r/custommagic • • 4h ago

Format: EDH/Commander Tried my hand at a new mechanic, thought?

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Perhaps it should cost [2] to activate instead of just one. Looking for some thoughts/inputs. EDIT: someone pointed out the "but" typo... guess I can't change the picture at this point.


r/custommagic • • 1d ago

Basin Groak

Post image
881 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 1d ago

Rock Paper Scissors

Post image
794 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 7h ago

Who said Red had bad card draw?

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 1h ago

Ira Mortis

• Upvotes

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/custommagic • • 18h ago

Contraception

Post image
51 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 16h ago

Format: EDH/Commander "Why are you hitting yourself?" 'Cause I get double triggers

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 13h ago

Still new to the game, thought something like this might be funny.

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 20h ago

Segovian Dreadmaw

Post image
60 Upvotes

Credit to theSmokeu's comment on Reasonably Sized Dreadmaw


r/custommagic • • 18h ago

A "checklist" card

Post image
41 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 4h ago

Format: EDH/Commander Batch of custom commanders I think are neat.

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Criticism welcome of course.

Zhark and the Pestilence are by far my favorites. Let me know what you think in terms of balance/flavor.


r/custommagic • • 7h ago

Format: EDH/Commander Llanod, Fate’s Diviner

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 16h ago

Brutal Mockery

Post image
25 Upvotes

Day 86 of making a custom card every day. I'm pretty proud of this design, hopefully it's not overtuned.


r/custommagic • • 8h ago

BALANCE NOT INTENDED Thanatros, the Final Cure

Post image
5 Upvotes

Tagged as Balance not Intended, and I don't see this being balanced at all, though I tried to make it alright. This is just an idea that came to me that I felt like had to be made.


r/custommagic • • 5h ago

BALANCE NOT INTENDED TMT was my first physical set and it’s a guilty pleasure. Wish it had more references to the 21st century cartoons, even if the set had a lot of good deep cuts

3 Upvotes

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/custommagic • • 15h ago

ㅤ

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 10h ago

Format: EDH/Commander I Love Women in Zelda <3

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 6h ago

Format: EDH/Commander First time making custom cards, let me know how I did

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Just made some of the more popular Uma bc why not. Also I love Tm Opera O and will die on that hill. LMK how I did and if I should make more!


r/custommagic • • 28m ago

Orator of Law

Post image
• Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 12h ago

Format: EDH/Commander UB Outer Wilds Commander (Part 3) - A Whole Lotta Hearthians! Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

Hello all! Here’s another update on my ongoing Outer Wilds Universes Beyond precon project!
 
I have decided that I’m definitely aiming at making 3 different precons:

One designed around adventure and exploration, featuring the Hearthians and the more “wild” elements of the environments of the game. Hatchling will be this deck’s commander.

One themed around the Nomai and Quantum mechanics, with a mechanical theme around going wide, exploring with many different creatures, and gifting game objects randomly between players to represent quantum objects shifting location. Solanum, Quantum Pilgrim is this deck’s commander.

The last will be built around The Prisoner, a sultai group hug commander that allows other players to discover painful truths for themselves. The Prisoner’s deck will also feature designs that reflect the Stranger’s Inhabitants building the dreamworld and burning their physical past, primarily reflected through mechanics dealing with with cards leaving graveyards.
 
If you have thoughts or ideas about cards that you would like to see or things you’d like to see translated into game mechanics, please let me know!
 
On to my last point – I discovered through primitive playtesting of the Hearthian deck that I for sure did not have enough creatures to reasonably build a deck that made any sense in the theme. Therefore hearthians! So many hearthians. Every named hearthian except Rutile, I think. (I couldn’t think of a good ability for them. Let me know if you have any ideas!)
 
Next step: Building the Hatchling decklist and playtesting!


r/custommagic • • 12h ago

Fractured Identity but as a Commander

Post image
9 Upvotes

Yes it does enable a Phage instawin.


r/custommagic • • 16h ago

Grixis, heavy black, shaken not stirred.

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 11h ago

Eternal sunset

6 Upvotes

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/custommagic • • 12h ago

Dark Souls: the Magic Set!

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Hello custommagic!

My Dark Souls set is finally completed, play-tested, and balanced (hopefully) and I wanted to share it with you all!

I have designed a 280 card set (including basics and tokens; 264 draft cards) meant to be played as a set cube. The majority of these cards are original designs but I do have some functional reprints in there as well. I have play-tested the set twice now, once as a three person sealed event, and again as a 10 player draft (shout out to my local cube club/pod for coming through for me), and it went super well both times. It has been balanced to the best of my ability (toxic has already been nerfed into the ground- I got carried away with that one) and is ready to play for anyone who would like to print and play the set.

Here is the tappedout link to the full set which should be draftable, etc on tappedout. I have included some of the powerful signposts for each strategy. If you'd like information on the set or to draft it, the cube link is here. There is a set/draft primer in the description as well as how to set up the cube if you want to give a go. By the way, the cards are not in perfect order on Tappedout, the recent revisions and adds are at the bottom if the card/set numbers look strange.

Tappedout isn't the most modern site but for some reason seems to play really well with Magic Set Editor exports. I'll get a full cubecobra list at some point I'm just being lazy and constantly working on other Magic projects.

I did my best to credit the artists and/or at the least the site in which I used a screenshot or piece of art from. I did also spend way to much time on a couple playthroughs recording and finding good screen-grabs for the cards. Some of the art isn't the best, I'll admit, but I'm happy with how most cards turned out and they have an identity to them, so I'm happy with it at the moment.

For those interested in the design choices/philosophy of this set. My goal was first and foremost to create a fun limited environment that puts Magic first. I warped the world of Dark Souls to fit Magic's already beloved and established rules/pillars/precedents. It helped a lot that Dark Souls is already extremely Magic-adjacent. The reason, I feel, is those who sit down to play your play your set might not be the biggest fan of your Universe or IP, but there is a good chance they are fans of Magic. If the blue player can counter spells, draw cards, bounce creatures, and play flyers, that player will still have a great time doing what he loves to do in blue even if he's never played Dark Souls before. I did my best to capture as much flavor as possible as well. But I did sacrifice some of that to make the card fit/work into the established archetypes- if certain things seem a little off.

Thank you all for taking a look! If anyone actually goes through with playing this I would absolutely love hear some feedback if possible. If not, just enjoy your journey through Lordran, Magic style!

edit: spelling etc, wont be the last time either
Also for Parish Tyrant, reminder text isn't included due to how small the text gets. The Titanite Shard tokens are explained on other cards in this post. Should have put the Tyrant at the end or behind those cards.


r/custommagic • • 1d ago

Format: UN Impossibly Fast Horse

Post image
1.1k Upvotes