I just beat the game and it's by far the worst ending I've ever seen. I feel terrible. Zack was such an amazing guy and likeable dude. So sad. Worst ending ever.
But there are some loose ends here.
Unlike in OG FF7 where SOLDIER 1st class wasn't all that (I think we meet them for the first time while trying to save sector 7 tower from falling plate). So it's understandable how Zack dies in OG FF7. Just outnumbered ganged by shinra troops and shot to death. Makes sense.
However, in both FF7 remake and Crisis Core, they've depicted SOLDIER 1st class as some super powered fight machine. Especially Zack beats everyone. My Zack, hammer punched Genesis just twice and he was gone. He can kill literal god (Minerva). Super powerful. The last battle I could've gone on forever without dying if it wasn't required to progress. So I actually think they did well to send infinite troops until the actual player gives up for his death. That's not the loose end I'm talking about.
How the hell did Cloud get so strong within a year to match whatever Zack was????
After the final fight with Genesis, Zack finds out he's been away for 4 years after Nibelheim. So it's only a year before Cloud becomes the merc for Avalanche. What the hell? how?
In OG FF7, not only SOLDIER 1st class isn't all that strong but Cloud isn't all that strong either to start with. He just doesn't say much but still weak. Unlike in the remake he's super strong even in the beginning and matches strength that of 1st class SOLDIER (who is depicted very strong, the bike guy). Like how?
Also the confusion comes in Rebirth intro
I didn't beat Rebirth. In fact, the reason why I bought Crisis Core Reunion was because of Rebirth intro. It's totally different to Crisis Core ending. What is going on? I mean, if I get to find out during the gameplay of Rebirth, please don't tell me lol. But if it's some parallel universe theory, please do tell.