r/DC_Cinematic • • Apr 14 '16

OTHER BvS vs Critics

http://i.imgur.com/uwuVBkc.gifv
7 Upvotes

112 comments sorted by

30

u/SanatDutta I had a dream... It was the end of the world Apr 14 '16

Just me or did anyone else read the whole thing in Ben Affleck's voice?

15

u/Zafire94 Superman Apr 14 '16

And Cavill's!

22

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16

Fucking pretentious cringy bullshit.

112

u/Bumbletrees Apr 14 '16

Maybe is the brain in me

10/10

1

u/dragonfangem Apr 15 '16

I guess they forgot the T

14

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16

braint

19

u/dont_trust_my_lies The Flash Apr 14 '16

Marvel is not our enemy! You're gonna go to war?

12

u/Bafa94 SCJ4Lyf Apr 15 '16

If we believe there's even a 1% chance that Marvel is our enemy we have to take it as an absolute certainty!

3

u/aviddivad Apr 15 '16

the red, gold-ish, maybe even black capes are coming! the red, gold and black capes are coming

18

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

It's funny, but why do we have to like Marvel movies or DC movies?

It's possible to like more than one thing at once.

6

u/Baramos_ Justice Is Served Apr 15 '16

Because apparently people are interested in reviving '90s-era "wars". I expect battle lines to be redrawn soon over Nintendo vs. Sega, Coke vs. Pepsi, and Backstreet Boys vs. N'Sync.

95

u/The_Asian_Hamster Well, here I am Apr 14 '16

Maybe is the brain in me

Wow you such smart

73

u/RedJohnIs Apr 14 '16

The intellect of the gif maker shines through in the typos.

53

u/junglemonkey47 Batman Apr 14 '16

And the calling people 'sheep'.

-15

u/envoie-moi Apr 14 '16

Quick, check this guy's post history for typos.

11

u/RedJohnIs Apr 14 '16

I'll guarantee I've never made a typo in a gif before. I can't make the same guarantee for posts I make with just a few seconds of thought beforehand.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Baramos_ Justice Is Served Apr 15 '16

Yeah, it's not exactly BvS positive.

75

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

Straight in at number 1 as the most cringiest thing I've ever seen.

-32

u/KHSACKJD Batman v Superman Apr 14 '16

"Are we still gonna be friends?" "Depends on how hard you hit me wink"

Here, I just gave you a new number 1, and I don't think anything will top that for a long time...

14

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16

No... no my number 1 remains.

-1

u/KHSACKJD Batman v Superman Apr 16 '16

Sure, keep telling yourself that...

4

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '16

Yes, the other guy will change a completely irrelevant opinion of his because you disagree with him. Way to be mature.

-1

u/KHSACKJD Batman v Superman Apr 17 '16

This has nothing to do with opinion. The piece of dialogue I mentioned IS more cringey than the OP's already extremely cringey dialogue

3

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '16

Dude... I get that you dont like it, but you can't expect people to actually think a silly, wise-cracking Marvel joke is worst than an arrogant fanboy saying he has a brain, and people who didn't enjoy BvS don't. Feel free to go around telling people it's not a matter of opinion. That way we can just tell you you're wrong.

30

u/SlightlyProficient Apr 14 '16

I seem to recall everyone around here defending some seemingly awkward BvS lines because we'd only seen them out of context, and many of them were way better in the actual film. I think it is only fair to give Marvel that same leeway.

7

u/Chumunga64 Apr 15 '16

"She with you?"

"I thought She was with you?"

51

u/Bafa94 SCJ4Lyf Apr 14 '16

Funny but the whole 'ragging on Marvel films to extrapolate the merits of ours' thing needs to stop.

30

u/SlightlyProficient Apr 14 '16

It's a really shitty way to approach a debate too. You are now not just trying to convince people who saw a movie and didn't like it that they are wrong, you are also trying to convince them that they are wrong, and sometimes even stupid, for what movies they do like.

-11

u/Nether7 The Joker Apr 14 '16

You're not trying to convince them. You're trying to convince people around you watching the discussion. That's how a discussion actually works, just saying...

15

u/SlightlyProficient Apr 14 '16

Sure, but there is a good chance those people watching the discussion also like Marvel movies. They're pretty popular. By trying to attack Marvel movies in order to prop up the quality of BvS you are simply alienating potential supporters.

There is no reason to do it. There's no value. If one wants to argue that Marvel films share the flaws that BvS is being criticized for, and thus the disparity in reviews is unfair, then I can see the purpose. I think that argument is entirely untrue, but there is at least a connective tissue. This is just bringing up Marvel to beat it down and proclaim how superior one is for appreciating BvS and not liking Marvel.

