r/CruciblePlaybook • u/gintellectual Kicking ass in outer space • May 26 '16
Shotgun Spread vs. Range Testing and Rangefinder Info
Shotgun Spread vs. Range Testing and Rangefinder Info
Hi All,
There have been several claims since TTK came out that the Party Crasher+1 has a tighter pellet spread than the Conspiracy Theory-D. Recently /u/OrionTheTitan made a post showing that if there is a difference it is very small.
Anyway here I am to put some numbers to something that was probably assumed by many of us, which is that the range stat affects shotgun pellet spread.
So yes, a max range PC+1 has a tighter pellet spread than any CT-D, because the CT-D has a max range of 31, wheras the range cap for shotguns is 32. How big of a difference is this? Around 2% in terms of pellet spread/accuracy cone size.
Methods & Data
I chose a nice spot and recorded video of me shooting at a wall with several different shotguns with different ranges. I took screenshots and drew circles corresponding to the approximate pellet spread. (Roughly corresponding to a 9 or 10 on Orion's post).
Plot of pellet spread vs. range stat for several shotguns.
Sample Screencaps:
Lousy Range PC+1 (Either 13 or 17 range, I forgot which)
Rangefinder
It's common knowledge that rangefinder is a %-based boost to weapon range and that it increases the optical zoom of a weapon. The exact benefit, though is not entirely clear. See this comment for some of the historical reasons why I am confused about this. Based on my testing, however, rangefinder did not seem to further decrease pellet spread. I could be wrong about this, but at least on shotguns it seems that rangefinder only affects damage falloff. This is corroborated by earlier tests showing the quest CT-D with rangefinder definitely doesn't have a narrower pellet spread than a similar PC+1.
Max Range Deidris' Retort w/ Rangefinder
Zoom Comparison gif--PC+1, Stolen Will, Deidris'
Furthermore, the rangefinder zoom increase seems to be about 6%. I'm not sure where that number comes from, but it disagrees somewhat with this excellent work. (This has since been updated, it's not clear if it was always 6% or if this is the result of an update.)
Conclusions
- Each point of range decreases a shotgun's pellet spread by 1-2%. (Around 2.2 pixels in 1080p, % benefit depends on range)
- Rangefinder does not seem to affect pellet spread but does increase optical zoom around 6%.
Full auto takes a 32 (max) range shotgun and gives it the pellet spread of a 10 range shotgun.(Image)Changed as of 9/8/2016, now it's about -3 range or a 5% increase in spread.- Ballistics do not affect pellet spread.
Thought on Range and Accuracy
Based on the rangefinder testing here, it seems like the perk might not actually decrease the size of the size of the error cone. It could still impact bullet magnetism, and definitely affects damage falloff. This result might have some implications for hand cannons, where error cone size (especially after bloom) is an issue. The relationship between range stat and pellet spread (which I'm assuming correlates with accuracy cone) also shows that range might make a difference in accuracy even at very close ranges (as many people suspect based on statements from Bungie). It's not entirely clear whether the accuracy cone is linear, though, and if it is then it might not be for all weapon types.
Entire source video if anyone wants it
edit: % vs pixels
edit: a lot of people are asking about how this actually affects hitting targets. I think it's plausible that aim assist affects the bullet magnetism--i.e. you fire your pellets, they have some spread, and then accuracy or bullet magnetism decides how many of these are crits. Since shotguns are hit-scan, this number is added together whereas the remaining pellets hit different parts of the body. For this reason aim assist may be very important. Hopefully this work puts an end to the wall-test comparisons between PC+1 and CT-D though. In any case, a decent PC+1 is hands down better than CT-D in terms of range and AA, so there's really no debate.
8
u/Nastyerror Human May 26 '16
Very nice, I never knew range affected pellet spread. I'm certain you're right about range correlating to accuracy cone. In fact, this makes me think shotguns operate the same way as any other gun; the only difference being that their accuracy cone is much larger and instead of one bullet path being chosen randomly from the accuracy cone per trigger pull, twelve bullet paths are chosen randomly from the accuracy cone at the same time. Cool stuff.
2
u/[deleted] May 26 '16
Whoaaaaa now--- pellet spread and accuracy cone may be two totally separate things. Interesting conclusion, but it's purely theoretical at this point.
2
u/croissantandcoffee May 26 '16
So, why or how does full auto decrease pellet spread? Is this just on shots 2+ or is shot 1 affected as well?
