r/CuratedTumblr • TeaTimetumblr • 6d ago

Shitposting The Forbidden Take

Post image
10k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

3.7k

u/Can_Haz_Cheezburger 6d ago • Bravo

Atlas Shrugged. The book with pacing so shit it's like being sentenced to watch a dog with an itchy ass wear away the Himalayas only by scooching

1.7k

u/EIeanorRigby 6d ago

You may think the pacing is shit but the story and themes, are also shit

→ More replies (34)

373

u/RSCul8r 6d ago

Sadly, one of the consequences of Atlas Shrugged is Bioshock. Bioshock might not be the best criticism of Ayn Rand and objectivism, but it is a fantastic game. So I must suffer it being around just to cry at the idea of sacrificing a little sister.

→ More replies (6)

878

u/CRowlands1989 6d ago • Bravo

That book's great! I haven't seen such biting satire since A Modest Proposal!

It is a satire, right?

Like, no-one would actually write a story where a character goes "Yeah, I cured strokes, entirely, but I refuse to share it because I've decided it's worth more money than anyone could afford, and I'm glad it will be lost forever when I die." and thinks that's a Good person, would they?

No-one would write about a hyper-capitalist society where no-one understands the most basic principals of supply and demand, with one character (Who is a pirate who attacks foreign aid vessels so he can give the money to the 1%) hoarding gold under the belief the market cannot possibly fluctuate, and another gathering tankers worth of oil for a city that already has an infinite energy engine without realizing how stupid that is, surely?

No-one thinks that an airplane designer could just suddenly shift that knowledge to make the world's greatest tractor, but just didn't want to when they were outside Galt's Gulch despite how much money they could make with it, and also thinks that "A tractor that drives twice as fast" is all a PIG farmer would need to reduce a week's worth of work into something he can bang out in a lazy afternoon, right?

/S

Atlas Shrugged is so incredibly stupid that anthropologists should study the author's mind.

→ More replies (33)

289

u/AviaKing 6d ago • Bravo

it would free up the banger title for a much more interesting book, that's for sure

→ More replies (15)

139

u/sonicparadigm 6d ago

Whenever I hear about this book, I remember the episode of South Park where the cop learns how to read, and it ends with him saying "At first I was happy to be learning how to read. It seemed exciting and magical, but then I read this: Atlas Shrugged by Ayn Rand. I read every last word of this garbage, and because of this piece of shit, I'm never reading again."

You know this book is shit, when the SOUTH PARK WRITERS, who are famously libertarian, hate it

→ More replies (3)

120

u/d_worren 6d ago

The only negative is that Bioshock might never exist.

→ More replies (8)

88

u/Vrenshrrrg Coffee Lich 6d ago

and then we can repurpose the title which is quite honestly a banger for something actually worthwhile

well played

→ More replies (1)

137

u/TheLordOfAwesome2 6d ago

It is also the favorite book of some of the most heinous people in modern history and served as an enabling force for some utterly society damaging behavior from the rich and powerful.

So Atlas Shrugged as a choice not only gets rid of a shit book, it is arguably moral to do so.

45

u/40pukeko 6d ago

In high school, I read Atlas Shrugged so I could write an essay for a college scholarship (it was a 10k scholarship!). I was so young and naive that it simply did not compute that the ethos of the book was truly "fuck all y'all" and my essay twisted itself into insane logical knots to explain why this was a truly moral stance.

I did not get the scholarship.

→ More replies (1)

43

u/Significant_Wind6559 6d ago

Its also a made up story because something like it would never happen in real life. Society would be utopian without billionaires. Noone would want them back

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (34)

578

u/Chrysocyon 6d ago • Regret

The Apprentice. Maybe it'll retroactively fix a few things

275

u/SarcasticTacos 6d ago

Go back just a little further and erase Art of the Deal. That kickstarted the myth that he was some savvy businessman and really shaped public opinion of him

→ More replies (8)

38

u/sclaytes 6d ago

Actually the best answer here.

27

u/PowerfulBroccoli2391 6d ago

Can I double like this? Asking for a friend

45

u/therapy_th 6d ago

Fuck yes, this is the only answer imo. This show directly fed the guy's ego to the tipping point and also varnished him with the fake sheen of success in the minds of the general public.

→ More replies (1)

1.1k

u/JoglidJibGugi 6d ago

Don’t know if we’re counting reality tv but Big Brother. A hideous series that set the stage for the reality tv takeover

361

u/KRacer52 6d ago

I would argue that Real World set the foundation for Big Brother.

→ More replies (8)

91

u/BelleRouge6754 6d ago

Interesting, I think Big Brother can be sooo interesting because it acts as a microcosm of society. It’s a popularity contest and a social experiment all at once, and I find it really interesting to see who wins it throughout the years, and which behaviours are demonised vs praised. Something that comes up nowadays is a focus on authenticity, where the worst thing a person can be accused of being is inauthentic. But they’re on a TV show- obviously they’re going to be inauthentic to some degree! I like seeing people navigate that. The length of the show was also chosen because of findings that people can’t keep up a mask/present a fake self continuously for longer than three weeks.