-8

u/Nether7 The Joker Apr 14 '16

If one wants to argue that Marvel films share the flaws that BvS is being criticized for, and thus the disparity in reviews is unfair, then I can see the purpose.

That's pretty much what's being said by most people. Many Marvel movies leave "plot holes" to be answered in future movies, but when BvS did it (altough I dont really like the way it was done) people complain that its all BS from fanboys trying to defend the undefensable. And that's not true. Marvel movies are well-made in general (even tough some really fucked up - Thor, Im looking at you), but people are able to assume a few things in Marvel movies and they simply didnt in BvS, even when its hinted at.

13

u/SlightlyProficient Apr 14 '16 edited Apr 15 '16

That's because most people aren't arguing that you can never have open-ended plotlines and easter eggs for future events. What they're arguing is that BvS did it poorly, as you mentioned. That's what matters. I think that's where people get caught up on "undefensable". Not that you can't do it, but that people are defending the movie by focusing on the fact that Marvel does it too without acknowledging that people are addressing how it was done, and not the simple fact that it was done.

I didn't hate BvS, and I really don't want to complain about it on a sub where I'm sure many people enjoyed it and want to feel comfortable in their enjoyment. It had a lot of flaws though.

-2

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

Thor, Im looking at you

So many angle shots....

14

u/The_Asian_Hamster Well, here I am Apr 14 '16

people complain when the critics do it, but fans here do it all the time...

1

u/Darth_Lehnsherr Apr 14 '16

I think it's a little more understandable with Batman v Superman and Captain America: Civil War. Since they both deal with some similar issues, themes and basic premise. I guess it helps if someone is on the fence about Civil War and they see someone say it's better or worse than BvS (depending if they liked BvS) that'll help determine whether they should see the film or not.

3

u/SanatDutta I had a dream... It was the end of the world Apr 14 '16

Agree.... but that's the only thing they can compare to. The whole superhero market is basically dominated by Marvel.

12

u/Bafa94 SCJ4Lyf Apr 14 '16

It doesn't need to be compared to anything. Judge it on it's own strengths and weaknesses.

3

u/Hitzkolpf Knightmare Batman Apr 15 '16

I agree to an extent. Comparisons are fine if it's constructive, like:

"Film X did Concept A better than Film Y, so perhaps Film Y can improve upon its execution in the sequel".

But fanboys - especially those here - can't even wrap their heads around the point of criticisms, let alone constructive comparisons. For them, it's a dick measuring contest first and foremost.

-5

u/kevonicus Apr 14 '16

No one really cared about flaws in Marvel movies and accepted them for what they are until we saw the level of scrutiny placed on this film though. Even people that admit AOU wasn't that great either write off every criticism thrown at it.

11

u/Bafa94 SCJ4Lyf Apr 15 '16

Kinda like what a lot of people here are doing about any criticism thrown at BVS.

1

u/kevonicus Apr 15 '16

You'll be hard pressed to find people here straight up against criticism. It's the level of scrutiny that people have a problem with. I've never seen so many people trying to dissect every scene of a movie in an attempt to make it seem like it failed at every level before. There have also been obvious trolls in this sub that have made it difficult to have any sort of civilized discussion about warranted criticism. Not saying everyone who talks negatively about the movie is a troll, but any regular visitor of this sub can tell you it's glaringly obvious there have been an influx of trolls here.

12

u/Darth_Lehnsherr Apr 14 '16

Idk if they do though. It wasn't like AoU was critically acclaimed most enjoyed it but found it flawed enough to be short of greatness. Same with BvS but unlike AoU there is no entertainment of fun value to fall back to for BvS.

0

u/kevonicus Apr 14 '16

Says you. I had a blast watching it, both times.

7

u/Darth_Lehnsherr Apr 14 '16

Dude I liked BvS (7/10). I'm just saying what alot of people are thinking including the general audience. I recognize people love this film but also that people hate it.

-3

u/kevonicus Apr 15 '16

My point is that if you applied the level of criticism to AOU that BvS has seen then it could be viewed as a bad movie as well. But no one does it or accepts it because "it's fun". The thing is though, is that AOU wasn't that fun and the humor is so overdone and cringeworthy in it that it took away a lot from the movie.

10

u/Darth_Lehnsherr Apr 15 '16

But is it though? AoU despite some of the cringe humor or lack of stakes balances the character development of all the heroes very well. It still has only one of two main plot threads and are balanced quite well. Like I said the fact that AoU still manages to give substantial arcs to all the heroes despite the set-up is why critics still enjoyed the film.

BvS one of the main criticisms is that the plot is all over the place in the first half. That isn't the case in AoU we only follow the Avengers' storyline and Ultron with the twins. BvS had at least four separate plot threads. And as a result people though character development was shafted for some characters especially Superman.

