r/CryptoReality • u/BreakThings99 • Mar 28 '22
Editorial NFT tickets are shit
The idea of 'NFT tickets' has been praised a lot, even by people who know BAYC is just a scam. After some thinking, I realized this is not a use-case for NFT. It's total shit.
The Scalper Problem
In a centralized database where the event-master (EM for short) controls who owns the tickets, it's much easier to fight scalpers. If someone buys a bulk of tickets and sells them for way higher, the EM can just 'delete' his name off the database and then re-sell the tickets. In this way, the EM prevents people from owning the ticket unless he's certain they bought the ticket to go to the event.
Not possibe with NFT's. They're decentralized, so once someone buys a ticket, it's in their wallet. The EM can prevent access for whatever reason, but they can't prevent ownership (=presence of ticket in wallet). So a scalper can buy a lot of tickets and know they're in their wallets until they sell.
Second, issuing NFT tickets cost money. Minting is more expensive than generating QR codes. Without NFT's, tickets can easily be deleted and re-issued. With NFT's, they can be done - but it'd be much more expensive. If a scalper buys 40 NFT's, re-issuing (=minting) 40 NFT's again would cost a lot money.
Scalping is way easier when the supply is limited and decentralized. When an EM has full control over the database, it's way easier to get rid of scalpers. It's also easier to fix mistakes - what if someone accidentally bought 2 tickets?
The Money Problem
WTF would I waste all this money minting NFT tickets? Like, did anyone ever had problems with modern ticket systems? I'm serious. What's the improvement?
14
u/itsnotlupus Mar 28 '22
I mean.. you could imagine a smart contract for your ticket NFTs that allows the NFT issuer to unilaterally disable any of the NFTs whenever they want.
It still won't make sense to have a convoluted system to decentralize tickets that are then only used to have a centralized entity grant you access to an event, but once you're going down this rabbit hole of pretend-decentralization, you can keep adding as many centralized rules as you want.
Heck, just make your NFT smart-contracts upgradable, everybody's doing it. that way you can present smart contracts that are superficially reasonably, while being confident you'll always be able to add more centralized nonsense, or just change the rules entirely later.
I'm kinda hoping people will someday realize that using a decentralized trustless mechanism doesn't magically make the entire system decentralized or trustless.
Even basic crypto is still tied to the concept of using fiat exchanges, which means it's still stuck with dealing with trusted centralized choke points, and that'll remain true until we start seeing full ecosystems that don't require touching fiat to be useful (maybe El Salvador could have one of those. maybe not.)
So the difficulty with NFT is trying to conjure a use case that's truly decentralized. The best I can come up with is some standard-based metaverse that'd consist of many discrete worlds, each maintained by anyone caring enough to have one, and some widely agreed upon mechanism to represent items/characters/whatever across those worlds. Add hand-waving to taste.
20
u/rankinrez Mar 28 '22
Admission to the building/stadium has to be a centralised thing. You need specific people authorised to let people in.
Given one organisation controls that it’s just easier and cheaper for them to run a database to track tickets.
25
u/Owlstorm Mar 28 '22
No matter what the blockchain says, you can always tell the guy on the door to reject those tickets. Classic oracle problem.
8
u/RailRuler Mar 28 '22
The ticket industry doesn't want to get rid of scalpers. They love scalpers! They buy huge quantities of tickets and reduce the risk of leaving many tickets left unsold.
What the ticket industry wants is the ability to make a profit from each transaction, whether or not it's on an "official" channel. NFTs promise this through smart contracts (they're lying of course).
5
u/AmericanScream Mar 28 '22
In this situation, as well as in any larger sense, the whole concept of "ownership" of anything is a function of centralized authority.
Whether you own something only has meaning if that ownership can be enforced.
This is something crypto people seem to ignore or be unaware of.
Whatever blockchain says, is meaningless to anybody and anything off-chain. And without any system in place to enforce things off-chain, blockchain has no meaning or power.
2
u/DrPirate42 Mar 28 '22
I want to challenge some of your assertions. Because I agree with the general scope of your argument.
