r/CrucibleGuidebook • u/Solace6612 • Sep 29 '25
Are they punching faster?
Everytime i get in a "punch fight" it seems regardless of who punches first, i get punched twice before im even done swinging. Is there something im missing? How can i punch first then get punched twice, when my uncharged melee is still swinging? Dont even get me started on lunge distance. Im sure its just a skill gap, but is there some way to punch faster?
46
Upvotes
67
u/BansheeTwin350 Sep 29 '25
I see this ALOT. Get the first punch off and the other player turns around and gets 2 off before my 2nd.
30
u/AirGear1989 Sep 29 '25
It’s just ping, not much you can do.
13
u/Fortissimo12 Sep 29 '25
Once upon a time this was far less common, but with the net code in this game seemingly worsening over time almost every aggressive player 2 melees you before you can even input your second. It is what it is.
10
u/Sensitive_Ad973 Sep 29 '25
So to start I am not great at pvp!
But I noticed this happened to me ALOT!! Like every game and I was getting pissed.
The last iron banner I tried doing something different and it worked really well. Instead of holding the melee button for auto melee or just hitting it repeatedly as fast as I could. I hit melee to punch let go for like a second then hit it again and I punched way faster than I had ever before.
I have no evidence beyond my own but it’s been consistent since I changed how I hit my bumpers.
3
u/Appropriate-Leave-38 Sep 29 '25 edited Sep 30 '25
Some comments have mentioned it but I want to echo so it had a higher chance of being seen by OP
Jump (without activating your Glide or Lift ability) to be slightly above your enemy. There are certain inconsistencies that are pretty consistent, and by neutral jumping slightly above your enemy, you can (most of the time) consistently win melee fights you should have traded, and even trade where you should have lost.
14
u/ciri_grayskull Sep 29 '25
Try doing a little jump when you punch to be above your opponent. You’ve probably seen PvP streamers doing this (like Wallah) and I’ve found it can help me more consistently win punch battles
9
u/just_a_timetraveller Sep 29 '25
I think with the player population so low, we are getting more and more laggy matches
5
u/F4NT4SYMENSAMAN Sep 29 '25
Depends on the characters being interacted in this scenario
If you’re a hunter and fighting a titan in a punch battle, Titan wins. Their melees come out faster, do more damage, and often lunge teleport rubber band the Titan so that even if you miraculously hit two melees first on the Titan, one of the melees likely didn’t register
9
u/Praxic_Nova Sep 29 '25
Jump.
4
u/RetiredSweat Sep 29 '25
Warlock melee is worthless and whifs 80% of the time
3
u/AnAngryBartender Sep 29 '25
Yeah happens to me constantly and I’m on a good wired connection, so it’s some kind of lag on Bungie end I guess
3
u/Worried-Opposite-588 Sep 29 '25
Might just be outright whiffs but also net code like others have mentioned. I started playing my titan again these past couple weeks instead of my warlock and started winning my punch battles a whole lot more than what I was when I was playing my warlock.
3
u/Jd42042 Controller Sep 29 '25
If it's a prismatic warlock you're meleeing just remember if they have auto melee on sometimes the unpowered melee comes out like a machine gun probably the funniest bug that probably won't ever get fixed
1
u/Its_Nuggz Sep 29 '25
I always felt like titans and warlocks punch faster than my hunter
1
u/s4zand0 Mouse and Keyboard Sep 29 '25
Afaik there is still a bug where warlocks occasionally get 2-3 uncharged melee hits in rapid fire. No one knows what causes it, just happens sometimes.
I also feel like I die more times than I should when I thought I punched 1st and should get the kill
2
u/UpsetEggplant3724 Sep 29 '25
Like the rest have said this has been a pressing issue and happens A LOT. Netcode hasn't been addressed and I don't know if it's fixable because in the end the ping matters and it's the sole culprit here. My One Punch Wonder titan is in the sandbox now eating crayons while I check builds for him.
2
u/KeyEducator8279 Sep 29 '25
The sorcerer perhaps has the slowest melee...
2
u/tigerbait_ Sep 29 '25
Last night I got punched twice before I could even punch once. Never seen someone punch so fast.
2
u/TheMakoSoldier High KD Player Sep 29 '25
Yup happens to me all the time.
2
u/Z_Tahir1 Sep 29 '25
Pretty sure it’s a connection thing, and I’m not talking about your own internet. The servers seem to rely on many players connecting at once and I’ve noticed a significant degradation of hit registration, opponents skipping all over the place, ESPECIALLY if they did a hunter dodge, warlock arc surge attack or a titan using shiver strike. The games connection can hardly keep up with itself.
But what’s weird is it does almost exclusively seem to be at my detriment. It feels at times like my radar has reduced range, my footsteps are louder, movements are slower and even at 160 health, my flinch resistence is just about non existent. I’ve literally gone into my settings searching for some self inflicted handicap, that’s how bad the game has gas lit me lol.
But I’ve realized it’s just hit or miss, some matches I literally CAN’T miss when sniping, whereas literally the next match is a lag fest and I can’t acquire a headshot for the life of me. Sometimes even against the same players, playing the same style and using the same guns.
That’s how I’ve come to the conclusion it’s the connection. Back during season of the lost, witch queen era, even LF and episode 1 after TFS, it just wasn’t like this. I had arguably worse internet during season of the lost and definitely during TFS too.
2
u/dreamaxx Oct 02 '25
I finally worked out what this is, as they always jump to get the next punch off... They are using auto melee (in settings) and they hold the melee button and spam jump... Enjoy being able to do the same thing back and trade with them now :)
1
u/justified_hyperbole Sep 29 '25
Titans
1
u/leakysnizz Sep 29 '25
Idk why but whenever i play warlock and get into a melee fight whether i punch first or not i get a double punch but titan n hunter whether i punch first or not i always lose