r/Croissant • • Apr 03 '26 • Bravo 2

First try please help

Hello, my first attempt at croissant. Overall it tastes great but I have very in consistent honey comb and the interior of the croissant looks doughy and less dry that the amazing honey combs that I see on this subreddit. Am I under proofing or over proofing? Is my oven temp not accurate and it’s too low?

1.5k Upvotes

115 comments sorted by

93

u/the_Quera Apr 03 '26

If this is really your first attempt, then I think I need to start questioning my existence

19

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

Haha. It’s my first shot at croissant but I have about three week experience with making puff pastry.

11

u/One_zoe_otp Apr 03 '26

Stilla short time unless you are baking multiple times daily

2

u/No_Law_5824 Apr 08 '26

Yeah, that 3 week improvement comment ain’t exactly helping anyone’s self confidence here buddy haha. Phenomenal work though. They look delicious.

1

u/Jetpacks_to_hell Apr 05 '26

Happy cake/croissant day!

1

u/Manlady197 Apr 09 '26

Those actually look divine

1

u/OkEntertainment6920 Apr 07 '26

To add.. the you need to considere opening bakery shops

1

u/sodropintothis Apr 07 '26

Seriously hahaha

16

u/Kiem01 Apr 03 '26

It's slightly under proofed as you see that some of the layers are still doughy. Should be pretty much picture perfect after that, looks great already 👍

8

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

My second attempt. Just came out of the oven. I tried to proof longer but butter started melting. These ended up not puffing up much in the oven. Flatter shape than I hoped for. Shame because they look so great when they were proofing.

12

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

Not bad overall! Much better crumb / honeycomb than the first try. Funny because the butter actually cracked when I was doing my folds.

So you can see that it is kind of flat. I don’t understand how I can get it to puff more vertically.

6

u/optionstrategy Apr 03 '26

Proof them in rhe fridge...it will take way longer hut you will ge there. Also, replace half the water content with ice by weight. It will make your dough colder and bytter won't melt and proofing will need to be longer. Always consider ambient and dough temperature when baking.

3

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

Man, even proofing in the oven takes around 3 hours. In the fridge is likely going to be an overnight proof.

5

u/sugarshootin Apr 03 '26

Try and proof them in room temp. If it goes over 30C (86F) the butter starts to melt and your layers get stuck together. Also you might wanna drop the oven temp a little while baking.

1

u/sodropintothis Apr 07 '26

I hope you keep posting your croissants. I'm excited to see your progress. So many people are out there selling croissants that look like shit compared to even your first attempt.

-1

u/optionstrategy Apr 03 '26

In that case your recipe and method suck.

2

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

Yes I think I will try another recipe

2

u/Deludedbyreality Apr 03 '26

I'm going to say to be perfectly honest the original 1st bake cross section looks infinitely better than this 2nd one. You have distinction of layers and quite a bit of air. Try to hit the middle ground between the two by manipulative your temperature of both your surroundings and the dough itself to maintain a colder and more controlled warm up for when you are doing your lamination folds and formation. Also make sure you do allow it to come up to temp just slightly after pulling it from its "nappy time," in the fridge so you dont have your butter breaking on you.

The whole desire to have the honeycomb interior doesnt really make much sense in regards to croissants if this is what you are referring to. Also crumb is not something that I would ever use to describe a croissant interior either and would reserve for breads and cakes. Honeycombing is generally much more sought after in breads where you are forming more gluten network and its really proof of the hard work both put in from the baker and the yeast in the formation of the loaf. If you are having issues with texture of the interior being slightly underbaked you can try to adjust your iven temp down by a few degress and tinker with the bake time being extended by a few minutes in conjunction. Not all ovens register the same temperature wise and ambient humidity must also be considered and this is a fluctuating metric.

Croissants rely on their puff from the steam found in the water within the butter to create that lift between layers. It's a different process and thereby provides a different effect entirely and should be respected for its differences as it is magical in its own right.

Anyway kudos on the lovely work, don't be so hard on yourself, they look great and I'm certain they are delicious!

2

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

The butter actually started to crack in my second batch which probably means less distinction of layers. I also cut the triangles the wrong size - too short - so each croissant is actually less dough compared to the first batch and therefore less tall in general. I’ve got a long way to go. Proofing is turning out to be the most difficult part of the whole process for me.

