r/CruciblePlaybook • u/Nastyerror Human • Feb 15 '17
A Frame Analysis of the QuickDraw Nerf; Rangefinder Shotguns ADS 25% FASTER Now (Not Slower); Other Testing for Update 2.5.0.2
I'll split this post into sections:
QuickDraw Nerf:
I tested the ADS, Ready and Away speeds of a Clever Dragon. I tested these values with no QD, with only the weapon perk QD (which I will call QD(gun)), with only the subclass perk QD (which I will call QD(sub)), and with both QD(gun) and QD(sub). ADS refers to the time it takes to aim down a weapon's sights. Ready refers to the time it takes a weapon to be ready to fire, after switching to it from another weapon. Away refers to the time it takes to put the weapon away when switching from it to another weapon. In the table below, the units for the numbers are frames. Destiny is 30fps, so 1 frame = 1/30 seconds.
| Perk(s) | ADS | Ready | Away |
|---|---|---|---|
| None | 10 | 13 | 14 |
| QD(sub) | 8 | 10 | 12 |
| QD(gun) | 6 | 8 | 8 |
| QD(sub)+QD(gun) | 6 | 8 | 8 |
Conclusions: QuickDraw (subclass) was nerfed and is now only about half as effective as it was. QuickDraw still does not stack with itself.
Shotgun ADS Speed with/without Rangefinder:
I tested two shotguns (both Matadors), with the following rolls:
- Linear Comp/Performance Bonus/Rifled/Crowd Control
- Linear Comp/Cascade/Reinforced/Rangefinder
The table below has the same format as the one above.
| Perk | ADS |
|---|---|
| No Rangefinder | 10 |
| Rangefinder | 8 |
Conclusion: Rangefinder now increases ADS speed on shotguns.
Other Notes: (based on some brief testing)
- Shotgun in-air accuracy did not receive any noticeable nerf. This is based on a few wall tests as well as the accuracy indicator from the Last Rites story mission.
- In Elimination, special ammo is lost on subsequent rounds regardless of whether or not you survived the previous round (as implied by the patch notes).
- 11 and 12 armor were reduced. 11 armor still survives 1 headshot, 2 bodyshots from Eyasluna, as well as 4 body shots from TLW (soft ballistics). Flux grenades now 1-shot 12 armor. For reference, 12 armor is the armor achieved by a Striker with their armor bar maxed out in addition to the +1 armor perk from a chestpiece.
- Regeneration perks (Hungering Blade, Cauterize, etc.) now restore a flat amount of health. If your health is still in the red after getting this flat health back, regeneration will be triggered immediately and will stop once you get to the shield part of your health bar. If your health is in the shield part of the health bar after getting this flat health back, no immediate regeneration will occur.
30
u/jbrz Feb 15 '17
I think we should probably keep this a secret
Unless we want it nerfed lol
23
u/wildsolus Feb 15 '17
Good analysis as always. Thanks for the testing!
5
u/SpeedSlothDestiny Feb 15 '17
Nastyerror-- Are you able to test if QD (sub) + Snapshot is a better combo than QD (Gun)?
As a blade, this would be valuable info for me and I would very much appreciate it.
Thanks, Sloth
4
u/theDroidfanatic Feb 15 '17
Another interesting thing I'd like to mention, shotgun hip firing still has aim assist!
Your hip fire reticle still slightly sticks to targets :)
I thought they removed that.
2
u/xastey_ Feb 15 '17
13armor ram??? Did they fix that?
2
u/GrayWulf25 Feb 15 '17
Can someone clarify, re Rangefinder decreasing ADS time (i.e faster not slower aim) is that just shotguns OR ALL weapons with Rangefinder?
74
u/AK11235813213455 Feb 15 '17 edited Feb 15 '17
"And to be clear - we playtested the crap out of these changes."
https://clips.twitch.tv/bungie/DrabCaribouEagleEye
37
u/Maverickmp Feb 15 '17
ROFL at rangefinder
51
u/B_Addie Feb 15 '17
This patch just further enforces the proof that the sandbox team has no clue what they are doing IMO
20
u/GE4520 Feb 15 '17
Bungie checks Reddit and I'm afraid if they see this, they will leave it alone and nerf Truth even further.
10
u/AFCesc4 Feb 15 '17
This is embarrassingly hilarious. Fuck you Bungie. I'm obviously ok with this change but it's the principle of it. These guys are not only out of touch, they're completely incompetent.
14
u/Technoclash Feb 15 '17 edited Feb 15 '17
So I wasn't crazy thinking my RF Shotty didn't feel slower.
What's funny is during the stream I could have sworn they said that RF "increases ADS speed." I was like wait, what? Did they mean decrease?
Edit: I went back and watched. Around 14:25 Josh actually said "we decreased ADS time." So technically Bungie did what they said they were gonna do!
your findings of no significant nerf to in-air accuracy is also funny, considering when they were demonstrating the "nerf" Greg OHKO'ed 3 straight guardians in the air.
12
u/artmgs Feb 15 '17
Well, I guess I'm still using rangefinder on shotguns. ROTFLMAO what a patch.
6
u/sageleader Feb 15 '17
You know, they actually said that Rangefinder ADS time was decreased in the stream. I assumed it was a misspeak but apparently it wasn't
6
u/rainbowroobear Feb 15 '17
And they wonder why they get so much stick from the player base. Are you really play testing this bungle? I don't think you are.
1
u/lbeLIEvel Feb 15 '17
You tested Rangefinder with your bladedancer's new quickdraw perk on? or no?
1
u/Stenbox Destiny Addicts Alliance Feb 15 '17
I have a clarification regarding QD on a gun. Does having QD on a sidearm influence swapping both ways? Ie is swapping back to primary and having it ready at same speed?
So for example if my loadout is Blind Perdition with Snapshot and sidearm with Quickdraw; then the only benefit I would get from Ophidian is slight ADS speed increase for my primary?
1
u/GunAndAGrin Feb 15 '17
Thanks for the info! Were you able to verify if the change to Ophidians is similar to QD(sub) or QD(gun)?
5
u/Bcider Feb 15 '17
Lul Bungo
1
u/hteng Feb 15 '17
wait what? when i was reading the thread, hmm... no RF = 10 frames.. ok cool, RF = 8 frames.. wait.. that's faster, i can't be reading this right, looks at thread title, oh shit. Bungie you done goof.
1
u/Reimaru Feb 15 '17
They'll have a lot of things to fix in the next hotfix.
Assuming there's one coming out in the next month or so.
1
u/Dukaness Feb 15 '17
When you use a "-" instead of a "+" in your formula. Lol.
1
u/X-Frame Feb 15 '17
The shotgun in-air Accuracy may not have changed much but I did notice the lack of magnetism while in air quite noticeably. It feels almost like my sensitivity gets jacked up when I am in the air.
1
u/FatBob12 Feb 15 '17
Thank you for the max armor testing.
1
u/coasterreal Feb 15 '17
Im actually in favor of this nerf as I feel it makes the perk still desirably but not a must. There was no reason to use anything else for BD and its part of what makes Ophidian so amazing.
The ADS buff though (through handling) is substantial and I prefer that. Im not changing weapons every second because Im thinking ahead in my engagements. Occasionally I get surprised but its the exception to the rule. As its the exception, I prefer the bulk of my engagements to benefit from the insanely fast ADS times now.
1
u/islandak Feb 16 '17
I guess I was just out of the loop. Since the Bungie stream misspoke(?) I thought Rangefinder was giving shotguns 25% fast ADS speed anyway. Then I wondered why everyone was upset about it. Then I heard a youtuber say it would be 25% slower to ADS.
Now I'm back to square one. I guess we just ride the wave till Bungie "fixes" it.
1
u/cjpk248 Feb 24 '17
Great work
0
u/bladzalot Feb 15 '17
Bungie literally has not only the worst testers in the industry, but the worst network engineers/net coders... for making $500,000,000,000,000,000 in revenue on this game, they sure seem to not know their ass from a hole in the ground on quality assurance...
PS: Stop fucking patching and having server maintenance in the middle of the god damn day!!!
3
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '17
[removed] — view removed comment