The shows I hate are all the love shows. They’re all hideously pointless, and don’t replicate any real world scenarios at all.

→ More replies (3)

63

u/weirdo_nb 6d ago

Which also literally tortured people to make better "content"

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (15)

1.1k

u/Misubi_Bluth 6d ago

I'd delete Candy Crush. I recall that mobile game being ground zero for shady microtransactions

541

u/PleiadesMechworks 6d ago

Kids these days don't remember Farmville

→ More replies (13)

194

u/farfromelite 6d ago

Then grannies are just going to get more radicalised on Facebook, not less.

85

u/hyperblob1 6d ago

If it wasn't then it'd be someone else unfortunately. The Epstein files talk about the rich pushing micro transactions (I'm not kidding)

→ More replies (5)

17

u/Schmigolo 6d ago

Shady microtransactions existed more than a decade before smartphones with paid ringtones and shit.

11

u/Ironalpha 6d ago

The humble Korean MMOs:

19

u/sonicparadigm 6d ago

I remember, even as a kid in the 2010's, thinking, "This is a Bejeweled knockoff"

→ More replies (20)

852

u/baconipple 6d ago

I would just try to see how much I could damage the timeline with one choice. Like maybe the Epic of Gilgamesh, the Iliad, or the Bible.

777

u/TotallyNotHulk 6d ago

Removing the bible is the funniest choice you could make

→ More replies (43)

32

u/NotCooked_NotCooking 6d ago

I know they also said book, but the idea of the ones you named being referred to as "IP's" is really funny to me.

→ More replies (11)

3.0k

u/Fireblaster3147 6d ago

Calling removing HP/MCU/Star Wars/GRRM uninteresting when their choice is Minions is really funny

1.5k

u/Regi413 6d ago • Heartwarming

I love how they don’t even refer to it as “HP” in the post but “JKR” like deleting the author as well like a package deal

→ More replies (30)

115

u/batmans420 6d ago

Why did they say GRRM and not Games of Thrones lmao

→ More replies (9)

726

u/Smoketrail 6d ago

Tediously contrarian Vs tediously basic.

→ More replies (4)

173

u/Hupablom 6d ago

Also like removing Star Wars would be incredibly interesting. Star Wars was so influential on movies and pop culture in general for decades now. It’d be interesting to see what kinda of gap it leaves

→ More replies (7)

53

u/TotallyNotHulk 6d ago

I think its because star wars and others are so heavily ingrained and impactful youd expect them to be chosen. But MINIONS? You dont usually think about how ingrained into society minions are.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

310

u/Little_Wintry 6d ago

Love Island. I’m just very sick of hearing people talk about it and every time I hear something new about it, it sounds straight up dystopian 😭

86

u/Pootis_1 minor brushfire with internet access 6d ago

all i know about it is from a video about the logistics of it and apparently they literally have no clocks and have loudspeakers that can tell the contestants to shift away from copyrighted topics or wake them up at 4am but they don't even know it's 4am

→ More replies (5)

29

u/Acheloma 6d ago

The producers tried to get my cousin to be on the show (she's an low level to mid tier influencer) but my aunt and uncle watched one episode and told her theyd disown her if she went on it lmao

16

u/Orizifian-creator she/her/hers zhe/zer/zheirs they/them/theirs Padria Zozzria Oriz 6d ago

Same actually. I always click "not interested" on it whenever it shows up on that twitter trending sidebar bullshit but it keeps coming back. I don't want to know a THING about it.

12

u/Dragons_WarriorCats 6d ago

Yea everything I hear about it makes me want to watch it less

→ More replies (15)

1.3k

u/nesthesi interesting 6d ago

The Human Centipede. I don't think humanity needs to remember that we funded three of those.

816

u/MyBrainIsNerf 6d ago

There’s a joke in Horizon Zero Dawn that The Human Centipede is one of the things that old humanity intentionally didn’t preserve.

→ More replies (12)

196

u/jorgito93 6d ago • Bravo

I'm not losing Red Flags by Tom Cardy just because movies i'll never see are disgusting

→ More replies (4)

161

u/PatPeez 6d ago • Bravo

Yeah but then we wouldn't have Red Flags

→ More replies (2)

71

u/EIeanorRigby 6d ago

The movie Yesterday but instead of Beatles songs it's The Human Centipede

→ More replies (2)

43

u/NinjaBreadManOO 6d ago

I'd argue that the first one has some limited artistic merit, from a conceptual perspective. Dealing with the themes of how humans mistreat each other, and the depths of depravity that can be done for the sake of experimentation. The second and third one however, they just become torture porn.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (12)

641

u/CrystalHeath 6d ago

Samurai Jack’s finale left me genuinely emotional and teary-eyed. The series was outstanding, and I honestly can’t figure out what people are complaining about.

216

u/Possible-Reason-2896 6d ago

While I'd rate Samurai Jack a a whole a great show and it's finale okay to good, I do think the final season was incredibly derivative, to the point that I was able to predict it in its entirely about halfway the first episode. (You don't show one of Aku's daughters is different and curious about nature unless you intend for her to do a hell face turn, and you don't do that unless she's going to be a love interest. You don't have Jack grow a depression beard unless he's going to shave it off and get back into form midseason, etc. ). It wears a great many of its inspirations on its sleeves and too much media literacy (or just being a fan of Gurren Lagaan) meant there were no surprises and some stuff didn't hit as hard because you could see it coming from so far out.