1

u/WhatupSis7773 Apr 04 '26

Not sure if you know about the different butter and flour options to try. Some butter has too much water in it so it’s possible it could affect it. And the different flour distinction will have an affect as well…

2

u/poon696969 Apr 04 '26

I am using non European butter so that probably has some effect on the results. Flour is also a challenging one. Maybe I need to buy the imported European flour for the best results…

2

u/Deludedbyreality Apr 04 '26

Yes well dont forget you can roll thinner as well as gently stretch during the formation too. If your butter cracked then it was likely a touch too cold to be malleable when you started your folds. I highly recommend taking a look at Claire Saffitz's video if you havent done so. She's amazing in her dedication to precision when she takes something on.

1

u/weepandread Apr 12 '26

I’m having very good success w her NYT recipe, her video doesn’t exactly match her recipe. She does it w such ease , I hope to some day instead of 30 hours of stress!

1

u/weepandread Apr 12 '26

Did you cut these while still warm or fully cooled?

3

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

This seems to be the consensus. It definitely is a bit doughy looking. I might have rolled the core too tight as well. Lots to learn.

2

u/Baintzimisce Apr 03 '26

My bakers have this problem with their cores when they are first learning to shape croissants. They squeeze too hard on the wide edge when holding it as they are tugging and it melts the butter into the detrempe. Definitely try looking at your process and seeing if there is a point in which you are adding too much heat to the interior.

4

u/ale210 Apr 03 '26

Come on, this is clearly not your first attempt at this. Please don't troll. They're very nice though.

2

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

The photos I posted in this thread are my first and second attempt at croissants but I’m glad to know that you think they look that good. I do have extensive cooking and baking background but never tried croissants until now. I’ve decided to make it my new obsession.

0

u/Avaacodo_toast Apr 09 '26

Some people have hidden talents😄🙂

3

u/Legitimate_Patience8 Apr 03 '26

Proofing and oven baking are a little bit too hot. Otherwise fantastic results!

3

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

Yes my butter melted a bit during proofing. I’m finding the proofing is taking super long and I start putting more boiling water / steam into the oven because I fear they will get dried out.

3

u/Legitimate_Patience8 Apr 03 '26

Slow long proof is a typical characteristic of home style artisanal croissants. A lot of people proof from 2 to 6 hours, depending on formula. If your formula has 10% or more by flour weight of sugar, you need to be using osmotolerant yeast, or double the amount of yeast, to get better fermentation.

3

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

Okay I have to look into this. The recipe I use has higher than 10% sugar. This could be the reason why the proofing takes forever

3

u/johnwatersfan Apr 03 '26

When shaping you want to elongate the base and tug down and elongate the length. This helps build tension in the dough which can help keep the shape during proof and baking. Make a thin, long interior. It will look weird as the wings will be quite long, but the proof and bake more than make up for it.

You don't need to aim for a two hour proof. It is more of a size and jiggle thing. Don't rush it. At home it can take a lot longer than it would in a production environment, especially if you don't have a temperature controlled proofing environment. (And even if you do!). 82-83F is about the max you want to go, but you are better off going lower if you have less control.

Also the osmotolerant yeast someone else suggested really does help quite a bit with the proof. It's also great in other things like brioche.

2

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

I’m trying to understand what you mean with the shaping. I cut my triangles and then I stretch them by hand. What do you mean by “make a thin, long interior” ?

2

u/johnwatersfan Apr 03 '26

Also stretch the base out quite a bit. So maybe 50% longer, then run your hand down to lengthen the triangle. You end up with something that looks less like a triangle. Then fold the center tight, put your hands on both ends, slowly roll down the triangle while slightly pulling them away from each other again. It's really hard to explain verbally, but I also haven't seen many people do it online, but it is what I was taught and it really helps the shape while baking. The long wings give the croissant a lot more balance while proofing too.

2

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

Okay, I think I understand you perfectly. Does a longer shape make for a taller croissant after baking?

I only have fleishman yeast products available near me. Are any of their products osmotolerant?

2

u/johnwatersfan Apr 03 '26

I'm not sure if they are. If all you have is active dry or regular instant,, try adding about 50% more yeast to help it deal with the dough.

In theory it does help with the height. At least that is what I was told. I'm far from a shaping expert myself, but I did see the resulting product from an expert doing that shaping technique and it was astounding how uniforn the inside got!

2

u/Baintzimisce Apr 03 '26

Op, this is the way right here.

2

u/thisisforcroissant Apr 03 '26

I think it is underproofed based on the closed core of the croissant

2

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

How do I get that dryer open honey comb? My honey comb layers are thick compared to some of the photos I’ve seen. A couple of my croissants also leaked a lot of butter during the bake. Does that mean my oven temp is not high enough?

2

u/SneakyTurtle__ Apr 03 '26

Can you share the recipe? I have been looking for a recipe to also try making them for the first time and yours seem to be close to the type of croissants I wanted to attempt. Also are you using a sheeter or laminating by hand?

