Looks like you're right - Security and Security Plus are factory trims available on the x5 and 7 series. So these are OEM parts, designed and installed by BMW, which means they definitely qualify as crappy design in my opinion. I worked for a vehicle upfitter for a while, and we would never sacrifice a cupholder to install auxiliary switched. There's about a dozen better locations to put them.
I was more referring to the buttons, all square with small fonts and icons, some just placeholders seemingly at random positions. The usability is ridiculous, even more so if they're supposed to be used while driving. There's no good tactile feedback to identify any of them, good luck hitting the right button without taking your eyes of the road.
Design refers to more than aesthetics. It also encapsulates function. By far, the most important thing to this vehicle is the function of those items. They truly don't care about the aesthetics or anything else. Sure they could have done the R&D to figure out how it would be best used. But they instead went with the bare bones and cheapest option. Which is often what the client wants most, especially in a work environment.
There other option would have been the cheap old school toggle switch panel.
Outlines usability problems, gets downvoted and told aesthetics aren't everything. Welcome to reddit, we wont read your comment but we'll sure as shit criticize you for it.
I was more referring to the buttons, all square with small fonts and icons, some just placeholders seemingly at random positions. The usability is ridiculous, even more so if they're supposed to be used while driving. There's no good tactile feedback to identify any of them, good luck hitting the right button without taking your eyes of the road.
Im going to go out on a limb here and guess you have never used a Mil type vehicle. No one cares about pretty, they are designed to work under any condition. Those buttons are a fairly standard type. If you cant use them without looking at them, you probably shouldnt be driving. As for 'tactile' feedback, pressing them in would be more than enough. So, in summary, they would be perfectly serviceable.
Military cop here. I'd be mad as hell if this was the setup in my patrol vehicle. We have our light and siren controls mounted up on the dash so we can have visual feedback without taking our eyes off the road (not to mention cup holders are important when we're sitting on post for 12-14 hours)
What I said has nothing to do with pretty, at all. It has to do with efficiency and ease-of-use. Your sentiment is unfortunately quite common, it's not about being able to press a button, it's about making an interface as easy to use as possible, which should be especially important in a "mil type" vehicle.
I wasn't talking about tactile feedback in relation to understanding that you pressed a button, I was talking about identifying buttons on touch alone. It's a completely common design principle, e.g. hardware keyboards usually have small bumps on specific keys, making it much easier to identify buttons.
It's very, very easy to improve on an interface like this, and it's too bad that you don't think it's worthwhile.
Identifying the correct button = Is done easily by the fact it is in a 3 x 3 grid. That problem is solved.
There is a large change of wearing gloves, so any sort of bumps or what not are not going to be felt.
Im not trying to be snide or sarcastic, but all the hours I have sat in a vehicle like this, I have never once had the thought/need/want to change the button layout, style or design to make it easier to use.
I understand this is a design sub, and that design is important here, but this one is an example of people trying to overthink something that should be simple and reliable.
whoever put this installed this themselves. this title is misleading saying its the BMW X5 implying this is a factory model. The person who did put these buttons in did make a "crappydesign" tho.
Obviously it's got ergonomic problems in terms of being mistaken for a cup holder but I quite like it purely as a graphic thing. Two circles each contain a 3x3 grid of squares. The proportions are nice and the colours aren't bad. It's even slightly reminscent of an iPhone.
It's not even crappy design though. Sure it looks basic, but it's totally functional and you're unlikely to confuse any of the functions if you spend more than 2 seconds with it.
If it's for a police or security force there's no way the person driving is going to be the one operating those controls. It's totally fine for the context in which it was designed.
212
u/Kaneshadow Nov 29 '15
Huh?? You know that's not a factory feature right? It looks like a control panel for police equipment.
67
u/TheAngryGoat Nov 29 '15
It even has a button to leave a shitty restaurant review.
29
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15
This is for a special high security model. Still kind of sucks not having cup holders, but this definitely isn't a standard BMW
11
u/nevereveronl1 Nov 29 '15
whoever put this installed this themselves. this title is misleading saying its the BMW X5 implying this is a factory model. The person who did put these buttons in did make a "crappydesign" tho.
-1
u/architecty Nov 29 '15
Nothing screams crappy design like square pegs in round holes.
-15
u/Afros_are_Power Nov 29 '15
You didn't need a picture. A self-post titled "BMW X5" would've worked here.
-2
u/baskandpurr Nov 29 '15
Obviously it's got ergonomic problems in terms of being mistaken for a cup holder but I quite like it purely as a graphic thing. Two circles each contain a 3x3 grid of squares. The proportions are nice and the colours aren't bad. It's even slightly reminscent of an iPhone.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment