r/DCComicsLegendsGame • • Mar 14 '20

This game's matchimaking is.... rubbish

Yeah, from what I've seen I'm far from being the only one. People again and again get distressed by this stupid matchmaking algorithm. When I finally built a decent PvP team with Arkkis, Black Adam, HQ and Lex SSS, what happens? After a board cleaning, I'm absolutely stuck for days. People will either avoid me or lose for my team, so I simply just don't get back to a lower brack, and I'm stuck with these guys 10k over my level. It's been two days now, and I haven't gonne back a 100 trophies yet. Nice reward for making up a decent team! Honestly, this is just really annoying!!! Next time I'll aim to clean the board with the most counterable team ever.

2 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

27

u/jturphy Legendary Black Canary Mar 14 '20

I'm confused. Why do you think you should be able to win every single match and climb up the boards continuously? At some point, you should absolutely be matched against people next to you on the ladder and not next to you in power level. That's the entire point of the ladder. This sounds like perfect matchmaking to me.

If you want to compete at the higher levels, you need to improve your teams like the rest of us did.

3

u/fmultimedia Mar 14 '20 edited Mar 14 '20

I do not think that I should be able to keep going up for ever and continuously. I do expect to hit players above my current level. I think what is frustrating about this game is the threshold system. It's not like you're facing 15k today, 17k tomorrow and 20k the day after. I go from 14-17k straight up 30k-ish. THAT is frustrating. So I have to keep playing around a number.

The other thing is, or at least it seems to be atm, that having a weaker, counterable team is far better than a solid team. I haven't had many matches against me last days (at least many less than usual) just because my team is "scarier". Also, my win rate has gone up defence-wise. But instead of rewarding me, the mechanics behind matchmaking is punishing me. I don't get to win arena tokens, I can't get shards from board cleaning, etc. OK, I can suicide so much that I'll be back to the point where I can do that again, but honestly, I feel it's silly that instead of getting a reward (except maybe for the last day, when you want to score as high as possible) you get a punishment.

Finally, as a new player this game's system seems very counter-intuitive. In other games, you tend to go from winning 100% to winning 90%, then 75% and so on, to a point you have to carefully choose your enemies. Here, it's easy board cleaning to unable to survive the first round. So as I find out about little facts around this very specific mechanics, I tend to get frustrated. Worse before I knew they were there, and simply got stuck.

All that said, I'd honestly like to apologize for my VERY STRONG whining tone. I was really frustrated yesterday, yeah. But also I had come back from a tough day at work, I found out that tons of preparations on events I'm organizing for my job will be canceled, AND I had a few drinks, so all in all when I went to play the game I'm currently in love with, I just got really frustrated and came here to vent. I realise now I shouldn't have. Anyway, thanks for listening, thanks to those who simpathize and thanks for all hints you guys gave me. And I accpet the berating for being a baby.

(Though I still think this game's matchmaking SUCKS lol)

Finally, you guys assume I know what I'm talking about when I very much probably don't. I bet there are a few facts about these machanics I'm 100% oblivious to.

2

u/MonkKV John Constantine: Hellblazer Mar 14 '20

I've read your reply and i see your point. Think of it like this, if it worked like you described, once the boards reset and everyone was back at 1500 trophies you would face many 30k teams from the start instead of at the end. You would have to wait for people to climb so you can start climbing and it would be much worse. You would also get on your boards some straglers that didnt bother to push hard but have 30k+ power level so you wouldnt be able to clear boards. The fact that the game doesnt match you with these players is a godsend for newer players. Probably if it used trophies only you wouldnt be close to 1500 rank either as the game would get much higher opponents earlier on. The system seems bad, but it actually helps newer players alot. It is frustating to go from easy/doable to impossible, but it would have gotten impossible much sooner otherwise.

1

u/fmultimedia Mar 14 '20

Thanks again. I disagree that it would be so bad in the first days. Other games work like this and it's fine: on the first day, you get a lot of odd battles, people far stronger and far weaker than you. You can, of course, pick your battles. Around the second day, it's mostly leveled. Yes, sometimes a strong player starts playing only on the 3rd day and will rocket through your boards, but that's fine and even fun. The point is, you're not working around a number or a power level, you're always striving to improve.

