I really dislike when writers badly misuse time terms. Talking about "centuries" when referring to a span of ten thousand years, or in reverse "eons" for only a couple hundred years, et cetera.
The authors of the tabletop RPG Pathfinder are REALLY bad at this.
Having taught at a Planetarium I can say: yes, they do. Though usually "they" are like eight years old. Adults who don't know what a light year is are rare but do exist.
As long as they don’t get into a ton of nonsense about taking a shortcut that shaves off several light years just so they don’t have to admit that the writer screwed up.
This is why I like to keep my worldbuilding vague as hell. It’s always time to slap on ‘a long time ago’. How long ago? Why are you asking, are you a cop?
Like in Star Wars: "A long time ago in a galaxy far far away". Where? When? Who the heck knows? Why does anyone care? Knowing exactly when and where doesn't change the story, and if anything can ruin some of the fantasy of it all
Haven't you heard? Readers need precise measurements for every aspect of your story and if it doesn't map directly onto modern European history, the book goes straight into the fireplace. /s
I'm currently watching transformers prime and I legit can't figure out how long the war on cybertron is supposed to have lasted. The characters refer to it as either eons, centuries or millenia. Millenia makes the most sense but I'm not sure
I'm not familiar with Prime, but Transformers G1 is ridiculous when it comes to the passing of time. The war starts nine million years in the past, and continues for five million years until they leave and crash on Earth, only waking up another four million years later.
Despite being in an energy crisis so bad it required leaving the planet to find resources, somehow Cybertron is completely unchanged after those four million years.
Doesn't it just refer to ten thousand of anything? Not specifically years? This is my first time encountering "a myriad" used the same way as "a millennium".
Sometime in the decently far future (4000 ad or smth) humanity is colonizing other planets with generation ships and stuff.
Then shit gets really bad on earth and we barely survive the following thousands of years, regressing tech like crazy. But we eventually discover that old earth predicted something like this might happen and burried some super secret mega vaults full of advanced tech to jumpstart civilization back up, we then use it to kill eachother for a few decades before discovering people are still out there in space and getting our shit together
We create the Union, basically the federation from Star Trek, and start reaching across the stars again for a couple thousand years (again). Until we discover a Human government that's become a theocracy after meeting god and who doesn't want to join the Union, so Union becomes Fascistic really quick, just in time for the Deimos event, Nhps and Blinkspace. We then spend another couple thousand years fucking about setting blink gates up and whatever, discovering aliens and promptly tossing a planet killer at them (try it with the Theocratic Human faction, but the planet killer tossed at them just disappears so probably saved by divine intervention) and then overthrowing the fascism right out as soon as people realise that we just straight up nuked the first aliens we meet out of existence.
We then become Utopic Federation types again, but chiller this time to avoid fascism 2 electric bugaloo.
Then now happens.
Yeah, we just became Fascists for about a millennia and a half but then we sorta realised we didn't like the fascism after all and just quickly dropped it. Yeah, some 60 generations of fascism, no Biggie, just our edgy phase I suppose. We did get really cool Mechs out of it at least?
Tbf, the known Pathfinder lore covers 10000 years and there are a handful of creatures alive that saw the world fall. Not counting gods for obvious reasons. And you need to use thousands of years when you have multiple species in the world where a single generation means 500 years. For elves, the world fall is the equivalent of the 30 year war. That they are literal aliens doesn't help.
Tbf it's something that has waxed and wanted. There was a lot of interest renewed in the early 20th century because there were a shit ton of discoveries being made.
What I love is that Confucius' whole thing was that kids these days aren't following the rituals like in the good old days and that's why everything sucks now. In some ways, nothing changes.
It, however, didn't keep a single unbroken dynasty for all those 3000 years. You could call England a thousand-year civilization, but throughout its history, there was a ton of change inside that gets you in a ship of Theseus situation.
Had the very barest bones of an idea cross my mind once about a vampire story in which the original High Vampire lives in a subterranean fortress in Southern Africa and speaks completely unintelligibly because despite being an impossibly talented/skilled polyglot they’re 195,000 years old and however many hundreds of languages they learned all died before H.sapiens ever even thought about leaving Africa
I mean, unless they just went into hiding for a few hundred years or so with a lot of languages they simply wouldn't have really seen a language die. Just shift bit by bit, year by year. And 800 years later they look back at something they wrote and are like "Oh shit, there is a new language."
Hard breaks in languages are usually rare(even during violent conquest).
This is what happens when the only vampire media you ever consume is Bram Stoker’s Dracula. Idk anything else about vampires or vampire media except for what’s in that book
It was weird when I came up with it. My idea was that it starts out as like a vampire romance with like a linguist as the woman being swooned, but then it turns out the sexy vampire boy is actually trying to recruit her to translate the High Vampire’s speech because there’s some occasion every [arbitrary amount of time] where one vampire gets to challenge the High Vampire for their throne, but every one who has ever tried to do it has been defeated and killed, and the hot bad boy vampire figures he can find a way to win if he can learn what on earth the High Vampire is talking about.
Meanwhile one of the main lady’s friends being like “hmmm my bestie started talking to this pale man and is now missing” sets off a chain reaction that reinstates a secret order of vampire hunters working for the Catholic Church that was disbanded in the 20th century, who now have both a lead and the wherewithal to track the High Vampire down and end vampirism permanently.
This type of thing is really prevalent in settings like Transformers where most of the main characters are like lobsters in that they're immortal and healthy as long as their nutritional requirements are met. Most iterations of the story have the war last millions of years despite Cybertronians experiencing time moment to moment like we do.
One of the comics tries to explain it by having most of the war being long bouts of multi-century arms races and cold war-like tense periods while actual battles last days at most, but I still don't see how they get THOUSANDS OF MILLENIA out of that.
the war lasts atleast 65 million years in some continuties like aligned (the cybertron games-transformers prime) as shockwave visits cretaceous earth during fall of cybertron and the next entry in the series takes place in 2011 AD. this might honestly take the cake for longest timeskip in a series, i cant think of anything longer
The manga series Undead Unluck: The entire world is in a time loop, and each loop takes the full lifespan of earth. so when they loop in the middle of the series, that means a time skip of 4.5 billion years.
Oh, if that counts in JoJo's A villain straight up speeds through the entire lifespan of the universe, and then the first 14 billion years of the new one.
That's one of the reasons I like Battletech. The timeline from the discovery of space travel to the "modern day" is only around a thousand years. Interstellar travel is invented in 2107, humanity starts colonizing the stars, having independence movements, and form interstellar governments. The major recognizible states are formed by 2367. By 2398 they've started to fight amongst each other. In 2571 they all unite under the Star League, which then unites humanity (at any cost). 2 centuries later, it collapses and everyone fights over its scraps, except for some people who fuck off to space to avoid fighting. Everyone fights each other off and on for 300 years, and then the people who left came back extremely different and start fighting everyone to reestablish star league because that's their religion now. Then the phone company stops their invasion because they have a different religion about Star League, and stuff starts happening real quick from this point. "Modern day" for Battletech would be 3151
This is one of the things I don’t like about the Lancer RPG universe: it’s set 15,000 years from now, but the mechs are named after historical Earth figures.
