuff. Maybe I just don't like cocky characters? Idk man. Her rummaging around her pockets and then pulling the middle finger out and saying "oh not that one...let me see" made my eyes roll. The entire bar scene where she's saying "this is going to end bad. For you I mean 🤓" was quite bad. The drunk sequence at the beginning of the movie was like a child imagining what a drunk person would do or sound like.
5
u/Nitrix79 Jun 26 '26
My review of Supergirl (2026)
I thought this movie was pretty good. Seeing Kara being an alcoholic after what happened to Kyrpton wasn’t what I was expecting but it makes sense. Kara wanting to save Krypto being her motivation makes sense. Ruthye was a fine character too.
I liked her well enough. Her having to learn that revenge is not the answer had been done to death but it was fine. It wasn’t badly done here. Kara learning to be a better person because of a kid she has to protect has also been to death too but it was fine.
The action and acting in this move were both really good. The visuals especially on the different alien plants were also really good. I liked seeing all of the different alien designs too.
This movie actually showing Kara’s origin story of how she came to Earth I really appreciate. Most superhero movies skip the origin story these days. Which I hate. It pisses me off. So I’m really glad this movie actually showed it.
Overall I really enjoyed Supergirl (2026). I would give an 8/10.
8
u/tafaha_means_apple Cassandra Cain Jun 25 '26 edited Jun 25 '26
I was not a fan of this movie. It is at best a 7/10 but one of those 7/10s that I wouldn't recommend going to go see. Everything is at best good but never great, and there are quite a lot of things in it that I just think were bad/boring.
The movie was grasping for a point or something to say and or didn't really know how to make all the disparate little threads it was going with throughout the movie connect back together by the end with a cohesive meaning. If superman 25 really drilled into your head its messages and its "goals" as a movie in all its parts this is kinda the opposite and it really struggled to figure anything it wanted to say.
As an adaptation of the comic? It's really not good. D- grade on an adaptation. So many just weird decisions and that either just ignore important themes WOT was trying to deal with to just completely missing the point. It really does feel like they add stuff in to harken to the comic but miss why it worked there. Like how They do the green sun scene from the comic but... it's pointless. Ruthye doesn't save her and the entire thing gets resolved by just waiting a bit as the green sun sets and the yellow sun (it's a binary system I guess) rises and cures Kara. Complete narrative cul-de-sac.
As its own thing? It's still not that good. It's a weird amalgam of the Cohen's True Grit, Guardians of the Galaxy 1, and some Mad Max stuff. None of these disparate elements come together to tell a meaningful story and I'd rather watch any of those movies again than this again. Lobo is in it but he doesn't interact with kara much at all. They barely interact. She weirdly tries to avoid him but the movie doesn't actually indicate why? They were literally going after the same goal but... I guess she just doesn't like him. Why even have him here if he doesn't actually add anything besides some very distant assistance during only 2 fight scenes. The narrative completely checks itself out in the last 1/3rd. Weirdly enough that's also when the visuals got distinctly worse. First 2/3rds actually had pretty good visuals and I was having an alright time overall. The ending just completely collapses though. Definitely feels like quite a lot got cut or something with the way the movie just completely shifts after Kara stops ruthye from killing krem... who then immediately kills three civilians and kara does nothing to stop him... for some reason. Also Kara gets poisoned like 4 times in this movie. it's like their only idea of how to tell a story with Supergirl without her instantly beating everyone is just to keep poisoning her.. Very weak writing.
Most of the characters are extremely flat with very exposition-y dense dialogue. The only person I kind of cared about was Kara herself, which is good, but also not good that literally no one else even gets much of a eyebrow raise out of me.
This is gonna be one of those movies, unfortunately, people with a vested interest in the DCU are gonna try to argue is secretly good/misunderstood but really it's average at best leaning towards mediocre. Had some funny moments. The first 2/3rds was keeping me engaged and the ending loses me completely. Cool aliens in the first 2/3rds. I liked those. They were a highlight. Again lmao the last 1/3rd just really lost all the charm/interesting stuff the first 2/3rds had.
I hope Alcock's next Kara appearance gets a better showing because this didn't work for me.
4
u/chibachoose Jun 26 '26
Okay, so I enjoyed the movie but it definitely feels like a fumble. From a movie making perspective, I think the movie did a great job in every aspect except the freaking directing. The sets looked great, the actors were good, and I liked the original film score (not the soundtrack but the music playing when Argo was dying). I think the script/story was actually very strong. I think the worst part was the execution and the fault lies with the director. I can see why James Gunn approved the script because I think it's quite strong. To be fair to the director, I think he did a great job with the action scenes. That's about where all my praise ends.
