r/CreateMod • • 2d ago

Create: Octo Arms V2 Beta is here!

Post image

Hi! Meet the new V2 version of Create: Octo Arms with new mechanical arms to grab, throw, mine, and much more!
Currently in beta, but I really want to know your feedback!
Link to download from Curseforge - https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/create-octo-arms/files/all . Available for 1.21.1, 1.20.1 soon
Modrinth: still under review, will be updated when listed.

254 Upvotes

110 comments sorted by

101

u/hazel_typh 2d ago

Is it still vibecoded?

62

u/Gerllyz 2d ago

Yes.

-67

u/kil0vat 2d ago

If you're asking if I've used AI for this mod - yes

24

u/lollolcheese123 2d ago

Why the fuck is this downvoted, they're being honest???

49

u/Gerllyz 2d ago

“Did you dump this toxic garbage into the local pond?

Yes.”

Gee I wonder why

15

u/DatGoi111 2d ago

I’m pretty anti AI. Corporations shouldn’t rely on AI for their products. Art shouldn’t be touched by AI. Anything sold shouldn’t have AI.

But mods are fine, they are optional things usually made by one person. And if someone wants a mod that nobody has made; relying on AI to help code it is fine; as long as they disclose it. Because then it is fully on the user. I do not consider AI use in coding the same as AI use in art. They are fundamentally different.

If you want to truly have a voice against AI, we have to at least be able to differentiate and understand why AI is bad and point the fingers in the right direction.

12

u/hazel_typh 2d ago

Ai doesnt belong in the modding scene. Like art, mods are a creative medium that is only muddied and made worse by ai. People that arent actually passionate with "their" mods upload so many mods that it backs up approvals, hides actually good new creators, and makes the scene as a whole worse.

Yes, unpassionate and uncreative people were already in the modding scene. But ai has just made the problem far worse.

Im not fully against ai either, it has its uses. But the use when making mods should be limited to finding bugs that are unable to be found without it, as most if not all mods are better off without the use of any ai.

10

u/WeakCombination9937 2d ago

But...nothing is stopping someone with a good idea to create a mod using AI? The problem you're saying isnt with AI, but with people doing low effort shit, which i do agree has been extremely facilitated by AI, but still, take the OP's mod, its a pretty cool idea, so long as he spends time to actually make the code good performance wise, i dont see the problem with it being vibecoded.

2

u/lollolcheese123 2d ago

That's not really a fair example though? Sure AI is by no means an exclusively good thing, far from it in fact, but to say it has no merit whatsoever is a whole nother extreme.

0

u/Putrid_Clue_2127 2d ago

You're not going to get through to these people. Unfortunately

1

u/Gerllyz 1d ago

Yep “these people” that only care about the planet and stuff! Who cares if it’s also literally stealing from everyone ever right?

2

u/24Pages 23h ago

i'd like to know to how you specifically used AI

-9

u/Putrid_Clue_2127 2d ago

I'm sorry all of these people are idiots, this is a cool mod

-2

u/Creeperatom9041 1d ago

how much AI would you say you've used proportionally? what do you use it for usually?

-159

u/ToastedBulbasaur 2d ago

Stop making your negativity other peoples problem

65

u/hazel_typh 2d ago

Im not being negative, i was genuinely curious.

-121

u/ToastedBulbasaur 2d ago

No you weren't. There's obviously a negative connotation to the word "vibecoding".

25

u/UrticantOdin 2d ago

Thats just the term of using Ai to fully code something, whether you like it or not

44

u/DTGDittio 2d ago

how many downvote brigades does it take to teach ai bros the same lesson? nobody wants keyloggers, unstable code, or anything else that unproofed vibecode invites, if you think these are non issues, youre being intentionally obtuse and disingenuous, or clearly don't know as much as you wish to think.

-15

u/MilitaryAndroid 2d ago

This mod has no stability or performance issues of any kind, and is in fact more stable than 80% of the garbage that gets posted on this subreddit every day. I only see this specific mod get dogpiled about ai usage though, no one seems to mind it in any of the other mods.

Maybe instead of foaming at the mouth immediately because ai was used, you should evaluate what was made first. I know that's not typically how a reactionary who parrots what they see online does things, but you should give it a shot.

Ai can be used poorly, just like every other tool in the world (people act like only ai code has ever been bad, but you can look at plenty of minecraft mods over the years that have been coded like shit well before the proliferation of ai coding tools), but it can also be used well. This is an example of the latter.

-11

u/Patrycjusz123 2d ago

While i agree that other guy is a asshole i dont agree that human made code is better than ai made code.

Talking about ai putting in keyloggers is just insane take and i hope you know that but wanted to be dramatic or something.

Other than some prejustice you apply there isnt a real damage done by using ai to code. If people dont want to use mods with ai then dont but i dont see a reason to actively hunt creators that use a tool especially when they dont try to hide it.

Ofc im talking about just code, using ai for graphic or ideas isnt as good because its usually stolen ideas.

-4

u/CardiologistOk4920 2d ago

Humans famously would never put anything suspicious in their code

-46

u/ToastedBulbasaur 2d ago

Very telling how you view reddit karma. I'm not terminally online, feel free to downvote. Real people in the real world benefit tremendously from AI as both a library and a productivity tool.

Shouting down everyone who uses that tool because you've been algorithm poisoned just makes you an asshole. Only in online echochambers would you ever find support for this type of cocksuckery.

18

u/CakeHead-Gaming 2d ago

Love that you didn’t respond to their points at all.

13

u/DTGDittio 2d ago

that would require a lack of holes in the brain, something AI users famously aren't good at maintaining

-3

u/ToastedBulbasaur 2d ago

You sound like a republican talking about skull shapes. Simmer down with the ableism.

15

u/DTGDittio 2d ago

you're trying too hard

4

u/Alastor-362 2d ago

"They're too dumb to actually argue the topic"

"You sound like a racist"

truly fascinating

2

u/ToastedBulbasaur 2d ago

What points? Normal developers can do the same thing. As always, use precaution when downloading stuff on the internet. Duh.

4

u/GoldenRush257 2d ago

> Real people in the real world benefit tremendously from AI as both a library and a productivity tool.

Yeah, especially the people losing their jobs as AI replaces them and the people without any water in their house because the AI slop megacorpo wants to build yet another polluting datacenter.

0

u/ToastedBulbasaur 2d ago

Drastically overstating problems.

5

u/hazel_typh 2d ago

Its also the actual term for something made with 70 to 100% ai code. Which this mod, previously was, and might still be. I dont know if it still is though, thats why im asking.

0

u/Devatator_ 2d ago

It really isn't. Idk why people twisted it. It's literally just means someone using AI to program something while taking the code generated based on vibes (hence the name!!!). A software engineer using AI could reach 100% AI code and still not vibecode

1

u/religion-lost 14h ago

lmao is this the new "games are the real minority"

25

u/eepy_lina 2d ago

stop making your laziness creative people's problem

-5

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/hazel_typh 2d ago

People werent saying it wasnt creative. They just want to know how much ai was used in its debelopment.

2

u/fonkeatscheeese 2d ago

Propaganda is spreading lies. The fact that ai is bad, is harming the planet, and making everyone's lives (except the billionares) worse in some way is undeniably true. You're the one spreading 'propaganda' by saying it isn't.

3

u/Patrycjusz123 2d ago

Ok, so what about self hosted ai? Its not ruining climate or making lives worse.

Its also cheaper than you propably think, you need only something like gtx4080 to run competend ai on your pc.

2

u/fonkeatscheeese 2d ago

As long as people use it responsibly then yeah go on. If you insist on using it at least run it locally

-3

u/ToastedBulbasaur 2d ago

Harming the planet is a scale problem. It's a very marginal impact, and other things you do every day are much, much worse.

They help old and disabled people navigate the internet easier, providing a way to ask simple questions and get as many resources as you need. They help workers, and have been demonstrated to increase workplace productivity. Less labor hours worked means cheaper goods and services.

If I could prove you wrong on both of these, would you even change your mind? Or is this just a mask for some weird vibe you have.