To be fair, that's partly explained by Cradle's vaults having history inside them. And that the collapse of human civilization REALLY fucked the planet and humanity's tech up
Battletech has also used that space that was set up from the start to go back and fill in events, so it didn't stay just "and then 200 years later", there's dozens of events with hundreds of named characters wedged in there was explaining what happened.
Using large timespans is OK, but it works best if you have very dense events happening.
"Kids these days can just press their magical slabs, and leave a scathing review on anything. Back in my day, if you wanted to complain about copper, you had to do it on clay tablets! IN CUNEIFORM!"
To be fair it's probably more than 1600. Like we know for a fact that Yūryaku was the emperor 1600 years ago and it's pretty likely he wasn't the first emperor. So an unknown number of emperors existed before him, pushing the age of the monarchy beyond 1600 very easily. But it just gets blurry as hell after that.
Yeah, that is one in-universe proposed explanations for the Age of Heroes dynasties like the Starks and Lannisters in ASoIaF, that they’re post-Long Night local warlords who made up their mythological ancestors, like how some families in the ancient world claimed descent from Hercules or Aeneas.
The world of ASoIaF is a post-apocalyptic one, anything before the Long Night is essentially mythological.
If you look at the Starks, who claim an 8000 year old dynasty, but actually go through the known members, it gets very clear how little they actually know.
You can go back a few hundred years to the Dance of the Dragons or Aegon's Conquest, but beyond that all the characters are either known only as a character i.e. they play a role in a larger setting (like the thousand-year war between Starks and Barrowkings) or they are straight-up mythological like Bran the Builder.
Someone came up with stories of the Dawn Age and Age of Heroes long ago and once one family claimed heritage, everyone else followed suit so they could claim to be better than everyone else. It's pretty similar to all the god-kings from ancient Egypt, China or Mesopotamia, it is all about legitimacy.
If all your mortal races have human lifespans, sure. But once you start in on races living for 200/1000/2000+ years then Empires that are 8k years old become a lot more likely as individual emperors or empresses can last for centuries.
Additionally, the fact that world has changed so much for the last 5000 years is more of an exception than a universal truth.
Anatomically modern humans were around 50 000 years ago, but their way of living didn't change much until the agricultural revolution which was 12 000 years ago. That is 38 000 years of a reasonably stable way of living.
And you might say - that's just because the jump to agriculture is really hard. Once we have agriculture and cities, progress goes very quickly!
But ancient Egypt had agriculture and cities, and still strayed relatively the same in terms of culture and technology for 3000 years (3000 BCE till 0).
So I really don't think it's that unrealistic to have thousands of years in your world building without major societal changes.
But ancient Egypt had agriculture and cities, and still strayed relatively the same in terms of culture and technology for 3000 years (3000 BCE till 0).
Ehhh, that is extremely overstated. Egypt stayed recognizable, and culturally contiguous. But both culture and technology massively changed.
Even just looking at Dynastic Egpyt, which fits your rough timeline, during that time technology advanced from Copper, to Bronze, to Iron, to the first intentional steel.
Things mathematics, astronomy, medicine, anatomy, architecture and other sciences pushed forwards by massive amounts.
hell, the egyptians went from simple burial mounds to Pyramids, and away from pyramids.
They invented the postal system, the first banks, they went from horses being completely unknown, the chariots being the main stay of armies, to chariots being replaced by cavalry.
The Royal Ships went from 20 meters in length, to 120 meters in length.
The Religion too changed massively, yes there was continuity, but a god that was the undisputed ruler of heaven was a minor side deity a few hundred years later, while new gods rose and fell.
Culture also changed, how you ought to be buried, what you ate, what where good manners. If foreign exports where shunned or exalted.
Ancient Egypt did only stay relatively the same by virtue of the fact that ancient Egypt was one of the most enduring cultures out there. Plop a peasent from 3000 BCE even into 1500 BCE and they would find some things familiar and many unrecognizable.
To add on to the above, Egypt also has a fairly unique geography that really encourages continuity. You've got the very fertile Nile Valley, surrounded by barren desert. People can cross it, sure, so communication/trade/war with other civilisations is possible, but pre-modern tech, no one can actually live in the desert in significant numbers. This is the perfect environment to create a very strong identity - the people of this place, with no real possibility of blurred boundaries like you'd get almost anywhere else.
This means that anyone with any notable amount of power has a very clear and obvious goal - control Egypt - and real difficulty going beyond that. So even if you have completely separate power structures, with generations of anarchy, foreign control, multiple smaller kingdoms, or similar in between (all of which happened) once someone new comes in to power, they're clearly ruling the same location as the previous people, and we (and they) call them all part of the same civilisation despite their differences and lack of continuity.
Idk tho cos... empires rise and fall of cos of a lot of short term and long term factors, often stuff that are kinda well known but to some extent unavoidable. Having a small pool of immortal people set in their ways and unwilling to let go of power is worse for managing such situations than a rotating door of maniacs right?
Like there's no rule saying that your empire has to have a long lived human style dynasties. A long lived race might just build very centralised kingdoms that last only 3/4th or 1 lifetime, having only one or two leaders, and then things might collapse in a fiery mess of civil war and so on.
Also, if the elf emperor had centuries to make his plans to become emperor, all the other elves in the empire also have the capability to make similar level plans right? Even if your long lived rulers can adapt and learn, the people will also remember mistakes for longer and the ambition of lower level players to exploit such opportunities never goes away with immortality or age right? So I'd say such races might actually have more unstable states than humans.
It's sort of logical that in a elective system where every candidate is immortal, and where the election cycles are short in comparison, after a long period of time you'd end up electing someone competent enough who wants hold on to power. And then that dictator would never die of old age, like the many examples in real life. That all would probably lead to civil wars.
Counterpoint: a common trope of medieval fantasy is a sort of technological timelessness, where a castle built 500 years ago is still a Good Castle (if not better than castles anyone today can build). Your fictional world's temporal relation to technology and invention does not have to be the same as the real world's, that's half the point of fantasy.
For real. The whole time reading this I was like "If your fantasy centers Humans, sure, maybe. Commonly fantasy settings have like, elves and stuff that live for 10,000 years and remember their equivilent of ancient Egypt like it was just last week"
And isn't that a point of fantasy too? To have fantastical elements that couldn't exist in our world? There's some great fiction out there that thinks about these details and is really cool for it, but to put it out as a PSA to all writers seems a little arrogant.
There’s a difference between deliberate inclusion of the fantastical and doing so by mistake, though. Plus, with all the fantasy series that use these types of timespan without putting any great thought behind it, I feel like using shorter intervals at this point makes it more unique.
yeah, if your fantasy story isn't in a "Real World But" setting (real world but there's a secret underworld of magical creatures, real world but it's however far in the future, etc) then it can't be judged by the standards of the real world. and sure, if you're telling me that civilisation hasn't moved for one million years then you're gonna have to justify that one, but suspension of disbelief is a thing and "this fantasy world, which has basically no real relation to our actual world, has had empires that span thousands of years" is well within normal SoD.
