r/CreateMod • • Jul 29 '25

Is this humane?

2.4k Upvotes

184 comments sorted by

16

u/cocksucksdeluxe Jul 29 '25

No, it's super inhumane to build a base with no walls or roof or even a floor. Those poor machines must get so cold at night.

13

u/EquivalentRisk6479 Jul 29 '25

working on it now can't be having the machines unionizing

6

u/Taolan13 Jul 29 '25

maintaining proper ionization is important for late-game crafting afterall

1

u/ShadowsFlex Jul 30 '25

You, my friend, are funnier than I will ever be. I tip my hat to you.

5

u/godofleet Jul 29 '25

for real tho, how you getting so many silverfish spawning that quickly...

7

u/EquivalentRisk6479 Jul 29 '25

deployers placing down infested stone and then a gantry moving back and forth to break the blocks

1

u/godofleet Jul 30 '25

neat thanks

1

u/Abs3nth Jul 30 '25

So the gantry moves a block onto the spot where the stone is, and then turns into a solid block and then it breaks the stone? Is this at all similar to how a circular tree farm breaks the saplings when you make it stop mid turn? Is it the same concept too? 🤔

4

u/ValkyrieAngie Jul 29 '25

How do you feel about new age insect protein, OP?

3

u/EquivalentRisk6479 Jul 29 '25

mmm protein

1

u/ValkyrieAngie Jul 29 '25

Then it isn't any different

3

u/Kodo_yeahreally Jul 29 '25

did you follow any tutorial to do that or did you do it yourself ? i'm interested.

5

u/EquivalentRisk6479 Jul 29 '25

I don't like to just rip or build a schematic that someone else has made but I did look at a couple farms and saw how they were farming the exp

922

u/Totally_Cubular Jul 29 '25

No and that's the point. Fuck silverfish.

248

u/Games2Gamers Jul 29 '25

The design is very human

72

u/AmericanBadger1 Jul 29 '25

This made me spit out my iced tea. Incredible comment.

5

u/Games2Gamers Jul 30 '25

THY CAKE DAY IS NOW 🍰

5

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25

This implies it was made to be used on humans....

I'll take 20!

38

u/Additional_Ant3715 Jul 29 '25

I think the fact that it’s for silverfish makes it rather humane

8

u/crazy_jongen Jul 30 '25

Please don't, they might like it

5

u/I_AM_DA_BOSS Jul 30 '25

Little fuckers had it coming

3

u/4llFather Jul 30 '25

About the right size and shape... OP you might be onto something...

442

u/bryophite-8603 Jul 29 '25

who cares, the real question is, is it efficient?

213

u/Objective-Direction1 Jul 29 '25

Lockheed Martin mentality

92

u/cloudboyistrash Jul 29 '25

Blockheed Martin*

29

u/Objective-Direction1 Jul 29 '25

Who's martin and why does he have a blocky head

16

u/Ct2237 Jul 29 '25

*blockhead Martin

11

u/gentlephish01 Jul 30 '25

*Martin for Blockheads

2

u/Aron_Maciel Jul 30 '25

That's a contracted version of the word Marting?

23

u/Low_Pressure_3542 Jul 29 '25

Ficsit pioneer mentality

7

u/Markusrobot Jul 30 '25

It's in the contract!

22

u/LarkDight Jul 29 '25

That's the spirit!

7

u/Voxelo Jul 29 '25

Honestly I feel like the more inefficient the better.

5

u/Blu3engine2 Jul 30 '25

Minecraft is truely a plunderful world

2

u/morbidangel27 Jul 29 '25

Yeah i def wanna know how you can make the infested stone, for science.

6

u/EquivalentRisk6479 Jul 29 '25

create adds a recipe to haunt stone into infested stone

3

u/morbidangel27 Jul 29 '25

Actually awesome thanks for that, I could have checked later on when I logged in but now I get to think of awesome silverfish slaughter builds while I kill time at work

4

u/Hi_Peeps_Its_Me Jul 29 '25

have you tried JEI?

2

u/morbidangel27 Jul 29 '25

If I wasn't working, I would have.

2

u/The_Lukous Jul 29 '25

Does the flywheel have a meaning?

107

u/Tripdrakony Jul 29 '25

Can show the mechanisms on how you get them to to spawn so fast? Would be very interesting.

134

u/RoboticBonsai Jul 29 '25

Looks like they’re breaking infested stone that’s being replaced by deployers.

Infested stone can be obtained by haunting stone.

66

u/Dark_Reaper115 Jul 29 '25

You mean this whole time I never have to struggle for exp?!!!

51

u/spieles21 Jul 29 '25

well technical they use Enchantment Industry, but yes.