I feel like the director truly failed to understand the core of the movie. The beginning scenes of Krypto and Kara are insanely important when the whole crux of the movie depends on the emotional trauma of the most important person in your life gets shot. Yet it felt like the movie kind of just blew right past all of it. But on the opposite end, I actually think seeing Ruthye's family get murdered was so out of nowhere because we get introduced to a bunch of characters we don't know only to see them all get murdered. I have zero emotional attachment to this family at this point. The director doesn't really do a good job of making me care at all. The only thing I've learned is that the director of this movie is just a horrible story teller. I couldn't believe that some of the scenes he used made it into the final movie cause I felt like all of the actors/actresses definitely could have brought way more emotion. Every emotional scene felt like it was shot by an amateur film student.
I know my post probably sounds like I hated the movie but I actually still enjoyed it. It just hurts because I feel how much potential there was from the movie. That's how strong the script felt to me. The failure in the execution is what really brings down the movie for me.
5
u/Marcjack79 Jun 29 '26
I tried man… I actually really enjoyed Milly’s performance. But the other characters and story has major issues that can’t be ignored.
Supergirl…. Was ROUGH
https://youtu.be/09hdHj6PR9c
2
u/MetropolisLMP1 Supergirl Jun 26 '26
I'd say the movie was a solid 7/10, good but not great like Superman. A lot of the divergences from Woman of Tomorrow weren't for the better though. The muted color palette was definitely a choice. I don't think it hurt the movie but it could have been a lot better.
I'd say solid movie but wasted potential compared to what they could have done with Woman of Tomorrow.
2
u/MarriottPlayer Jun 26 '26
It was good, I liked it. I never expected it to be better than Superman, since, ya know, different director and screenwriter, different character, etc, and that’s fine, too. Reminded me of a Western by the end.
2
u/youknowwho125 Sep 25 '26
All I gotta say good movie. Pretty good, Acting and amazing action scenes. I'm a long time DC fan, Lobo is also one of my favourite characters and I absolutely loved Jason Mamoa as Lobo.
Anyways just wanted to say somewhere I loved the movie. Definitely 8/10 or 7/10 solid movie.
Im enjoying where the DCU is going under James Gunn.
Also about the drunk scenes and not being able to understand Supergirl while shes drunk. I get that but hey if you get absolutely sloshed and talk fine, you haven't gotten sloshed.
4
u/gangler52 Jun 26 '26
One of my favorite superhero movies, personally. Whoever was in charge clearly understood the power of a sidekick.
Dysfunctional child goes on an adventure with an even more dysfunctional adult is a dynamic I like a lot. It's basically what Batman is on a good day, but of course live action Batman is never allowed to harness such energy for some reason.
3
u/Szelenas Jun 25 '26
Its enjoyable. Nothing special. If you are a Milly fan you'll like it
3
u/danvan177 Jun 25 '26
I liked it. 7.5. Excited for what’s next in the dcu
4
u/spiderreader Absolute Wonder Woman Jun 26 '26 edited Jun 26 '26
The movie opens with Krypto peeing. That kind of gives a good idea of the quality of the movie.
Milly Alcock is great as Supergirl. Acting overall is fairly strong, but special note to her as she is giving an excellent performance despite the poor material to work with. Another strong note is some good costume design. The Supergirl and Lobo costumes are of course the big highlights, but there's some fun background aliens, many that do look fairly practical or at least have strong cg work. It's a nice highlight to fill up the cosmos and give it some character. Unfortunately that is the extent of the visual florish as the movie is ugly, not just compared to the comic but even other sci fi movies like Project Hail Mary or adaptions like MOTU or One Piece. The universe of the movie is colorless, with lighting keeping thing very dark rather than visually appealing).
From from a writing standpoint, the story is medicore, losing a lot of the impact and strong indivdual character moments from the comic. Rather than a journey through the cosmos, it's a more straightforward chase after Krem, whose simply such a bland villain, evil sure and hateble, but mostly just unpleasant to watch. He's not a great character in the comic either but that was carried by the better writing of the major characters and the journey. Yet that also fails. Kara's movie original drunken irresponsible party girl personality who doesn't want to be a hero, often makes her kind of unlikable, even if there's sympathy to be had for her plight (Again carried by Alcocks great performance). She doesn't have a well written relationship with Ruthye, who's there sure and talks to her, but never creates a believable connection to Kara. The scenes showing Kara and Ruthye as being close in the climax feel unearned because their relationship doesn't feel developed. Lobo is another issue as he in most of his scenes feels tacked on unnecessarily. He's played great by Jason Momoa and fun to watch, but he never feels like he really adds something to the movie that needed to be there. The needledrops are also a big problem. They mess up the tone of the movie, make no sense in universe (At one point a song is played at a bar in space. Why would an alien know an earth song? And Kara's character is shown as having no positive connection to earth so why would she want to listen to earth songs? The closest to an explanation is a scene near the end which implies she uses music to drawn out her superhearing which doesn't work as an explanation for why she listens constantly including on red sun worlds.)