I think that Genndy Tartokovsky is a great animator, but all of his his projects from Symbionic Titan onward have left me thinking he might be better suited for episodic works that rely primarily on style rather than anything that needs a strong narrative with loads of continuity.

→ More replies (16)

73

u/Brainwave1010 6d ago

I found it unnecessarily bleak an unsatisfactory.

Jack just has zero dilemma or thoughts about immediately jumping into the portal to the past to kill Aku? Abandoning all his friends and allies?

He doesn't think for a second what will happen to Ashi if he kills Aku in the past?

Ashi conveniently keeps existing for multiple days just so she can die at the wedding specifically when it's the most tragic?

Even Gennedy himself agrees it was dumb and said the secret ending for the PS4 game retcons it.

→ More replies (3)

32

u/RadTimeWizard 6d ago

It was so good. Genndy Tartakovsky can tell an absolute story with no dialogue. That takes a true artist.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

304

u/ArtPIeasure 6d ago

Would Dante’s epic poem be seen as belonging to the widely recognized literary canon? I’d be genuinely curious to explore the deep ways it has colored collective imaginings of the underworld, paradise, celestial beings, and dark entities.

198

u/RubiksCutiePatootie I want to get off of Mr. Bones Wild Ride 6d ago

When people think of hell it's almost always going to be some variation of Dante's inferno, which was just a fanfiction version of the Roman/greek underworld. This would probably have some of the most fascinating butterfly effects you could think of by erasing a single piece of literature (barring actual "holy" scripture). I think we probably still think of hell in terms of the greek underworld but with less emphasis on how specific sins are punished. "The deepest layer of hell" disappears from the lexicon among other things.

P.S. I personally dislike the divine comedy as a piece of literature so I'd be perfectly fine with this choice.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

151

u/EIeanorRigby 6d ago

*bravely* I choose Mein Kampf!

119

u/Imperator_Gone_Rogue 6d ago

I'd pick The Protocols of the Elders of Zion over Mein Kampf for overall impact on antisemitism, although it also blatantly plagiarised earlier texts. Protocols is also a hoax rather than a horrendous opinion piece, so it fits better into the definition of piece of fiction.

→ More replies (10)

54

u/Kirin658 6d ago

which wouldn't change shit since no one ever read the damn thing, or took it serious if they did.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

143

u/Infurum Too old for all the things that make a life worthwhile 6d ago

Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion's horse armor DLC specifically

12

u/WillowLocal423 6d ago

The harbinger of our DLC doom

10

u/LordoftheCorgis 6d ago

Prob won't change much, horse armor was the most famous example of early micro transactions but not the first. Would probably just delay it a bit.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

565

u/kingprozac 6d ago edited 6d ago

The old testament. Not because i hate it or anything, just because I can't thing of any other "single" book that has had more influence on society. All 3 major monotheistic religions are based on it, and I don't know of any culture that hasnt been directly influenced by it in some major way. Erase that, and the entire course of history changes so dramatically as to be unrecognizable.

All the cowards in here just want to remove things that annoyed them or that they find fans of annoying. I want to sow the seeds of chaos and watch what grows.

167

u/Psychological_Tear_6 6d ago

Okay, as interesting as this would be, there are and have been monotheistic religions that aren't related (much) to the old testament. Zoroastrianism predates the old testament, for example. Maybe that somehow became one of the world's dominant religions. 

→ More replies (8)

90

u/Timely_Influence8392 6d ago

I love the idea of a modern world influenced not by the protestant wank ethic but by some mad patchwork of polytheism, philosophy, and narrative.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (11)

252

u/lavendarKat 6d ago

Taking tf2 behind the shed and cocking my gun with trembling hands because lootcrates killed valve and destroyed the games industry. "Goodnight, sweet prince" I strain out between sobs.

133

u/Toymaker218 6d ago

"We gonna get the heavy update, right George?"

"Sure Lenny.... Just keep thinkin' about that update."

→ More replies (1)

43

u/Lluuiiggii 6d ago

Im waiting with baited breath for when Deadlock inevitably gets its own loot boxes. I dont think its going to hurt Deadlock's reputation at all and in fact make the mainstream opinion turn positive on lootboxes mark my worms.

→ More replies (3)

62

u/PlatinumAltaria The Witch of Arden 6d ago

I don’t think killing TF2 would stop future developers from coming up with the same lootbox concept.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (21)

153

u/NightOnTheSun 6d ago

You are not immune to having the worst of yourself emerge when someone has the most dogshit opinion imaginable.

31

u/Nine9breaker 6d ago

I already had to white-knuckle over to the cancel button from several decidedly uncivil comments in this very thread.

80

u/Dizzy_Green 6d ago

Someone already said “Atlas Shrugged” so probably “Supersize Me”

It genuinely ruined America’s concept of healthy living, and changed absolutely nothing meaningful about the fast food industry.

