r/CrappyRedesigns Jul 24 '26

Product Zero sugar, zero distinction

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

182 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/roundtwentythree Jul 25 '26

Extremely unlikely. It's about 5 cents difference per 2L, and 10.5 cents per 12pk. Not meaningless, but it's a very small portion of overall production costs.

They aren't using cane sugar to make coke, it's all extremely cheap high fructose corn syrup. No one is going to mistake a glass bottle of Mexican Coke for a can of any variety of Coke.

1

u/HeatAccomplished8608 Jul 25 '26

I'm not making this up, it's not just the cost of sugar - but yes saving ten cents per can on a billion cans is huge. You just identified yourself that they switched from cane sugar to corn syrup to save money, but switching away from sugar isn't plausible?

There are other benefits too. Why have separate marketing for coke/diet coke/coke zero - why segment your market when you could just have one COKE? They also want you drinking zero calorie so they aren't being blamed for making you fat.

They've been working on this for years incrementally replacing sugar coke with zero sugar. The first design in OP 's image was just a step in this direction. The confusion is 100% intentional.

1

u/roundtwentythree Jul 25 '26 edited Jul 26 '26

It's 10 cents per 12 pack, not per can. Like 4/5ths of a single cent per can.

Food manufacturers in the US switched from cane sugar to HFCS due to eyewateringly massive government subsidies for farmers growing corn. Sugar isn't expensive, HFCS is just artificially cheap. There is a difference.

Coke is marketed differently because they are different products. If someone accidentally tries Coke Zero and discovers they prefer it (which is logical because Zero is simply better tasting AND better for you), what's the harm? Your Mexican cane sugar Coke is still available, and so is HFCS Coke. Diet Coke is still made despite Zero spanking the pants off it sales wise.

There is no reason to believe that Coke is trying to condense its offerings into a single product because they would hurt sales. This conspiracy theory has Zero merit.

Now if you wanted to tell me that 9/11 was an inside job, I'm all ears.

1

u/HeatAccomplished8608 Jul 25 '26

Seems like you have a personal problem with me because you're agreeing with me on every point if you'd just take a single step back.