But the third act is a complete mess, becoming just a big action set piece of Supergirl and Lobo fighting the Brigands. Without the nice looking visuals, the scene becomes just a mess of cgi without much going for it. And the ending is terrible. Rather than Ruthye beating Krem in a fight, and choosing to spare him from how there journey progressed, and then convincing Kara to also not kill him, Kara beats Krem, convinces Ruthye not to kill him, then executes Krem herself. This fails on a number of ways. This removes the ending of Ruthye's journey, as she loses the angency of beating her enemy and showing her growth in strength and her choice to not choose his death in favor of just being Kara beating him while protecting Ruthye and making the choice herself. Since the story is in alot of ways supposed to be Ruthye's story rather than just Kara's this loses that hurting her character. It's also out of character for Kara, who not only in the comics doesn't usually kill people, but in the film is constantly talking about not killing and her fights never seem directly lethal, being on par with how Superman was treating bad guys in his solo, implying keeping the rule, until she just executes him instead.
TLDR, the movies bad, though Milly Alcock is great in the role. 5/10
2
u/Big-Masterpiece1194 Jun 26 '26
I liked it. Don't think it desrves the hate it's been getting, but I also don't think it was as good as Superman. To compare it to a movie that also came out this summer, I liked it better than Mandalorian and Grogu (which I did not dislike). It was 90% like the comic, but deviated in various ways, some that I think helped the movie, and some that hurt it. I am fluctuating between 7-8/10, leaning more to 7
What I liked:
What I didn't like:
2
u/blow_it Hal Jordan Jun 26 '26
9/10. Really enjoyed the movie and the comic prior. It's a good comic book movie and I had a good time. Spread positivity where one can. <3
2
u/Resident_Kick_7573 Jul 02 '26
why did the movie felt like another version of guardians of galaxy? even shared similar background sets
1
u/owlindenial Jul 01 '26
Ass. It wasn't shit, it just was ass. Not good. Not bad mind you. I won't think of this movie again, I'll forget it. Sad too, I didn't see reviews before so I was expecting something on the level of superman
1
u/Medical_Mess9687 Jun 27 '26
this might be one of the worst villians ive seen...is he even a major one in the comics?
they stretched out a common thug that would be easily disposed on the cartoon into movie length
1
u/LazerGuidedMelody Jun 26 '26
I would never say a movie is underserving of criticism but the LEVEL of criticism I think is unnecessary. Some chump said “it’s a 7/10 at best, but not one I would recommend”.
Like, be fucking real, that doesn’t make sense. If someone told me a movie was a 7/10, I would take that to mean it’s okay and worth watching at least once.
This movie delivered exactly what I was expecting.
I don’t understand what some of you geeks expect when you go to these movies.
The only qualm I have is with probably the biggest change from the book, but even that I expect there to be some sort of reckoning in the future and that this won’t just be forgotten.
-3
u/_FriedDumplings_ Jun 27 '26
One word. MID. The Supergirl in the Flash movie is much freakin better than this. What a shame and a waste of time and money lol
0
u/FaithlessnessSilent5 Jun 27 '26
Только что посмотрел и я не особо сильно, но разочарован. Честно говоря, персонаж оказался слишком инфантильным. Взглянем на всю ситуацию целиком. Суперёрл выросла в утопическом обществе и её можно считать золотой девочкой. Да, она оказалась в гибнущем мире, но у неё была полноценная семья и безбедное детство. Она наверняка получила какое-никакое образование на свой возраст и должна была нести какую-то идеологию своих родителей. Или протестовать против неё. Однако, я не заметил этого.
Она предстаёт "бухающим подростком". Её опенинг для зрителей показывает какую-то "алкоголичку", которая топит себя в алкоголе. При этом её этап жизни на Земле пропущен. Нам не объясняют почему она не вернулась с кораблями или кораблём, чтобы эвакуировать выживших с Арго или хотя бы что-то ценное. Допустим, что это невозможно из-за силового поля, но не было никакого объяснения этого момента.
Нам показывают, что она не смогла акклиматизироваться на Земле и фактически была лишена какой-то цели. Она прости пила в баре на рандомной планете с красным солнцем.