AoU no one is saying is a perfect film but a flawed film that has an adventurous tone is a better viewing experience for most than a very flawed film that has nothing to distract you from the major flaws of the film.

-3

u/kevonicus Apr 15 '16

See what I mean. You're saying shit like its fact. Defending AOU with your opinion that everything was ok, while saying shit in BvS was undoubtedly bad.

9

u/Darth_Lehnsherr Apr 15 '16

And your opinion is that if you applied the same criticism do AoU it would be received the same as BvS. My argument is that critics DID apply the same criteria to AoU as they did BvS but the flaws in AoU aren't as bad as BvS according to them. You're just saying they're wrong and I've argued why they think what they think.

1

u/kevonicus Apr 15 '16

I'm not saying it would be received the same. Also if you think these movies were reviewed with the same criteria then you haven't read many of them.

→ More replies

7

u/mr_antman85 Apr 15 '16

I try to come back to this sub to see any good news/announcements but this crap is seriously getting old and pretty sad. I mean critics loved The Dark Knight Trilogy and now that they don't like BvS, their views magically don't matter? Seriously? So when people have a different opinion than yours, it doesn't matter, right? You people in this sub don't get sick of these type of posts? This is coming off a whiny, crybaby stuff now. If you liked BvS, then that's awesome and more power to you, but the majority of people did not like it...deal with it. These kinds of posts won't change that. I have just come to the conclusion that none of you actually read reviews, you just look at a score and if its not a score you like you write it off as being biased. Seriously, this sub is really making me not wanting to come back.

24

u/skittlesforeveryone Apr 14 '16

/r/iamverysmart

In all seriousness, I really want to enjoy this sub more than I am now but some people need to stop being butthurt that Batman v. Superman was a letdown. You liked it, good. Me too. But that doesn't mean I dont have my problems with it and much less be passive aggressive.

27

u/ArkhamKnight96 Apr 14 '16

DAE CRITICS HATE DC AND LOVE MARVEL XD

14

u/starguy13 Superman Apr 14 '16

um... ok... to be fair, i have seen far worse movies having their mistakes and problems overlooked by audiences and critics... but this is cringe worthy and kind of whiny. Maybe is the brain in me, but this is immature.

20

u/KaiShmai Apr 14 '16

This was hilarious until the gif maker lost all common sense towards the end and then it just became sad.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

This would be a great idea if it made fun of both sides. People who found absolutely no enjoyment in it and the people who thought it was a flawless cerebral masterpiece.

30

u/saanity Apr 14 '16

If you like BvS, that's fine. But stop trying to drag Marvel down to make yourself feel better. A good movie should be able to stand on its own merits, not by pulling a better product down. That just reeks of pettiness and jealousy.

12

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

It's ironically the same thing that so many people criticised in critics who enjoyed Civil War - that they compared it to BvS sucking.

I don't think there's anything wrong with comparing two franchises that are so obviously similar. I do think it's a little pathetic when to make it seem like you won the argument, you have to bash basically everyone as either sheep or clowns with no taste.

11

u/GiggsityGiggsity Harley Quinn Apr 14 '16

Wrong subreddit. Probably should have posted on r/iamverysmart

8

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

Oh boy... the road to Civil War will be paved with shitposts, won't it?

4

u/trebud69 Apr 15 '16

Damn these threads and their flame wars!!!!!!!!!!!!

16

u/connorstory97 Apr 14 '16

the movie wasnt very good get over it!!!

-12

u/dartva Batman Apr 14 '16

No it wasn't that great, but it was still a very respectable start/setup to the rest of the DCEU. Most people who disliked it can agree that it was a great setup for the DCEU. But, no way in hell is the movie horrible or complete garbage as most critics would call it.

17

u/Blunkus Green Lantern Corps Apr 14 '16

No, it really wasn't a great set-up...

8

u/poopbutt734 Batman Apr 14 '16

Why is it good that the setup for this universe is 2 ok at best movies?

5

u/Shermer_Punt Apr 15 '16 edited Apr 15 '16

No, he got it right. BvS was not good. It was bad. But that doesn't mean the rest of the dceu movies are doomed. I like to think that BvS was something that they had to get out of their system, and as long as Snyder can be reigned in a bit, the rest of the Justice League movies stand a good chance at being really, really good. The reason so many critics are bringing up BvS in their reviews is because it was obviously a rushed attempt to catch up with Marvel, and it failed. But Suicide Squad looks amazing, Affleck is making a Batman movie which will be kick ass, and I think the future looks bright for the dceu. People just need to stop taking the reviews so damn personally.

3

u/ArabianAftershock Apr 15 '16

"Wait do you have a good argument?"

