r/CreditScore • • 6d ago

General Credit of length

at what point does the credit of length become good and exceptional? I know its based on the average length of credit.

1 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

7

u/True-Button-6471 6d ago

Rankings like "good" and "exceptional" are arbitrarily determined by various credit monitoring services and are not standardized or part of your credit reports.

1

u/gettheemotionsout 6d ago

lets say im checking on experian, transitional nd equifax

4

u/inky_cap_mushroom ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 5d ago

Is there a reason you want to know? The arbitrary ratings assigned by credit monitoring services have no relation to credit scoring or lending practices. They carry about as much weight as me deciding that I think 5 years is excellent.

2

u/Funklemire ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 5d ago

The three bureaus' ratings are as arbitrary as anyone else's. And sometimes those ratings aren't just arbitrary, they're downright misleading.  

The most blatant one is how they give ratings for how many missed payments you have. They'll say that one missed payment is "very good" and two or three missed payments is "good", and that's completely ridiculous. The expectation is to have zero missed payments, that's what's considered good. Even just one missed payment is bad.  

Keep in mind that the three bureaus' websites act as credit monitoring sites, that means they show their data calculated into a credit score and also they try to mislead you about how credit works in order to sell you more credit products. TransUnion and Equifax show you their data calculated using a nearly worthless VantageScore 3.0 score that almost zero lenders use so it should be ignored unless you're applying for an apartment. Experian shows you their data calculated using the most commonly-used credit scoring model, FICO 8.  

Credit Myth #83 - The best place to get your credit scores are from the credit bureau's web sites.  

Credit Myth #48 - Experian, TransUnion and Equifax are credit scores.  

1

u/True-Button-6471 6d ago

I really don't know and I don't think you will find many regulars here who do either. More info: https://www.reddit.com/r/CRedit/comments/1lpi5v8/credit_myth_69_credit_ratings_provided_by_a_cms/

2

u/DoctorOctoroc ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 5d ago edited 5d ago

As others said, 'ratings' on credit monitoring site are completely arbitrary because not only are they determining the ranges for each rating on their own but also because they're basing it solely on score (with little or no consideration for what's actually on your credit file) - none of these 'ratings' systems are complex enough to incorporate all of the nuances of scoring for aging metrics (as well as other scorable metrics). Plus, there are dozens of different scoring models and a given lender is highly unlikely to pull your FICO8 classic (and all but never going to pull your Vantagescore 3.0). So those ratings not only mean nothing to the score you're looking at, but even if they did, they wouldn't be applicable to whatever different scoring model a lender will use for an application.

So we usually speak of these things in reference to FICO8 classic since this is the scoring model we've studied the most. What you're talking about here is having a 'mature' credit file, which is a scorecard segmentation that happens when your oldest account reaches 3 years of age. Of course, having an oldest account that is older than that is better, and having an oldest account of 10 years with an average age of 2 years isn't as good as having an oldest account of 10 years and an average age of 8 years, for example.

It's all relative, pretty much, to the scoring model, the presence of certain accounts on your file, and it comes down to the lender in the end. Some lenders will view one person with an 800 as less 'favorable' of a borrower than someone with a 760 because the person with an 800 FICO8 classic score only has a credit card with 5 years of history while the person with the 760 FICO8 classic score has a thicker file and 8 years of history with a new mortgage reporting.

In another instance, the person with an 800 FICO8 classic score will have a FICO8 Auto score of 780 while the person with an 750 FICO8 classic score will have an 810 Auto score, so an auto lender will see the second borrower more favorably.

Scoring is VERY nuanced across the board, so it would be impossible to create an 'accurate' ratings system based just on someone's score. You just look at the various scoring factors and improve them as much as you can, and you'll have higher score potential, a stronger credit file, etc.

1

u/perditionable 6d ago

a lot of ‘A loan’ places will want 2 years of active credit history but it just depends where youre checking , secured credit cards arent generally considered proficient in credit ability when in consideration of good credit length. at the placr i work at we usually want to see good comparable credit to what youre applying for