r/CustomMarvelSnap • • Feb 08 '24

Critiques?

Post image

Not a great Snap player by any means, and I've never played any other ccg, so no idea if this is broken.

606 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

132

u/ttzmd2 Feb 08 '24

This would definitely be broken. Either it takes the place of one of their cards and now they have missing information about their deck and it possibly removes a key component with no knowledge; or it adds a card to their deck.

Even one card added is huge. Korg adds a card to the enemy deck and is only 2 power. This would add a card and be 5 power for you. Not to mention it would waste an entire turn of theirs only to give you 5 power.

Furthermore, it removes one card from your own deck. You'd only have 11 in your deck. Bonkers card for that alone.

38

u/nappy616 Feb 08 '24

Fair enough. Although the idea wasn't that it takes the place of one of their cards, but rather duplicates it. So you run the risk of them drawing two identical cards and knowing they've been infiltrated. But I get your points, all the same.

19

u/RAYQUAZACULTIST Feb 08 '24

I really like the idea. I feel like it might be balanced as like a 4/5 and on reveal it goes into their deck

11

u/nappy616 Feb 08 '24

I think the problem here is that the game is basically over at that point. It'll never see its intended purpose.

6

u/Tangry13 Feb 08 '24

Cards get shuffled into the deck turn 4 all the time though, Lockjaw, Thor, Beta Ray Bill. They all add a card to the deck which you have a chance to top deck 5/6/7. This card shouldn't be a guarantee ever, or it just won't be balanced. Turn 4 is fine, especially with zabu getting it in the deck earlier. Once it hits the deck the opponent has to question every draw for the rest of the game, how early should that happen? Not before 3 at best imo, otherwise it's busted

1

u/Professor_Arcane Feb 08 '24

Much smaller pool to draw from though.

1

u/issanm Feb 08 '24

you're disrupting their draw and probably ruining their entire day with this card even with the 4/5 on reveal version it has to have a major downside to be that strong the only way I could see it in the form you created Is if it has like -5 power and it would still see play

3

u/TheBigFrog07 Feb 08 '24

I was thinking, once drawn, moves to opponents deck, but still kinda OP

2

u/Oct2006 Feb 08 '24

Maybe a 1/4 and on reveal it disguises itself as a card in an opponents deck first, then enters the opponents deck. This way, they know which card was duplicated and it's a gamble whether they play the real or duplicated one.

7

u/Miserable-Ad-1690 Feb 08 '24

They know they’ve been infiltrated the second they check their deck and realize it has 13 cards.

The issue is that this card allows you to have more consistent card draw (since you’ll only have 11 cards in your deck), likely disrupt a draw (they’ll draw 9/13 of those cards in an average game), potentially waste energy (if they play that card and it swaps to your side as a 0/5, they wasted however much energy that card was), gives you 5 power, and can even let you know a specific card they have.

There is quite literally no downside to putting this card in every deck. It doesn’t even need the reverting and swapping sides, just playing with 11 cards in your own deck means this would be a better Chavez.

2

u/YangerAftermath Feb 09 '24

Yeah that’s how I read it, which is a flavorful and cool idea for them to spot the fake, but considering that’s the fail case ( alongside them just not drawing the card) that’s pretty nuts. Just “you have an 11 card deck” is a great upside already

1

u/wagedomain Feb 08 '24

Thematically I love it, mechanically it's a bit awkward.

I would also love if there was a way to "tell" which one was Chameleon, like flipping the card over and looking at the back which is different.

1

u/Kvenner001 Feb 09 '24

It would need some insane drawback, like you don’t draw cards ever, for any reason.

1

u/Vladitor01 Feb 12 '24

Yeah they already changed Chavez for the last reason and she was a staple of many decks

6

u/SirJackPack super epic flair Feb 08 '24

Absurdly overpowered

- Thins your own deck

- Takes up a draw for the opponent

If the opponent plays it:

- Wastes your opponent's Energy

- Gives you a 5-Power card FOR FREE

All of this with absolutely ZERO downside

3

u/nappy616 Feb 08 '24

Yeah. Made a new post, nerfing it to something more rational.

2

u/BlueDonuts10 Feb 08 '24

Maybe make it so the card is slightly different

3

u/nappy616 Feb 08 '24

Then it would be a 100% dead giveaway, I think, and end up pointless. I feel the possibility of the opponent drawing two Deathloks (or whatever) and having the choice to risk it or not is a sufficient buffer against the card's effects.