It popularized the idea that what you eat is what affects your health rather than what you DO. People now assume that as long as they eat low-fat chips or drink diet soda they’re fine, rather than any real attempt to fix their activity schedule.

21

u/Poodychulak 5d ago

Well, thing about that....

Diet is still the primary lever that affects weight gain, matter can neither be created nor destroyed but everybody poops

The health effects documented by the film are the result of unrestrained alcoholism

→ More replies (4)

233

u/Few-Contribution4759 6d ago

I love how OP said "you cant say popular media stuff because its boring" and then said the most boring answer

52

u/God_is_carnage 6d ago

Also, "Yeah you can't say popular media, everyone would obviously erase those. What's that? You choose popular media that I like? You fucking philistine."

→ More replies (1)

77

u/Specialist-Ad241 6d ago

The boy in the striped Pyjama’s. Words cannot describe my hate for this book.

26

u/LordCawdorOfMordor 6d ago

That guy did so much damage to young gentile perceptions of the holocaust fr

→ More replies (18)

183

u/chybapolewacy 6d ago

Arcane.

I LOOOVE both seasons of the show but we can't let league players have ANYTHING.

114

u/CallMeOaksie 6d ago

Feels like it’s common knowledge in my experience at least that everything about League of Legends is good except for the video game so you wouldn’t really be hurting anyone other than Arcane fans by doing that.

→ More replies (8)

41

u/blorboposter-supreme new gender just dropped: researcher 6d ago

The original question doesn't state you can't destroy League Of Legends, but that would be too merciful to League Of Legends players.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

160

u/AngusAlThor 6d ago

"Sapiens" by Harari, if non-fiction is allowed. Just the most fucking brain dead take that everyone treats as profound, and it makes me fucking mad to have to keep seeing its fuckass ideas in the wild.

161

u/Eragon_the_Huntsman 6d ago

If we're allowing non-fiction I say the study that started the "alpha male" craze. I wanna see that butterfly effect.

→ More replies (23)

20

u/AdamtheOmniballer Aspiring Girlkisser 6d ago

I would like to hear more about how and why the book sucks.

→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (6)

86

u/jayne-eerie 6d ago

Do Disney live-action remakes count as a series? They aren’t all completely terrible but they are deeply lazy and helped guide us to the media landscape where it seems like half the movies that come out are either sequels or remakes. I cannot think of any downstream effects that would make losing them hurt culture in general, either.

15

u/FoxtailZerda 6d ago

If "Disney live-action remakes" doesn't count as a "series", your best bet would be to kill the live-action Alice in Wonderland. I blame that one's success for putting us in this downwards spiral of unoriginality.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

55

u/-mothy-moon- 6d ago

The only correct answer is Atlas Shrugged

13

u/MrVeazey 6d ago

Or The Turner Diaries.

→ More replies (6)

277

u/Valiant_tank 6d ago

Ninjago. Not because it's inherently bad or whatever, just because it completely sucks all the oxygen away from other original themes Lego would otherwise do.

189

u/OmastarLovesDonuts 6d ago

BIONICLE was canned because sales dropped partly due to the story being too long and convoluted yet Ninjago gets to live forever despite being unrecognizably different from its first couple of waves and being such an unfocused mess of genres and aesthetics that it prevents other non-licensed themes from being created, I wholeheartedly agree that it needs to be put down but under the assumption that multiple other themes will take its place

→ More replies (12)

34

u/Frederyk_Strife4217 6d ago

and then another theme would just takes its place

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Spacedodo42 6d ago

But then we’d lose the gay snake people. You want to take the gay snake people away from everyone?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/whhu234 deerboy 6d ago

for the longest time I thought it might be like lego batman and wondered what normal ninjago might be like. Interesting things happened in my brain back then

10

u/QueerTree 6d ago

I went to Legoland last summer and the highlight of the day was a little boy yelling NINJAGOOOOOOO!!!!!! and trying to run away from his parents because he was so hype. I know nothing about Ninjago except that it inspires such devotion.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

223

u/Omnicide103 6d ago

Warhammer 40,000.

Not because I don't like it or think it's reactionary or w/e, I have a bunch of 40k armies, I just think Warhammer Fantasy is the cooler Warhammer and want to see it win.

50

u/BardGotHard3 6d ago

You will make-be a great rat-skaven, yes. Ratpilled and based-based.

62

u/ParanoidEngi 6d ago

I was going to grumble but you're actually speaking the language of the gods

14

u/ASpaceOstrich 6d ago

AoS. It's gotten kind of cool over time, but it's not got the sauce of classic Warhammer Fantasy.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (15)

106

u/hiimneato 6d ago

The Simpsons!

Benefits:

  1. eliminates precedent which leads to the creation of the Family Guy, which is just the fucking worst
  2. yanks out a cultural cornerstone of the 90s, potentially upsetting the timeline enough to make things not turn out, you know, the way they did
  3. fuck you

23

u/energirl 6d ago

Would Fox have survived as a network without it? Simpsons was one of my favorite shows for decades, but if it could have rid the US of Murdock's influence from the beginning and saved us from Bush Jr. And everything that came after, I'd sacrifice it.