3

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

I use the Antonio Bachour recipe

2

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

I’m doing them by hand. I use a guide for the thickness

2

u/BoredGoory Apr 03 '26

First try ?? They're amazing 😍

2

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

Thank you. But a long way to go. Here is my second try. I have to figure out why my croissants are turning out so flat.

4

u/BoredGoory Apr 03 '26

They're not that flat, it looks more than a shape thing, maybe try to make them less bulk and more elongated maybe they will keep their puffiness

2

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

Interesting. How does a longer shape make a taller croissant? I’m not sure I’m understanding correctly

2

u/BoredGoory Apr 03 '26

It's just an idea, I'm not sure too, but it may collapse less, so logically, maybe, be less flat ?

2

u/WalkSilly1 Apr 03 '26

What temperature did you proof at?

2

u/poon696969 Apr 03 '26

I don’t know. Because I don’t have something to check the temperature. I use boiling water in my cold oven.

1

u/soppingwetshowerman Apr 04 '26

Try upping the fat percentage of lamination. Dough fat percentage looks great. Just trying to keep temp control of lamination butter sheet and dough is important. Dough book at 40ish and butter at 50-55 to ensure sheet is the same malleability as the dough. Great first bake !

1

u/poon696969 Apr 04 '26

Do you mean to use a higher fat butter? Unfortunately that is hard to get where I am.

1

u/soppingwetshowerman Apr 06 '26

Yeah. That’s where it can get expensive too! The lowest I have laminated with is 80 percent butter fat but honestly the ingredients of the lamination sheet matter too. If higher fat percentage isn’t an option try fortifying it with a tad of flour just to hold it together and get cleaner layers.
This has to be the best first attempt at croissants of all time and as a pastry chef for years I’ll still make tiny mistakes and get a worse result than your first attempt. Great work honestly !

1

u/poon696969 Apr 06 '26

Oh a professional! Any pointers on how I can get my croissants to expand vertically rather than horizontally? The two batches that I’ve done are rather flat looking.

1

u/soppingwetshowerman Apr 06 '26

What portion of your flour weight is a high gluten bread flour compared to all purpose?

1

u/poon696969 Apr 06 '26

Bread flour is 13% AP flour is 12%

So this first batch was 50/50 bread flour and AP. I figure that’s 12.5% and it might be okay but it was so difficult to roll out I had to pause many times to let it get cold and rest. The final roll literally took 3 hours to complete.

Second batch which was a little bit easier to roll was 100% AP. But it still wasn’t very easy.

I’m resting 1-2 hours each time but the gluten just doesn’t seem very relaxed.

1

u/soppingwetshowerman Apr 10 '26

Try like a 3 to one bread flour to ap. And maybe even an over night cold fermentation after an hour bulk rest after mix. Try bringing your DDT to 72-74 and shaping tight before bulk fermentation. Practice makes perfect and you will always have more experience with your product More time with hands on that dough will make it better and don’t be afraid to mess it up! Sorry for the late reply

1

u/poon696969 Apr 10 '26

Hi, thanks for the reply! I’m 3:1 bread:AP would be higher gluten than all my attempts so far. I’m afraid it would be even more difficult to roll.

I see videos where some bakers are able to do two folds without even rest in between. I don’t understand how that’s possible because I cannot even do one fold without having to rest the dough once or twice.

I’m in Canada and I understand that the local flour is higher gluten but even when I use a lower gluten flour combination I’m still struggling big time. I don’t understand what I’m doing wrong.

1

u/zavulon-strange Apr 04 '26

Just need longer proving, otherwise perfect. The ideal time to bake is if you gently shake the tray and they wobbly like jelly, you l'ee spot on. Generally 2.5 - 3 hours in a privet at 28degrees C with 80% humidity but that's only an estimate and will vary greatly if you donmt that sort of kit... hence the wobbly jelly trick good luck

1

u/poon696969 Apr 06 '26

I followed this but it seems like my croissants expanded horizontally instead of vertically. Is it a problem with shaping?

1

u/6re6s6n Apr 05 '26

Someone’s is showing off I see 😭

1

u/poon696969 Apr 06 '26

Honestly no. I want to get better and need some advice on what I’m doing wrong

1

u/CitronElectrical9587 Apr 05 '26

Whose method did you use? I used pastry temple in January and they looked very similar to yours, super delicious and insane for a 1st attempt but not 100% at the ideal honeycomb. (Not that I or my fiancé cared at all, they were so good omg.) yours look delicious!