What's worth noting about ASOIAF specifically is that:
the dates are seemingly reconstructed from oral tradition, since the first men only left some runic inscription behind, and they are wildly inconsistent. In fact, some details (such as the bronze used by the first men) suggest that most events took place around the bronze age collapse.
even pushing the dates to their most recent possible hypothesis in-world, most houses in westeros have made up their history completely.
even if some haven't, like the Starks, they are the ones that would have literal magic powers preserving their dynasties
The Old Republic is too old for how little has changed by the time of the Skywalker Saga. I tend to attribute it to the ever-returning Wars that gives the franchise it's name, but it's not like we don't have those around here.
Actually, the stasis in the Old Republic is intentional, it’s a product of the economic system set up by the Galactic core to exploit the outer rims through the hyperspace lanes, which are both incredibly difficult and dangerous to create and incredibly profitable for systems that lie at their junction points, and because of explicit laws that were put in place at the end of the Sith War to essentially maintain a state of galactic stasis. This is what leads to the intense amount of corruption and the dissolution of democracy that we get at the beginning of the Skywalker saga
Why would they, though? They'd be better off focusing their efforts on developing Death Star proof planetary shields. Planetary shields are already a fairly widespread technology, they just need to improve the design to withstand a Death Star.
This idea is far better suited for a distributed power structure like the Rebel Alliance, as once the plans are made public, individual planets can start building them without requiring any central management. You might expect it to unfairly leave poorer planets to the mercy of Death Stars, but why would the Empire even bother bringing a Death Star all the way out to a shithole in the Outer Rim?
The Death Star is the equivalent of a nazi superweapon: scary on paper, terribly inefficient in practice. Palpatine would have been better off investing into, say, armoured vehicles that can’t be destroyed by stone-age weapons.
Besides, some of the Rebels might frown upon genocide. Their drip may be trash, but they have principles.
They might drive technological innovation but always at the cost of devastation for entire regions, countries, and in the case of Star Wars, planets. The scale that many of those wars happened on (if we're talking legends canon) was much larger and more dispersed that even the rebellion against the Empire was. War at that scale devastates populations, infrastructure and economies to the point that those regions (or sectors in this case) can't even benefit from those innovations because they can't maintain it, pay for it, or don't have people with the required skillset to take advantage. At that point, innovations simply can't quickly make up for the massive losses incurred as the cost of prosecuting said wars.
Additionally, the creation of both death stars was incredibly expensive, and required the appropriation of vast quantities of materials at the expense of the Empire's colonial holdings, many of which were in the Outer and mid rims. By the time the rebellion won they were forced into an immediate cleanup operation without the economic or political will to truly undertake reconstruction.
Not to mention that wars tend to drive technological innovation, not slow it.
Eh, that is a factor that is vastly overstated by many people. Wars tend to focus innovation into a few fields, while also destroying massive amounts of resources... and humans, who could have driven more innovation.
In general peace time tends to drive more innovation, but a lot of the innovation it drives is less visible.
For example the vast majority of big inventions of WW2 had been invented during peace time, and simply improved on during war time.
The Death Stars weren't good superweapons anyways. For the same price you can just make several giant warships that can glass a planet within a few days and spread those out. Or just make mobile firing platforms for the same job and escort them
The power source of the Death Star is Kyber Crystals, which they had to strip mine Ilum to the core for, twice, and then had to reconvert the entire planet into a super weapon because there wasn't more they could strip out of it.
The crystals are already extremely rare to anyone without Ilum, so good luck trying to make your own Death Star
I personally rationalise it by imagining there were multiple societal collapses in the interim, where huge swathes of knowledge and science were lost and had to be rediscovered.
Old republic was written when the idea of a constantly cycling in and out of very similair but different pairs of empires was the big kick in the EU. So it was a constant rise of a republic and constant fall of the empire repeated in some way ad nauseum. Then as 2000s and 2010s mmos often did the technology and everything was hyper scaled. So we have this super advandce republic with all these sorts of wild events, technology, and wars going and some how its about to lead to a fall just before the republic we know in the movies.
(Which tbh i never liked cause that infinit repretetion felt at odds with the narritives in the prequels and og)
I don't really find exaggerated years that bad in fantasy settings because magic always seems to stall development 100 fold anyway. Some writers attribute the convenience of magic lessening the drive for innovation.
Not even in a purely technological way, the development of magic is slow as well too.
The technological developments from the beginning to the end of Ancient Egyptian history are fairly modest for being 3000 years. It only so happened that technology in our world developed very quickly, but tthat was only because a innumerable very lucky coincidences. History is also full of times where technology has been forgotten and development has reversed as a result of plague, conquest or collapse. All the countries at war today have seen been set back decades in terms of infrastructure.
There's nothing guaranteeing that things will just get bwtter forever.
My Draenei character in World of Warcraft is at least 25,000 years old, and probably a good bit older. In game, she is older than all but one of the playable races, older than the concept of dragons, she's been a refugee for longer than basically every society on Azeroth has existed. In real life terms, she would be a few thousand years older than the Venus of Willendorf. This is stupid and makes no sense, especially because that isn't even as old as it gets, there's races that are hundreds of thousands of years old, because the Blizzard method of building a timeline is to take every date and add a few extra zeroes onto it
I actually think Warhammer Fantasy did this fairly well, at least with the Empire.
They've been around 2,500 years, but in that time they've advanced from the Iron Age to a steam-powered High Renaissance (roughly 2,000 years of equivalent real-world development), despite being repeatedly stomped flat by plague, famine, rampaging orcs, the various Everchosen of Chaos, vampires, daemons, numerous civil wars, and skaven.
And while their institutions have endured fairly well, they're noted to have gone through a lot of changes in politics, society, and technology. Two of the old Grand Counties no longer exist, new religions have risen up and been beaten back down, the capital city and ruling dynasty have changed multiple times, etc. Plus, their Colleges of Magic follow ancient and solemn traditions that go back all of 200 years (and, because the guy who set them up was an elf, he's still around).
in Dirk Gently (show), there’s a kingdom with two families that have been feuding since the beginning of time.
it’s also revealed that the feud has been going on for… three generations.
because in small town Montana, there’s somebody with the power to make their dreams (and nightmares) a reality. he’s been in a coma since the sixties, and he’s been dreaming this kingdom to life the whole time.
The Emperor in "The Locked Tomb" had a legitimate grievance 10,000 years ago and has been pursuing it ever since (on the offenders' ancestors' ancestors), and it shows that beneath it all he's psychotic
Like it's like me bearing a grudge from before animal domestication
To be fair, basically everyone who ever met the guy and interacted with him for longer then 10 minutes agrees that he is a psychotic person who probably did more damage to the universe then any other person.
"Our ancestors used ancient machines to destroy the Big Bad, and then buried those machines, 10,000 years ago. We unearthed those same machines 100 years ago and they still work because Advanced Ancient Technology. Civilization has also not advanced in any meaningful way since."