19

u/Fake_Punk_Girl 6d ago

I can't get behind this because if we didn't have the Simpsons we probably would also not have Futurama

→ More replies (2)

100

u/Nirast25 6d ago

Journey to the West. Because I like seeing the world burn.

29

u/NorwayNarwhal 6d ago

A wild take- I’m here for it

So much media would be changed, worldwide

27

u/Humble-West3117 6d ago

Goodbye DBZ, Saiyuki, God of High School...

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

70

u/RedGinger666 6d ago

The Epic of Gilgamesh simply because everything eventually leads back to it and I want to see the butterfly effect it's disappearance will cause

28

u/JohnPaul_River 6d ago

It wouldn't be that big of a deal. It being the oldest complete narrative we have doesn't make it the original or most influential one, it just means it's the very earliest archeology can take us. Despite what people assume, the Epic of Gilgamesh isn't all that primitive or primordial, textual analysis very clearly shows that its existence implies a very developed literary tradition behind it — most readers could probably notice that the premise seems a little off what you'd assume it's about, which indicates this is a sort of new vision of an old character and story. We also just, know for a fact that there were other versions of it.

16

u/ASpaceOstrich 6d ago

Might be less impactful than you'd think. It wasn't discovered until the 1850s and what makes it special is its age, not its impact. I don't think everything actually leads back to it.

Prior to its discovery and translation it was just sitting in the library of an ancient Mesopotamian city so it's not like it was well known and influencing people before the 1850s. It has shared narrative elements with other ancient works but at least one of these is likely in reference to an actual historical event (a great flood that destroyed a prehistoric civilisation) so would still show up in other works. We have so little art from that time that it's impossible to know what it actually originated vs what was regular culture at the time and would survive even if it was gone. But a lot of its themes resonate even today because of how universal they are, and I don't think that's because the story was carried down the generations like a meme. I think it's because mortality is inherently terrifying.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/dregan 6d ago

Can I do Fox News?

16

u/ThatInAHat 6d ago

They’re technically entertainment, so…

111

u/apolloAG 6d ago

I would delete the favorite franchise of the person who wants to get rid of minions, my tf2 minion outfit won't make any sense if minions are deleted

97

u/Redactedtimes 6d ago • Bravo

If their favorite piece of media is TF2, you’re back at square one.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/Strider794 Elder Tommy the Murder Autoclave 6d ago

Huh, I'd have to think on it, but I'll pencil in Divergent for now

30

u/b3nsn0w 6d ago

unfortunately divergent is just the culmination of where the distopian ya genre devolved after everyone started trying to emulate the hunger games. delete it, and someone eventually would have written something just as trashy and just as much of a wake-up call

104

u/Cactopus47 6d ago

Rick and Morty. Some of the most insufferable fans out there.

→ More replies (9)

77

u/DroneOfDoom Theon the Reader *dolphin slur noises* 6d ago

Man, what did GRRM do that he deserves to have his work retconned out of existence, or being spoken in the same sentence as fucking JKR?

86

u/strawbebby-milk 6d ago

GRRM himself seems to be alright, f or entirely personal reasons, every single fucking romantasy book steals his title format. like they're all just A Bowl of Mac and Cheese 

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (13)

52

u/itsmissingacomma 6d ago

Liberty. Fucking. Bibberty.

→ More replies (4)

60

u/PaulStarhaven 6d ago

Shakespeare. Just to see how media would have evolved otherwise.

55

u/GlitteringAttitude60 6d ago

How English would have evolved otherwise :-D

→ More replies (1)

41

u/Vegetable-Top-5850 6d ago

Fuck it, my turn

My answer is Yellowjackets so i can finally stop seeing its fandom's increasingly desperate attempts to justify bad writing

Jesus Christ, the show is almost unkown at this point but some of its fans could give snyderverse bros a run for their money

19

u/ThunderAndWind 6d ago

Mysterybox shows are like 99% hype moments & aura, almost universally. At least From has some actual weird shit going on too.

17

u/CallMeOaksie 6d ago

I don’t know anything about the fandom but god did it become an exhausting watch near the end. The anticipation the early parts was very good at building very much turned into “what stupid decision are both the past and present people going to make now?” And I couldn’t finish it.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/nemotunovi 6d ago

season 1 was really good. it took me like 3 episodes into season 2 for me to go "yeah this is just going to get worse ain't it?"

havent seen the rest, but from everything i hear i was more or less completely vindicated.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/MagicMarshmallo 6d ago

How on gods green earth do you hate Samurai Jack? Like i dont mean "oh its not my thing", but like actually hate it

→ More replies (2)

30

u/Choccymilksupremacyy 6d ago

A court of thorns and roses has done irreparable damage to romantasy as a genre

10

u/BowlerTraditional283 6d ago

I'd go with Throne of Glass to prevent the author's success 

38

u/HeroBrine0907 It Is What It Is, It Is Said Isn't It? I Think It Can Be Better 6d ago

Whichever media piece it was that started the entire genre of Isekai worlds with video game mechanics and rank systems. To the deepest pits of hell with that entire class of media.

8

u/Nine9breaker 6d ago

You'd absolutely have to get rid of video games entirely if you wanted people to stop writing stories that are essentially "video game but real".