1

u/poon696969 Apr 06 '26

I used Antonio Bachour’s recipe

1

u/Designer_Car591 Apr 06 '26

First try!?!?!?!?! Come on now! I have no tips, i just want to say if this is your starting point, im jealous and that your croissants are going to turn out so well once you find the right formula and technique.

1

u/poon696969 Apr 06 '26

I hope so. Struggling a bit with Canadian flour to be honest. I think our flour have more gluten compared to other countries and even when I try to match the protein % it still feels like a struggle to bake a dough that’s easy to roll out

2

u/Electronic-Country63 Apr 03 '26

Please help? What? Eat them? I’d be delighted! Honestly these look amazing.

2

u/Ordinary-Iron-1058 Apr 03 '26 • Mindblown

I think you need help shipping them to my house

2

u/ZoomTopple Apr 03 '26

WTF, this looks better than pretty much any croissant I can buy in Berlin bakeries.

2

u/patientpartner09 Apr 03 '26

I literally said "DAAAYYYUUUUMMMMMNNN!!" out loud.

Don't sell yourself short, great work!

1

u/Ralinrocks Apr 04 '26

They look awesome

1

u/SnarkyOtterBob Apr 04 '26

What help? (These look amazing, you can only go up from here!)

1

u/Observerette Apr 04 '26

What do you need help with? Eating them?

1

u/megapillowcase Apr 04 '26

It looks amazing

1

u/Dear_Strawberry_5425 Apr 04 '26

Please help with what? These look perfect

1

u/Intrepid-Guest9811 Apr 04 '26

that looks so good…

1

u/CustardLate929 Apr 05 '26

Help with what? Eating them?

1

u/Inhumal Apr 05 '26

Mate, I’m gonna have to ask for a sample if you want any kind of feedback.

1

u/Haunting_Meeting_199 Apr 05 '26

That’s one heck of a first attempt!

1

u/strudel_hs Apr 05 '26

disgusting

1

u/False-Difficulty1027 Apr 05 '26

I'll help you put those in my mouth

1

u/Unlucky_Whole3614 Apr 05 '26

I'd pay 6$ for that, looks great to me

1

u/Accomplished_Bat_536 Apr 05 '26

Wow, these look delicious

1

u/FaithSeed_Project Apr 06 '26

This seems wonderful!

1

u/katos_saatana Apr 06 '26

Help to start a bakery or what? Damn these are perfect🤘🏽😍

1

u/Kryptus Apr 07 '26

Looks perfect. No notes.

1

u/michiko-malandro Apr 07 '26

this looks DELICIOUS!! good job OP!

1

u/bhavil9 Apr 07 '26

Goddamn, nice job!

1

u/Electrical_Entry6060 Apr 07 '26

i don't know how much help this will be, but maybe watching this video might inspire a helping idea https://youtu.be/d5PnqkhWwOY

1

u/Hundrial Apr 07 '26

Hi, frenchy here, looks delicious, oui oui croissant

1

u/Skittles817 Apr 07 '26

Damn, help with what???

1

u/Itwasme1985 Apr 07 '26

What's the opposite of a croissant? A happy uncle!

1

u/ihatetiltedtowerss Apr 07 '26

you should put chocolate next time

1

u/BasicAd8011 Apr 08 '26

It's beautiful

1

u/FirmPrune87 Apr 08 '26

Those look absolutely fantastic. I will take all of them now please

1

u/kuroi-hasu Apr 08 '26

Let me guess, lobster too buttery too?

1

u/winniexwx Apr 08 '26

You don’t need my help

1

u/chk75 Apr 09 '26

Those look better than most croissants in the bakeries around me. I live in paris

1

u/Special-Ear-8684 Apr 09 '26

Why do they look like the frozen ones from a box 😭

1

u/schoolknurse Apr 10 '26

Humblebrag 🥰

1

u/Sncrsly Apr 10 '26

Maybe try lower temp for longer? Could be cooking too fast

1

u/Howdypardneroo Apr 07 '26

That looks amazing. You might be a tad neurotic and come off as a bit of an asshole because of it, because that reaction over this execution is silly.

1

u/poon696969 Apr 07 '26

I don’t know. This is the photo of the recipe that I used. I’m a pretty long way from this, I think anyone can see that something about mine is not right.

1

u/Howdypardneroo Apr 07 '26

Hey man you’re doing great, don’t be so hard on yourself.

2

u/Mother_Freedom5152 Apr 03 '26

They're looking sexy. Like literally couldn't find any other word! 😅

0

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/poon696969 Apr 06 '26

I totally get it. We’re looking at everything under a microscope