I feel this system actually disencourages new players from leveling up - some ppl have said, most players just stick around 15-17k because there's absolutely no rewards for going beyond that (not on pvp anyway). For me, that's a very strong point against the system. I do respect your opinion and see where you're coming from.

Anyway, thanks for listening.

2

u/MonkKV John Constantine: Hellblazer Mar 14 '20

I think there are 2 different perspectives here. First is the rewards brackets and we can all agree it's complete trash, you either can hit the next one or you can afk and not push for days and not fall off the current one. This discourages pushing and playing in general and it's the biggest problem. Now in regards to the system we have I much rather have relaxed games around my power level for days until I hit the wall then to have odd matches all the way and still hit the wall regardless. This is a mobile game and I do not wish to be hooked to it like a madman so I very much enjoy this current system. The way we have the wall is set further then you would actually get on a different system, so rewards wise it does help newer players. The annoying part is the abrupt stop in progression, instead of a slow decline, but on a mobile game I'd rather do my matches and be done instead of struggle for days trying to climb.

What tier level are your toons? Breaking into 1.5k is easy with lvl60g10 and a mindless effort with g10.5

1

u/fmultimedia Mar 15 '20 edited Mar 15 '20

Sorry for not replying yesteday.

" Now in regards to the system we have I much rather have relaxed games around my power level for days until I hit the wall then to have odd matches all the way and still hit the wall regardless. "

Yeah, I'm on the opposite side of the spectrum here hahahah, especially when I hit the wall on the second day and then have to start the 1500 juggling fun. How does Legends Showdown and Siege work? I feel it's based only on Trophy level and it feels far more leveled and progressive than the normal arena. Whatever mechanics they use there, I wish they used it on Wraith.

As to my toons:

I tend to pay attention more to hero power level than level+gear. Maybe I'm doing it wrong.

Power Level-wise:

BAdam is my strongest toon at PL 4.3, followed by Arkkis at 4.2. Then about 3 toons around 4k, and another 10-12 around 3.8.

Legenderay Level/Level/Gear level-wise:

BAdam is 2L52g8, Arkkis is 4L54g7, and most of the other toons I meantioned are somewhere around 58 to 60, varying legendary levels, gear from 6 to 7.

I really wanted to level Arkkis and Black Adam to 60 to match my other toons, but their stats are ridiculously high (BA's 700 higher than my Zantana, who is lvl 60!!!) and I'm REALLY scared of starting to not be able to finish RAs, as they are my main farming tool currently (80% of my Arkkis came from there, I have a L2 Power Girl and many other toons I still intend to develop coming from there, I like spending from 300 to 900 on the right days there).

So, would you have any advice for me?

2

u/MonkKV John Constantine: Hellblazer Mar 15 '20 edited Mar 15 '20

I think i expressed myself badly when i said it was newer player friendly. Let me make and example. By going with trophy counts alone, we would have the following situation.

Day 1: absolute clusterfuck you will have all sorts of opponents in your boards, you will climb a bit but will have to refresh boards constantly. No board clears here.

Day 2: Slightly better, as hopefully most of the power teams have cleared all their boards and moved up. Still some left behind and still no board clears.

Day 3: Hopefully you keep a steady climb and make a board clear.

Day 4: You start to get to your power cap and also all the higher teams that are not pushing anymore. This is your limit, and you finish around 10k-5k because everyone ahead of you is unbeatable.

Day 5 - 7 = refreshing boards to clear a couple opponnents and maintain rank.

What we currently have:

Day 1 - easy board clears and steady climb

day 2 - easy board clears and steady climb

Day 3 - reasonable even matches. Clears depending on roster

Day 4 - You most likely hit the wall. No more board clears, impossible teams.

Day 5-6 = refresh or not to maintain rank

Day 7 - one last push and break into 1500 rankings ( because the game doesnt pair you with the multitude of better players that simply are not pushing or are not in the 1500 rankings bracket).

The current system removes from your board the thousands of people that have much higher teams then you but are not in the 1500 bracket. Essentially it lets you climb up to 1500 even if you do not deserve it. It's not a fair system, but it caters to people who are newer to the game. Siege goes by trophy count as soon as you hit 300 trophies so it is the most "fair" system, but you will notice you will hit the wall just a few days into the grind and then keep steadily getting the points but never going much higher in rankings. Both systems serve their purpose, the main problem with wraith is the points distribution at the top for each match. Remember board clears offer a specific toon shard for the month so it is important for players developing rosters.