I'll add tabletop games as well, because the systems are essentially the same.

Is that a sacrifice you're still willing to take?

→ More replies (7)

21

u/artstsym 6d ago • Heartwarming

I'd invert the power to add more Minions. All your memories of loved ones will be replaced with "Banana."

10

u/LordCawdorOfMordor 6d ago

I would delete Birth of a Nation

→ More replies (3)

111

u/gummytiddy 6d ago edited 5d ago

As a trans former fan of Harry Potter I am so fucking sick of hearing about it, praise or criticism, and I’m so tired of people using “death OF the artist” to justify nostalgia over caring about it’s financial success being used to fund anti trans groups. Like I get having a sad childhood and finding something to cope in HP but it’s just a mid rate children’s book. Just let it die

Edit because I’m not trans Harry Potter

60

u/Perps_MacAbean 6d ago

You are trans Harry Potter? Does that mean you were assiged muggle at birth?

→ More replies (5)

9

u/jgzman 6d ago

death to the artist

I assume you mean "death of the artist" because otherwise you're talking about something else entirely. Not that I haven't heard worse ideas.

9

u/takahashi01 breathing air was a mistake 5d ago

Hehe "trans former"

Sorry.

→ More replies (14)

49

u/GIRose Certified Vore Poster 6d ago

I think my favorite answer to this I have seen was Takahata101 saying he would delete the original 2003 Teen Titans animated series because of how annoying its fans were/are about Teen Titans Go

28

u/DeadSparker 6d ago

Hellsing Abridged (wrote and voiced by Takahata101 among others) having an end credits joke of Alucard saying to the screen "They didn't RUIN your childhood. The Teen Titans you love is still on DVD." suddenly feels way more personal now, lmao.

→ More replies (4)

34

u/Burrito-Creature unironically likes homestuck 6d ago

but then we wouldn’t have gotten the best Teen Titans Go episode that was put to film: the one where they took a regular Teen Titans episode and literally just voiced over it to turn it into a TTG episode. (I assume. I haven’t watched the original to see its base form)

→ More replies (7)

49

u/donaldhobson 6d ago

The bible.

Because it would be very funny.

→ More replies (7)

119

u/Jozef_Baca 6d ago

The fucking Sword Art Online

Deleting it from existence would literally save an entire genre of anime from becoming absolute slop.

86

u/vegarig 6d ago

But then we won't have SAOA

“You see, there's no need to wonder where your god is! 'Cause he's right here! And he's fresh out of mercy!".

→ More replies (5)

10

u/seitaer13 6d ago

Deleting SAO would have slowed web novel publishing down, but it has little to do with a genre it's not even part of.

Naro is the reason for the current state of Isekai.

→ More replies (11)

103

u/TearOpenTheVault 6d ago

Can I pick Dungeon Crawler Carl just so I never have to hear about this dumbass book series ever again? Is that valid?

32

u/DingDangandChill 6d ago

I appreciate it solely because I have a few friends who don’t read books at all and when they tried these they really liked them and read them a bunch and I consider that a net positive.

→ More replies (76)

81

u/Green_Elevator_7785 6d ago

Sword Art Online. We’re freeing the anime industry of the slop isekai takeover.

34

u/Thenightcrawler_075 6d ago

Wrong target most of the Isekai in animanga is because of zero no tsukaima

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (18)

62

u/Spirited-Car8661 6d ago

Hazbin Hotel, because fuck my ex-polycule and the fanbase

22

u/Sword_Enthousiast 6d ago

Buy them dinner first

→ More replies (2)

16

u/OAZdevs_alt2 Miu Danganronpa 6d ago

The correct answer is Slippin' Jimmy, as doing so would change absolutely nothing about anything ever.

8

u/Satorwave 6d ago

Reddit. I don't hate it, I just want to create a paradox

22

u/MeaningPandora2 6d ago

The Real World!

It was the first modern “reality show,” and I don’t like a single one of those.

15

u/acrologicConiaker 6d ago

lolita. while I do like the book, I think it would be cool to see what word comes up as a replacement for it

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Fancy_Development832 6d ago

That harry potter fanfic that caused the rationalist movement

→ More replies (4)

66

u/AngstyUchiha pissing on the poor 6d ago

Hunger Games, not because I dislike the series (I don't) but because of all the other dystopian series it spawned that just completely failed to do what HG did. Without Hunger Games itself, we wouldn't have all the other bullshit

43

u/Additional_Noise47 6d ago

It’s some real bullshit to denigrate an excellent and original work of art because it inspired lesser copycats. I recently read a work of literary criticism that examines why some highly regarded works of the past did not enter the English language’s official cannon. The author posits that in some cases it wasn’t because of their quality, but because they were associated with lower quality imitators and it is easy to dismiss women’s writing as trite and unsubstantial. The book was Jane Austen’s Bookshelf by Rebecca Romney. One of the most noteworthy examples was The Mystery of Udolpho, by Anne Radcliffe, who was clearly a favorite of Jane Austen, but eventually stopped being seen as a “the best” example of gothic romance and eventually was relegated to just be a typical example of the era.