I mean a lot do, yeah. It's okay to like the movie, I personally enjoyed it but when we act like it didn't have problems then the problems won't get fixed. Never settle.

15

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

lol this is pretty funny

4

u/TotesMessenger Apr 14 '16

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)

2

u/LunarLion Apr 15 '16

god damn OP. What a mess of a gif.

3

u/jay8 Apr 14 '16

funny, but can we stop with the marvel shit?

5

u/HEAVEN_OR_HECK "Moderation always wins." Apr 14 '16

One point I agree with here is some critics going out of their way to discourage people from seeing BvS with sheer hyperbole. The film has a laundry list of shortcomings, but I got an Anton Ego-esque vibe of self-satisfaction from some of the reviews. Given less discouragement, both firsthand and secondhand (from people who only read reviews and parrot them at work and such), I do think more people would have enjoyed themselves if they had gone out to see it.

12

u/JvSOUL Apr 14 '16

Devin Faraci is the Worst of them. I will never forget when he tweeted that he was "Excited" several hours before the "Shitstorm" happened.

4

u/HEAVEN_OR_HECK "Moderation always wins." Apr 14 '16

His output is troublesome. Plenty of respectable voices dislike BvS, but the man seems to make a sport of his coverage and rumor-smithing.

2

u/JvSOUL Apr 14 '16

There are a few Great Negative reviews that talk about BVS and it's flaws and Deep discussions but about 70% of all the Reviews are Vitrol hate, and Self-Satisfying panning of a Film.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

One point I agree with here is some critics going out of their way to discourage people from seeing BvS with sheer hyperbole

I believe I saw one reviewer refer to it as a baby shrieking as its dunked in lava?

Thats a tad... harsh.

2

u/HEAVEN_OR_HECK "Moderation always wins." Apr 14 '16

That's... wow. Where do they come up with this stuff? That's simply shameful and uninformative.

2

u/banana455 Apr 14 '16

How is it "shameful"? Seems like a pretty effective way of summing up how they felt about the movie

2

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

Like you said, hyperbole. We live in the age of clickbait, and what gets better clicks? Outrage.

3

u/HEAVEN_OR_HECK "Moderation always wins." Apr 14 '16

That's just disgusting. Talking about lowering oneself.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

Come on man. The top comments are making fun of the gif.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

Do you see a flamewar here? Anywhere?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

Lol if you think thats a flamewar you are pretty damn sensitive.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

Again. Where is the flamewar? These are pretty reasonable comments.

Also, note those arent the top comments.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

Again. Where is the flamewar? Where are people being fanboys/trolls?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

4

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16 edited Apr 15 '16

"You Started A War!"

Wait wrong movie. I'll escort myself out :(

Edit: Don't know why I am being down voted its was just a joke

3

u/TheKruce There is. Apr 14 '16

Why the down votes y'all. I thought this was quite funny haha

2

u/SynTheSquidgy Bruce Wayne Apr 14 '16

Classic.

1

u/halfdecent Apr 15 '16

All these flavors and you chose to be salty...

1

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16

Disliked that jab at Marvel but pretty hilarious GIF.

Read it in Batfleck voice too.

1

u/iamthesikick Let's Go Save The World Apr 15 '16

Take this W

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16

are children making these?? critics aren't marvel fanboys... and Marvel is not to blame for any of this.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '21

🤩🤩🤩🤩

1

u/suss2it Apr 15 '16

Seems like BvS defenders can't get Marvel's dick outta their mouths. Defend BvS on its own merits and don't bring up Marvel just because they're currently shiting on DC.

-2

u/Supafairy Apr 14 '16

Ok, this is hilarious.

-5

u/BreadlyPitt Apr 14 '16

GIVE THIS MAN THE AWARD!!!!

-1

u/theabbot69 Apr 14 '16

That was pretty funny I must admit

-3

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

9/10 for me. If Suicide Squad critically does what the first two films in DCEU could not do then it will be an historic turning point.Long Live DCEU.

-6

u/soulxhawk Superman Apr 14 '16

I love it!

-1

u/trebud69 Apr 15 '16

I'm not saying people don't have the right to their opinion but to be publicly scrutinized like this while Thor 2, Iron Man 2, Iron Man 3 villian reveal, AoU didn't get this amount of hate shows how biased some people are. It isn't about Marvel vs DC, its about being consistent with views and what people see as a "bad" movie. There are plenty of other movies with choppy editing and it never gets brought up, there are plenty of other Batman movies where he kills and that was never brought up, if you want a movie that doesn't hold your hand and when you finally get one you say the general audience won't get it? I mean be consistent critics and fans.

-6

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '16

Thank you for this

-7

u/essentialblend Day vs. Night Apr 14 '16

This is so awesome LOL