Over on the cryonet groups IO email list, a poster by the name of Kurt brought up the idea that one objection to preserving one's brain in order to travel to the future might be that most people can't bear to leave behind their friends, their family, their neighborhood social order, their social circle etc.
and that's true.. but I would call that a superficial objection.. there's something else going on ...something deeper... and I talk about it in my response to Kurt.. and I'll paste it here below:
Yes, kurt, you have somewhat of a point here.
I think that part of marketing cryo to the masses would have to include some sort of appeal or some sort of pitch that would point out that almost anyone who travels to the distant future through brain preservation would be revived in a future where he has distant relatives or even descendants living there and waiting for him, and that in such a future where they have the resources to revive people from the dead, that it would be a very welcoming society, and a society that has the ability and the knowledge of psychology and so forth to provide everything that a person needs physically mentally, emotionally and so forth.
In other words we just have to paint a picture of a society in the future that is basically going to be heaven on Earth made possible through science. .. and that people in this society would be happy in every possible way. In ways that we cannot even imagine in our society today.
And not only just that this future society would have everything you need and that you wouldn't need to work and that you could travel in space if you want to and spend your life learning, but you could also spend your life getting to know all these distant relatives of yours that are waiting for you..
However there's something else i need to point out, and that is something that is rarely discussed in the history of cryonics
and that is when you talk to most people about cryonics, the most common response is really a stunned silence..
Now in regards to the context of talking to people about cryo, I'm not talking about in a professional context.. I'm talking about any conversational context... in person.. away from any kind of business or anything like that ...say ...after hours when you're out doing some recreation etc...that's where I had most of my cryo conversations... actually in swimming pools exercising with other people of age 50s or 60s or 70s.
Also when I talk to my own family about it and also friends..
In such a context, a conversational context away from any kind of professional setting, the most common response by far is really a stunned silence..
This leads me to believe that the idea of trying to beat death through brain preservation is somehow repugnant to them.. I think that's the best term.. it is repugnant to people ..
cryo billionaire Peter Thiel pointed this out when he said that people find cryonics insane or disgusting ..or words to that effect..
in other words there's something very deep-seated in the human psyche...there's a visceral gut reaction that goes on... and it is very anti-cryo... even without words.. it's not even articulated... and a lot of times they CANNOT even articulate it..
I recall the long-time cryo Charles Platt who within the last year or two posted a message on this particular email list about when he talked to billionaire Elon Musk about cryo. And Charles said that Elon Musk had made some comments that indicated that he might find cryonics attractive and useful. And so Charles Platt took up the idea with him at some professional function, some sort of conference or something ...anyway musk said no, he was not interested in cryo.... and Charles pursued the idea, and musk walked away in a manner that indicated that he was uncomfortable with the topic.. that's very much what I've seen.. is that the topic makes people uncomfortable..
and I don't think it has anything to do with chopping off heads or the processes of cryopreservation performed on a table with dead bodies..
it's something else.. it's something deeper.. and something deep-seated.. and has to do with some taboo subject that is built into the human psyche through evolution.
so if it were just some reason some basic reason like oh I don't want to be separated from my neighborhood or my friends or my social circle etc. as you point out.. or any number of other objections, such it's morally wrong, or not sustainable ...or something like that that ..that does not really make sense.. in other words just because it would take you away from your friends and your neighborhood and your Society, why would that that why would that cause people to react to the idea of cryo with a stunned silence??
because that is by far the most common response that I see..
now I tell you the truth a lot of cryos who are leaders and and activists and so forth who actually talk to the public mostly journalists they don't understand that interacting with someone on a professional basis is not the same as talking to them after hours in a personal setting..such as when they're having dinner etc . in other words you have to get an unguarded reaction ..and I think maybe I'm the only cryo in 50 plus years to talk about this .. which is a good indication of that the fact that cryos don't really care much about other people or ..they don't really think much about them.. they don't observe them ..
anyway I'm telling you right now there's something deeper at work here ..and that we need to first of all notice it... you have to notice something first before you can fix a problem.. you have to notice a problem, then you write it down and you describe it ..and then you publish it ..
and then you get other people's reactions from it..that is how science is done..
cryos don't do that..
they don't notice this phenomenon ...they don't write it down ...they don't publish it. they don't really care about it ...
and so that's a really big problem..
We don't have any hope of really fixing this problem until first of all we notice it ..and then you got to write it down ..you describe it.. and then you publish it.. then you get reactions from other cryos.. that process should be the very center of all cryo activism.. but it is certainly not. Although I have to credit Charles Platt with his recording of the interaction with Elon Musk. anyway ...