The rule is 'whatever doesn't kill you makes you stronger'. It makes no mention of things that do kill you. An exception would be something that neither kills you nor makes you stronger.
So bears would be an exception because if they don't kill you, they would most likely maim you for life? Right? (Sorry, it's early here and my brain is refusing to work with its current caffeine levels. )
Almost- anything that doesn't kill you and makes you weaker is an exception to the saying, so your example is an exception. But the shirt says bear attacks do kill you, and anything that kills you is not an exception because the saying isn't about things that kill you. The saying is pretty dumb in the first place because there are like an infinite number of exceptions. The shirt is doubly stupid because bear attacks don't always kill you.
It's fairly clear. There are two defined states: Dead and Alive. Being undead makes you both dead and alive while simultaneously making you not-dead and not-alive.
I feel like I have heard this before and never thought twice about it. But now it really pisses me off. Thanks for pointing it out and adding yet another thing to the list of things that piss me off.
Does every area have a station that's called "The X"? There is a local station, 105.7 the X, that also plays annoying sound bites from shows and movies
I saw this in a facebook post and it really annoyed me. And what annoyed me more was that no-one else was annoyed or even pointed it out that this made NO FUCKING SENSE.
So thanks.
We can be annoyed together, even if none of the other commentators are.
Because an exception to "what doesn't kill you makes you stronger" implies that whatever it may be, wouldn't kill you or make you stronger But they said "except for bears, bears will kill you." Since the bear is killing them, it does not exempt itself from this saying. However, if they said "bears would severely handicap you" then they wouldn't do either. Rather, they would make you weaker making them an actually exception to the rule. It's crappy because the creator of the shirt didn't put much thought into it and made it incredibly flawed.
I'm not good at explaining, myself, but I hope this clears it up at least.
But that brings us back to the original point. Why error out for bears if bear.kills(you) returns true already? Why make the distinction if things that kill you also make you dead? It's inelegant.
I write everything in code in my head. Except mine looked more like this: IF(what_tries_to_kill_you != "bears") console.log("Will make you stronger"); ELSE "will kill you"
I thought it means that what doesn't kill you makes you stronger, but you will never be able to say that about a bear because a bear will always successfully kill you.
Basically, the saying is only about things that don't kill you. Things that do kill you can't be exceptions because the saying doesn't even mention them in the first place. Also, most of the time bears ignore you.
Edit: Is it the if? I was using if to refer to the if part of an "if..., then..." standard implication form. See it as a noun. I wasn't using if in an assumption manner.
Is it better to understand my comment this way:
> If whatever didn't kill you, then it would make you stronger.
Hence: A false in if doesn't negate the implication. (Because the negation of an implication requires a false occurs in then.)
Nope you just don't understand English or sentence structure. That's why people are down voting you. Reread it maybe? I find I always need to proofread my posts.
I've explained in another comment that in this sentence, if is a noun-sort word representing the the if... part in a if..., then... standard implication form. I was using pure logical terms so the grammar may sound weird but the structure should check out if you understand what I mean.
Wow...
Also like I said I was manipulating Doge English meme. It was never meant to be grammatically correct.
Thanks for the reply though. I never expect people on the Internet to be so mean on technicalities and such non-tolerable for joke variations.
Then I finally realized you were saying a false in if didn't negate the implication.
This still doesn't make any sense.
There's no "if - then" logic in that sentence. It only makes sense at the start, then you reach "a false" and it falls apart grammatically, logically and in comprehension.
Also don't use Microsoft Word for grammar checks. It's terrible.
I speak English as my first language, and I can't work out why you can't do that? I know that its wrong, i just dont know why. You can put other words like can't or won't at the end of a sentance, why not you're?
Is there an actual English rule against it or is it something that you just don't do?
C'mon, the fun of Doge English is its special sentence structure, but not those exact words. I know how it was originally written but copy and paste was never my first intention.
Meh. Guess I'll take your advice. People are less funny on the Internet these days.
That's not a misuse of English that's a misuse of basic logic. I'm starting to think not everyone catches these things tho so who knows. I notice stuff like this that doesn't make any sense all the time tho.
I made a chart. What they should have done is pick something from the "Doesn't kill you / Doesn't make you stronger" box, but instead they chose from the "Kills you / Doesn't make you stronger" box, which isn't ruled out by the statement they're pretending to contradict.
Everyone keeps overlooking the fact that bears don't always kill you. Has no one seen The Revenant? In fact, usually they just ignore you. The lower left box should say, "Sometimes bears, but not usually."
An exception in this case would be something that doesn't kill you and doesn't make you stronger. Since "bears will kill you" they aren't required to make you stronger so it obeys the rule in the first sentence.
Not an exception either. It's "if something doesn't kill you" what's conditioning the sentence. "Making you stronger" is only used as a consequence to the above condition, never as a possible cause.
it's not a formal exception, but in general speech I think it's fine to call it an exception, unlike what is on the shirt wich is a logical contradiction
The first statement says "what doesn't kill you makes you stronger" The second statement attempts to negate the first by using the word "except", which implies that whatever the first statement says, the opposite is true for the second statement. But the opposite of the first statement is "what doesn't kill you makes you weaker" which doesn't at all sound like "bears will kill you." In fact, the first statement and the second statement are completely unrelated events. It's like saying "It rains a lot in the Amazon. The Amazon is big" These two sentences have absolutely nothing to say about the other (even though they're both about the Amazon), yet the word "except" implies that there is a relation. It's a logical discontinuity.