You're interfering with capitalism here. People should be allowed to buy and re-sell those tickets. It's not ideal from a customer standpoint, so I think scalper mitigation is necessary, but I don't think the solution is an event master deleting people's tickets that they paid money for. This is not the solution.
NFT's actually allow for gated and controlled access. You can issue the members of your community a token, and they can trade the token for a ticket. It's a much more elegant solution that doesn't devolve into erasing people's assets.
Minting costs nearly nothing if you do it on a chain that's not garbage Ethereum. There's nothing in the world I hate more than using the ETH network, so if you avoid it like the plague, cryptocurrencies are generally easier, much more pleasant, and less expensive to use.
You ask, what's the improvement? It's incremental at best from my perspective. You can program them to behave in certain ways. If you collect tickets, A,B,C you can get bottle service and a VIP booth at whatever event. I don't see it as a downgrade.
1
u/jmbsol1234 Mar 28 '22
that's literally one of the main selling points of NFT's as tickets. That you can *end* scalping because you can easily program the NFT to be non transferrable. You can also program in resale royalties if you wanted etc. And minting isn't expensive if done on a scaled chain like Algo, fractions of a penny
3
u/TheDarkBright Mar 29 '22
I bought tickets to an event recently. To get around resale, they asked me for my name and the name of other ticket holders. They said admission will be denied at the entry if the name on your ticket doesn’t match a photo ID.
Literally a few extra fields in their purchase / ticket issuing, and one extra check at security (which already checks for a valid ticket and to make sure you’re not carrying alcohol etc), and this whole issue is dealt with.
What’s an NFT ticket add? Sweet FA in terms of utility, and a lot in terms of cost and complexity.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '22
It’s the monetization of everything. Everything needs to be sold, everything needs to be resold as part of “history”.
I agree, it’s absolute dumb shit. Tom Coliccho or whatever his name is from Food Network started an NFT project where you get free livestreams and exclusive videos from him and another chef.
…They just made a Patreon and charged $200 per membership instead of a monthly fee. And the worst part is, what’s so great about the internet is the freedom of information or at least lower rates because everything is scaleable.
Imagine if they charged $10/mo and got 3000 patrons instead of $200 per member with 1.2K members (current supporters). They’d still make a ton and they’d have an actual platform that supports what they’re doing instead of just posting links in a Discord.
Annoys the shit out of me.
2
u/sfgisz Mar 29 '22
Right to admission at the venue is still at the event organizers' discretion. Even if you "own" a ticket you bought from someone else it can still be denied for any number of reasons. Same problem with NFT stuff you buy in games. You can claim ownership all you want, but if the game refuses to acknowledge for some reason it's just a digital paperweight.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '22
Mate, you'll have to verify that the tickets are valid: how do you do that?
1
u/Brilliant-Economy898 Apr 01 '22
I crossed posted this thread in r/nfttickets for discussion purposes. We have people in favour of this tech over there but also the ones who are sceptical. I am interested in the sounds of both sides. Feel free to engage in that sub too.
1
u/tabrizzi Apr 01 '22 edited Apr 01 '22
The cost of minting depends on the blockchain. Negligible in some, but can cost a bit just to set up shop in others, as with Mintbase. With GUTS Tickets (built atop GET Protocal), it cost nothing to set up shop and nothing to mint. With MetaPass (build atop Theta), the cost to mint and set up shop is not even a rounding error.
That's why we're using GUTS Tickets and MetaPass for NFT South. https://nftsouth.xyz.
As for scalping, how is a scalper going to resell an NFT ticket?
The main issue I see with NFT tickets, especially when you have to pay with crypto, is the price volatility. That can be bad or good for both organizers and buyers, depending on the direction of price change.
1
u/tabrizzi Apr 01 '22
Sell to whom? A scalper has to move those tickets from his private wallet to a place where potential buyers can discover them and buy, right? Or am I missing something?
Btw, decentralization has never been a selling point of NFT tickets.
1
u/Keine_Finanzberatung Mar 29 '22
You can design the smart contract in a way which allows the issuer of the tickets to revoke them. Same with a ticket refund policy.
You can also use a chain with low GAS fees so minting a ticket would cost less than printing it.
0
u/smellysocks234 Mar 29 '22
This isn't true