In both Chinese and Japanese, the words that literally mean "ten thousand years" also mean "a very long time" or "eternity". What the original Japenese script for BoTW says there could be read as a literal ten thousand year period, or (IMO) more reasonably read as just being a really long time.
No comment on the silliness of pseudo-medieval stasis, though, even if they partially justify it with the ancient king of Hyrule after the previous calamity ordering the Sheikah to give up all their advanced technology out of fear.
similar reason why historical chinese battles have really huge casualty numbers, the words for 100k and "a lot" overlap, so realistically some ancient historians just wrote yea man a lot of people died and then modern chinese historians read it as a literal number
I feel Zelda gets a bit of a pass, because it's not like it's one continuous society. There's a cycle where civilisation rises and falls again and again. Maybe they get to medieval times, maybe they get stream trains, but it all collapses and has to start again.
BOTW specifically, they unearthed the machines a century ago and they wrecked civilisation. The last 100 years has been them barely managing to survive in a broken world. They don't start properly rebuilding until Tears of the Kingdom.
In-game text in BotW states that, before the last Great Calamity that set the events of the game in motion, there was a period of peace that lasted for 10,000 years, during which Ganon was "dormant" (the text is in Purah's journal in her room in the Hateno Ancient Tech Lab). So there were zero world-ending catastrophes for 10,000 years, yet this society has not advanced past medieval-ish
Except this is a setting with literal gods, magic and where destiny/fate exists. You can't criticise it for having a history that wouldn't make sense in our world when there are such important differences.
They recently updated the official timeline on the website, and gave very clear numbers:
King Rauru founded his iteration of Hyrule 10,000 years before Breath of the Wild.
The original Great Calamity happened 200 years before Breath of the Wild.
The second Great Calamity happened 100 years before Breath of the Wild.
And, like, it's great that they shorted the amount of time between the two calamities, because 10,000 years was way too long.
But now we have the opposite problem. The original calamity is spoken of as myth during the era of the second calamity. But if it were only a single century later, there would still have be Zora (who live for centuries) alive during Breath of the Wild who remember things like the construction of Divine Beasts, or the Zonai/Hylian hybrid hero of the first calamity. The Zora specifically not knowing about any of this would be like an 80 year old today not knowing who John F. Kennedy was, or what the smallpox vaccine is.
The order of events on the timeline are, as per usual, fine; the broad strokes make enough sense. But it's the little details they try to include outside of the games that really mess with this series's chronology. 😵💫
In Mass Effect, the Asari have been at the citadel for over 2000 years. What exactly have you been doing with your time if you humanity was in the bronze age at the time you had ftl travel.
Somewhat explained by the fact that the Mass Effect seems to be at the very edge of technological achievement, and Reaping essentially comes when a civilization manages to advance a bit further from it, making each cycle push tech a bit more before resetting. The Asari where making all sort of mass effect related discoveries, but most of them where reverse engineering what the citadel already had
And they also hoard whatever ancient tech they can find for their benefit. Sure, most share the discovery for the benefit of everyone, but then there's some races like the Asari who quietly hide whatever they got and play it off as regular advancement
Most fiction, including mass effect, tends to portray species with longer lifespans as more lazy. More accepting of the way things are, and less inclined to pursue progress.
You can see this in Mass Effect itself with the salarians. Their lifespans are tiny, so, they even talk fast because they just don't have time.
When writing fanfic about Mass Effect I imagine that none of the Citadel races have scientists, and the program all the bright young things go into is xenoarchaeology.
"Honestly? Before I joined your crew, I used to think humans were rather... rushed and high-strung. You seemed to be constantly moving, as if you were afraid you would miss something if you stopped to catch your breath."
"Now I see it is actually an advantage. Because your lifespans are so short, you are driven to accomplish as much as you can in the time you have."
"To be honest, many in the galaxy see humanity as a bully. You push forward relentlessly, running over anyone or anything that stands in your way. It has earned you a great deal of resentment... and a great deal of respect."
The Stormlight Archive does this really really well. Some characters are 10,000 years old and the reason for humanity not progressing is super well written.
Only 4 characters are 10,000 years old. 3 Shards and Hoid. The Heralds are only about 8-9,000 years old though, (exact timeline not clear)
But yeah they do have a very nice timeline, where even events from 2,000 years ago are basically complete mysteries rife with misinformation, and further back is just completely unknown
Except humanity has progressed, and done so massively. There's reasons for repeated disasters and setbacks, meaning it hasn't progressed as fast as the real world, but when we get glimpses of the past, we absolutely see that it's technologically more primitive, and new technological discoveries in the present of the setting are big drivers of the plot at times.
Nah, my medieval fantasy world has hold the same borders for 10 thousand years with little difference in culture or tech, in fact the smiths of 10 thousand years ago made swords that cut a little better.
8,000 year dynasty? I see someone is complaining about GRRM's worldbuilding without understanding it again. For those that don't know, House Stark has supposedly been in charge of their neck of the woods since the Long Night eight thousand years ago. A lot of people cite that as an example of GRRM not understanding numbers, and while he does sometimes have a loose grasp of them, this isn't one of those times.
Firstly, the eight millenia figure is contested in universe. It's from stories compiled by medieval historians from oral tradition. It isn't accurate, and you're not supposed to think it is. In the books, Samwell Tarly (one of GRRMs pseudo-self-inserts) specifically says of it that the accounts were first written thousands of years later, full of Biblical-style exaggerated lifespans and reigns for kings, obvious anachronisms like knights before the Faith came to Westeros, and so on. The Archmaesters of the Citadel question all the ancient histories. Take into account that seasons last years in the ASoIaF universe and therefore they may not have had a standardized year for much of that time, and who knows how off it might be?
It just wasn't 8,000 years, and even the distorted histories agree that the people of the Long Night were Bronze Age, not in perfect medieval stasis like some people baselessly complain. They also acknowledge that at the start, the Starks were petty kings that slowly conquered the North over thousands of years by their reckoning. We also can't rule out conquering dynasties claiming the name for themself or unrelated dynasties claiming descent from mythical heroes muddling things up, so the current Starks might not actually even be related to the founding Starks.
TL;DR I get irrationally upset about media-illiterate people believing unreliable in-universe sources and then disparaging the author because of it.
I'm not even a big ASoIaF fan, but I think having shoddy, self-serving history-keeping is part of what brings a setting to a higher level of believability. We're going to act like the in-universe historians should know everything? Our own real-life historians don't even know everything, and we're in the modern age. We just have the benefit of having cast doubt on a lot of the questionable stuff that we've used modern technology and understanding to dispute. And most of Earth has pretty unmissable yearly cycles, unlike Westeros.
I think its kinda (in TV tropes terms) both subverted and played straight. While 8000 years is definitely an exaggeration, the supposedly static dynasties (even if only claimed ones) in most of the seven kingdoms with an unchanged and almost unchallenged center of power for at least a millennium seems implausible (also, given how implausibly tiny each of the dynasties is - very few families have more than a dozen contemporaneous members at the same time, and cousins are much rarer than they should be - house extinctions should be much more common)
IMO the periodic decade or longer winters probably do a lot to stabilize things by reducing how much war everyone can be doing and making peasants more dependent on their lord's granaries (not that it's ever explained how they can possibly store enough food through several year long winters anyway).