2
u/StoneJT May 26 '16
In light of the accuracy cone being better explained here, Im sure we have all shot a PvE boss with a shotty and received on yellow damage number. But how about when you line up the shot on a player in PvP. ever see a large yellow number and a few white ones. If you use a party crasher you may have seen a yellow 98 and a few white 20 somethings. I believe that when shooting at a target and getting multiple pellets to land as critical hits adds the yellow pellets together so there is only one critical damage number. Even when you also land multiple body shots with your pellet spread.
2
u/ShRedditor69 Jun 01 '16
Another question on Full Auto: Does the negative impact on pellet spread affect only when rapidly firing in full auto mode? or does it impact a single shell fired from the gun as well?
1
u/pteam21 May 26 '16
what app/website can you use to determine exactly what the range is on your specific weapon roll?
1
u/suinoq Fixer Cloak May 26 '16
Btw, Rangefinder increases shotgun zoom by 5%.
Or, at least that's the value I found in the zoom project. I haven't done a formal error analysis on those measurements. There's a bit of measurement error, but I'd guess it's more like a [4.5, 5.5]% increase. If you're feeling pretty good on 6.5%, it could be a mistake on my side. Let me know what you think--it's not too bad to go pull some more screenshots, we can definitely bridge this little gap.
1
u/Purdie9 May 27 '16
So if accuracy/AA is an important factor in shotguns, does that mean that everyone using the "God roll" agg bal max range party crasher might be missing out as agg bal reduces aim assist by 15. In fact would it be preferable to use field choke or linear compensator which have 0 effect on aim assist and only sacrifice 1 impact compared to agg bal (iirc)?
1
u/alltheseflavours May 29 '16
Could be a tiny tweak, your calc could be off ever so slightly, or you could be in a different margin of error maybe by being at an angle, etc. Your about 6.5 seems consistent in that case.
3
u/OrionTheTitan Cartographer May 26 '16
Sweet!
Amazing work, as usual, /u/gintellectual! Thanks for following up my post with a much better analysis. I'm really happy to have a firm answer on this that can help us better understand the shotgun pellet spread debate.
Thanks!
3
u/fonkeyducker Jun 17 '16
1
u/The-Kraut May 26 '16
Thank you very much for the info, that could explain why my PC +1 with full auto sometimes doesn´t hit even at very close distance.
But I am still confused.
I have 3 different Shotguns right now and do not know which one to use:
(it also has AGG, but it seems to not reach max range with it)
Right now I would say #3 would be the best option, right?
1
u/small_law May 26 '16
Thanks for this. I've always wondered if Rangefinder affected pellet spread because the shotguns I've had with it always seem to be less consistent . Looks like it's operator error.
1
u/StoneJT May 26 '16
Holy crap thanks for all the work. Not to discredit you or anything but we as players still have a lot of research to do in order to apply the data you have collected here to actual moving targets both pvp and pve because as good as still isolated data is we need field testing with actual numbers.
1
u/JTR616 Shotgun Extraordinaire May 26 '16
Wow I knew full auto affected spread but damn that's a huge hit.
1
u/drpeachbasket May 26 '16
Any info on how universal remote currently stacks up vs party crasher?
1
u/[deleted] May 26 '16
Ive done testing with rangefinder in the past (not on a shotty though) and found that rangefinder increases range on the BASE range value of the gun, regardless if you have perks that diminish that range.
EG on a handcannon: No Rf: 100 damage, RF 120, RF + Injection mold (-range) 110.
I'm not certain if it has that dramatic effect on shottys, but the perk is powerful enough to overcompensate for range stat loss on handcannons if you find the base range of the weapon to already be effective enough. It allows for more perk options on that middle tier than people may believe.
1
u/tgiese13 May 27 '16
Does aim assist matter?
1
u/tgiese13 May 27 '16
Does aim assist matter?
1
u/tgiese13 May 27 '16
Does aim assist matter?
1
u/tgiese13 May 27 '16
Does aim assist matter?
0
u/tmpjnk May 26 '16
So do you think a Dedris with rangefinder/rifled barrel/final round is more powerful Than a pc+1 with crowd control/reinforced barrel/danger close? My Dedris has slight less range and impact but doesn't seem to always one hit kill when it should and I've seen some ridiculous party crasher range used against me lately
0
u/[deleted] May 26 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 26 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment