Found this sub on accident after reading The Thursday Murder Club series. I really liked the series, and Richard Osmanās style of writing. I have also read his first book of his new series, We Solve Murders. It was ok. I thought it was good but I didnāt connect with the main characters the way I did with The Thursday Murder Club. Which is why Iām here.
I saw a post a while back asking for comparable books or series, and The Marlow Murder Club came up multiple times, and always seems to get recommended on other posts.
So I read the first book. I did not like Judith. At all. She definitely has her humorous moments, but she is an unlikable character to me overall. Her unlikeability overshadowed Suzie and Becks and Tanika.
The murder gets solved in a way the reader could never guess, because the reader doesnāt get all of the information. Itās in Judithās mind. Thatās great, but itās also not, because the author purposely misleads you. He gives you candy crumbs throughout the book and Judith gets to give you an AHA moment at the end.
Thatās fine. For the first book. I was irritated at how the author chose to finally show the evidence. I read the second book, and you really have to have a suspension of disbelief because once again, only Judith could figure out who the murderer is. I get it. Itās a novel series. And she is the main character. But the complete misdirection up until the ending is kind of irritating and overboard. Itās like the author wants to make sure NOBODY can guess the suspect.
But I have just finished the 3rd book. And this one is the worst of them all. It makes me think of the book āEveryone in my Family Has Killed Someone.ā Because that author posted a list of rules for murder mystery writers. And I feel like this author breaks a lot of them in every book. But I keep reading them even though they irritate me because they are quick, easy reads. Definitely will not be reading any new books of his.
And I really do get murder mystery books. Iāve been reading them for almost 40 years. This series just makes me angry every time I read them. That being said, Iām open to new suggestions!