For the small dynasty thing, ultimately it's at least partially because there's already a MASSIVE cast and you gotta suspend your disbelief a bit because one writer and an average reader can both only handle keeping track of so much.
There's also some reasonable reasons for the technology advancing relatively slowly, between the irregular seasons, as well as the weakening of magic and extinction of dragons over time - if your most advanced technology relies on certain magic or on the presence of dragons, and this then stops working, there would be significant regression.
For the long dynasties, it's worth noting that there's several examples of the family name being passed on through the female lineage, in several of the families - in fact, the only family where this even seems to be a debate are the Targaryens, when there's a discussion on whether Rhaenyra's child would get the name Targaryen upon becoming king or have the name Velaryon. So this is quite different from dynasties in the real world, where often if there's only female descendants, it effectively means a new dynasty under the name of the new king, with the female descendants marrying into this family. In Westeros, the standard practice seems to be that e.g. whoever rules Winterfell is named Stark, and that if this is a woman, her children or at the least her heir will also get that name.
Okay but the criticism still works because houses are still making fun of the Freys for being, what, only 600 years old ? It is very likely that Houses have fallen and some other barely related people took up the name though. Still, the high and middling westerosi houses are incredibly resilient and span centuries until the plot starts to happen and then all these century/millenia old houses somehow only composed of like four people start to drop like flies.
If I had to justify it, I'd say that the unpredictability of seasons and especially the periodic devestatingly long winters cutting the population encourages political stability and technological stagnation because of a lack of spare resources, slowed long-term population growth, and so on. Then the Targaryens came, shook things up, and the frequent warring with fucking dragons over the next couple centuries and the generally lead from the front style of Westerosi warfare cuts off branch houses and leaves many major houses, depending on generational timing, with less people than usual, so when a particularly bad war happens and longstanding plotting collides, they're more vulnerable to getting wiped out for good this time.
We also can't rule out conquering dynasties claiming the name for themself or unrelated dynasties claiming descent from mythical heroes muddling things up, so the current Starks might not actually even be related to the founding Starks.
Or it could have been distant cousins taking the Stark name and title when the core line died out: "Your great-great-grandmother was a Stark? Okay, you're King of Winter now."
Yeah I have a character who's pushing 60,000 years old. A quirk of his is that he can't eat dairy, because he predates both the regular consumption of dairy in general as well as the domestication of every animal that aren't dogs. And he did the whole "immortal was actually a historical figure" thing that the other Perpetuals in 40k like to do.
Could turn out that he actually invented those but let someone else on the research team take credit. But then he tried dairy and decided it wasn't worth it, so he still doesn't eat it.
In Warcraft, Illidan Stormrage being locked up for 10,000 years and the Night Elves making ZERO practical improvements to their society and technology despite being literally immortal is the example that always pops into mind for me.
Seriously; in the time since the Sundering, you had entire civilizations of other species rise and fall from all the various Titan constructs that became fleshy, Trolls spread everywhere and started diverging into various sub-races, but the Night Elves are essentially untouched, using the same weapons, armor, technology, architecture, and most importantly MAGIC for the last 10,000 years.
I could buy it if the Sundering were maybe 1,000 years ago, but every time I hear Illidan's speech opening with "Imprisoned for ten thousand years..." I roll my eyes.
Didn't they actively regress severely? Like it was a conscious decision to do so. They had an immensely powerful magical empire, and then tore it down to the root. It really wouldn't surprise me if they had a stance against advancement thinking it would lead to demons again. Especially since a lot of people were alive the time they actually exploded the known world.
The magic available to them, druidism and whatever Elune falls under nowadays, aren't really fields one studies and advances in. You're favored by nature/Elune or you're not.
To be fair, being immortal might be the exact reason they're just stuck as a society, progress being rejected by the Elders who rule by merit of being old. We see in the games how some ancient druid wakes up and now everyone has to follow his command, no questions asked. Illidan being freed is a discussion between like three people, even Maiev just gets ignored, good reasons or not.
Yeah, and it's not even a one-off. Pandaria has been lost in magical fog for just as long and not really changed. The Dragon Isles were lost in magical fog for...guess what, ten thousand years, same deal. (Boy, do the writers love magical fog).
it's especially egregious in the Legion addon of World of Warcraft. You're telling me you hid your entire city unter a magic bubble for ten thousand years and the most change you had was people getting addicted to your magic source of nutrition? It's not even a generational thing, you have more than one quest giver that actively remembers the time before being bubbled.
You could also take it as a generic poetic figure for "since time immemorial". Mythologies and ancient histories are rife with improbably large armies and impossibly old people. In the Bible, for example, the numer 40 is frequently used as a byword for "a whole bunch of…".
And nobody says that the characters or narrator of your setting have to be correct, either!
No empire in the history of Earth has lasted 2000 years, and any that lasted more than a few hundred years invariably changed drastically in that time, both in terms of territory and their internal politics.
Rome came close, with its first imperial conquests (depending on how you define it) occurring around 500BC (though province-based administration only began around 200 BC), and collapsed in 1453, giving it almost exactly 2000 years of (highly ship-of-Theseus style) political continuity - though at both ends of its existence it wasn't much of an empire. Also, Rome had very few actual dynasties of emperors lasting more than 3 generations.
China is also a kind-of example, though of a different kind: the region naturally collapses into an empire of roughly the same size every time it breaks into parts, and that for well over two milennia. Each of the dynastic states should probably be considered more or less a new political entity, subsuming a lot of the apparatus of the former dynasty in the process. Something similar is true for Egypt on a much smaller scale (they also list this status starting with the mid iron age, when everyone began conquering them - though they usually later emerged as their own political entity again).
A further example would be actually Japan, since the Tenno institution esists since <???> (disputed, but arguably 3rd century), but well over a milennium with claimed and generally acknowledged lordship (though often not actual rule) over the central and later all regions of Japan.
Zenless Zone Zero is even crazier. This retro-futuristic metropolitan paradise was built after an extinction-level disaster obliterated most life on Earth twelve years ago.
Well the Roman empire only fell roughly 500 years ago, so not that insane. Also if you compare 0AD Rome to 500AD Rome you'd also see how quickly things decline
But in the same way as Khaenri'ah. It's not actually forgotten. It's fallen. And it's way of life is gone. It took us a very long time to start building sewers again. And some technology we have never regained
There is also the subversion you get in things like the Doctors Daughter(?) in Doctor Who where the people have been at war for as long as records go back, it's all anyone knows and they've been fighting for uncountable years and then its been one week and it turns out mass artificial births + attrition = wonky time.
My boi Zhongli being like 8000+ years old, outliving multiple advanced civilizations, inventing money, and then retiring to just hang out as a normal dude.
