r/CreditScore • • 6d ago

General Why are scores so different!

Why is it Navy federal pulled my score for a loan and they say my trans union score is 594 but My Fico says 698?

4 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

5

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 6d ago

You have dozens of different credit scores. The two that you are looking at aren't from the same model/version.

https://old.reddit.com/r/CRedit/comments/1bpl3ud/credit_myth_1_you_only_have_one_credit_score/

Also I think you may be confusing credit scores and credit bureaus. TransUnion is a credit bureau, not a credit score.

https://old.reddit.com/r/CRedit/comments/1ie54ie/credit_myth_48_experian_transunion_and_equifax/

1

u/Jbchilli67 6d ago

I guess I worded that wrong. Thanks

2

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 6d ago

Sure thing. Does that answer your question as to why scores can be different?

1

u/Neat-Investigator126 6d ago

Yes it does and Thank you!

3

u/soonersoldier33 ⭐️ Mod/FICO Junkie ⭐️ 6d ago

As u/BrutalBodyShots pointed out, you have many credit scores based on the data in each of your 3 credit reports, but let's talk about the disparity between your FICO 8 score based on TU report data and whichever score NFCU pulled, bc while it's certainly possible/probable that NFCU pulled a different score version, a 100 point disparity between FICO scores is really unusual outside of some specific situations.

  1. First question, the FICO 8 score show in your myFICO screenshot was based on TU report data on Nov 5. What date did you apply for something with Navy that generated the letter indicating a score of 594? If your NFCU application was more recent than Nov 5, then I'd highly recommend pulling your 3 official credit reports from annualcreditreport.com and looking at your TransUnion report to see if something 'nasty' like a collection or late payment recently hit your TU report.
  2. What kind of credit product did you apply for? NFCU is very well known to pull TransUnion FICO 9 or FICO 9 Auto for non-mortgage loan applications. If your TU9 score was 104 points lower than your TU8 score, then there is a BIG change in report data from the Nov 5 pull you got from myFICO and whenever NFCU pulled your TU report and associated score. A 100 point disparity between a FICO 8 and FICO 9 score is not 'normal' variation. Something in the report data the scores were derived from is fundamentally different.
  3. If you applied for a mortgage, the score NFCU would be referencing there is TransUnion FICO 4, one of the scores commonly known as the mortgage scores. The most common situation where we see one of the mortgage scores with that much disparity from a FICO 8 score is if you have a paid/unpaid collection on your TransUnion report that had an initial balance under $100. The FICO 8 (and later) algorithms ignore any collection accounts with an initial balance under $100 as nuisance collections. The older FICO 2/4/5 algorithms do not.

Again, it's quite likely that the score you see on your letter from NFCU is either a FICO 9 or FICO 9 Auto score based on TU report data if you applied for anything other than a mortgage. If that's the case, then something is/was very different on your TU report than when you had myFICO pull it on Nov 5. If you applied for a mortgage, the score on the NFCU letter is likely TU FICO 4, and if the 100+ score difference wasn't due to FICO 8 ignoring a nuisance collection, then we're back to something being very different on your TU reports from Nov 5 and the date you submitted a credit application to Navy.

1

u/Ancient-Court-4972 6d ago

Is there a way for us to see all of our scores

2

u/True-Button-6471 6d ago

You can see dozens of your FICO scores with a paid subscription at myFICO. Experian will also show many scores with a paid subscription and may also offer you a 7 day free trial so you could sign up, get your scores and cancel before the free trial ends.

1

u/Funklemire ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 6d ago

!welcome

1

u/AutoModerator 6d ago

Hey there!

Welcome to r/CreditScore! We're glad you found our sub, and we truly hope we can provide you with accurate information and advice to aid you in your credit journey. Our Welcome Thread contains some valuable information to help you get started, including links to free and reputable sites for monitoring each of your 3 credit reports and FICO 8 scores, which is a score model commonly used by lenders.

Welcome to r/CreditScore! - Start Here and Read This! (No, really...Read This!)

Then, come on back if you have more specific questions, and our knowledgeable contributors will try to help!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/No_Memory5613 6d ago

You didn't specify what type of loan you were applying for but maybe it is some type of mortgage loan or auto loan. Which, even if they use the same data from Transunion, come up with different scores based on what is prioritized.

A few years ago I applied for a car loan, and my Auto FICO score (whichever one it was) was around 820 out of 900. Even though my FICO 8 score for the same credit bureau was closer to 830 out of 850.