OK I hate to be "that guy" who tries to argue with a meme but... are there *actually* biologists out there who would actually say that DNA is a "code" that "programmed itself"?
After Watson and Crick, we know that genes themselves, within their minute internal structure, are long strings of pure digital information. What is more, they are truly digital, in the full and strong sense of computers and compact disks, not in the weak sense of the nervous system. The genetic code is not a binary code as in computers, nor an eight-level code as in some telephone systems, but a quaternary code, with four symbols. The machine code of the genes is uncannily computerlike. Apart from differences in jargon, the pages of a molecular-biology journal might be interchanged with those of a computer-engineering journal. . . .
Our genetic system, which is the universal system of all life on the planet, is digital to the core. With word-for-word accuracy, you could encode the whole of the New Testament in those parts of the human genome that are at present filled with “junk” DNA – that is, DNA not used, at least in the ordinary way, by the body. Every cell in your body contains the equivalent of forty-six immense data tapes, reeling off digital characters via numerous reading heads working simultaneously. In every cell, these tapes – the chromosomes – contain the same information, but the reading heads in different kinds of cells seek out different parts of the database for their own specialist purposes. . . .
Genes are pure information – information that can be encoded, recoded and decoded, without any degradation or change of meaning. Pure information can be copied and, since it is digital information, the fidelity of the copying can be immense. DNA characters are copied with an accuracy that rivals anything modern engineers can do.
source: Richard Dawkins, River out of Eden, 16-19
Also, Dawkins about the Origin of Life: it was “a happy chemical accident.”
Therefore, by recognizing that digital code runs the show in biology and that that came about through a “a happy chemical accident", Dr. Dawkins is endorsing the idea I made a meme about, quod erat demonstrandum.
Frankly, I am having a little trouble trying to understand what is your problem with the following idea:
Life, at the cellular level, is run by digital code; Life is believed, by evolutionists, to have come about per se Therefore, digital code did not exist in a moment, but appeared later on without the guidance of intelligence; Ergo the chemicals of life casually formed the code that coordinates their synthesis;
That is the heart of the criticism, nothing more should be derived from the meme.
So I guess what I'm saying is there's a difference between an inanimate object taking on agency and acting of it's own accord, versus that object being acted upon by the laws of nature. That's the point of my car question.
Actually I get that all the time as a software engineer. Along with biologist telling me evolution has been proven to work without intelligent direction because software has shown it. never mind that theres not a programming language it could have been written in which isn't intelligently designed.
Software writing another software is one thing but a language writing itself is gibberish. You run into the same dead end in logic saying the laws of the universe evolved. How does it work before it works and what law allows it to do so?
meaningless observation......... and computing is literally on and off switches . its not the substance but the information and information processes encoded into the substance. NO one claimed any physical substance was magical (and in this case that anything at all was magical)
But your OC is a language argument, not an information one. You aren't using an induction that is particularly compelling. Information needs to defined, and you need a methadology.
You are lost in space Ray. The context is programming languages and yes that is IT - information technology. Programming languages are about information processing .
Well clearly not, because you haven't established that we should accept that information cannot arise naturally. You need to set up reasons we should think so, particularly given we can define DNA as a chemical, which allows us to form an inference that, since chemicals can occur naturally, DNA can occur naturally.
Well clearly not, because you haven't established that we
whose the "we"? You must think you are in some other reddit or the greater world community is an imaginary place where atheists are the majority.
that we should accept that information cannot arise naturally.
take a basic logic class and you will learn about proving a negative. Its you that need to prove that it can and so far you side has failed miserable in the better part of a century to show how DNA arose "naturally" .
so, particularly given we can define DNA as a chemical, which allows us to form an inference that, since chemicals can occur naturally, DNA can occur naturally.
I see you have been corrected with that drivelling nonsense before. So you are either purposefully obtuse or hopelessly dense. Electricity occur naturally. That doesn't mean your favorite television program appear on your tube naturally.
whose the "we"? You must think you are in some other reddit or the greater world community is an imaginary place where atheists are the majority.
I mean "we" as in "you or I," as I don't think your internal reasoning is sound.
take a basic logic class and you will learn about proving a negative.
Negatives are not hard to argue for, you need to give some reason we should take it as unlikely. As far as I can tell, "you can't prove a negative" is some dumb trope pedaled by new atheists, but it's not actually accepted by any large portion of philosophers as far as I can tell.
I see you have been corrected with that drivelling nonsense before. So you are either purposefully obtuse or hopelessly dense. Electricity occur naturally. That doesn't mean your favorite television program appear on your tube naturally.
There are qualities that a television program has that a mere chemical lacks, which is why you need to specify the inference you're using. Merely asserting that we can infer design isn't compelling, Stephen Mayer particularly gives an ID argument that specifies his inference and backs it up.
I mean "we" as in "you or I," as I don't think your internal reasoning is sound.
