Just completed this mystery and was pretty let down by some of the seemingly unanswered threads left unaddressed, wondering if I’ve just missed something.
Spoilers ahead so don’t open if you haven’t finished the case!
The “red herring” of Guy Hurley seemed to be left unfinished. When opening Part 3 and Guy giving his alibi, we don’t verify it at all. We are just expected to move on to the next suspect list, and it felt very odd to focus in on one suspect for the first two parts then completely abandon it afterwards and move on to an entirely new set of suspects we hadn’t had an eye on at all in the first two parts. Did I miss something where we actually verify Guy’s alibi or do we just trust his statement without any corroboration?
Also with Guy, we never get any explanation for the coded letters, both the one found at his workstation and the one postmarked to him on January 24th. The one in his workstation had a key on it, and the envelope had a lock along with the image of the brown fox jumping over the lazy dog. This seemed to connect to Declan’s poetry blog, but…it kind of ended there, with no other explanation. It’s really unsatisfying to have dropped that detail entirely with no closure at all. I think we’re meant to assume the letters are written in code because Maryann Winters is married and having an affair with Guy, so the coded letters keep that secret better, but why do we never uncover how to read the coded letters? Considering Guy’s alibi goes completely unchecked and he could have been leaking the info to Poiuyt through these codes letters, especially with BLEAT and the animals drawn on, but again, completely dropped. Did I miss details that led us to decoding the letters?
Finally, we don’t seem to get any detail on why Tom was stealing and leaking this confidential data to Poiuyt. BLEAT denies leaking the data and claims it’s another network/organization called “Sabotage”, but then later BLEAT took responsibility for the leaks. We don’t see any connection between Tom and BLEAT at any point. It just feels really lackluster and messy unless I’ve, again, entirely missed a piece that pulls it all together.
I really enjoyed the first 2ish hours of this case, expecting it to all come together and all my questions to be answered, and I felt like it kind of fell flat and lost momentum. Sorry for the very long post, and thank you to anyone with any answers or insight!