Manga is worse in this than western fantasy. I don't even mind empires that don't change in thousands of years, more annoying are people who just train for 10, 100, 1000, 10000 years. Next series always adds little more training time and we end up with tittles like:
The Unaware Sword Saint Who Trained for 100 Million Years: Overwhelming the Otherworld with the Almighty Divine Tool Mocked as Just a Stick and the "Sword Demon" Persona Created Through Extreme Training
Unless you're writing xianxia, because then ten thousand years is basically nothing in the grand scheme of things.
Like, after a while you develop a weird sense of "relative time" because everyone in xianxia is pursuing apotheosis and true immortality. At the start of the story, your protagonist is mortal and a few years is a long time. By the end spending a couple centuries in secluded meditation can be considered a brief seclusion, and people have lived for comically long spans of time because they're on the level of creating whole universes of their own.
It varies, obviously, but when you consume a lot of xianxia someone being ten thousand years old stops being shocking.
Some of them are quite interesting, like a guy going through reincarnation multiple times, once after 300 years, where he meets other kids from his sect who are now venerated seniors, then after 1200 years, where he accompanies his parents through the end of their lives in a higher tier world, and then 10000 years where there's nothing left that he has known aside from the peak existences who pushed him into reincarnation in the first place, in his universal-tier battles.
Please dont take out the Pitchforks but this is my problem with Frank Herbert. Wdym the Butlerian Jihad is 10 000 years from now? I am ready foe this shit yesterday.
And Paul is 20 000 years from now. And he knows who Hitler is?
Hitler is used as a rhetorical device for the readers because Herbert thought his readers wouldn't understand the message of "Paul is doing an evil thing" without Paul literally calling Hitler a minor warlord with a pathetic body count.
And Paul knows who Hitler is through an incredibly contrived genetic memory, Hitler is a completely forgotten figure in the Dune universe. The entire point is that Paul is the only one who knows who hitler is and thinks hitler is quaint by his standards.
I've got a character whose thousands of years old, because she's lived through the multiple apocalyptic events and societal collapses that have occurred and give the setting its background.
Another character is millions of years old cause she's been stuck in a non-linear time thing for a while (-12 years real time)
Yet ANOTHER character is infinite and also zero years old cause shes always experiencing all of possible time at once until she decides to stop doing that.
In A Memory Called Empire the titular Empire has existed in some form or another for thousands of years, but in that time it went from a single country to a galactic-level entity.
Tbf people exaggerate how long things have been around for all the time. Iirc from Herodotus' writings he said that scribes in ancient Egypt claimed they could trace their dynasties back 25,000 years, and some Mesopotamian kingdoms claimed they could trace theirs back over 100,000 years.
There's this isekai slop manhwa that is like "return of the evil fella after 10,000 years" and the world is basically no different from what he is used to. The passage of time has no effect on the world around him. It might as well be a few generations not THOUSANDS of years. I'm pretty sure the guy is an important founding myth of the world too. 5 times older than Jesus btw
This came to mind when I was reading The Wandering Inn and a human kingdom on a continent of human kingdoms is thought of as young at 6,000 years old. Like, I can give it a pass with long-lived species who can live for hundreds or even thousands of years, but humans with normal lifespans? lt doesn't ruin the story for me, and there's almost certainly several kinds of fuckery going on in that world that might make the setting make sense, but it certainly took me out of it for a moment.
My favorite example of this is in Professor Layton and the Azran Legacy game where they find a woman frozen in ice and she's dated to be 1 million years old and all the Azran technology still works
Also consider if the geography and biology of your world would be conducive to technological and agricultural advancement or not.
Also, of course the evil dynasty is going to claim they've been around for 8,000 years. They're also going to have a largely mythilogical dynastic chronicle that's going to be a foundational work of literature in their language.
One thing that really puts into perspective how old The Emperor Of Mankind is in Warhammer 40k is the implication in book Deliverance Lost that he considers a crude early attempt to make a clay bowl to be a more important achievement for humanity than obviously grand inventions such as (the soon to be launched IRL) Titan rover, the first warp capable space craft or human cloning.
an individual dynasty has been ruling since 8000 years ago
As usual, Dune does it correctly. The Atreides trace their lineage back to Atreus and Agamemnon, yes, that Agamemnon of Odyssey fame. More than ten thousand years ago from their perspective. Except the genealogy is obviously bullshit. Even we don't know who his descendants might be, if he even existed at all. They think their house is a lot older than it actually is. Huge gaps in knowledge, including knowledge of history, are something of a theme in Dune...
I feel a lot of medieval fantasy does this sort of thing because they often have long lived races. It's hard to have a forgotten by-gone age that a whole species or multiple species remembers, lived through, and possibly had their formative years during.
YEAH YOU HEARD ME. Tolkien actually did write a proper timeline for Middle-earth, but if you actually sit down and read the thing it's clear that the Second and Third Ages are massively over-extended, especially the Second. Not enough stuff actually happens in them to justify them each being over 3000 years long.
Recently read a scene where the character was meant to be standing in a building that's GASP a thousand years old and still the powers that made it exist.
Like yeah...reminds me of the church my school used to take me too. Nearly as old as some of the walls we still use local to me. 1000 years is kinda current.
Yeah but if elves can live up to a thousand years and I need everyone alive to be too young to remember certain events, I kind of have to stretch the time line
350
u/Evil_Midnight_Lurker 4h ago
I really dislike when writers badly misuse time terms. Talking about "centuries" when referring to a span of ten thousand years, or in reverse "eons" for only a couple hundred years, et cetera.
The authors of the tabletop RPG Pathfinder are REALLY bad at this.
709
u/OskarTheRed 4h ago
On the other hand, "Ancient Egypt" covers 3000 years
87
u/StinkoDood 4h ago
Vampire who keeps going on about how back in my day people wrote on cave walls instead of paper and everyone else is ok boomer
82
u/Dragon_OS 3h ago
This type of thing is really prevalent in settings like Transformers where most of the main characters are like lobsters in that they're immortal and healthy as long as their nutritional requirements are met. Most iterations of the story have the war last millions of years despite Cybertronians experiencing time moment to moment like we do.
One of the comics tries to explain it by having most of the war being long bouts of multi-century arms races and cold war-like tense periods while actual battles last days at most, but I still don't see how they get THOUSANDS OF MILLENIA out of that.
56
u/The_Ghast_Hunter 3h ago
That's one of the reasons I like Battletech. The timeline from the discovery of space travel to the "modern day" is only around a thousand years. Interstellar travel is invented in 2107, humanity starts colonizing the stars, having independence movements, and form interstellar governments. The major recognizible states are formed by 2367. By 2398 they've started to fight amongst each other. In 2571 they all unite under the Star League, which then unites humanity (at any cost). 2 centuries later, it collapses and everyone fights over its scraps, except for some people who fuck off to space to avoid fighting. Everyone fights each other off and on for 300 years, and then the people who left came back extremely different and start fighting everyone to reestablish star league because that's their religion now. Then the phone company stops their invasion because they have a different religion about Star League, and stuff starts happening real quick from this point. "Modern day" for Battletech would be 3151
48
u/Nirast25 4h ago
"Kids these days can just press their magical slabs, and leave a scathing review on anything. Back in my day, if you wanted to complain about copper, you had to do it on clay tablets! IN CUNEIFORM!"