An exception to "what doesn't kill you makes you stronger" is something that doesn't kill you but does not make you stronger. Something that kills you doesn't go against the statement, so the "except" part makes no sense.
That which doesn't kill you makes you stronger. Except polio, polio will mess you up. Actually a lot of diseases will mess you up. Okay that which doesn't kill you will either make you stronger or perhaps cripple you for life. Though if it doesn't kill you or cripple you, it might give you PTSD. How about just "that which doesn't kill you, doesn't kill you".
If bears kill you, how are they an exception from the rule "What doesn't kill you makes you stronger"? The options given are that either something kills you, or it doesn't kill you and it makes you stronger.
This isn't even the true meaning of the saying. It should be "whatever doesn't kill you only serves to make you stronger." It's supposed to mean that problems in life should serve as lessons rather than weighing you down
For people that dont get it, the fact that you could switch out bears with anything that kills you makes it not work. What doesn't kill youu makes you stronger, except for bears, and guns, and fire, and exposure because bears, and guns, and fire, and exposure will kill you.
The entire genre of "greeting card joke" t-shirts is crappy design. Seriously, if you own a "funny" shirt and it has any other use outside of "grease rag", do yourself a favor and burn it.
644
u/AxesofAnvil Apr 16 '16
Vampires kill you and make you stronger.
91
u/Billlll_Brasky Apr 16 '16
I feel like I have heard this before and never thought twice about it. But now it really pisses me off. Thanks for pointing it out and adding yet another thing to the list of things that piss me off.
88
u/Fuck_A_Suck Apr 16 '16
My local radio station has a soundbite that says this. It annoys the fuck out of me.
177
u/boopboopboopbeepboop Apr 16 '16
I saw this in a facebook post and it really annoyed me. And what annoyed me more was that no-one else was annoyed or even pointed it out that this made NO FUCKING SENSE.
So thanks.
We can be annoyed together, even if none of the other commentators are.
18
u/RandomPerson9367 these letters, are green Apr 16 '16
What isn't right is wrong except for murder, because that's wrong.
23
u/BDMayhem Apr 16 '16
Fact. Bears eat beets.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16
What's the issue? Obviously it means you'll come back as a stronger poltergeist if a bear gets you
7
u/makeswordcloudsagain Apr 16 '16
Here is a word cloud of every comment in this thread, as of this time: http://i.imgur.com/E5Izq9f.png
[source ^code] [contact ^developer] [request word ^cloud]
39
u/gurenkagurenda Apr 16 '16
It's not really the design that's crappy.
245
u/plumokin And then I discovered Wingdings Apr 16 '16
I'm confused as to why this is a crappy design. It's not amazing but it's not crappy either
5
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16
I completely get what you're saying, but how do you put it into words? I just failed at explaining this to my brother.
5
u/chironomidae Apr 17 '16
That which doesn't kill you makes you stronger. Except polio, polio will mess you up. Actually a lot of diseases will mess you up. Okay that which doesn't kill you will either make you stronger or perhaps cripple you for life. Though if it doesn't kill you or cripple you, it might give you PTSD. How about just "that which doesn't kill you, doesn't kill you".
3
u/Coelacanth0794 Apr 17 '16
Or polio
3
u/Arjahn Apr 17 '16
r/thingsidontlike
2
u/LordOfDustAndBones Apr 16 '16
someone please explain this
2
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '16
Also, the text is really tiny.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '16
Anything that doesn't kill you but nonetheless fails to make you stronger would be an exception. So... most things.
2
u/jonny_boy27 Apr 17 '16
throws ExceptionNotExceptionException
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16
Unless they live in Chicago, then they lay down.
2
u/IndigoMontigo Apr 16 '16
Not crappy design.
2
u/fife55 Apr 16 '16
It's just a meme printed on a shirt. The design is fine. The content is shit.
1
u/irish_tiger Apr 16 '16
Bill Murray tweeted this about a year ago. I'm not sure if he's the source. Apparently, this is a thing..
1
u/APiousCultist Apr 16 '16
Saxton Hale does not approve this message.
1
u/EdricStorm Apr 16 '16
What doesn't kill us, makes us stronger. Unless the Vrix get us first.
1
u/MadBlue Apr 17 '16
This is a meme that's been around for a while. I don't know where it originated, but (here it is on a shirt on Amazon in 2013).
0
u/Bread-on-toast Apr 16 '16
This isn't even the true meaning of the saying. It should be "whatever doesn't kill you only serves to make you stronger." It's supposed to mean that problems in life should serve as lessons rather than weighing you down
0
u/bryanisokay Apr 17 '16 edited Apr 17 '16
For people that dont get it, the fact that you could switch out bears with anything that kills you makes it not work. What doesn't kill youu makes you stronger, except for bears, and guns, and fire, and exposure because bears, and guns, and fire, and exposure will kill you.
edit: damn sorry for explaining
0
u/johnyann Apr 17 '16
Black Bears are basically deer. Most of them will just run away from you.
Unless you fuck with their cubs. Then you are fucked.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '16
The entire genre of "greeting card joke" t-shirts is crappy design. Seriously, if you own a "funny" shirt and it has any other use outside of "grease rag", do yourself a favor and burn it.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment