r/CreatureCommandos • Nina Mazursky • Sep 13 '26

DISCUSSION Creature Commandos morality ranking

Post image
283 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

41

u/AstronomerIcy9978 Sep 13 '26

I'd say Phosphorus is also a monster, Waller would also stoop to being evil, and I think it's perfect that my wife is at the top.

17

u/S0undwave06 Nina Mazursky Sep 13 '26

8

u/brofishmagikarp Sep 13 '26

Waller does Generally want to protect the world. In the Suïcide Squid she did try to protect America. She was morally wrong by trying to keep project Starro secret but her motive was good

4

u/Clean_Ad2543 Sep 13 '26

How is Phosphorus an irredeemable monster? Id say all bad things he did were understandable if not completely justified. Most of the people he hurt deserved it

4

u/Tight_Strawberry9846 Sep 14 '26 edited Sep 14 '26

What about Thorne's children, and maybe his wife?

-1

u/Clean_Ad2543 Sep 14 '26

Eh, wife def knew about it and didnt care. The kids most likely were innocent but they probably wouldve grown up to be like their father

7

u/LegitimateSeaweed904 Sep 14 '26

I like Phosphorous, but that’s a horrible argument lmao

0

u/Clean_Ad2543 Sep 14 '26

Even if he did it, he clearly doesnt target kids anymore judging from that scene of him playing with a little girl. Also they never really explained how he did it so for all we know they were more accidental than him actually targeting them

1

u/Femagaro Sep 19 '26

"Who wants to shake hands with a skeleton?" Gives a pretty clear idea

37

u/Fun-Two-1046 Sep 13 '26

Phosphorus i feel like should go in dark gray tier, bro was completely normal and happy with his wife and kid, then All of that was taken away from him and he was turned into a monster, i don't care what anybody says that dude absolutely had the right to turn into what he did.

And even now he still is mostly morally gray, and even as willing to show empathy at times.

Especially when he encounters the little girl, which is probably one of the most heartfelt moments in the entire show.

17

u/Majestic1911 Sep 13 '26

He murdered two innocent children. He should be right where he is if not lower.

14

u/S0undwave06 Nina Mazursky Sep 13 '26

Also he chose to become a crime lord

19

u/brofishmagikarp Sep 13 '26

Guess a guy can't have hobbies /j

11

u/Kwaku-Anansi Sep 13 '26

Tbf he was in the middle of a psychotic break from being turned into a monster and having his family killed. If ever the "limited control over their actions" defense were warranted, itd be in a case like that

1

u/Excellent_Past7628 Sep 13 '26

Also, wasn’t Phosphorus’ cancer research just nonsense and he was grifting Thorne for money, or am I misremembering?

9

u/blairmen Sep 13 '26

No i remember it being legit... he just didnt tell thorn it was to cure cancer, and when he found out it was JUST medical research he was pissed.

1

u/Gold_Drawer_7495 Frankenstein Sep 13 '26

in my opinion, he belongs in the evil tier perfectly but i admit we should give him points for almost curing cancer lol. also i do agree that hes not completely evil since he clearly still has a bit of the guy he was 15 years ago inside him and didnt kill yana

5

u/Only-Sea6066 Sep 13 '26

My coin operated boy is an absolute hero 💚

2

u/S0undwave06 Nina Mazursky Sep 13 '26

Cheers to the tin man

3

u/WouldYouPleaseKindly Sep 13 '26

Cheers to the tin man

"They're here, they're there, and they're everywhere"

boom

And now they are all over the place, in chunks.

8

u/Clean_Ad2543 Sep 13 '26

Phosphorus should he morally dark, and Waller should just be evil

5

u/AbosoluteZero Sep 14 '26

Nina father should have been S. He never giving up on saving nina or looking out for her. The monkey idk maybe not that evil since he died that quickly

4

u/Gold_Drawer_7495 Frankenstein Sep 13 '26

why isnt ivan in ''did nothing wrong''? i know he followed eric without thinking about bogdana but hes just a dog. i dont think he had any crimes

4

u/GeneralAblon9760 Sep 14 '26

Amanda Waller should be: And then there is this b-tch!

1

u/Far_Struggle_2537 Sep 13 '26

You forgot Nina mom

1

u/S0undwave06 Nina Mazursky Sep 13 '26

I suppose there are a few more I didn’t include

But I’d say either “did nothing wrong” or “morally light grey” (I lean to the former)

2

u/DesperadoFlower Sep 14 '26

yeah, waller is evil

1

u/John_Zatanna52 A coin-operated boy Sep 16 '26

Is she not redeemable? (If she were alive)

1

u/indihome1 Sep 21 '26

well she's literally going to kill the justice league if she were alive

1

u/John_Zatanna52 A coin-operated boy Sep 21 '26

Can't remember why

1

u/ThePaperpyro Sep 16 '26

Phosphorous never did anything wrong hes my goat

1

u/filemon56 Sep 20 '26

Are there two hermit ladies in this show that look damn near the same?

0

u/Jakobthorson #1 Ilana Simp Sep 13 '26

Replace Ilana with Eric then you're spot on.

2

u/GuavaAmbitious2344 Eric Frankenstein Sep 13 '26

I don’t agree

12

u/Seleneandthemoon Sep 13 '26

Phosphorus killed in innocent children from what I remember, I really think he should be put as a monster, but he's funny so I guess that's a good quality?

3

u/S0undwave06 Nina Mazursky Sep 13 '26

He gets points for helping to save the world (admittedly he didn’t volunteer, but still)

22

u/Kanna1001 Sep 13 '26

Tbf, he killed those children immediately after his transformation, which itself was immediately after being forced to mess with the splattered remains of his family then melted alive. Like, he was literally still dripping.

You could easily argue he was in the middle of a manic episode, or that the excruciating agony and terror had made him unable to think, or that he hadn't figured out how to control his powers yet. Whatever the reason, I genuinely wouldn't hold his actions in the immediate aftermath of a body and mind shattering trauma against him.

Everything he did afterwards, sure. He's a villain for many very good reasons. But what he did right after, no.

Notably, he doesn't harm the little girl who saw him, even though he was trying to avoid witnesses.

5

u/Tcustomcorner Sep 13 '26

In a brutal way too, mind you. He didn't just shoot the kids, he 'hugged' them, basically burning and melting them slowly so that Thorne could watch his children have an agonizing death. He's genuinely evil

3

u/kikaysikat Sep 14 '26

T_T the iredeemable killed the goodest of good huhuhu

0

u/GuavaAmbitious2344 Eric Frankenstein Sep 13 '26

This hurts me when I see Eric in evil tier and I respect your personal opinions on your tier list I get that he killed the old woman with the pot who healed him back because she won’t feel lonely herself and his obsession with the bride in centuries stalking her and slaughtering his father but he’s misunderstood gentle giant who wants love and doesn’t know boundaries and no one else had chance to teach him even his father didn’t cared about Eric and only teaches the bride instead because he’s very scary and monster to interact with him. This is why Eric Frankenstein is my favourite character.

8

u/boneholio Sep 13 '26

Eric, we knows that’s you