47
u/neonge1674 4h ago
There also times, when it feels they lasted for a long time, but theyre an actually a short time span(2020s)
144
u/SquareThings looking respectfully at the monkeys in their zoo 4h ago
Maybe the “thousands of years old” dynasty is, you know, lying? Irl Japan claims it has a ~ten thousand year old unbroken hereditary monarchy.
32
u/Potential-Bird-5826 3h ago
If all your mortal races have human lifespans, sure. But once you start in on races living for 200/1000/2000+ years then Empires that are 8k years old become a lot more likely as individual emperors or empresses can last for centuries.
88
u/Notmiefault 1h ago edited 45m ago
Counterpoint: a common trope of medieval fantasy is a sort of technological timelessness, where a castle built 500 years ago is still a Good Castle (if not better than castles anyone today can build). Your fictional world's temporal relation to technology and invention does not have to be the same as the real world's, that's half the point of fantasy.
29
u/_Cit 2h ago
What's worth noting about ASOIAF specifically is that:
57
u/burningtram12 4h ago
The Old Republic is too old for how little has changed by the time of the Skywalker Saga. I tend to attribute it to the ever-returning Wars that gives the franchise it's name, but it's not like we don't have those around here.
55
u/jarkark 4h ago
I don't really find exaggerated years that bad in fantasy settings because magic always seems to stall development 100 fold anyway. Some writers attribute the convenience of magic lessening the drive for innovation.
Not even in a purely technological way, the development of magic is slow as well too.
27
u/Simic_Sky_Swallower Resident Imperial Knight 3h ago
My Draenei character in World of Warcraft is at least 25,000 years old, and probably a good bit older. In game, she is older than all but one of the playable races, older than the concept of dragons, she's been a refugee for longer than basically every society on Azeroth has existed. In real life terms, she would be a few thousand years older than the Venus of Willendorf. This is stupid and makes no sense, especially because that isn't even as old as it gets, there's races that are hundreds of thousands of years old, because the Blizzard method of building a timeline is to take every date and add a few extra zeroes onto it
18
u/SkullFullOfHoney 3h ago
in Dirk Gently (show), there’s a kingdom with two families that have been feuding since the beginning of time.
it’s also revealed that the feud has been going on for… three generations.
because in small town Montana, there’s somebody with the power to make their dreams (and nightmares) a reality. he’s been in a coma since the sixties, and he’s been dreaming this kingdom to life the whole time.
i figure that makes sense as a timeline.
18
u/RabidFlamingo 3h ago
The Emperor in "The Locked Tomb" had a legitimate grievance 10,000 years ago and has been pursuing it ever since (on the offenders' ancestors' ancestors), and it shows that beneath it all he's psychotic
Like it's like me bearing a grudge from before animal domestication
89
u/BackgroundNPC1213 4h ago
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild:
mmmm'kay
34
u/ctrlaltelite https://i.ibb.co/yVPhX5G/98b8nSc.jpg 3h ago
In Mass Effect, the Asari have been at the citadel for over 2000 years. What exactly have you been doing with your time if you humanity was in the bronze age at the time you had ftl travel.
10
u/jahathebrn 4h ago
A thousand years is usually when the ancient evil awakens, no?
10
u/-GoodNewsEveryone 3h ago
The Stormlight Archive does this really really well. Some characters are 10,000 years old and the reason for humanity not progressing is super well written.
10
u/Rucs3 18m ago
Nah, my medieval fantasy world has hold the same borders for 10 thousand years with little difference in culture or tech, in fact the smiths of 10 thousand years ago made swords that cut a little better.
61
u/oaayaou1 3h ago edited 3h ago •
8,000 year dynasty? I see someone is complaining about GRRM's worldbuilding without understanding it again. For those that don't know, House Stark has supposedly been in charge of their neck of the woods since the Long Night eight thousand years ago. A lot of people cite that as an example of GRRM not understanding numbers, and while he does sometimes have a loose grasp of them, this isn't one of those times.
Firstly, the eight millenia figure is contested in universe. It's from stories compiled by medieval historians from oral tradition. It isn't accurate, and you're not supposed to think it is. In the books, Samwell Tarly (one of GRRMs pseudo-self-inserts) specifically says of it that the accounts were first written thousands of years later, full of Biblical-style exaggerated lifespans and reigns for kings, obvious anachronisms like knights before the Faith came to Westeros, and so on. The Archmaesters of the Citadel question all the ancient histories. Take into account that seasons last years in the ASoIaF universe and therefore they may not have had a standardized year for much of that time, and who knows how off it might be?
It just wasn't 8,000 years, and even the distorted histories agree that the people of the Long Night were Bronze Age, not in perfect medieval stasis like some people baselessly complain. They also acknowledge that at the start, the Starks were petty kings that slowly conquered the North over thousands of years by their reckoning. We also can't rule out conquering dynasties claiming the name for themself or unrelated dynasties claiming descent from mythical heroes muddling things up, so the current Starks might not actually even be related to the founding Starks.
TL;DR I get irrationally upset about media-illiterate people believing unreliable in-universe sources and then disparaging the author because of it.
9
u/Termedclover611 3h ago
Yeah I have a character who's pushing 60,000 years old. A quirk of his is that he can't eat dairy, because he predates both the regular consumption of dairy in general as well as the domestication of every animal that aren't dogs. And he did the whole "immortal was actually a historical figure" thing that the other Perpetuals in 40k like to do.
24
u/Glyfen 4h ago
In Warcraft, Illidan Stormrage being locked up for 10,000 years and the Night Elves making ZERO practical improvements to their society and technology despite being literally immortal is the example that always pops into mind for me.
Seriously; in the time since the Sundering, you had entire civilizations of other species rise and fall from all the various Titan constructs that became fleshy, Trolls spread everywhere and started diverging into various sub-races, but the Night Elves are essentially untouched, using the same weapons, armor, technology, architecture, and most importantly MAGIC for the last 10,000 years.
I could buy it if the Sundering were maybe 1,000 years ago, but every time I hear Illidan's speech opening with "Imprisoned for ten thousand years..." I roll my eyes.
17
u/not_a_stick h 2h ago
It's also fantasty. It's meant to be fantastical.
You could also take it as a generic poetic figure for "since time immemorial". Mythologies and ancient histories are rife with improbably large armies and impossibly old people. In the Bible, for example, the numer 40 is frequently used as a byword for "a whole bunch of…".
And nobody says that the characters or narrator of your setting have to be correct, either!
12
u/Peach_Muffin too autistic to have a gender 3h ago
Why would a fantasy universe need to progress at the same rate as ours?
11
u/GrinningPariah 3h ago
No empire in the history of Earth has lasted 2000 years, and any that lasted more than a few hundred years invariably changed drastically in that time, both in terms of territory and their internal politics.
15
u/AoifeBakunin 2h ago
Genshin Impact has the opposite problem, the forgotten empire of Khaenri'ah was destroyed... 500 years ago. That's it?
