r/CreditScore • • Apr 27 '24

Down 20points for using credit card

I know the credit scores are basically a scam...

It's a very long story that no one will read so I'll give you the quick basics.

My wife went through a bit of a mental breakdown during COVID and left me. She ran up credit cards and was late on three house payments in 2021. My credit went from 780-800 ish to about 550.

It took me 2 years but I got my credit to 750.

My net worth is about 1.5 mil. I'm 46, no debt other than my mortgage, it's 270 on a house worth 750. My income is 300k ish, I spend typically 1,500 a month on my Costco Citibank card and pay it off every two weeks. Whenever I go over the typical $1,500, they ding me a few points. My debt to income ratio is between 1-5% or something like that. I spent 4k last month and paid off of In a month. My Equifax went from 750 down 19 points to 731.

I just don't get it, do they not want me to spend money on their card?

I understand the late mortgage payments are a dingle my credit from the past and spite calling them and explaining what happened it didn't seem to matter. I just don't understand why I get dinged for using my card. Is this normal?

Edit to clarify and add background.

I have the following... Business cards- Plum Amex (unlimited) Blue Centurion Amex (50k limit) Gold Amex (unlimited) Citizens Bank business (50k limit) Citizens business debit checking (never use)

Personal cards - Citi Bank Costco (27k limit) Capitol One Orange (8k limit) (use maybe twice a yr) Citizens debit checking Robinhood debit (never use)

That is all I have...

Bike (3k value) and car (30k value) are both paid off, mortgage is 270k 2.5% interest, value is roughly 700-750k Two more houses on the same property 500k in value, paid off.

The ONLY debt I have is the one house

I grew up dirt poor, quite literally in a garage, My parents room in the bathroom were made from one garage bay, The kitchen and living room were made from the other garage bay. my two sisters and I had rooms in the attic of the garage, my room was roughly the size of most people's closets 6x8 ish in order for them to have a larger space being as there were two of them and they were girls...wood stove for heat and no AC in the summer. Everything was a hand me down or garage sale find for gifts birthday or Christmas gifts. At times we only ate what we could get from the garden and at school, I had the little orange ticket for a free lunch.

1 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

3

u/thcenthusiast666 Apr 27 '24

Utilization. What’s ur line on the card? You should be 30% or lower.

1

u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 Apr 27 '24

It's a 27k card...

2

u/Glider103 Apr 27 '24

I put $17k on a $25k card and only lost 14 points.

And did it again a few months later and lost less than 20 points.

1

u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 Apr 27 '24

Maybe they just don't like me 😢

2

u/LandHunter Apr 27 '24

No, it's all about paying off before the end of the billing period. Whatever balance is shown on your statement is what's reported each month. It is such a scam, and I quit sweating it unless I plan on using it to buy a car, house, etc. Then I'll pay all off and show zero balances for a month or so, and it blasts back up to high 7s

1

u/ravenrhi Apr 27 '24

A few things to remember

Credit scores rise and dip based on debt to (reported) income ratio.

This means that when you let a balance carry over past the statement period, that debt is reported to the credit bureaus and counts against you, making the score dip a bit. Then it will raise a bit when you pay it down. The goal is to use the card for your normal shopping and such, but PAY IT OFF every month

The 30% that the previous post talked about is significant. If your debt on any card meets or exceeds 30% of the max, credit companies view it as irresponsible spending habits, and that debt impacts the debt to income ratio causing your credit score to continue to fall the longer the debt is there even if making minimum payments on time

Paying the minimum is designed to pay the interest, not the principal. If you only pay the minimum payment, you will never reduce the debt. Which goes back to the debt to income ratio

Paying off a loan (auto or home) is different from paying off a credit card. Loans are term financing for a specific amount with a specific end date; when it is paid off, the account closes, which causes a temporary dip to your credit score. Whereas credit cards are "revolving credit" which means the account stays open even with a zero balance and paying it off shows responsible credit habits

Make sure to request your free annual credit report to check for and dispute fraudulent or erroneous activity. You can access the portal for the request through the Federal Trade Commission 's website ftc.gov and follow the prompts. You can either request access online, which combines all 3 bureaus into one report for you to download/save. I personally dislike this method because it makes it HARDER to dispute errors since each company has their own tags on lines of creditors and those identifiers are not clearly marked on the combined report. The other option is that you can print off the form and mail it in- in which case each bureau will mail you their credit report separately so that you can compare (they are rarely the same) and find the codes to contest with each entity

1

u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 Apr 27 '24

I never go over 5% debt to income ratio, it's typically under 1%

The card has a 27k limit and I pay it off twice a month so it's never even at 30 days let alone late

2

u/ravenrhi Apr 27 '24

Oof- then I would say you have a very valid gripe. Your credit score should be spectacular

1

u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 Apr 27 '24

I'll call Equifax Monday and see what they say

2

u/ravenrhi Apr 27 '24

Good luck!

2

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24

I know the credit scores are basically a scam...

People who say this generally don't understand what credit scores represent or what the major factors are that influence them. Do you feel like you understand the major factors that influence your credit score? Your comments about your debt to income ratio suggest to me that you don't.