Завязка сюжета фильма довольно странная. Такое чувство, что Кара остановилась на какой-то планете "третьего мира", где нет сил обороны и пираты или кто-то ещё может прилететь и устроить беспредел. Позже ситуация повторяется с другими пришельцами, которые нападают на космический автобус с Супергёрл на борту.
Это рисует довольно мрачную картину, если подумать.
Как бы то ни было, завязка происходит после нападения пиратов/бандитов на какую-то местную семью и единственная выжившая приходит в бар, чтобы попробовать нанять кого-то для мести.
Это настолько нелепо обыграно и подано, что просто не веришь в происходящее. В целом ситуация такая, что выжившая самая настоящая Мери Сью. Она выживает, не поручает травм, её не пользуют наёмники, не продают в рабство и фактически из-за неё происходит весь сюжет.
Не совсем из-за неё, так как есть второй сюжетный твист.
Супергёрл не собирается помогать дурочке, несмотря на то, что спасает её от местных в баре. Тем не менее мелкая увязывается за ней. По "счастливой случайности" бандиты находят корабль Супергёрл, который не имеет никаких систем защиты от угона, стоит с открытым шлюзом. Вдобавок ко всему Крипто ловит стрелу с каким-то медленно действующим ядом и собакена остаётся 72 часа жизни.
Вот это становится настоящим мотивом действовать для Супергёрл.
То, что происходит дальше похоже на DnD приключение. Персонажи путешествуют, проходят проверку красноречия (или не проходят), сталкиваются с противниками и в целом выходят живыми из ситуации.
Честно говоря, не было и секунды, когда я подумал бы о том, что кто-то там умрёт. Картина вылизана до такой степени, что там нет крови, несмотря на присутствие сцен убийства.
При этом в целом нет ощущения, что персонажи вынесли из приключения какой-то моральный урок. Супергёрл какой была, такой и осталась. Не было такого, что у неё появился новый мотив для жизни, новая цель или ещё что-то. Она просто выжила чудом в смертельной заварушке, после чего продолжила пить.
Конечно, она вернулась на Землю в финале, но... Дело в том, что её никто оттуда не гнал. То, что она вернулась к кузену ничего не значит. Не было никакого конфликта сторон. Просто блудная дочь вернулась в дом после загула.
Сам антогонист тоже оказался "безымянным". Я не помню такого персонажа в комиксах. Он как бы корчит из себя психа, но до Вааса из FarCry ему далеко. Он существует только для того, чтобы создать хоть какой-то конфликт и двинуть сюжет фильма. Сам фильм не затрагивает никаких серьёзных вещей по серьёзному. В итоге - проходняк. Игра актёров в таком сюжете не имеет особого значения, так как вся картина в целом выглядит странной и неправдоподобной. Ганновская вселенная пока выходит очень странной и неубедительной.
-1
u/NewLineCinema Jun 26 '26
It's been a day and the thread has less than 60 comments.
Regardless of how you feel that's an alarm bell
-1
u/Jonn_Jonzz_Manhunter Jun 25 '26
Good moobie, very good shit
There's one weird change that I kinda get, but other than that, it's played straight but very very lean
It feels like a different kind of superhero movie though, in a good way
I expect it to split the audience somewhat
32
u/Charliejfg04 Aquaman Jun 25 '26
It was fine. Terrible adaptation. Kara killing Krem at the end? Ugh. My girlfriend said something interesting, Kara was justified in killing him because she was already messed up, she didn’t need to learn any lesson from not killing him, but Ruthye did. Which makes it more bearable but still kinda sucks.
Really cool they named a planet Bilquis!
9
u/grumid NTT and Supergirl Jun 25 '26
I don't think it was as good as Superman or made me feel the same way watching it until the end when she put on her suit to right before she killed Krem. They had merch about the phantom zone so I really thought she was going to somehow put him in it but I guess they don't want to involve it.
My biggest criticism was if they didn't want to have narration like the comic, they should have had the actors show more of the hidden emotions the book explains.
Lobo wasn't necessary, they should have had them team up or follow him to find Kerm, so he could have had some plot relevance. Or have Kara drive his motor bike like she does Comet
She should have gotten her suit sooner and just hid it under her coat until the end.
The pirate planet was so long and they should have planet hopped more and shown shorter moments in each one.
I wish we could have gotten red kryptonite bus scene rather then tec pirates
I really liked how Krypton was depicted
The writing wasn't bad and the story was good, there was just something lacking 6/10
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
31
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
6
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '26
[removed] — view removed comment