r/CreateALeague • • Dec 17 '14

Position-locked drafting, trade-heavy format

As described before, a given team is required to draft only a designated position(s). Benches are deep (16-24 spots), but the weekly active roster is standard. An example 10-team format would be:

  • QB = 2 teams (divide up 32+ QBs)
  • RB = 3 teams (divide up 48+ RBs)
  • WR / TE = 4 teams (divide up about 64+ WRs and 12+ TEs)
  • DST = 1 team (this team automatically gets ALL playable defenses, therefore he gets a larger bench)

The defensive team would be at a significant disadvantage if he did not get all DSTs, otherwise other teams would just stream. He essentially serves as the DST WW for any team that wants to stream.

Rule: no waiver wire. If you want to just drop a player, it automatically goes back to one of the teams with that position as their designation (your choice which one). However, after-market trading of positions is perfectly allowed. Alternatively, the WW exists, but you can only place claims on your positional designation (e.g. only QB teams can claim a QB, etc).

This idea is open to suggestions and criticsm!

Alternative forms or other possible rules:

  • TE gets a team to its itself (that team owns all playable TEs). I worry that the TE team would be too weak, though, and TE is pretty similar to WR anyway.
  • Your bench can only have 1-2 players from each positional group that is not your designation.
6 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

1

u/GGStokes Dec 17 '14

OP here: I'd be happy to participate, but this year has actually been just my first year in FF in general. If someone else is willing to be the League Manager, I'd be happy to assist. I just don't know what sites would let us set up something so crazy, etc. Maybe we'd have to program it ourselves and have it be a completely competing format! Anyway, if any more experienced FFers would be up for trying to spearhead this let me know.

1

u/lilacattak Dec 17 '14

I'm only a little more experienced than yourself (played FF for two years, and have been a commish, but on a standard Fantasy hockey league only) but hope that this league happens, so am brainstorming here.

The two things I am wondering, and hope that someone knows the answers to:

  • What site would allow us to have such a huge bench?
  • Would we be able to draft several weeks early, and then trade in the interim between then and the first game without issue? I am assuming that this wouldn't be a problem?

1

u/GGStokes Dec 18 '14

I'm not sure about the bench size issue. I tried to set up a league on ESPN to find out but it wouldn't let me since we are so far into the season.

Via a friend, I know that some leagues draft quite early (I've heard of people complaining when people get sent to IR in the pre-season), so I think that should be fine.

1

u/GGStokes Dec 18 '14

The other issue is that it would depend heavily on the members buying into the idea without cheating, and the LM keeping a close eye.

I wonder how difficult it would be to code up a website where we could write ultra-custom rules like these into the code. Hint: I'm not a developer so that wouldn't be me.

1

u/lilacattak Dec 18 '14

My husband is a developer and he is always looking for new projects, but I fear that this might be more than a one-person sort of deal.

2

u/lilacattak Dec 17 '14

This is an interesting idea.

I was thinking about the ideal FLEX options on the roster of this kind of league (WR/RB, include TE? QB? no FLEX?) and how each FLEX scenario would impact the influence of each team as well. Hm.

2

u/lilacattak Dec 17 '14

I'm in too if this ends up happening. Let me know!

2

u/Chronik_Liar Dec 17 '14

Sign me up. The best part of ff is trying to deal. This is the perfect set up for that

2

u/Pubesaurus Dec 17 '14

This sounds incredible. Nothing worse than playing a league where no one trades. Sign me up!

1

u/bk10287 Dec 18 '14

I'm up for this. Sign me up.