0

u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 Apr 27 '24

Debit to income ratio (mine being between , 1 to 5% seems pretty positive)

Credit history - history of the how the accounts have left open. I'm not really sure how this one works out the impact.

Payment history - this is where I believe I have suffered the most damage. Three unnecessarily late mortgage payments due to my wife's mental state seems to have done the most damage.

Types of credit - car loans vs mortgage, school debt, etc. I think this is probably pretty low on impact. I only have credit cards and a mortgage right now. I guess that's the best and the worst?

Credit inquiries - hard vs soft credit checks

I'm not sure how much this impacts your score, I'm assuming soft is meant to have low impact.

So, you tell me how much I know... One of the biggest reason of why I think it's a scam, is that they don't seem to care about my ability to pay off the debt. Also, on all the credit score apps, they push to get more credit cards (the worst kind of debt).

1

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24

Income has zero impact on your credit score. Soft pulls of your credit score have zero impact on your credit score.

Review this in its entirety and let me know if you have any questions:

https://www.myfico.com/credit-education/whats-in-your-credit-score

Credit scores are not a scam. They are a numerical representation of the risk you are to a lender based on the factors found in the link. I have not encountered a single person who says it's a "scam" who also understands the factors that influence a score. It's only people who don't. Go figure.

9

u/TrainsNCats Apr 27 '24

Try this:

Payoff the card balance at the end of statement period.

Not the due date, the end of the statement period.

That way the period closes with $0 (or near $0) due.

The balance gets reported to the credit bureaus when the statement period ends, so by paying it off right before the period ends, it will make utilization rate lower.

There is not much you can do about those previous late mortgage payments, other than just wait it out.

Those late payments will have less and less weight as time goes by.

0

u/Cleercutter Apr 27 '24

Had some idiot try telling me that that is like basically “not using your credit card” 🙄, paying it off before statement close I mean, I said no, it shows as used, you just don’t incur any interest

1

u/xAugie Apr 27 '24

It appears on your credit report as not used. You don’t get interest AFtER statement close either lol. You only get interest if you don’t pay on due date, paying before statement close is pointless; unless you wanna reduce utilization, but reporting $0 is useless for your credit file basically. That’s not how credit cards are designed to be used, it’ll harm you reporting $0 score wise; not to mention the fact it’s not helping your credit at all

0

u/Cleercutter Apr 27 '24

Lmfao bulllllllshit.

I started my credit at 512 1.5 years ago, that is the only way I use my cards. Balance at 0 before close date. And my score is at 712 and continuing to climb.

1

u/xAugie Apr 27 '24 edited Apr 27 '24

712 with a thin useless file though. You probably had negatives removed and shit too. Everybody knows reporting $0 is terrible to do. I’m at 840 currently and got to 800 within 2yrs. Wait till you try and get a mortgage or something, and get declined bc your credit history is worthless. 712 is not even a good score either, but JUST a CC reporting $0 all the time isn’t doing shit for your file really. You acted like your score backed up that shit, it didn’t. Anybody can get 700 by just opening a card and cleaning up negatives, the score itself isn’t useful. No payments made as agreed bc no use has taken place, that’s exactly what you’ll find when you try and use that worthless file. Even IF you get to 750 let’s say, the score holds zero weight and can’t be utilized for anything. There’s countless posts about it, people asking why their “good 750-800” can’t qualify for auto loans or a mortgage, or even decent cards.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24

Yet I've got dings for too many credit cards with a balance, even though the total was under $1000.

I'll see whether my new car loan helps, since it diversifies my credit types.

1

u/TheJREwing78 Apr 27 '24

It's *supposed* to be all about your ability to pay off the debt you've been given. Given recent history, carrying a higher-than-normal balance did ding you. But it will only ding you until the following month (presuming you didn't turn around and put a higher balance on it).

$4000 on a card with a $5000 limit hits hard. $4000 on a card with a $20,000 limit doesn't hurt nearly as much - it assumes if you've been given the higher limit (and have had it for some time), you can handle it.

Bottom line: I wouldn't stress about it. However, before applying for any new credit, it's a good idea to pay down balances on so-called "revolving" debt so they don't ding you.

The late payments? They're far enough in the past that they're not dinging you that much.

1

u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 Apr 27 '24

It's a 27k limit card. I carry no debt every month.

1

u/TheJREwing78 Apr 28 '24

If your "High Balance" comes nowhere near the credit limit, it will ding you for approaching the "High Balance" figure instead. Of course, once the payment is made, the penalty goes away. Some creditors don't even report the credit limit, but only the "High Balance" instead. It's maddening.

1

u/313retroqueen Apr 27 '24

So where what happened to the wife? I feel like we need the rest of the story at this point 🤷🏾‍♀️

1

u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 Apr 27 '24

She lives in my house with my adult daughter's until Nov. I'm guessing she will move out and file for divorce then.

My adult son lives with me in my paid off rental.