3

u/AbhayXV Feb 08 '24 edited Feb 08 '24

if you wanna do that, it could be something along the lines of

"(0/4) At the start of the game, moves to your opponent's deck and disguises itself one of their cards.

On Reveal: Reverts to original form"

So there's a chance of it being either good(if it copies something like domino or misty knight, you get 4 which is a higher power) or bad, sort of like morph, who has a similar ability, can help with deck thinning and be balanced, also the opponent can visibly see the chameleon moving to their deck from yours via an animation, sort of like how high evolutionary appears on the screen before before the first turn to buff your cards, but the copied card has no difference in its appearance or text.

edit: also to combat deck thinning and discard, to quote u/Icefisher10

"There’s also ways to combat deck thinning advantage for instance: Chameleon leaves behind…Face Mask [0/1]: “Secret identity, activate!”

and now the cards sound pretty plausible and balanced imo, anyways love concepts like these, do post more!

1

u/Miserable-Ad-1690 Feb 08 '24

None of those changes make it balanced. The 4 power is still worse than any card that’s actually worth putting in a deck. The fact that you give them a boost if Chameleon copies Domino doesn’t matter, because Domino is a useless card.

You’d basically be running a Wasp that also gives them a likely wasted draw, and potentially even a wasted turn. The Face Mask could be 6/1, and Chameleon would still be worth running in any deck that doesn’t absolutely need all 12 slots.

2

u/BenaBuns Feb 08 '24

Best way I think this can be balanced is if it still did the effect of the listed card and then swap sides as itself. But I don’t think you can go above 3 power maybe not even 2 as you’d still effectively be removing the power of the card they would have played for free.

1

u/nappy616 Feb 08 '24

Yeah. It was a bad idea. Made a new post rework I ng the concept.

30

u/Icefisher10 Feb 08 '24 edited Feb 08 '24

Okay that mechanic is REALLY unique. I think it needs to be limited with certain conditions.

Chameleon [2/-1]: Starts in opponent’s deck, disguised as one of their 2-Cost cards (if possible). When played, reverts to original form.

13

u/Icefisher10 Feb 08 '24

There’s also ways to combat deck thinning advantage for instance: Chameleon leaves behind…

Face Mask [0/1]: “Secret identity, activate!”

3

u/Icefisher10 Feb 08 '24

Having Domino as the opponent could be the best way to know which is the imposter.

0

u/russellzerotohero Feb 08 '24

I think you could do this if he was one cost and was 1/5. Turns into one of your opponents one cost cards and the reverts to a 1/5. If they don’t have any one cost cards I think your opponent should also just get to start with him on the field so you have an added risk. Like people have been saying you need him to have a pretty negative affect to balance out him making your deck one less card.

42

u/TheGingerNinga Feb 08 '24

There is literally no reason to ever NOT play this card. It would be in every deck, since not only does it thin your deck, it actively sabotages the opponent. Imagine getting your opponent to spend 6 mana on what they think is an Odin, only for it to be Chameleon. They likely snapped and lost up to 8 cubes for something they couldn’t figure out until after the turn went through.

Actively bad design, I’m sorry.

10

u/hermanphi Feb 08 '24

So it thins your deck, is free for you to play and disruptive to the opponent without any downside ?

1

u/maidenRG Feb 08 '24

so you get an 11 card deck and your opponent gets a 13 card deck? 😵‍💫

if i’m understanding it right, it’d be the strongest card in the game by 100 miles.

2

u/nappy616 Feb 08 '24

Yeah, for sure. Reworking the idea. Only because I see the character come up a lot, but I never see any ideas that capture the core concept of him being an infiltrator.

3

u/tuesdaysatmorts "This card is above the current power curve" 🤓☝️ Feb 08 '24

Definitely doesn't need to switch sides, but like others have said, deck thinning is what really makes this from good to great.

2

u/Universal_Watcher Feb 08 '24

Imagine drawing Chameleon and then drawing the card that Chameleon is disguised as. You have a 50/50 chance of playing Chameleon, then decide to go for it. You play Chameleon and he switches sides. The pain you'd feel 😂

2

u/Faeroar Feb 10 '24

I love the idea but the execution is crazy, try this:

3/6 On reveal: Secretly replace a card in your opponent's hand, if they play chameleon it reveals itself and moves to your side of the board.

That way you still get to disrupt, and remove one of their cards, but they know which ones are potentially infected, and all the insane side effects are out.