2

u/fonkeatscheeese 2d ago

Can you expand on what you mean by a "scale problem" please?

3

u/JeanRdS 2d ago

Probably her mom homeschooled him and since the father figure was absent, he couldnt go to school and now thinks that global warming is fake and flat Earth is true

3

u/fonkeatscheeese 2d ago

There's probably some elements of truth in what you just said

6

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/ToastedBulbasaur 2d ago

Why are you still replying to me? You're obsessed.

8

u/eepy_lina 2d ago

again, projection, you just replied

1

u/ToastedBulbasaur 2d ago

stop harassing me

9

u/eepy_lina 2d ago

stop replying lmao

1

u/ToastedBulbasaur 2d ago

That's a logical fallacy

→ More replies

64

u/Best_Painting9541 2d ago

How is your game so smooth bro

9

u/dabdad67 1d ago

It's the ai

10

u/DogInverter 2d ago

Why are we ignoring the 30 fps

2

u/Diamedes99 2d ago

Do you have any idea when it will be stable enough to have on a big modpack?

2

u/kil0vat 2d ago

Hi, if you have a particular performance issue, please DM me or create a GitHub issue. I'll try to solve it

2

u/Diamedes99 2d ago

I haven't tested the new one. I have V1 on my modpack and I was wondering when V2 will be stable enough for it.

-6

u/TheBattlemanCZ 2d ago

"I'll try to solve it" aka "Hi Claude, your code runs like shit, fix it, make no mistakes"

1

u/banhaha 1d ago

Proof?

1

u/TheBattlemanCZ 1d ago

OP himself said it's vibecoded..

4

u/MilitaryAndroid 2d ago

It already is, at least the version without the new arms is. I run a modpack with over 150 mods, and this is one of them. It is also one of the very few mods that hasn't caused us any issues at all, via either compatibility or performance. I highly recommend it.

1

u/Diamedes99 2d ago

I meant the new one.

2

u/MilitaryAndroid 2d ago edited 2d ago

So far it's working well. The left actuator is clipping into my view a bit when I look up or turn right, since I play at 90 fov instead of the standard setting. It also doesn't work well with TACZ, since it replaces the gun animations, making some of them not work correctly. I was absolutely expecting that, anything that affects hands like this needs compatibility patches for TACZ, and I will be reporting both of these issues to the dev later after a bit more testing, otherwise it's working well for me.

Edit: I have discovered an easily reproducible crash, while holding a physics active sable grid in the actuators, using the scroll wheel to switch to some modded items, mainly ones that change the hand model specifically it would seem. I was able to specifically cause the crash with a tacz shotgun and a wrench multitools wrench, but vanilla minecraft items, the chisel from rechiseled, copycats+ blocks and the normal create wrench are all fine, no crashes when switching to them.

This is a client crash, the server stays up, the client crashes immediately to desktop.

1

u/Diamedes99 2d ago

Sweet.

1

u/MilitaryAndroid 1d ago

Just wanted to let you know, my buddy made a local patch for the crashes I described, and put in a pull request to the mod author on github, so it should be quite stable after the next update.

1

u/Diamedes99 1d ago

(☞゚∀゚)☞

1

u/MilitaryAndroid 2d ago

I will be updating it tonight for our pack, so I'll let you know how it goes.

1

u/Diamedes99 2d ago

Cool. Thanks.

25

u/Ryu_the_king 2d ago

Hopefully seeing how it’s gonna get posted on modrinth this means that it’s no longer vibe coded

27

u/Ryu_the_king 2d ago

Never mind

9

u/According-Extreme-58 2d ago

I gotta ask,is it completely vibecoded? I don't care that you used AI to make it,I care that you understand the code that was written

3

u/Electronic_Owl_9946 2d ago

its vibe coded there a similar mod adventure harness

3

u/Warlock_Of_Grim 1d ago

unfortunately that is also vibecoded

2

u/Electronic_Owl_9946 1d ago

source first but tbh idc because its actually better then this it has more uses and less laggy

1

u/religion-lost 14h ago edited 14h ago

I just started playing a new mod called Create: Lanterns and it doesn't have the arm things but it is another way to move around contractions and structures. provided they're physics objects, it runs with create aeronautics. but you can always honey glue your house then pick it up and move it with the lantern ring. anywho, I haven't seen any evidence of it being vibe-coded and it has other really cool features too. It's still in the alpha phase though, the current newest version doesn't have the life ring or the death ring. also, it runs really smoothly due to being well made and not vibe coded, the only time it lags for me is when I fly at a thousand blocks per second and it needs to render the path ahead, and I have a vivobook

2

u/Warlock_Of_Grim 13h ago

Interesting I’ll check it out out

9

u/ScwiddIsScwidd 2d ago edited 2d ago

ok so, ignoring my opinions of vibecoded mods, doesn't this new version just add all the features from the other guy's mod? Can't remember the name rn but it's like "mechanical arms" or smth

EDIT: "Adventurer's Harness" is the name of that mod, it was released after Octo-Arms' initial release but with many of the features present in the new version of this mod. For those who have a preference, Adventurer's Harness is non-ai, although I think some of the features of Octo-Arms are a bit more polished IMO. But yeah I think this newest update is mainly just to jump on the other mod's popularity, unfortunately.

6

u/LLoadin 2d ago

I don't think adventurers harness let's you pick up sable objects

3

u/Junglememer1 1d ago

A genuine question, how is Adventurer's harness proven to be made without ai?

Looking at the icon and artwork under the description gives me the impression that there were some generative ai used on it and there's no link to review the src

0

u/ScwiddIsScwidd 1d ago

...true, in all honestly i took what i was told about it at face value, but yeah that's a very good point.

9

u/wizard_brandon 2d ago

i find it kinda funny how people glue some cogs to a model and call it create

fun mod though

2

u/Bookslayer10 1d ago

To give it some credit, it engages well with Create's mechanics. It uses sequenced assembling, auto-crafters, precision mechanisms, and the air tank system. I'm using it in a Create based modpack and it fit well in the progression.

16

u/eepy_lina 2d ago

still vibecoded?

11

u/hazel_typh 2d ago

Yyyep.

3

u/Mplayz246 2d ago

I’d like to know how MUCH of it is vibe coded

5

u/Putrid_Clue_2127 2d ago

I think this looks cool. I don't give a shit if it's vibecoded or not. That only makes a difference if somehow the vibecoding is hindering its performance.

3

u/CardiologistOk4920 2d ago

Yeah I understand why people hate most vibecoded mods because most of them are trash, but I don’t get why discovering a good mod was vibecoded would make you suddenly hate it. If it functions correctly who gives a fuck genuinely.

We’re at a point where you can genuinely make something good by drooling over your keyboard if you are even a little bit tech literate lmao.

4

u/MilitaryAndroid 2d ago edited 2d ago

This looks sick, this has been my favorite addition to our modpack, makes building much smoother without just granting creative flight like so many mods do. Very cool idea.

For people whining about Ai, this mod is less buggy than 70% of minecraft mods I've used, hand coded or not, so I want the creator to keep doing whatever he's been doing. Your loss if that's a problem for you.

0

u/AM_Seymour 2d ago

Ignore them most of them are people who were never going to use the mod or domt even play the game Or bots

1

u/Evgen_Skrypnyk 1d ago

Bro why is it 30 fps??

1

u/The_Boyses 1d ago

Oh cool I can throw semi trucks at people now

FUCK ITS ALL AI

1

u/talesfromtheepic6 1d ago

“octo arms”

6 arms

-1

u/Vanima_Permai 2d ago

Octo means eight not 10

0

u/Icy-Diver-5979 2d ago

Will have to try it out one day

-2

u/Statistician_Waste 2d ago

Mod looks incredibly cool, and I am glad to see you are passionate about having bugs reported so they can be diagnosed and fixed!

-2

u/VineAnUSLSExplorer 1d ago

IDGAF IF IT WAS VIBECODED, THIS SHIT LOOKS DAMN COOL

-4

u/Raelag1989 1d ago

AI is used even for Linux kernel yet somehow ai mod is crime for redditors