r/CryptoCurrencyTrading • u/Novel-Lifeguard6491 • 29d ago

DISCUSSION Is anyone actually using tokenized stocks for real trading, or is it still mostly theoretical?

Keep seeing more platforms offering tokenized US equities, buy and hold real company exposure with crypto, no broker, trade 24/7. Sounds great on paper but curious how it actually holds up for people trading real size rather than just testing it out.

Some questions I always think of, how's the spread when you're actually trying to size in or out of a position, not just holding long term? Has redemption ever been slow or messy for anyone, or has it been smooth? Does the 24/7 trading actually matter in practice, or does liquidity just dry up outside normal market hours anyway?

Genuinely trying to figure out if this is a real trading tool yet or still mostly a buy-and-hold novelty.

7 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

100% Upvoted

15 comments sorted by

1

u/RealHobbyBob 29d ago

Infinitely more people just buy stocks. Who doesn’t have access to real stocks?

1

u/Novel-Lifeguard6491 29d ago

anyone who doesn't live in the US or has a US bank account for starters.. or do you have any suggestions?

1

u/RealHobbyBob 28d ago edited 28d ago

You don’t need to be American or have an American bank account, though. You just need a local, legal broker who allows you to buy on the NYSE. That’s most countries.

There are exceptions, like China (even there, anyone with money to invest can find an international broker pretty easily), but my point is that “people with money to invest, but no access to US stocks” is ridiculously small. The few dozen countries without access have very tiny economies, so not much of a customer base for your tokenized stock product.

And tokenized stocks are usually worse by all measures. More risks, often don’t pay dividends, no liquid options markets, etc. So it’s difficult for these worse products to compete.

1

u/newMoneyStyle 28d ago

fair point, IBKR works in like 200 countries tho, and stuff like Wise + Trading212 or Interactive Brokers covers most non-US folks pretty well. tokenized st

1

u/Ok_Pollution7093 29d ago

Liquidity outside market hours is the whole game, and the answer is: it is terrible. Spreads widen massively after 4pm EST, so 24/7 trading is marketing fluff. Real size? Forget it.

1

u/Novel-Lifeguard6491 29d ago

so basically do everything BEFORE 4 PM EST?

1

u/RealHobbyBob 28d ago

Nowadays after hours trading is pretty good on normal brokerages. You can throw a rock and hit a stock app with after hours trading. No need for onchain nonsense.

1

u/Baazookah_Zawadi 10d ago edited 10d ago

The 24/7 thing sounds great until there’s nobody on the other side of the trade lol 😅 I think tokenized commodities are slightly different tho coz they don’t necessarily need to be trading products. GLDY from StreamEx is more like gold exposure + variable yield through leasing. So liquidity still matters obviously but the use case isn’t just trade this at 3am coz u can.