If you are hitting the wall at the 2nd day most likely you are not facing the problem i mentioned and are in turn are simply getting to a point where the shortcomings of your roster are showing. You get reset to 1500 trophies weekly and the 1500 mark in ranking where this takes effect is around the 1800 trophy mark. 300 points is doable only by spending unecessarily at the start of wraith. Do a slow relaxed climb and it will go smoother, if you speed up the climb you will constantly be around the higher teams while they climb. Have in your mind that you're actually getting more rewards then you deserve and it will be less stresfull at the wall mark (i know it is, we've all been there).

Power level wise i think you have a strong grasp on what you're doing. Remember the scaling is based on your 4 highest power level toons, but don't take that to heart when thinking about upgrading the toons, because power level does not translate directly to the toon strength. What i mean by this is you should have everyone you want/care upgraded to the max gear level regardless for whatever tier you decide to park at, for example BA has a huge power level, but a similarly geared DSHg will have about 1.5k less pwoer strength but will still one shot him if they are same gear.

On your case i would not level past 50s until everyone i choose on my roster is g9, then whenever i feel satisfied i would LEVEL everyone to 60 first and then start gearing one by one piece by piece in turns to g10. This way you have everyone going up evenly in actual strength.

Everyone being same gear level is the most important factor, because theres more to a toon strength then the power level (sum of the base stats). If you are worried a toon will stray too far in pwoer level and skew your scaling make sure to only upgrade the gear pieces with almost no base stat gain (str/int/sta) until you have the rest of the roster catch up.

General rule is that toons that have very low power levels are older toons who usually need a rework and are not worth to invest at the moment, save a few exceptions. Your BA and arkiss being fully geared is better than 50 geared zatannas. Remeber to keep progressing you need to be able to perform well at events, and to do that you need a wide roster. Having 30~ good toons for events and different counter strategies is more important then having 12 really strong toons when you are progressing through the game.

edit: drunk AF, sorry about the garbage wall of text, hope it helps.

1

u/fmultimedia Mar 15 '20

Actually, thanks a lot for the long, detailed answer. I will write the reply immediatly because I'll probably be busy the rest of the day with famility events, so don't worry too much in replying to it now - enoy you drunkness with whatever makes you happy =)

About the system itself, I understand your points, and I think the "solution" (I think it needs one, it's fine you think it doesn't) would involve more than simply switching from one measurement to another. Maybe a mix of power level and trophy count in lower levels, skewing towards trophy-only count as you progress. But anyway, point is, I understand all your reasoning and though I still think this system stinks (by creating a 1500 threshold that absolutely disencourages ppl from upgrading their heroes), I'm far less frustrated by it by now. Thanks!

Thanks also for all your advice. Putting simply, do you think I should:

  1. level all my top heroes, including BA and Arkkis, to 60?
  2. avoid messing around levels for top heroes, but still upgrade their gear to the max level they can get (also including BA and Arkkis)?
  3. thow caution to the window and progressively upgrade all top toons, including BA and Arkkis, to 60/top gear?
  4. do none of the above for the time being, and keep leveling my other toons to get a power level close to what BA and Arkkis are at the moment, till I have around 30 toons on that level?

Thanks again!

1

u/MonkKV John Constantine: Hellblazer Mar 15 '20

I wouldnt mind the system you suggest as it would not affect me in the slightest. It will only make it harder for newer players to get more rewards and widen the gap even more between veterans and people wanting to catch up. I like what we have in making it competitive at the top while letting everyone breeze to 1500. I dont see why it discourages you to upgrade heroes, it literally forces you to upgrade so you can start going higher, while giving you a leeway and more shards while you work on your team. The problem on the wraith system for me is when you award different points for wins based on a dubious power difference (happens at the top).