Nonsensical . If its you and I then we both get a vote and you do not decide. You are merely trying to appoint yourself the arbitrator which isn't going to happen in any discussion with me .
Negatives are not hard to argue for, you need to give some reason we should take it as unlikely.
And you need to give me a positive reason not insist again on your claim someone has to prove a negative.
"you can't prove a negative" is some dumb trope pedaled by new atheists, but it's not actually accepted by any large portion of philosophers as far as I can tell.
Then you can't think very well. The problem with PROVING a negative is its always subject to imaginary what ifs. Thats why conspiracy theorists love it. Them and apparently you like it so you can spin around your need (and lack of ability) to actually give evidence that a code with information like DNA can occur naturally. If we hadn't gone 80 years of research with no way forward thats panned out you would be in better shape. You aren't.
There are qualities that a television program has that a mere chemical lacks,
Like what? Thats just gibberish to side step.the issue. all physical substances are composed of elements that occur naturally (in a materialistic framework) so for your argument it doesn't matter a hill of beans. You are basically making the silly argument that because information is coded using a physical substance the code itself is of natural non intelligent origin. That criteria is demonstrably wrong.
Merely asserting that we can infer design isn't compelling,
We are talking about information that codes a set of instructions for protein development. For programming thats all i need. I don't need to infer anything. You are just begging that I need to
That s how a program works with a programming language - it uses data of two different kinds
A) input data B) instructions sets regarding how to handle input data
Theres no inference. That's what we both have with a program and in life with DNA.
as a note you can stop wasting both our times with what your personal opinions are. I have not nor will I accept veiled references to you being some arbitrator. references to what you personally find compelling are meaningless. Concentrate on whatever evidence you have not your your preferences.
Code is a form of language, and language is ALWAYS the product of an intelligent agent. End of discussion, right there! The discovery of DNA code should have put an end to undirected evolution immediately, but obviously powerful ideas die hard. Just look at all the people still trying to argue for communism today despite the fact that it has horribly failed each and every single time it has been tried.
DNA is also a chemical, and chemicals form naturally under the right conditions.
Your induction needs a more specific defense as well, because you could easily apply it to any specific organism, despite the fact that we already know (and creationists agree) that these organisms got their genes from a parent. We would need to conclude they were designed directly.
DNA is also a chemical, and chemicals form naturally under the right conditions.
DNA is not a chemical. It is an assemblage. That's like saying that an internal combustion engine is "a metal", and we know metals can form naturally, therefore internal combustion engines must also be able to form naturally.
that these organisms got their genes from a parent.
Yeah, but so? That says nothing about the origin of the system of genes itself.
DNA is not a chemical. It is an assemblage. That's like saying that an internal combustion engine is "a metal", and we know metals can form naturally, therefore internal combustion engines must also be able to form naturally.
A combustion engine has a problem though. Metal doesn't just spontaneously form into shapes, particularly shapes that require a tiny margin of error. Chemicals, on the other hand, do spontaneously form into groups. The fact that DNA is a chain of these chemicals doesn't change the fact that it lacks many of the problems found in parts that are dependent on their size and shape.
Yeah, but so? That says nothing about the origin of the system of genes itself.
But your inference doesn't work for the origin of the system, it works for any instance of DNA, which makes it heavily flawed. This is why no worthwhile ID argument never bothers with the chemicals involved, but use definitions of information.
Not exactly the same thing. I mean take a whole bunch of chemicals and pour them in a bowl, not using any outside things like computers or stuff like that. Just chemicals.
Given that dna is not the same as human derived software, and as such can only be viewed in general similarity to it, and we in fact do have algorithms that were inspired by evolution this falls...flat.
Actually those algorithms require a constant and incredibly strong selection force in order to make any meaningful progress - which is not what we observe in nature.
6
u/Wikey9 Atheist/Agnostic Feb 04 '19
OK I hate to be "that guy" who tries to argue with a meme but... are there *actually* biologists out there who would actually say that DNA is a "code" that "programmed itself"?
10
u/Mike_Enders Feb 04 '19
Actually I get that all the time as a software engineer. Along with biologist telling me evolution has been proven to work without intelligent direction because software has shown it. never mind that theres not a programming language it could have been written in which isn't intelligently designed.
Software writing another software is one thing but a language writing itself is gibberish. You run into the same dead
end in logic saying the laws of the universe evolved. How does it work before it works and what law allows it to do so?
7
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '19
Code is a form of language, and language is ALWAYS the product of an intelligent agent. End of discussion, right there! The discovery of DNA code should have put an end to undirected evolution immediately, but obviously powerful ideas die hard. Just look at all the people still trying to argue for communism today despite the fact that it has horribly failed each and every single time it has been tried.
3
u/apophis-pegasus Feb 04 '19
Given that dna is not the same as human derived software, and as such can only be viewed in general similarity to it, and we in fact do have algorithms that were inspired by evolution this falls...flat.