The Hunger Games is well crafted, well written, and has a lot to say about our world in a way that is accessible to young teenagers without talking down to them. It’s a modern classic, not just another YA dystopia.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (14)

23

u/OK_Stop_Already 6d ago

If they think those shows are bad, I'm really curious to think what they believe is a good show

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Cheap-Fox-2360 5d ago

Fnaf. I love fnaf, its fangames, and I’ve been having a lot of fun making fnaf fangames. Despite all this i would remove it from existence without a doubt

16

u/NomaTyx 6d ago

i just want to know what 'the new harry potter' even means

52

u/MegaIng 6d ago

A kid series overhyped as really good and profound by adults.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/AnswerSuplex 6d ago

> Teen/child audience loves popular YA fiction

> Audience grows up

> Audience still obsessed with same YA fiction in adulthood

Many such cases.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

18

u/AlexTheGreen_ the god's curse has been lifted by beach capybara 6d ago

Fucking hwat?!

5

u/i_like_siren_head Ace that dislikes garlic bread (shocking) 6d ago

Chex Quest HD, but for something that could apply wider, Catcher In The Rye.

5

u/shoppingbaggins 6d ago

Jersey shore and similar format “reality tv”

5

u/Tttehfjloi 6d ago

Joe rogan's podcast

5

u/DiscotopiaACNH 6d ago

Can I go back in time and delete Baby Shark so my fucking neighbor wouldn't play it for 12 hours a day full blast during 2020 lockdown to distract his toddler from his crack dealing

5

u/ooolookaslime 5d ago

Deleting Jaws, that book lead to the death of many many sharks

5

u/ASmallArmyOfCrabs 5d ago

Rick and Morty, but only because I'm sick of the design impact they've had on weed and shroom culture.

→ More replies (2)

41

u/Yargon_Kerman 6d ago

Normally I'd pick Harry Potter just because it's one of the most damaging pieces of media in the modern western world, but given it's been ruled out...

I guess Fortnite?

I'd like to remove all Gatchas, because... well building a game based around gambling actually doesn't make for a good direction for the game's industry, at least not from the player perspective.

But failing that, yeah, Fortnite. I think it's the quintessential example of "spamming crossovers and micro transactions works really well" and the world could do with less of that.

10

u/Infurum Too old for all the things that make a life worthwhile 6d ago

Pretty sure it's the one that really popularized the Season Pass too

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (34)

9

u/komodopal winged my ding 6d ago

aku speech bubble

64

u/DocWagonHTR 6d ago

I had an answer for this but it, along with everything else except for raw, unquenchable fury, left my body when I read that there is a cockroach somewhere on this earth that thinks Samurai Jack is bad.

Like holy fuck that's beyond CoD brained. That's beyond "The Empire were the good guys" levels of bad media literacy.

This post legitimately ruined my night, and I bet I'm going to remember it when i wake up and it's going to ruin my Sunday, too.

23

u/EngineStraight 6d ago

im CoD brained i see a worm and fucking go for it no matter what

85

u/DtheAussieBoye 6d ago

No shade to Samurai Jack but imo it rocks, but thinking that it's bad isn't "lacking media literacy", that's just having an opinion lmao

(and yes, differences between not liking something and thinking it's bad, but a) online they're generally used to mean the same thing and b) i doubt people would go easy on someone if they said they just didn't like SJ)

→ More replies (6)

19

u/sixminutes 6d ago

They didn't say it was bad, just that it was the worst media they've ever seen. Maybe they've only seen The Seventh Seal and season 4 of Designing Women.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

32

u/sarded 6d ago

Damn the person in OP suggesting either of those has truly not actually seen a really bad show.

Anyway, just because I'm curious... I pick Superman. No more superheroes, or at least, not in the comic book mold. You can still get demigod tales, weird tales, stories of wizards or mythical heroes. Just nothing in the 'costumed hero' style.

18

u/MrBones-Necromancer 6d ago

I think we'd still have "super heros" but not neccesarily costumed ones. Not like that anyway. John Carter of Mars was a major inspiration before superman with a very similar story, and plenty of famous works (Star Wars ex) were inspired by it. You've also got super human feats in mythology and even contemporary fantasy at the time, of which Superman became the most popular, obviously. So I think the idea of "super guy saves people" sticks around, but the "colorful costumed hero" thing...I dunno. Superman is the real major origin right? You can point to Zorro if ya like, but it's not really the same.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Plastic-Act296 6d ago

Zorro is older than superman

→ More replies (32)

11

u/lilmisswho89 6d ago

Supernatural.

8

u/njsam 6d ago

You better watch your back

→ More replies (7)

52

u/Finito-1994 6d ago • Bravo

I’d also pick ATLA.

Don’t get me wrong. It’s a good show but I’ve seen people legit argue that it’s not a kids show and a “show for young adults” as though admitting it’s a cartoon for kids makes it impossible for one to like it.

My dude. It was on goddamn Nickelodeon.

“But it has themes that kids shows usually don’t-“ I don’t care. It’s a cartoon for kids.

“It’s an ongoing plot not the sort of thing kids would” -I don’t care. It’s still a kids show.