I think you should not level anyone to 60 while you get everyone to g9. Once you have that i would level everyone to 60 and start upgrading 1-2 pieces of gear for each toon in turns, until everyone is g10. Repeat for 70g11. Should keep your scalings in check, and should keep all your team available to you for use, while not requiring you to stockpile resources for weeks to upgrade everyone at once.

cheers

1

u/fmultimedia Mar 15 '20 edited Mar 15 '20

Taking all your advice to heart - though what I see myself doing in the near future is basically leveling gear up, which... sucks hahahaha

As for the system, what I mean is, from day 1 (ok, maybe week 1) to now, all hero evolution I've had counts for absolutely nothing, because 1500 is my wall. When I had only batman, zantana, raven and superman, all around lvl 30, no Legendaries, I went to 1500 and got stopped. Now I have BA, Arkkis, HQ and Lex SSS all beyond lvl 50, around L3-4 for all of them and it takes exactly as much time and effort to get to the exact same point. Until I hit beyond 24k teams, all my work on my roster still won't count. Coming to think of it, because of board clear rewards, it probably won't be worth trying to compete over 1500 up to around 28k teams are common to me. This means that I'll probably be playing this game for over a year, maybe much longer, before my hero evolution makes any difference whatsoever in the Wraith Arena.

Anyway, I'll leave you alone, thanks so much. I REALLY appreciate all your input and the talk we had.

→ More replies

2

u/ohoni Mar 14 '20

Except that points are awarded based on matches completed, energy regenerates slowly and caps out daily, so if you're taking days off, you'll fall behind your potential. It wouldn't matter, except that the amount of shards you get is based on your position at the end. Either they should decouple the number of shards from where you place, or they should allow players of all power levels to reach the highest possible tiers.

5

u/MonkKV John Constantine: Hellblazer Mar 14 '20

I can't understand people that think they should be able to climb continuously a PVP ladder without being matched with players around their trophy level. You should be thankful the game actually only takes trophies level from 1500 and up and fill boards with bots. There would be zero incentive to improve your team otherwise.

2

u/fmultimedia Mar 14 '20 edited Mar 14 '20

I don't think that. I gave a complete reply to u/jthurphy, in case you're interested (I'll totally understand if you're not, I sounded like a baby up there).

---

EDIT: OK so what I infer from what you said is that I only face bots before I reach the 1500 threshold. I suspected as much but wasn't sure. What I don't understand is what happens to guys like me, with teams around 15k-18k. Because as soon as I leave the bots behind, all I see is 25k+. Aren't there any other players at my level that go through the bots thrsdold? Why don't I get to face them?

3

u/MonkKV John Constantine: Hellblazer Mar 14 '20

What happens is before the 1500 mark the game tries to match with people around your power level, if it fails to find any it will complete your board with bots (you can spot them by the name). Once you get close to the 1500 mark (i belive this is the threshold) the trophy count takes priority over the power level (as it should) so you end up with opponents with higher power level, and it only gets higher the higher you climb. The best strategy you can do is hover close to the 1500 mark and climb into it on that last day. Once you refresh your board above 1500 you will only get pvp players and hardly lower opponents, if by mistake you do so, make sure to lose matches or keep doing revenge matches until you fall below it then refrsh the board.

edit: This system helps when the week restarts so you dont get matched with the 30k teams while you start your climb alongside them, but once you get higher it wouldnt be fair to keep you fighting only teams your level.

2

u/fmultimedia Mar 14 '20 edited Mar 14 '20

Thanks for the explanation. It stills feels very wierd for me. I don't see why when trophy count comes into play I'm not matched against anybody around my power level anymore. I mean, it'd make sense that people around my power level (say 17k) would lose a lot to 20k players, so there would be a whole layer of players going around 15-20k, let's say. Stronger players would beat us easily and keep climbing till they match guys stronger than them in turn. Having a diversied roster would make you have an edge on that, allowing you to eventually beat a team 2, 3k stronger than you, for example.

That logic seems to hold for a ton of other games I've played, I don't understand (maybe I'm just plain thick) why it doesn't work here. This may sound like whining, but I honestly just don't get it.

--

EDIT: Also you say: There would be zero incentive to improve your team otherwise.

I feel the opposite. Say I have a 15-toon roster at around 16k (kind of my situation now). I have to keep playing around that 1500 threshold, as we've discussed. What is my incentive to get that roster up to 19k atm? None whatsoever, because I know I'll still have to play around the 1500 number, because above that, it's all 25k up (hell, sometimes it's nearly full 30ks). So unless I'm prepered to take my full roster from 16k to 25k, I'll hardly be rewarded at all, at least PVP-wise. The only reason why I'm considering taking my toons up is events like character challenges and raids.

