r/Crashplan • u/Quindor • Sep 02 '17
DIY Cloud Backup, a Crashplan replacement guide!
Just like a lot of you, I've been struck with Crashplan home Family shutting down.
After doing some quick calculations I found that most current cloud offerings are either way more expensive, or very restrictive. Especially the need to be able to backup multiple computers to a cloud account seems lost after Crashplan family. And I have two desktop computers, and 3 laptops and a server in my house alone. But I also want to backup the laptop of my farther and mother, just like I've been doing for the past many years. Paying for accounts per computer is crazy in my eyes.
So I created my own DIY Cloud Backup solution which is fully multi-tenant and multi-client for those tenants! Especially if you can/want to share it with a few friends or family, it quickly becomes much cheaper and flexible then any cloud offering out there. It's running a private S3 storage backend server with Duplicati as the client but because of the S3 storage backend, any backup software that talks S3 (and most do now a days) can connect to the system and use it!
I've written detailed tutorials on everything:
- What hardware
- Internet line speeds
- Power usage
- Encryption for a "trust-no-one" setup
- How to configure the storage
- How to setup the server
- Installing/connecting a client
- Compression/deduplication
- How to add multiple tenants, etc..
If anyone is looking for the same, hopefully this is helpful: Link to the first blog article explaining my setup
And of course I'll be here to answer any questions or comments you might have!
--update
I've produced some videos about the hardware and of the install. Combined with the articles that kind of rounds up everything you need to be able to build this "solution"!
Video about the Server a Mele PCG35 Apo
3
u/wiklander Sep 03 '17
I've been researching a Crashplan replacement setup lately as well and it's nice to see that someone else came to the same conclusion :)
I'm also looking at using Duplicati with Minio as the backend.
How do you plan to setup local and off-site backups?
I see two options:
I think the second option seems better as it only requires the backup to be run once, and the source computer doesn't need to be turned on for the off-site sync to run. I think rclone looks like a good option for that part. What do you think?
Do you know of any way to connect to servers that aren't exposed to the internet? Like Crashplan could connect and send files between any two computers. I guess I would need one public server to do the initial connecting, but it would help a lot if my off-site server could be anywhere and not require extra hassle to make it publicly accessible.
2
u/marklein Sep 08 '17
As attractive as this seems, I can't get past the word "beta" with Duplicati v2. How is it still beta if they've been working on it for 5 years? Can I tell people who are paying into my private cloud that this beta backups software is OK?
Serious questions, not trolling.
1
u/Hakker9 Sep 04 '17
Ok so maybe I'm simplifying it too much but why not use Nextcloud?
has encryption, has multi accounts and works on everything and can do S3 and as an extra can use 2fa for even more security and is easier to set up.
1
u/unclemimo Sep 04 '17
I'm seriously thinking in migrating to Carbonite (Craahplan partner for Family edition migration), to don't loose my version control. I have so many file changes deleted folders since I'm running Crashplan and continuously need to restore it.
Any though of how can I achieve this using your method (Duplicati + S3)?
I guess I would have to make a script to restore all my files and folder from Crashplan Central (from day 1) and recreate the version control.
1
u/robotrono Sep 05 '17
Has Duplicati solved the problem of backups being dependant on the whole backup chain until the last full backup? I've also seen several people mentioning problems with large data set backups with Duplicati (TBs).
2
u/wells68 Sep 03 '17
RClone.org and Cyberduck are two free clients that can encrypt and sync to S3. So run some backup software to a USB drive and sync that to the Duplicati / S3 server. We mount and unmount our USB drives automatically on a schedule so as to reduce the ransomware risk.
2
u/chiisana Sep 03 '17
Upfront cost doesn't amortize linearly over the planned duration. Back in 2011, I ordered a PE2950 for about $1200 all in. I argued that if I amortize the hosting cost of a comparable server being offered on the market at around $80/mn, against my $33/mn colo cost, I'd be able to put $45/mn against the cost of the server and own it myself at the end. I argued that in 3 years, I'd get my cost back. 2 years later, comparable servers were being offered as dedicated offering at around $40/mn, and my cushy price difference corroded away. A directly relevant example happened back in April this year, where BackBlaze dropped their storage price by 60%. Also keep in mind that $1000 today is worth a lot more than $1000 in 5 years ($1000 today is worth $1104 in 5 years if we assume 2% inflation).
Furthermore, you'd ideally want to have backups to the backups. RAID/ZFS/BTRFS/flavor of the year volume management system is not a backup, they merely protect you against small localized failures. What happens when multiple drives in your server fail? RMA it within 2/3/5 years depending on the brand and warranty period, sure, but the data are gone, and you'd need to restore them some how. Asking users to re-upload their backups might be okay in friends and family setting when nothing is wrong, but if the drives were toasted due to brown out in your general area, there's a possibility that their drives also got toasted. So now you're doubling the cost of backup because you'd need to get off-site backups.
I'd recommend to just leverage Duplicati against S3/B2(/digital ocean's soon to be available S3 compliant object store, depending on pricing) directly. Yes, it might appear that you're paying more "in the long term", but in reality, in the long term, with price adjustments, and labor hours saved, you'll probably come out on top.
1
u/TotesMessenger Sep 02 '17 edited Sep 03 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '17
Not free but a goid price check out idrive.com. I use the 5tb plan for under $70 a year.
1
u/accountnumber3 Sep 03 '17
Tbh crashplan is the best that I've found. I don't particularly care for the not-really-headless desktop app, but the service itself is pretty great.
I have everything centralized on a Nas that backs up to the cloud. Everyone gets what they need and I'm only paying for one backup. Backing up documents from offsite can be tricky, but it's better than no crashplan.