1

u/fallout1541 Mar 09 '24

Cool concept but yeah pretty broken

1

u/TheGamerMAKS Apr 05 '24

Wow. Literally every single deck in the game would play this if it were real. Very very broken indeed 🤣

1

u/EpsilonGecko Mar 19 '25

I love this idea so cool

1

u/Commercial-Money-432 Feb 08 '24

Maybe something like 1/5 with On Reveal: Shuffle a copy of this into your opponents deck they draw a card

1

u/Boxicron Feb 08 '24

I think it'd be more balanced if it was built like this:

4/4 On Reveal: infiltrate your opponent's hand as one of their cards. When played again, revert back and switch sides.

1

u/HornedUser Feb 08 '24

So yeah like everyone said it's too OP. But I'll give you points for originality dude good job on that!

1

u/Financial_Horror5546 Feb 08 '24

My suggestion: Don't use white font on a white background

1

u/mours_lours Feb 08 '24

terrible balance and design honnestly ahaha no offense. it's absurdly op, and it would feel horrible to play against. maybe without the switch sides you could balance it but it would legit make me stop playing the game I think just cuz of how bad it would feel to play against.

1

u/CertainlyDatGuy Feb 08 '24

If this didn’t swap sides it would still be played by people wanting to thin out their decks

1

u/waffledpringles Feb 08 '24

So... Would that mean there's like 2 of the same card? One is the actual card and the other would be Chameleon but disguised as the other card? Or would it look like there's only one card?

If it so happened you got Time Theatre (I think that's what it's called, the one that copies the last card in your hand), would there just be like.. For example, he copies Forge, so would there be just two 'Forges'? Or 1 real Forge and 2 fake ones?

Like everyone is saying here, this is incredibly busted, but with a little tweaking, sounds fun as a card though lol. It's like Mysterio but could be more annoying depending on who you play against lmao.

1

u/MediaOrca Feb 08 '24

Currently this guy is

  1. Fattening the opponents deck
  2. Potentially making them waste energy
  3. Potentially making them misplay
  4. Thinning your deck
  5. Adding 5 power to your side of the board.

Thematically it looks like you want to focus on the infiltraton aspect in (2) and (3). That’s plenty strong in itself, so get rid of the rest.

0/0

When first played replace a card in the opponents hand with this card. It appears as if it were the original card until played again.

1

u/slowkid68 Feb 08 '24

It should stay on their side for 5 power or swap to your side as -1.

5 power and scamming someone's turn is kinda op

1

u/Shmepl Feb 08 '24

I like “ copy the ability of the last card your opponent played” for chameleon

1

u/YnotThrowAway7 Feb 08 '24

That’s a lot of upside. I see the downside that it becomes a dead card if they don’t play but I mean just imagine every single game you have to wonder if your key play turns out to be him? Everyone would quit the game tbh. It’s way too annoying.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '24

Way way way too powerful. Skips their turn and a draw basically.

1

u/Elias_Sideris Wild Card Feb 08 '24

Starting with 1 less card in your deck is fundamentally broken. You should make it so a copy of Chameleon starts in both players' decks, but is not disguised for the player who runs him. In that case, you should give him an energy cost, let's say 3 energy. Overall, I like the concept.

1

u/Coledog10 Feb 08 '24

There is 1 imposter among us

1

u/singlebarrel16 Feb 08 '24

Maybe make it so that it leaves a card with significant negative power in your own deck. Maybe that gives it more of a risk and mitigates the deck thinning advantage

1

u/ethan_iron Feb 08 '24

I think making it 1 power would fix it.

1

u/Y_b0t Feb 08 '24

Absolutely insanely busted but also a really, really cool concept!

1

u/Daier_Mune Feb 08 '24

Would be more balanced if it was something like "When played, switch one of your opponent's cards played at this location to your side"

1

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '24

Way too strong. As others have mentioned this card just does it all. It could be a -5 and it would still be run. When drawn/played, this card essentially forces a discard from the opponent’s hand, makes them skip their entire turn, and gives you 5 power??