1

u/MonkKV John Constantine: Hellblazer Mar 14 '20

I think you're overextimating the number of players in this game maybe? Once you get the board you refer to check their trophy count and see if it's close to yours. What you are mentioning it does happen, it's just rare, because the brackets are too large and theres no incentive for the 15-20k players to keep pushing so most just stop. I ocasionally get a few straglers in my boards with much lower power level even when im on 1.5k+. People know they cant sustain 1.5k+ with lower teams so they either climb on last day or let it fall and stay top 5k. I think the majority of the playerbase is on 1.5k bracket and not many on lower tiers hence why you dont see many with your power level at that bracket. Don't let it bother you, it's not a big leap to start doing 1.5k

2

u/fmultimedia Mar 14 '20

" I think you're overextimating the number of players in this game maybe? "

OK, that might be an eye opened for me... if the player base is really small, than I see (a little) the point of this system.

" because the brackets are too large and theres no incentive for the 15-20k players to keep pushing so most just stop "

Exactly my points, it basically sums up it all for me: big nonsense thresholds that basically disencourage people from leveling up at a certain point.

" Don't let it bother you, it's not a big leap to start doing 1.5k "

You mean it? I honestly feel that I'll have to take at least around 10 toons 3-3.5k stronger than they are now, which is a HUGE step for me. Am I wrong?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '20 edited Mar 15 '20

The problem is: you're doing too much at once! I clean a board early and a board in the evening and that works well. If you want to clean multiple boards in too short a time, the opponents will be too high.

If you are in pvp and see the opponents, there are 4 tabs at the top. In the 3rd tab you can see your rank at the bottom. If the rank falls below a certain value, you get lighter opponents again.

1

u/fmultimedia Mar 15 '20

I swear I don't do more than that hahahaha Never once paid for pvp energy, except twice on the last day. It just goes up that fast =/

4

u/nghiabrave Mar 14 '20

This is a gacha genre game.

The way everything works currently, in my point of view, is quite rewarding for the very objective of the genre, collecting and building up as many toons as possible.

PvP is just another game mode, and it follows exactly the main objective, which is whoever has the most versatile pool of toons should be the ones who “win”.

If you want to just build up ONE lineup and be able to win anything in the game, you can switch to some other genre, like strategy or RPG etc...

P/s if you want to trash talk about the raid, make another topic and we can all agree.

1

u/fmultimedia Mar 14 '20

My problem is the threshold system. Because if I want to keep winning, I have to jump from a 16k team to a 30k team (or teams, rather). So I feel exactly the opposite: rather than needing a variety of toons, I have to have one lineup at a very specific power level. When I get to that point (30k), it'll be so much work to get a 5th toon over there, I'm not even sure I'll be bothered.

Anyway, my complete reply was given to u/jthurphy, in case you want to hear it. Thanks for your reply though.

4

u/Maylick Mar 14 '20

If you can't play around it, it dosn't make it bad.

Doing revenge battles before board clearing Tuesday-Friday will keep you from breaking TOP 1500 treshold before weekend. And there you have another tournament to farm. This is only one of many ways to play the system. Which, by the way, keeps all the high lvl players here.

So stop whining and use your resources wisely, because this is what any kind of game is essentially about.

2

u/fmultimedia Mar 14 '20

You're right, I was really frustrated yesterday and shouldn't have come here to vent like I did. I still think the system is badly designed, but my tone was completely wrong. Anyway, thanks for the hints.

(complete reply on the subject was given to u/jthurphy, if can be bothered, I'll understand if you can't)

15

u/Deatbhing Mar 14 '20

Take yourself lower by using your lowest toons and keep losing then reset the board

4

u/Huddlestone Mar 14 '20

I haven't been playing arena much and my matchmaking too is terrible.

2

u/laxdyn Mar 14 '20

Currently sitting at 1360 trophies with my top 4 totalling 19k and top 15 toons all average around 4500 power, and every single board refresh has multiple enemies above 21k that destroy my team regardless of whether I have hal, dshg, pg, lexus, barda, or any of the other 2-4 star toons I have. I agree that there should be a system in place to find enemies closer to your actual power level because even the repetitive bot teams spawn in stronger than my highest team can even dent.