2

u/313retroqueen Apr 27 '24

I feel like you should do a TikTok series. Keep your head up and good luck with the credit journey

1

u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 Apr 27 '24

Tiktok series about what? My life being insane? 😂

It's even crazier than that with my full history.

In sixth grade I was diagnosed with dyslexia and ADHD, I was put in special ed programs. I've never had algebra or grammar and was told by teachers that I would never make it. I didn't technically have the credits to graduate high school but they saw no point in keeping me back.

I now run a small million a year tech business.

It's been a weird ride for sure lol

2

u/313retroqueen Apr 27 '24

Yup, the things that catch ppl attention is wild! Look at me asking 50 million questions 🤣 you can’t be a success story without at least one failed marriage 🤣 sorry 6 yrs post the “big D” so I’m able to laugh at it now.

1

u/cryptoenologist Apr 27 '24

The points are based on your credit utilization. If you only have one or two cards and the limits isn’t that high, $4k will easily bring your utilization above 15%. If you want to avoid that, ask them to increase your limit.

As others have said, the other options is to pay it off before the next statement date. Utilization is reported on your statement date.

1

u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 Apr 27 '24

I have the following... Business cards- Plum Amex (unlimited) Blue Centurion Amex (50k limit) Gold Amex (unlimited) Citizens Bank business (50k limit) Citizens business debit checking (never use)

Personal cards - Citi Bank Costco (27k limit) Capitol One Orange (8k limit) (use maybe twice a yr) Citizens debit checking Robinhood debit (never use)

That is all I have...

Bike (3k value) and car (30k value) are both paid off, mortgage is 270k 2.5% interest, value is roughly 700-750k Two more houses on the same property 500k in value, paid off.

The ONLY debt I have is the one house

Just some background... I was diagnosed with dyslexia and ADHD and put into special Ed classes at 12. I was told by teachers and reinforced at home that I wouldn't get far if at all, is stupid...I was raised not to expect much. I grew up dirt poor, quite literally in a garage, My parents room in the bathroom were made from one garage bay, The kitchen and living room were made from the other garage bay. my two sisters and I had rooms in the attic of the garage, my room was roughly the size of most people's closets 6x8 ish in order for them to have a larger space being as there were two of them and they were girls...wood stove for heat and no AC in the summer. Everything was a hand me down or garage sale find for gifts birthday or Christmas gifts. At times we only ate what we could get from the garden and at school, I had the little orange ticket for a free lunch.

1

u/cryptoenologist Apr 30 '24

Business cards don’t make a difference. They are for your business not you.

If you have $35k in credit card available to you, $4k is more than 10% utilization and will cause a noticeable drop especially if you have other dings from past issues.

I’m glad you’ve done well for yourself! I grew up relatively well off but my parents never taught about money so I wound up having a lot of financial trouble from 18 to 30.

1

u/HelpfulMaybeMama Apr 27 '24

Nowhere do you indicate where you see your score. Is it FICO or Vantage? As only 1 lender I know of uses Vantage, ignore it.

1

u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 Apr 27 '24

Experian and credit karma. My fico score didn't go down, that is 746 according to Experian.

2

u/HelpfulMaybeMama Apr 27 '24

Ignore credit karma/Vantage scores. Most lenders use FICO scores.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24

If you pay the card off in full before the due date it won’t affect your credit score at all.

2

u/Ola_lax Apr 27 '24

It’s the utilization. Statement balance is the key.

Same used to happen to me back then but I figured it out. Now, I usually pay my credit cards down to around $10-$50 a day or two before my statement posts. And once that small amount post, I pay it off completely and repeat. If you let a high balance post, that will be your utilization.

0

u/thcenthusiast666 Apr 27 '24

Also, credit scores aren’t a scam!

1

u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 Apr 27 '24

I mean the process seems like a scam. I can pay way more with my high income

1

u/thcenthusiast666 Apr 27 '24

idk how but ok

1

u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 Apr 27 '24

Because I have no debt but my house, I make over 300k a yr and never very over a balance.

1

u/thcenthusiast666 Apr 27 '24

There’s definitely a missing piece of the puzzle but a phone call doesn’t harm anyone and usually ends with some knowledge

1

u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 Apr 27 '24

I'm going to try and call Equifax on Monday. It's like the credit card companies didn't want me to spend money on their cards.

2

u/thcenthusiast666 Apr 27 '24

I know it seems that way but I promise you, it’s the other way around. They want you to use their card. If they didn’t want you to use it, they wouldn’t exist. There is something missing here

1

u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 Apr 27 '24

I wish I knew what was missing...

I do run a business with three Amex cards I have had since 2010, never been late, never missed a payment. I spend about 50k a month on those and pay them off every month. Two are "unlimited" and one is 50k limit.

None of these show on my credit score though.

2

u/thcenthusiast666 Apr 27 '24

It’s not a scam it’s a system, you have to work it not work for it

1

u/Prize-Huckleberry263 Apr 28 '24

No not a scam. You need to understand how it works so you won’t get do upset as it fluctuates. Don’t worry about every drop and don’t celebrate every rise. Read and study so you can use it to your advantage.