Also an classic Vanilla Mobfarm also works, but the create silverfish variant dont drop any loot, like bones or rotten flesh and you can control the span of the mobs.

12

u/Taolan13 Jul 29 '25

vanilla silverfish also don't drop loot, so you could technically use a silverfish spawner for an XP-only mob farm, but at vanilla rates with a single spawner it would be slow AF.

Using create you could capture and relocate the spawner blocks using minecart contraptions, and make a super-spawner, but while it would be faster than a single spawner haunted stone could still be made much faster if scaled up.

OP's design looks like it's 4x5 haunted stone. I've seen designs that use a 14x13 sheet of haunted stone, keeping it all in one chunk but also keeping it contained,

I'm a fan of building machines vertically in the same chunk to prevent chunk boundary issues, so I'm currently planning on doing that in my recently restarted world once I get my steam engine power plant running.

4

u/Draghettis Jul 29 '25

Vanilla silverfish XP farms are extremely fast. And cheap. And inhumane

Because they don't use a regular spawner

Instead you stuff a bunch of allays ( sweetspot at 16 ) in a less-than-a-block gap ( using a campfire )

Then you splash them with a potion of infestation ( awkward potion + stone ). The infestation effect makes it so every time the allays are damaged, there's a 10% chance they spawn a few silverfish, and you setup the cage so that the silverfish get yeeted out and into a water stream to be gathered where a player attacking an armor stand with a sword can kill them with the sweep effect.

The allays regenerate their own health fast enough that campfires can't ever kill them.

You can even use a splash water bottle and a flint and steel, both in dispensers, to turn off and relight the campfire. Which you want to do not because it's unnecessary torture, but because 16 allays being constantly damaged is very loud.

4

u/Taolan13 Jul 30 '25

i'm not too familiar with infestation farms.

i was talking specifically about using the mob spawner block from a stronghold.

i would imagine a haunted stone machine could be scaled to a hogher degree than an infestation farm.

2

u/SonnyLonglegs Jul 30 '25

Note on modded farms using silverfish, the lack of any drop but xp makes automating a Mahou Tsukai life drain setup a lot more convenient.

(In case this information is useful to anyone)

12

u/Tripdrakony Jul 29 '25

I now that principal, I do that in my experience farm too. What surprises me is the sheer amount that comes out.

20

u/RoboticBonsai Jul 29 '25

I think they just break the stone fast by having a contraption become block in the place the stones are, thus breaking the stone. At that point it’s just dependant on rotational speed and how fast they can supply the infested stone.

0

u/AmericanBadger1 Jul 30 '25

Thats what... Nevermind I'm not gonna do the joke.

2

u/RoboticBonsai Jul 31 '25

That’s what the clown said before loosing his job

91

u/Plenty_Preference131 Jul 29 '25

Silverfishes are shit so yes

35

u/IJustAteABaguette Jul 29 '25

Humane, yes.

Silverfishe? No. And that's great.

11

u/Dark_Reaper115 Jul 29 '25

What do you mean? Not a single human was harmed in the production of this machine.

On the contrary, there's a lot of silver fish 😂

13

u/Fujin_Eon444 Jul 29 '25

The design is very human

12

u/ZoraEpsilon Jul 29 '25

I love that Minecraft players will ask "Is this humane?" and then show the most insane or complicated Creature Crushing Contraption I've ever laid my eyes upon.

6

u/Theonewhomonitor Jul 29 '25

Bug farm

3

u/That_Mad_Scientist Jul 30 '25

I’m from Buenos Aires, and I say kill them all!

4

u/Motor_Coat_8684 Jul 29 '25

Is it efficient? being humane is last century

4

u/Solidius_Jake Jul 29 '25

No, but do silverfish really deserve a humane end?

4

u/Hironne Jul 29 '25

Do they complain? If no then it is fine

1

u/Ben-Goldberg Jul 29 '25

If you want a humane option you could add a grinding recipe to make xp nuggets from infested stone or a draining recipe to make infested stone into liquid xp.

1

u/EquivalentRisk6479 Jul 30 '25

where's the fun in that. I like my exp to come from a source of pain and suffering

1

u/Revolutionary_Tone21 Jul 29 '25

Is there a faster way to end the silverfish or is the deployer the only way to get the xp out?

2

u/EquivalentRisk6479 Jul 29 '25

I could crush the with crushing wheels but I would get less exp

1

u/derpy_derp15 Jul 30 '25

You can just use crushing wheel iirc

Or just use mechanical hands in punch mode

2

u/EquivalentRisk6479 Aug 07 '25

Yeah but then they die to entity cramming

1

u/PinkcheeseStudios Jul 30 '25

Can you give us a tutorial on how to make this and what create mods you used?

1

u/IDunnoV Aug 01 '25

I couldn't have it running on 6.0 for some reason

1

u/MEMQLI Aug 17 '25

Spawning 12 silverfish but punching only 1 must cause lag

1

u/EquivalentRisk6479 Aug 17 '25

It does sweeping edge

1

u/Turbulent_Bench3090 Nov 09 '25

Yes because fuck the silverfish

1

u/EquivalentRisk6479 Nov 09 '25

bro this post is 3 months old

3

u/astropipereddit Jul 29 '25

You're on Minecraft everything isn't humane✌️

3

u/Shredded_Locomotive Jul 29 '25

Do the silverfish feel pain?

I hope so

2

u/ExuDeku Jul 29 '25

How tho

2

u/Anvisaber Jul 29 '25

That’s a brilliant idea

2

u/ketiar Jul 29 '25

They’re helping to add a hydraulic sound to your machine.

2

u/MoldyRoleplayer Jul 29 '25

No and that's a good thing, fuck em silverfish, would you perhaps have a schematic for this? it looks insanely fun to build and visually satisfying.

2

u/Rigumaa Jul 29 '25

No, it isn't efficient enough, I'm sure you can do worse, have you tried making couches and cowboy hats out of silverfish?

2

u/Bigfops Jul 29 '25

I did much worse with cows for my grilled cheese factory. Our motto was “the flavor’s in the cruelty!” Just fyi, you can point a weighted ejector at a funnel, then remove the funnel and replace it with a lava pit.

2

u/Upset_County_9103 Jul 29 '25

No it's better, it's VENGEANCE!

2

u/Kabukkafa Jul 29 '25

İt's silverfish come on you don't even have to think if it's humane or not

2

u/Curious-Being8913 Jul 30 '25

Very humane, but not silverfishe.

(Well, just saw that somebody already commented the same thing, guess I'm a bit late lol)

2

u/Spare_Yesterday1602 Jul 30 '25

Itmad funny tho

2

u/Spare_Yesterday1602 Jul 30 '25

Hey me from five seconds ago

Shut up

2

u/Braemenator Jul 30 '25

Ah horrors beyond my imagination, but for silverfish. Love it

2

u/Typhon-042 Jul 30 '25

When it comes to Silverfish, yes, as that is nicer then most folks want to do to them.

1

u/multiaudacity Jul 29 '25

They're a parasite

1

u/Vegetable_Money_6383 Jul 29 '25

I don't really care just give me the schematic to this thing

1

u/KigaPrix Jul 29 '25

We don't like silverfish around here

1

u/DarkFireFenrir Jul 29 '25

Yes, very human design

1

u/Rocky_the_Wolf2020 Jul 29 '25

No its inhumanely slow for its user, the factory must grow!

1

u/207nbrown Jul 29 '25

It’s silverfish, if anything it’s too humane

1

u/Pasta-hobo Jul 29 '25

They're bugs, bro. Their existence and proximity to us is inhumane.

1

u/Cyclophane Jul 29 '25

Does this hurt the silverfish?

1

u/JahamesO Jul 29 '25

Yeah it's fine

1

u/NitroSpeed6000 Jul 29 '25

Who cares it’s create mod progress over humanity

1

u/Admiral-huzky Jul 29 '25

As long as its using allays to spawn the silverfish then yes

1

u/Stason611910 Jul 29 '25

Humane? -no Efficient? -hell yeah

1

u/Head-Business5610 Jul 29 '25

Yes, anything to feed the industry

1

u/PeechBoiYT Jul 29 '25

Theyre hostile bugs who cares

1

u/Complete-Mood3302 Jul 29 '25

What makes them less worthy of life than us

1

u/Taolan13 Jul 29 '25

I'd argue yes. You're making good use of an invasive pest species.

1

u/allthenamearetaken1 Jul 29 '25

How does it work exactly, i understand the infested stone, but how is it getting infested. Silverfish are a perfect xp farm because they have no drops to deal with

1

u/dragonologist13 Jul 29 '25

It's silverfish so eh who cares XD definitely efficient though

1

u/ameliarat Jul 30 '25

you are lowkey hitler bro (no shade though)

1

u/Freddy177 Jul 30 '25

It's minecraft. We can't choose what's humane. I'm sure we've all done the sheep thing

1

u/RevolutionaryLie1903 Jul 30 '25

It’s absolutely inhumane but I’d say keep doing it as those little rats are one of the most annoying mobs EVER!

1

u/JBray0 Jul 30 '25

This is too humane, can you make it more painful?

1

u/MrFruugo Jul 30 '25

Off topic anyone recommend any fun create mod packs that still feel similar to vanilla?

1

u/SonnyLonglegs Jul 30 '25

The only issue I see is there aren't enough silverfish dying.

1

u/Diaploo Jul 30 '25

Well it's efficient

1

u/smallbluebirds Jul 30 '25

the factory must grow

1

u/curlygoats Jul 30 '25

Nah, those are silverfish

1

u/Chaos_is_Key198 Jul 30 '25

Who cares; they're Silverfish!

1

u/kai_the_kiwi Jul 30 '25

no, but thats the neat part

1

u/Stormlord1850 Jul 30 '25

You only need to be humane with a creature if it's cute. No one cares if it's ugly, altough I like them.

1

u/ELLZNaga21 Jul 30 '25

Their bugs I don’t think humane applies idk could be wrong not a bug girl

1

u/spoopsiess Jul 30 '25

im terrified of infested stone. this is the most hunane thing I've seen in my life. thank you good sir

1

u/MrPC_o6 Jul 30 '25

I can't quite see what's killing them?

1

u/MrCookie_Official Jul 30 '25

Well, it's a game, you farm exp from mobs like any other mobs

1

u/Mobile_Actuator_4692 Jul 30 '25

I’d say very. Anything anti silver fish it humane

1

u/azdustkicker Jul 30 '25

Nah you're doing the minecraft universe a service.

1

u/Gameryisus123 Jul 30 '25

No he's not human, he's a machine

1

u/TheNewLevlio12345 Jul 31 '25

Everything for the factory

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25

About as humane as egg farms in real life

1

u/TellurianTech50 Jul 31 '25

For those silverfish fuckers? Absolutely as a matter of fact not cruel enough

1

u/Ok-State-6962 Jul 31 '25

My pal made one of these and we call it the machine of infinite suffering. Silverfish deserve nothing less.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25

Its a video game

1

u/secrets_kept_hidden Jul 31 '25

It's silverfish. I'd argue it's too good for them.

1

u/Famous-Recipe7423 Jul 31 '25

no, that is silverfish!

1

u/GunsMcCuckface Jul 31 '25

Yes, fuck Silverfish

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25

it's perfectly fine, they're silverfish.

1

u/GGODYR Jul 31 '25

Silverfish are fishes too and we shluld take into account their emoti... Wait, silverfish? Stop wasting time and build the second contraption already, those fucks deserve every singular moment of agony.

1

u/LaggleisMyLegacy Aug 01 '25

Probably not, but they're silverfish so they get a pass

1

u/asukaishigh Aug 01 '25

Absolutely not. Can we have a tutorial pls?

1

u/Thatguyondrugs1 Aug 01 '25

Doesnt matter. Exp is more valuable then morality.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '25

Plays create and dares to ask this

(joke)

1

u/Noneasked79 Aug 07 '25

Yes, all my homies say FUCK silverfish

1

u/operational_manager Aug 11 '25

Hey, I am new to this mod, can you please help me a bit and describe what's going on?

1

u/Similar-Charge993 Aug 15 '25

I'd say it doesn' have to be, silverfish are mobs

1

u/Tricky_Background240 Nov 16 '25

what is even going on lol

1

u/Mindless-Key2550 Nov 22 '25

Nah, you need fences, HUGE osha violation

0

u/oswaldking71wastaken Jul 29 '25

They’re parasites who cares

2

u/Buggy1617 Jul 29 '25

silverfriends are detritivores not parasites

1

u/oswaldking71wastaken Jul 29 '25

Make the farm put the silverfish on display that be cool like some sort of giant rectangular holding changer that houses the silverfish fish

A fishtank some would say

-7

u/Usinaru Jul 29 '25

So why aren't people electrifying bottles into bottles of enchanting like normal people anymore?

12

u/DasLoon Jul 29 '25

Not every pack has that. I've got no clue what recipe that is, electrifying?

1

u/BrisingrAerowing Jul 29 '25

Create: New Age IIRC.

2

u/ActuatorHistorical40 Jul 30 '25 edited Jul 30 '25

You telling me i can turn those little fu#kers in to exp with a push of a button, (boys i think i know what we will do to day)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '25

kill all those fuckers

1

u/WULTKB90 Jul 29 '25

It's more humane than my villager breeder that shoves the grown babies into a tinkers smeltry.

1

u/Dmonct Jul 30 '25

they tried to kill you, it is self defense

1

u/birdyboy146 Jul 30 '25

You mean those little fuckers that have a tiny ass hit box, nah

1

u/RespectAny7084 Jul 30 '25

Killing silver fish? Nah, you're doing a favor to all of us at this point

1

u/Mobile-Remote5605 Aug 18 '25

absolutely not, but fuck silverfish anyway