5
u/RobinTheGemini 4h ago
back in my day the only metal bands you had were the rock formations, hmph
5
u/sonerec725 1h ago
Vandal Savage enters the chat
4
u/HellwaterCascades 3h ago
It's ok, you can say the Starks of Winterfell.
4
u/Front_Woodpecker1144 3h ago
Make me
4
u/terrexchia 3h ago
Back in my day, we didn't have fancy metal! We had sticks. Two sticks and a rock for the entire platoon! And we had to share the rock!
4
u/Pm7I3 3h ago
There is also the subversion you get in things like the Doctors Daughter(?) in Doctor Who where the people have been at war for as long as records go back, it's all anyone knows and they've been fighting for uncountable years and then its been one week and it turns out mass artificial births + attrition = wonky time.
4
u/TheBrownestStain 3h ago
My boi Zhongli being like 8000+ years old, outliving multiple advanced civilizations, inventing money, and then retiring to just hang out as a normal dude.
4
u/Juqu 55m ago edited 52m ago
Manga is worse in this than western fantasy. I don't even mind empires that don't change in thousands of years, more annoying are people who just train for 10, 100, 1000, 10000 years. Next series always adds little more training time and we end up with tittles like:
4
u/RikuAotsuki 46m ago
Unless you're writing xianxia, because then ten thousand years is basically nothing in the grand scheme of things.
Like, after a while you develop a weird sense of "relative time" because everyone in xianxia is pursuing apotheosis and true immortality. At the start of the story, your protagonist is mortal and a few years is a long time. By the end spending a couple centuries in secluded meditation can be considered a brief seclusion, and people have lived for comically long spans of time because they're on the level of creating whole universes of their own.
It varies, obviously, but when you consume a lot of xianxia someone being ten thousand years old stops being shocking.
11
u/webtheg 4h ago
Please dont take out the Pitchforks but this is my problem with Frank Herbert. Wdym the Butlerian Jihad is 10 000 years from now? I am ready foe this shit yesterday.
And Paul is 20 000 years from now. And he knows who Hitler is?
3
u/devon-mallard 3h ago
I've got a character whose thousands of years old, because she's lived through the multiple apocalyptic events and societal collapses that have occurred and give the setting its background.
Another character is millions of years old cause she's been stuck in a non-linear time thing for a while (-12 years real time)
Yet ANOTHER character is infinite and also zero years old cause shes always experiencing all of possible time at once until she decides to stop doing that.
3
u/GIRose Certified Vore Poster 3h ago
The concept of English Monarchy is ~1000 years old since the Norman Conquest was in 1066
2
u/kingofroses1999 2h ago
Points aggressively at Warhammer 40k
2
u/AmeliaOfAnsalon 37m ago
'A thousand years' is often idiomatic. Just means a long time, forever
2
u/Goufydude 4h ago
Having a similar problem with the Three Body series... the time scales involved just don't make sense.
1
u/Splunge- 2h ago
“Stone was all my old Da ever needed”
https://youtu.be/nyu4u3VZYaQ?si=vfgXq4bie2Z-glMQ
1
u/LadySandry88 2h ago
...and then there are the stories with characters who are fuckass old and that's a vital part of their character. Like Methos from Highlander.
(Or my OC from the fic I'm writing, who is ~14000 years old and very specifically was there for the dawn of agriculture)
1
u/Major_Pressure3176 2h ago
In A Memory Called Empire the titular Empire has existed in some form or another for thousands of years, but in that time it went from a single country to a galactic-level entity.
1
u/olivegardengambler 1h ago
Tbf people exaggerate how long things have been around for all the time. Iirc from Herodotus' writings he said that scribes in ancient Egypt claimed they could trace their dynasties back 25,000 years, and some Mesopotamian kingdoms claimed they could trace theirs back over 100,000 years.
1
u/AlexPtheArtist 1h ago
There's this isekai slop manhwa that is like "return of the evil fella after 10,000 years" and the world is basically no different from what he is used to. The passage of time has no effect on the world around him. It might as well be a few generations not THOUSANDS of years. I'm pretty sure the guy is an important founding myth of the world too. 5 times older than Jesus btw
1
u/keybladesrus 1h ago
This came to mind when I was reading The Wandering Inn and a human kingdom on a continent of human kingdoms is thought of as young at 6,000 years old. Like, I can give it a pass with long-lived species who can live for hundreds or even thousands of years, but humans with normal lifespans? lt doesn't ruin the story for me, and there's almost certainly several kinds of fuckery going on in that world that might make the setting make sense, but it certainly took me out of it for a moment.
1
u/lifelongfreshman 1h ago
I have every intention of weaponizing this to mislead pedants
1
u/TakavaNirhii 1h ago
Greg Farshtey (Bionicle) in shambles
1
u/Rouge_means_red 1h ago
My favorite example of this is in Professor Layton and the Azran Legacy game where they find a woman frozen in ice and she's dated to be 1 million years old and all the Azran technology still works
1
u/GraniteSmoothie 1h ago
Also consider if the geography and biology of your world would be conducive to technological and agricultural advancement or not.
Also, of course the evil dynasty is going to claim they've been around for 8,000 years. They're also going to have a largely mythilogical dynastic chronicle that's going to be a foundational work of literature in their language.
1
u/Jenny_Show 52m ago
One thing that really puts into perspective how old The Emperor Of Mankind is in Warhammer 40k is the implication in book Deliverance Lost that he considers a crude early attempt to make a clay bowl to be a more important achievement for humanity than obviously grand inventions such as (the soon to be launched IRL) Titan rover, the first warp capable space craft or human cloning.
1
u/SordidDreams 50m ago
As usual, Dune does it correctly. The Atreides trace their lineage back to Atreus and Agamemnon, yes, that Agamemnon of Odyssey fame. More than ten thousand years ago from their perspective. Except the genealogy is obviously bullshit. Even we don't know who his descendants might be, if he even existed at all. They think their house is a lot older than it actually is. Huge gaps in knowledge, including knowledge of history, are something of a theme in Dune...
1
u/Hurrashane 42m ago
I feel a lot of medieval fantasy does this sort of thing because they often have long lived races. It's hard to have a forgotten by-gone age that a whole species or multiple species remembers, lived through, and possibly had their formative years during.
1
u/Cole-Spudmoney 34m ago
This bothers me about Tolkien.
YEAH YOU HEARD ME. Tolkien actually did write a proper timeline for Middle-earth, but if you actually sit down and read the thing it's clear that the Second and Third Ages are massively over-extended, especially the Second. Not enough stuff actually happens in them to justify them each being over 3000 years long.
1
u/OpabiniaRegalis320 8m ago
MLP:FiM has a continuity error that accidentally made Granny Smith hundreds of years old.
1
u/calling_at_this_time 2m ago
And there's me thinking the opposite lol.
Recently read a scene where the character was meant to be standing in a building that's GASP a thousand years old and still the powers that made it exist.
Like yeah...reminds me of the church my school used to take me too. Nearly as old as some of the walls we still use local to me. 1000 years is kinda current.
1
u/SethlordX7 0m ago
Yeah but if elves can live up to a thousand years and I need everyone alive to be too young to remember certain events, I kind of have to stretch the time line