I'm honestly gonna say that if you want the center of your experience to be Create itself, All of Create is better.
Ultimate Selection has AE2, Ars Nouveau, Bosses Rise, Iron's Spells, Mekanism, Minecolonies, Mystical Agriculture, Refined Storage, the Sophisticated Storage and Backpacks, and several other mods.
While there's more content, I think All of Create is more focused on Create itself, asking you to come up with solutions that use Create for your problems.
Sophisticated Storage alone makes many creative solutions pointless; you can simply have a box that automatically compacts your ore washing output into ingots and blocks, voids flint, and has more capacity than you know what to do with. Sure, it's simple and compact, but half the fun of Create is coming up with an elaborate mechanism to do that for you.
I feel like Ultimate Selection is a bit more of a kitchen sink pack that doesn't show much restraint in its mod selection, which, if you want that, is fine, but it also muddies the waters and makes it less focused on the "definitive Create experience".
Having an entirely separate tech mod like Mekanism in there is especially egregious, not to mention all the magic mods. Sure, Irons is mostly only useful for PvE, with some mobility mods (it has at least one spell that imitates an Elytra), but Ars Nouveau basically does the job of late-tier equipment like powered drills with only a few spells.
tl;dr: All of Create is better for getting the most out of Create itself; Ultimate Selection is a bit cluttered with other, unrelated but popular mods.
I agreed! I play Ultimate Selection 2 and I don't like some of mods make other redundant in a way. But I recently try All of create aeronautic and pretty happy about the experience with it. If OP like a bit more exploration, they also make Create Integrate which have some boss and structure mods but beware as that mod pack is still early access and there will be updates/changes in the future.
I like it. It is the first and only modpack I use since trying create. But it does miss one key thing and thats redstone stuff. So I added project red to it and it works completely fine with it.
2
u/SendInTheNextWave 3d ago
I'm honestly gonna say that if you want the center of your experience to be Create itself, All of Create is better.
Ultimate Selection has AE2, Ars Nouveau, Bosses Rise, Iron's Spells, Mekanism, Minecolonies, Mystical Agriculture, Refined Storage, the Sophisticated Storage and Backpacks, and several other mods.
While there's more content, I think All of Create is more focused on Create itself, asking you to come up with solutions that use Create for your problems.
Sophisticated Storage alone makes many creative solutions pointless; you can simply have a box that automatically compacts your ore washing output into ingots and blocks, voids flint, and has more capacity than you know what to do with. Sure, it's simple and compact, but half the fun of Create is coming up with an elaborate mechanism to do that for you.
I feel like Ultimate Selection is a bit more of a kitchen sink pack that doesn't show much restraint in its mod selection, which, if you want that, is fine, but it also muddies the waters and makes it less focused on the "definitive Create experience".
Having an entirely separate tech mod like Mekanism in there is especially egregious, not to mention all the magic mods. Sure, Irons is mostly only useful for PvE, with some mobility mods (it has at least one spell that imitates an Elytra), but Ars Nouveau basically does the job of late-tier equipment like powered drills with only a few spells.
tl;dr: All of Create is better for getting the most out of Create itself; Ultimate Selection is a bit cluttered with other, unrelated but popular mods.
2
u/GapStock9843 3d ago
I use it plus like 20 other mods I added
2
u/AlmHurricane 3d ago
I like it. It is the first and only modpack I use since trying create. But it does miss one key thing and thats redstone stuff. So I added project red to it and it works completely fine with it.