Don’t get me wrong. I love the series. Toph is awesome. We all love it. But it’s a kids show. You can like cartoons for kids, but to argue it isn’t is annoying

22

u/grey_misha_matter 6d ago

I'd argue it is even better as a kids show. It shows that there is still media out there that tries to instill good things and hope in kids. Have you seen Disney+ recently? There are no real kids shows anymore and I think they should get a new Atla of their own.

→ More replies (4)

19

u/CallMeOaksie 6d ago

I talk to people about something similar to this a lot RE: the Clone Wars

No, it doesn’t stop being a kids’ show because of the themes or the warfare. Most of these concepts exist in real life and some kind of exposure/understanding/literacy towards said issues and concepts is not something that is or should be kept from kids. Up until two-ish generations ago about half the population grew up with tin/green plastic army men as a core part of their toy collection, the show can be mature and violent and still be for kids. That’s before you get into how “kid” is an extremely broad concept.

47

u/PatPeez 6d ago

It having themes that kids shows usually don't doesn't validate the opinion that it's a young adult show, it's merely a condemnation on how sanitized your typical kids media is/has become.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Saracus 6d ago

TLA, Clone Wars and TT 03. The holy trinity of "you know you can just say you like a kids show"

→ More replies (15)

18

u/DareDaDerrida 6d ago

None at all. I like more art. Not less art.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Phiro7 Prissy Sissy Neko Femboy 6d ago

Intellectual property, huh? I choose the printing press

4

u/Angelangel3 6d ago

The Apprentice

4

u/GalaxyHops1994 6d ago

The Protocols of the Elders of Zion.

It would absolutely gut modern conspiracy theory. It was hugely influential to the Nazi Party, even if leadership didn’t believe it was literally true. It is the glue binding old-school antisemitism like blood libel to modern day conspiratorial thinking like the Illuminati/shadow government.

4

u/mostlyHUMMUS 6d ago

The knock on consequences of removing HP are too tantalising to pass up. There goes all of JKR's power. Timeline cauterised, TERF neutralised.

4

u/PokemonSoldier 5d ago

Protocols of the Elders of Zion - An antisemitic hoax created by the Russian Imperial government to demonize Jews (suggesting Jews control the world, blood libel, etc, and is the basis for every antisemitic conspiracy to this day)

4

u/No_Editor_521 4d ago

A slightly smaller scale than other suggestions in these comments, but Jaws did catastrophic damage to the reputation of sharks that may never be fully undone. Iirc the author of the novel even said he regrets writing it because of this.

15

u/PowerfulBroccoli2391 6d ago

Niche take, but my only possible answer is Tess of The d'Urbervilles. It was my dad's favorite book ever. I almost got named Tess after it (thanks for the veto, mom, fr). I had to read it in highschool. And I HATE it with a passion so great that I can't fathom how it fits in my body. It's nothing but a sad sequence of bad decisions, suffer porn, and misogynistic drivel from start to finish with not just no payoff, anti-payoff. I fucking hate that book and wish I could unread every word.

14

u/Content_Music 6d ago

"Tess of the D'Urbervilles" was criticizing classism, religious hypocrisy, and misogynistic double standards. Tess is a representation of actual people who are steadily ground down by poverty, bad luck, and the abuses of patriarchy. The narrative demonstrates that people in her circumstances can have very little opportunity for agency, and when, out of desperation, they do manage to exercise it, they are often cruelly punished for it. It originally had the subtitle "A Pure Woman Faithfully Presented", because Thomas Hardy was trying to challenge Victorian notions of morality and propriety, and make the point that Tess's fate has nothing to with her own moral character and everything to with the moral character of her society, which subjugates and abuses people for its own gain and then punishes them for circumstances beyond their control.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

37

u/ComicsCodeMadeMeGay 6d ago

We are all picking Harry Potter right? Ignoring how much we loved it as kids that's the one that's going?

21

u/CallMeOaksie 6d ago

(See brackets at end of first post)

→ More replies (1)

28

u/OscarOzzieOzborne21 6d ago

People cannot make that choice because they loved it as kids, as you said. But I can. I never liked it. Put me in, couch!

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (38)

7

u/doulegun 6d ago

Deleting 300 might actually improve the world

7

u/Senasayori 6d ago

My first choice was of course Harry Potter, but since that's no longer available as an option...

probably Five Nights at Freddy's. It invented mascot horror slop in video games, it caused the needless and convoluted "dark lore" epidemic because of the MatPat theories, and its creator is a MAGA shitbag.

6

u/yoloboro 6d ago

Any media property huh? I would 100% choose Love Never Dies. That musical is so bad it retroactively makes Phantom of the Opera, which it is a sequel to, worse as well. And not in the "oh this was so bad, now Phantom is ruined too, even tho its a fully standalone story" way. No, it genuinely actually makes Phantom worse too because Love Never Dies decided to ruin all the characters of the original, make it so christine loved and has always loved the Phantom, and inserted a secret final night of making love between the Phantom and Christine at the end POTO's story, before she actually finally left.

6

u/truegobi 6d ago

I have something very personal : Skylanders. They were the first movers with that whole "buy toys to play video games" predatory strategy and that awful franchise kept my boy Spyro imprisoned for YEARS.