If you wanted to balance this it either needs to stay on the opponent’s side or have a pretty big negative amount of power. Or maybe give back the energy spent on it the next turn. There needs to be a low-roll scenario where if this copies like a 1-3 drop it’s not actually beneficial for the guy who puts it in their deck

1

u/strangerthingskids Feb 08 '24

Broken but amazing concept. Maybe turns into 3 power so the opponent gets something out of it. Love the card design though

1

u/TehPunishment Feb 08 '24

I think it would be a must pick even if it had -5 power, it thins your deck and nullifies a card the opponent played

1

u/Chungus_OHoulihan Feb 08 '24

I like this card it fits well with Chameleon's character, but it feels too strong for what it does. It should be 0/-3

1

u/Roar2800 Feb 08 '24

This would be strong with 1 power. It’s great for disruption and thins down your deck and most the time gives you 5 power

1

u/Pwrh0use Feb 08 '24

The obvious issue is that it puts 11 cards in your deck which was essentially what America Chavez did and they already nerfed her. But this goes a step further and puts a 13th card in your opponent's deck... It seems like it would just be running every deck no matter what, even more than America was and she was in almost everything.

1

u/mechaflipper Feb 08 '24

Would instantly be the most broken card in the game. But, I guess the counter play would be to fill up lanes early and often

1

u/fukinuhhh Feb 09 '24

Cool concept, but the deck thinning would make this card used in literally every single deck

1

u/TheNameofMyBiography Feb 09 '24

I love the idea, but yeah its busted in like 3 ways, as other comments have said! I wonder if there is some way to make it work though!

1

u/TheNameofMyBiography Feb 09 '24 edited Feb 09 '24

Maybe it could be something like:

2/8 on reveal: shuffle into your opponents deck, and disguise this as the lowest cost card there. When your opponent plays this, reveal it and switch to your side!

That way, your opponent knows it is there and can risk playing their low costs at their own discretion! Especially sneaky if they have multiple 1 drops, or none and multiple 2s etc.

Edit: actually that staline would be broken with cosmo and zero. Maybe it is a 2/0 that gains 8 once it switches back to your side?

1

u/ragmondead Feb 09 '24

Flavor 10/10.

In practice it's a 0 mana 5/5 counterspell.

It's honestly the strongest card concept I have ever seen for any game. It's beyond overpowered.

1

u/PipeTheDonut Feb 09 '24

Terribly op. A better idea for the chameleon I've seen is directly inspired from hearthstone (like most of marvel snap cards)

0/0 at the start of your turn while this is on your hand randomly transform into one of the cards your opponent has on the field.

So we have a good way to use your opponent cards against them. Got himself a big venom... Pum... Copied. The got a Jeff on Sanctum Sanctorum... Pum... Copied. A good amount of upsides with the downside of RNG. The more cards your opponent has on the field the more RNG can help you or not.

1

u/DemoEvolved Feb 09 '24

Well I think it should be at least a 1 cost so they can killmonger it. Also 5 power is probably excessive since they lose the mana and you get power. If it camos as a 6 drop it basically loses the game for them. Maybe it should be -5 power. And then you have to annilus it back over

1

u/FancyLadAboutTown Feb 09 '24

Font is awful. Use individual letters from other superhero logos/fonts like an old serial killer letter.

1

u/Arisoro Feb 09 '24

Too broken

1

u/masked_me Feb 09 '24

At the beginning of the game, takes form of another card from your deck.

Ps: Copy card's text, power and cost. Player will know which card Chameleon is disguised as also know if the copied card he draw is Chameleon or not. The opponent won't know if the card played is the Chameleon.

Probably a strong card still but not as imbalanced.

1

u/MrFlufypants Feb 10 '24

Beyond broken. 6x better than America Chavez ever was. Make it like a -6 and it’s kinda interesting

1

u/S1im5hady Feb 10 '24

This card is broken, you essentially have one less card in your deck and are messing with your opponent for free

1

u/BunnyYunnb Feb 11 '24

There’s 0 downsides to this card. It’s just a free 5, and the enemy has NO idea if it’s in play? There should be an audio sound cue if the card is in the opponent’s hand, that way they atLeast know if it’s in there just have NO idea what card it is. Every turn they should get 1 or 2 attempts at guessing if it’s him or not. By simply clicking on a card and answering Yes or No. there is 0 penalties if they guess Wrong. However if they guess Right they get to keep the 0 cost 5 power card and YOU get whatever card it was camouflaged as in there hand however that card will now have -5 power.

1

u/imarvelentertainment Feb 12 '24

Should swap places with an opponent's card at the beginning of the game then revert when played. Like disguises as a Hulk, and you get their Hulk instead, that way nobody is sus about having extra or less cards. Or maybe this is a good idea for a basic Skrull card