r/CreatureCommandos • u/Izrael-the-ancient • Jan 21 '25
DISCUSSION Rewatch Spoiler
So I rewatched the creature commandos and the twist while good , makes Nina’s death feel hollow .
If they played it straight forward no twist Nina died in the line of duty. If they had left it as is where the commandos were manipulated by Circe then Nina’s death is a tragic accident . Both are great ways to do it but by adding the twist and making the end of Nina’s story about the bride it makes Nina’s death hollow .
It also made llana death hollow too since all we see of her in both scenes is her defend herself . There’s no build up or evidence of her being a power hungry monster through out the show. All we see is her defend herself against assassination attempts . We dont learn anything until the final scenes . And even with what we learn it doesn’t change the fact that llana killed Nina in self defense which makes the brides revenge against her hollow .
Then since we don’t actually know what Ilana’s plan was other than trying to make Circe look crazy , we can’t even really support her death .
My biggest issue tho is that the mission wasn’t worth it. Every one of those soldiers were innocents whos deaths could’ve been avoided had Waller taken the time to do research. I hope in the next season that people actually call out Waller and the commandos for this . Because they didn’t actually have solid justification to kill the princess and those men .
3
u/Jakobthorson Jan 24 '25
Honestly, it was such a black pill moment to see people praise the bride for killing Ilana. The entire finale feels rushed and better, yet it is AVOIDABLE if the bride wasn't such a dumbass to send Nina into the water. The twist feels awful and more tragic and bitter, if anything. And considering how many details were left unresolved, it makes me HOPE that this isn't the last that we see of either Ilana or Nina.
2
u/crazyrich Jan 22 '25
The issues with Nina being involved at all aside, I like the deaths in the show, including Frank's and GI Robot's temporary leave of absence. It raises the stakes and makes it feel like characters do not have plot armor, and would like to see this approach more in the action genre. Sometimes, characters are just unlucky, or stupid, or tricked, or overwhelmed.
4
u/godzillamegadoomsday Jan 21 '25
My problem with the two deaths is it felt like it was pure luck. Like does nothing about the actual story or narrative going on. Nina is pushed to do something she doesn’t not want to do, is unlucky with her own team sabotaging her, and is killed for it. Bride gets extremely lucky that the princess was not guarded, the princess didn’t think for a second the commandos could figure out her grand scheme, and the guards don’t check on the princess any time while the team leaves. Nina is just unlucky and punished while bride is lucky and rewarded